Upload
liviarangela
View
216
Download
0
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
7/25/2019 A Querela Do Mtodo Em Psicanlise
1/13
Leitura, Interpretao, Comentrio e Reconstruo
A Querela do Mtodo em Psicanlise
Christian Ingo Lenz Dunker
!"#$% %#'()($ * +,(-*)./(,# -010 $1 1230%0 %# 3"*3*1#)30 # -010 $1
1230%0 %# ()4#,3(5*6708 90%#10, ()3$(" :$# #,3# 1230%0 %# ()4#,3(5*670 ,(3$#;,#
-010 ()'/# ,#?* #1 ,$* # +*"3(-$/*"1#)3# -01 B*-*)> 3*/ 1230%0 %# ()4#,3(5*670
10,3"0$;,# 3*1C21 %03*%0 %# $1* ,#5$)%* *-#+670D * ()4#,3(5*670 +,(-*)*/=3(-* %#
3# 0$ %#4#"=*10, )0, -0),3"*)5#"
*0, 1230%0, %# ()3#"+"#3*670 # *0, -"(32"(0, %# "(50" :$# 3#1 -*"*-3#"(G*%0 *, -(H)-(*,
%* /()5$*5#1> 0 %("#(30 0$ * '(/0,0'(*I
J0),(%#"#10, *, *)3(5*, #,3"*325(*, %# /#(3$"* # ()3#"+"#3*670 %# 3# ,#?* #/* %# # ,#)%0 ,#$ ,#)3(%0 %# $,0 /(4"# # %#3#"1()*%0 ,#5$)%0 0 /#(30"8 E,3# 2 $1
+"0C/#1* "#/*3(4*1#)3# %*3.4#/ $1* 4#G :$# *, ,0-(#%*%#, ,#1 #,-"(3* "#,0/4# 0 3#1*
%* ()3#"+"#3*670 "#1#3#)%0;0 F 0"*/(%*%# %0 1(30 # F *$30"(%*%# %# ,#$ ()32"+"#3#8
O +"0C/#1* %* ()3#"+"#3*670 %# 3# :$# 2 * %*
#,-"(3*8
O, +"(1#("0, -@%(50, ?$"=%(-0, %* 1#,0+03Q1(*> *, +"(1#("*, #,-"(3*,
*,3"0)R1(-*, ()%0;#$"0+2(*, # 0, 3#
#,3*4*1 ,$?#(30, *0, '#)R1#)0, %* +*,,*5#1 %0 3#1+0> :$# -"(* * -0),-(H)-(* %# ,$*
+"@+"(* L(,30"(-(%*%#8 M -"(,30/05(* # * L#"1#)H$3(-* C=C/(-* #,3*C#/#-#"*1 *,,(1> *32
7/25/2019 A Querela Do Mtodo Em Psicanlise
2/13
:$# B$3#"0 # E,+()0G* :$#,3(0)*,,#1 #,3# +"()-=+(0 )0 ,2-$/0 STU # STUU
"#,+#-3(4*1#)3#> :$# 0, 3#
(1#%(*3*1#)3# *+"##),=4#/ # %#3#"1()*%08 O, +"0C/#1*, /#4*)3*%0, *:$( ,70
"#/*3(40, F +"@+"(* 1*3#"(*/(%*%# %0 3# * '(%#/(%*%# %# ,$*
3"*%$670 0$ 3"*),-"(670 #1 "#/*670 F 4#",70 0"(5()*/> ,$* +#"3()H)-(* * $1
-@%(-# 0$ * $1 -Q)0)#8
Y8 +%&'()* .&./0/(1*D ,$"5# *:$( 0 ,#)3(%0 ,#5$)%0 %0 3# :$# -0)4(%* * $1*
/#(3$"* +0/=3(-*> "#1#3#)%0 *0 ,(5)('(-*%0 -0/#3(40 %* L(,3@"(*8 E/# 2 $1 3# %# *)3#-#%H)-(* -$/3$"*/ 0$ %# "#/#4Q)-(* L(,3@"(-*8
A#,3# -*,0 * '$)670 %0 3# %#'()()%0 *,,(1 $1* */(*)6* #)3"#
#/#,8
Z8 +%&'()* "*-.,D #,+#-('(-* $1* ()3#"+"#3*670 +,(-0/@5(-*8 M:$( 0 3# -01 #'#(30, +"*51.3(-0, %# #/#4*670 0$ %# "#C*( %(*)3# %# $1* %*%* -01$)(%*%# %# ,#)3(%0>
0$ %# "#()3#"+"#3*670 %0 1$)%0> %* */1* # %0 %#,3()08
[8 +%&'()* .,%/0-(1*D +"#,$1# * # *)*/05(* 0$ #1+*3(*8
7/25/2019 A Querela Do Mtodo Em Psicanlise
3/13
9#"-#C#;,# *,,(1 :$# 0, *)3(50, L#"1#)#$3*, #,3*4*1 ,# %#C*3#)%0 -01 0 :$#
L0?#> -L*1*"=*10, %# 1230%0, %# /#(3$"* %# 3# %#,-"(30, +0" M"(,3@3#/#,D )* -\,+(%#
#,3*4* * -*$,* '()*/ ]0C?#30 %# -0)3#1+/*670 3#@"(-*^ # )* C*,# ()'#"(0" * -*$,*#'(-(#)3# ]+#/* :$*/ %#4(*1 ,# ()3#"#,,*" 0, *"3#,70, # 3"*C*/L*%0"#,^8 E)3"# #/*,
#,3*4*1 * -*$,* '0"1*/ # * -*$,* 1*3#"(*/8 M L(#"*":$(* #+(,3#10/@5(-* %*, -*$,*,
"#'/#3(* * L(#"*":$(* ,0-(*/ %0 1$)%0 *)3(50 # 1#%(#4*/> -01 0, *"(,30-"*3*,
_+#),*)3#,` #1 -(1* # 0, *"3#,70, # 32-)(-0, _3"*C*/L*%0"#,` #1 C*( #/* +*"#-# 3#"
()4#"3(%0 #,3* L(#"*":$(* %0, ,#)3(%0,D 30")*)%0;,# +*"* )@, -"#,-#)3#1#)3#> 1*,
(1+0"3*)3# * %(1#),70 %# *":$(40> %# %0-$1#)30> %# 3#,3#1$)L0 %0 :$# * %(1#),70
%# ,#)3(%0 /(5*%* -01 * "#4#/*670 %# $1* -*1*%* %# ,#)3(%0 ,#-"#3* # #+('Q)(-*8
M, -(H)-(*, L$1*)*,> # -"#(0 :$# )#,3# *,+#-30 #/*, ()-/$#1 * +,(-*)./(,#>
-*"*-3#"(G*1;,# +#/0 '*30 %# :$# ,#$, 1230%0, )70 ,# '$)%*1#)3*1 )* # 1*, #/# ,# %. )* ,$+#"'=-(#> ,#1 +"0'$)%(%*%#> 1*, )*, *"3(-$/*6N#,
#)3"# ,(5)('(-*)3#,8 E/# )70 2 -01+0,30 +0" -0)3#\%0,> 1*, +0" 4*"(*6N#, %# '0"1*8
E/# )70 -0),(,3# #1 ,(5)('(-*%0,> 1*, #1 +0,(6N#, ,(5)('(-*)3#,8
J01 (,,0 +0%#10, %(G#" :$# * 10%#")(%*%# #1 5#"*/> 1*, B*-*) #1 +*"3(-$/*">
()4#"3#$ * L(#"*":$(* %*, #,3"*3('(-*6N#, %# ,#)3(%0> -0),(%#"*)%0 1#)0, (1+0"3*)3#
,#$ ,#)3(%0 */#5@"(-0 # 1*(, (1+0"3*)3# ,#$ ,#)3(%0 /(3#"*/8 O 3"$:$# *:$( )70 2 :$#
4*10, 40/3*" * $1* '2 ()3#"+"#3*3(4* )* 3"*),+*"H)-(* # )0 *-#,,0 (1#%(*30 *0 ,#)3(%0>
1*, #1 *C0"%*" * +"0%$670 %# ,#)3(%0 +#/* )#5*3(4(%*%#> 0$ ,#?*> +#/*, G0)*, #
#,3"*325(*, %# +"0%$670 %# _)70 ,#)3(%0`8 K *,,(1 :$# )0,,* -0),-(H)-(* /(%*
()3$(3(4*1#)3# -01 0 ()-0),-(#)3#> -010 G0)*, 0$ 0-0""H)-(*, %# &2* $%&'()*8 a*,
L. 1$(3*, '0"1*, %# 4#"('(-*" * )#5*670 %0 ,#)3(%0> # *:$( "##)-0)3"*10,> %# 10%0()4#"3(%0> * -/*,,('(-*670 1#%(#4*/D
7/25/2019 A Querela Do Mtodo Em Psicanlise
4/13
X8 O &2* $%&'()* 5#"*%0 +0" $1 _#""0` )0 )=4#/ %* /#3"*> %* (1+"#,,70> 0$ %*
#,-"(3*8 M:$( 2 -010 ,# #,3(42,,#10, #1 $1* 4(0/*670 %# ,#)3(%0 +0"
-0""$+670 %0 -*)*/ 0$ %* /=)5$* :$# ,# #,3. $3(/(G*)%08 90%#10, %(G#" :$# *:$(
#,3*10, F, 40/3*, -01 $1* "#,(,3H)-(* )0 )=4#/ %* /#(3$"* %* /#3"*> -010 2 0-*,0 %# $1 3# 1*/ (1+"#,,0 0$ ,0C"#+0,30 * 0$3"08
Y8 O &2* $%&'()*0-*,(0)*%0 +#/0 %#,#)-0)3"0 %# ()3#"+"#3*6N#,> -010 2 0 -*,0
%# :$*)%0 301*10, $1* +*/*4"* 0$ $1 -0)-#(30 # /L# *3"(C$=10, %('#"#)3#,
,#)3(%0,> +0":$# #1 -*%* $1 %#,3#, ,#)3(%0, #,3*10, '*G#)%0 4*/#" $1
%(,-$",0> 0$ 1#/L0"> $1* ,2"(# ,(5)('(-*)3#8 E,3# 2 0 -*,0 %*, '0"1*6N#, %0
()-0),-(#)3#> -010 0 -L(,3#8 E -*$,*)%0 #1
)@,> :$# ,010, +0,(-(0)*%0, -010 $1* 3#"-#("* +#,,0*> 0 #'#(30 %# "(,08
Z8 O &2* $%&'()*-*$,*%0 +#/0 0C?#30> 0$ ,#?*> * )#5*670 %0 ,#)3(%0 +,(-0/@5(-0
%# $1 3# 0$ ,#?*> %*, 4*"(*6N#, %# #)$)-(*670 :$# +0%#10, (1+0" * $1
#)$)-(*%08 A#,3# -*,0 4#"('(-*10, 0 )70 ,#)3(%0 )0 ()3#"(0" %0 :$*/ 0 ,$?#(30
+0%# #1#"5("8 b$*)%0 B*-* %(G :$# "#-#C#10, )0,,* +"@+"(* 1#),*5#1
()4#"3(%* %#,%# 0 O$3"0> #/# #,3. ,# "#'#"()%0 * #,3* +"0+"(#%*%# %# (&7%-$2*>
]:$# 2 $1 3(+0 %# )#5*670^> +#/0 :$*/ 0 ,$?#(30 *+*"#-# */( 1#,10 0)%# #/# ,#
)#5*8 O ,$?#(30 #1 $1 3# #1 _E1
d$,-* %0 P#1+0 9#"%(%0`> 0C"* 1#10"(*/=,3(-* %# a*"-#/ 9"0$,3 :$# #1
%#3#"1()*%0 101#)30 ()3"0%$G> +*"* ,$"+"#,* %0 +"@+"(0 /#(30"> $1
+#",0)*5#1 -L*1*%0 _a*"-#/ 9"0$,3`8 E1 0$3"*, +*/*4"*, 0 )70 ,#)3(%0_+,(-0/@5(-0` 0$ _10"*/` +0%# ,#" /0-*/(G*%0 )*, %(4(,N#,> )*, 0+0,(6N#,> )*,
7/25/2019 A Querela Do Mtodo Em Psicanlise
5/13
"#+#3(6N#,> )*, ()4#",N#, 0$ )*, %#'0"1*6N#, :$# +0%#10, +#"-#C#" %(*)3# %*
"#/*670 %(*/@5(-* ()(-(*/> ,$+0,3* #)3"# 0 #1(,,0" %* 1#),*5#1 # ,#$ "#-#+30"8
[8 O &2* $%&'()* #40-*%0 +#/*, 0+#"*6N#, /@5(-*, %# -0)3"*%(670> %#
()%#3#"1()*670> %# ()%#-(%(C(/(%*%# 0$ %# ()%(,-#")(C(/(%*%# %0 3# 0$ ,#?*>)*, 4*"(*6N#, %0 #)$)-(*%0 %(*)3# * +"#,$1(%* $)(%*%# # -0),3Q)-(* %*
#)$)-(*6708 M,,(1 -010 )0 -*,0 *)3#"(0" #,3*"=*10, )0 -*1+0 %# &*&6$%&$%
]# )70 %0 .=6$%&$%^> 1*, *50"* ,# 3"*3* %# $1* )#5*670 %0 ,#)3(%0 5#"*%* +#/*
4*"(*670 %0 #)$)-(*%0> )70 %* #)$)-(*6708 K :$# #)-0)3"*10, )0 )70;,#)3(%0
%0, ,()301*,> -010 $1* #,+2-(# %# ,#)3(%0 (1+0,30> -0#"-(3(40 # -0)3"."(0 F
4*"(*6708 90" (,,0 B*-*) *,,0-(0$ 0 %#,#?0 -01 * 1#30)=1(*> :$# 4*( %#,/(G*)%0
0 ,#)3(%0 # 0 ,()301* -01 * 1#3.'0"* :$# %#321 # 1*)321 0 104(1#)30 %0
,#)3(%08 M #1#"5H)-(* %0 ,()301*> # 3*1C21 %0 ,0)L0> 1*, #1 0$3"0 ,#)3(%0>
-"(*1 $1 +"0C/#1* L#"1#)H$3(-0 #,+0)3Q)#0 *0 ,$?#(308 E/# ,# 4H
,$"+"##)%(%0 +#/* (1+0,,(C(/(%*%# %# 4*"(*" 0 ,#)3(%0 # *0 1#,10 3#1+0 +#/*
"#+#3(670 # (),(,3H)-(* %#,3# 1#,10 _)70 ,#)3(%0`8 90" # )0 -*,0 %0
e01#1 %0, f*30,> 0 ,(5)('(-*)3# _f*3#)`> "*30, #1 */#170> "#1#3#
,(1$/3*)#*)#)3# * _>%(-.'%&` ]1.$.-> # * ,$* %('(-$/%*%# #1 %#-(%(";,# -*,*"g *
_-.''%&` ])?7().^> # * %=4(%* )70 +*5* /#5*%* +0" ,#$ +*(g * _-.'%` ]"*30^ *)(1*/
,$?0 # *5"#,,(40 :$# #)3"* #1 /0-*(, *+#"3*%0,g * _+4(%,-.'%&` ]"*30 %# ?050^>
*/5$21> -010 ,#$ +*(> :$# 3#1 $1* -01+$/,70 +0" ?050g # * _@.'%& A%,)
]10#%* %0, "*30,^> #,+#-$/*670 -"(*%* +#/0 e01#1 %0, f*30, :$# 3"*%$G(*
:$*/:$#" 4*/0" 10)#3."(0 #1 $1* %#3#"1()*%* :$*)3(* #:$(4*/#)3# )0 :$# #/#
-L*10$ %# _,$* 10#%* %0, "*30,`8
P*)30 * 3#0"(* 1#%(#4*/ %0 ,#)3(%0> -010 ,$* 4#",70 ()4#"3(%*> 10%('(-*%* #
)#5*3(4*> :$# +0%#10, "#-0)L#-#" #1 B*-*) ,70 4#",N#, %# */5$1*, -0)%(6N#,
#/#1#)3*"#, %0 *30 %# -01$)(-*6708 V#5$)%0 W*-0C,0) 30%* -01$)(-*670 #)40/4#D
$1 #1(,,0"> $1 "#-#+30"> $1 -@%(50 # $1* 1#),*5#1> */21 %# $1 -*)*/ )* :$*/ *
1#),*5#1 ,# #'#3$*8 h#,3*, -0)%(6N#, W*-0C,0)X %#%$G($ -#"3*, '$)6N#, %*
/()5$*5#1D * B!&C2* BD'(1.> :$# #)'*3(G* 0 /*60 #)3"# #1(,,0" # "#-#+30"> * B!&C2*
1Jacobson, R. (1961) Lingustica e teoria da comunicao. InLingustica e Comunicao, So Paulo:
Cultrix: 1999.
7/25/2019 A Querela Do Mtodo Em Psicanlise
6/13
-%B%-%&1(.,> :$# #)'*3(G* * "#/*670 %* 1#),*5#1 -01 0 1$)%0> * B!&C2* %;4-%$$(7.>
:$# ,*/(#)3* * "#/*670 %0 #1(,,0" -01 * ,$* 1#),*5#1> *B!&C2* "%'.,(&/!?$'(1.> :$#
/(5*;,# F "#/*670 * 1#),*5#1 -01 0 -@%(50> # '()*/1#)3# * B!&C2* 4*E'(1.> :$#
4*/0"(G* * "#/*670 #)3"# * 1#),*5#1 # ,#$ -*)*/8
O"*> *, -0)3"042",(*, L(,3@"(-*,> ,0C"# -010 /#" $1 3# )0 '$)%0 ,70 4*"(*6N#,
#1 30")0 %# 0)%# -0/0-*" 0 *-#)30 %* %#3#"1()*670 %0 ,#)3(%0D )0 *$30"
]+,(-0/05(,10> L#"1#)H$3(-* "01Q)3(-*^> )0 "#-#+30" ]#,323(-* %* "#-#+670>
*)3"0+0/05(* %* /#(3$"*^> )0 -@%(50 ]L(,30"(-(,10> -0)3# 0$ )* +"@+"(*
1#),*5#1 ]#,3"$3$"*/(,10^8 90%#10, 3"*),+0"3*" #,3*, *3(3$%#, %(*)3# %* +"0%$670
%0 ,#)3(%0 +*"* %(,3()5$(" 0 :$# 4#1 * ,#" 0 # )* :$*/
+"#%01()* * ()3#)670 %# *"3(-$/*670 %0 3# :$# 2 0 # 0$ %#
"##,-"(3* ,()323(-*> %0 3#'-G/,(1>H%(' # * I%-J%-B!&/]'0"*-/$,70^ :$# +#"1*)#-(*1 0C,-$"*, *0,
+,(-*)*/(,3*, %* ,$* 2+0-*8 B*-*) 2 3*1C21 $1 /#(30" %# !"#$% *0 #)'*3(G*" *
(1+0"3Q)-(* +0/=3(-* %# "#30")*" *0, ,#$, 3# -010 * K&'%-4-%'.C2* )*$
+*&>*$> * L$(1*4.'*,*/(. ). I(). M*'()(.&.> 0$ M>($'%$ % $!.$ @%,.CN%$ -01 0
U)-0),-(#)3#> +*"* 0C3#" $1* ?$,3* -01+"##),70 %# ,$* 0C"*8 P*1C21 *0 4*/0"(G*"
3# *0 3"*G#" +*"* * 0C"* '"#$%(*)*
%#,#)40/4(1#)30, :$# )70 #,3*4*1 #4(%#)3#, # )#1 #"*1 +"#,$1=4#(, %* +#,:$(,*()*$5$"*%* +0" !"#$%8 E,3# 2 0 -*,0 %* ()3"0%$670 %* )0670 %# ,(5)('(-*)3#> -010
7/25/2019 A Querela Do Mtodo Em Psicanlise
7/13
-"=3(-* %0 -0)-#(30 '"#$%(*)0 %# "#+"#,#)3*670 ]I*-$'%,,!&/^> %* ()3"0%$670 %* )0670
%# ,$?#(30> -010 -"=3(-* %* 3#0"(* '"#$%(*)* %0 )*"-(,(,10 # %* ()3"0%$670 %* )0670 %#
50G0> -010 #,+#-('(-*670 %* 3#0"(* '"#$%(*)* %* +$/,70 %# 10"3#8 E1 30%0, 0, -*,0, 0
-"(32"(0 *%03*%0 2 * )70 ()-01+*3(C(/(%*%#> * )#-#,,(%*%# #+(,3#10/@5(-* # * # #,3"*)L* F 0C"* %#
!"#$%> * ,*C#"> * 3#0"(* L#5#/(*)* %*, )#5*6N#,8
f#$)()%0 0 # 3#1.3(-*> C(05".'(-*>
L(,30"(05".'(-*> 3#)%0 #1 4(,3* $1 -"(32"(0 :$# 2D * 4#"%*%# %0 :$# ,# #)-0)3"* )0
3# W0"5# k*L*"> Xllm83
Lacan, J. (1954) @%$4*$'. .* M*"%&'D-(* )% R%.& ST44*,('% $*=-% . VI%-&%(&!/W )% U-%!)8 U) E,-"(30,>f(0 %# W*)#("0> W0"5# k*L*"> Xllm84Folscheid, D. & Wunenberg, J.J. (1992)Metodologia Filosfica. So Paulo, Martins Fontes: 1997.
7/25/2019 A Querela Do Mtodo Em Psicanlise
8/13
O -01#)3."(0 *3$*/(G* * /=)5$*> * "#-0),3"$670 -"(* L010/05(*, #)3"# ,(,3#1*, %#
#,-"(3*8
E,3# 2 0 1230%0 #,3"$3$"*/ :$# B*-*) +"*3(-* #1 ,#$, ,#1()."(0,> # -$?0 # -L*1*%0 * M.-'. @*!=.).> %# 3*/ 1*)#("* *
# %# 10%0 -01C()*%0> */3#")*%0 # -0),3*)3# $1
/#(30"> $1 ()32"+"#3#> $1 -01#)3*%0" # $1 "#-0),3"$30" %* 0C"* %# !"#$%> */21 %# $1
*$30" :$# %#,#)40/4#$ ,#$, +"@+"(0, +"0C/#1*, # ,0/$6N#, 30")* * *C0"%*5#1 # ,#$
3# *,
0,-(/*6N#, 1#30%0/@5(-*, %# ,#$ +"05"*1* #> -0),#:$#)3#1#)3#> * L#3#"05#)#(%*%#
%# ,$* +"0%$6708 M, ()\1#"*, L010/05(*, :$# #/# +"0+N# -01 0$3"0, *$30"#,> -01
a*" e#5#/> o*)3> W0j-# # -01 * 1*3#1.3(-* ,@ ,70 -01+"##),=4#(, F /$G %*,
%(,3()6N#, :$# *+"#,#)3*10, *-(1*8
c1 %0, 103(40, +*"* :$# * 0C,-$"(%*%# %0 1230%0 /*-*)(*)0 *()%* )70 3#)L*
+"#0-$+*%0 0, -01#)3*%0"#, # ()32"+"#3#, %# B*-*) +0%# #,3*" )* ()%('#"#)6* -01 *
:$*/ ,# 3#1 3"*3*%0 0 '*30 %# :$# B*-*) '0( $1 1#1C"0 *3(40 %* V0-(#%*%# !"*)-#,*
%# !(/0,0'(*> +*"3(-(+*)%0 "#5$/*"1#)3# %# ,#$, #)-0)3"0, # "#$)(N#,> *0 /*%0 %# K1(/#
d"2L(#"> B#0) d"$),-Lp(5> M)%"2 B*/*)%# # a*"3(*/ i$2"0$/38 U,,0 3#"(* +#"1(3(%0
#)3"#4#" * 5"*)%# *'()(%*%# #)3"# * ,=)3#,# 1#30%0/@5(-* %#,3#, +#),*%0"#,> +"0+0,3*
+0" T(-30" i0/%,-L1(%3 # 0 1230%0 %# B*-*)8
9/*30)(,3* # #,3$%(0,0 %0, +#),*%0"#, -/.,,(-0, i0/%,-L1(%3 %#%(-0$;,# *0
+"0C/#1* %* "#/*670 #)3"# -01#)3."(0 # ()3#"+"#3*670> +#"-#C#)%0 :$# #,3# #)40/4(*
$1* #,+2-(# %# +"#,,$+0,30 ,0C"# -010 0 3#1+0 ()-(%# )* 0C"* %0, '(/@,0'0,8 !0(
*,,(1 :$# #/# #,-"#4# ,#$ 0+\,-$/0 _Y%"4* Z0/(1* % Y%"4* S($'0-(1* &. K&'%-4-%'.C2*
)*$ +($'%".$ U(,*$0B(1*$`q -010 *%#)%0 1#30%0/@5(-0 *0 ,#$ 1*5(,3"*/ 3"*C*/L0 %#
5Lacan, J,. (1966):$1-('*$8 f(0 %# W*)#("0> W0"5# k*L*"> Xllm8
6
Lacan, J. (1955) O Mito Individual do Neurtico. Rio de Janeiro, Jorge Zahar: 2008.qi0/%,-L1(%3> T(-30" ]Xl[q^O @%,(/(2* )% L,.'2*8 h('#/> V70 9*$/0> XlnZ
7/25/2019 A Querela Do Mtodo Em Psicanlise
9/13
"#-0),3"$670 %* 0C"* %# 9/*3708 V#5$)%0 i0/%,-L1(%3 L. %0(, 1230%0, 3"*%(-(0)*(, %#
()3#"+"#3*670 L(,3@"(-* %0, ,(,3#1*, '(/0,@'(-0,D 0 1230%0 %051.3(-0 # 0 1230%0
5#)23(-08 O :$# $1 +*"#-# 3#" %# -(#)3='(-0 0 0$3"0 +*"#-# 3#" %# "(50"0,0> ,#)%0 *
*1C(670 %#/# "#$)(" #,3*, %$*, *1C(6N#,8 V# +#),*10, * '(/0,0'(* -010 # 0$ ,#?*> ,#5$)%0 * L(#"*":$(* %# *"5$1#)30,
:$# /05(-*1#)3# ,# -0)%(-(0)*1 $), *0, 0$3"0,8 h#,3* 1*)#("* $1 3#1* *C0"%*%0 )0
mO+ -(3D X[r8
9Op. cit. 143.
XrO+8 -(38 X[Z8
7/25/2019 A Querela Do Mtodo Em Psicanlise
10/13
'(1 -"0)0/@5(-0 %# $1* 0C"* +0%# ,#" "#-0)L#-(%* -010 /05(-*1#)3# ()(-(*/ 0$
+"(1#("0> *0 +*,,0 :$# -#"30, 3#1*, :$# *+*"#-#1 )0 ()=-(0 %# $1* ()4#,3(5*670
+0%#1;,# "#4#/*"> /05(-*1#)3#> \/3(10, ,#5$)%0 * 0"%#1 %*, "*GN#,8 U,,0 ,# %#4# *0
'*30 %# :$# -#"3*, %#,-0C#"3*, # -#"3*, )#-#,,(%*%#, %# # L(,3@"(* %0, '*30, #-0)R1(-0,> L(,3@"(* %*, -(H)-(*,>
L(,3@"(* %* *"3#> L(,3@"(* %*, (%#(*, 5#"*(,> :$# ,70 L(,3@"(*, # %(*)3# %# $1* %(,+*"(%*%#> %# $1*
()-0)5"$H)-(*> %# $1* 4*"(*670> )70 %#4#10, +"0-$"*" $1* #,+2-(# %# ,=)3#,# 0$
,0/$670 '()*/> 1$(30 1#)0, $1* L(#"*":$(* :$# ,(3$*,,# )0 '(1 %* 0C"* * )#-#,,(%*%#
%* 4#"%*%# %# ,$* 5H)#,#8 M, %('#"#)6*, :$# * 0C"* *+"#,#)3* -01 "#/*670 * ,( 1#,1*
,70 ,$* #,3"$3$"*8 V$*, %(,+*"(%*%#, %#4#1 ,#" *-#(3*, ,#1 *+/*()*1#)30, )#1
%#,-$/+*,> -010 ,# 0, #""0, %# ?$4#)3$%# '0,,#1 *+#)*, +"#+*"*6N#, +*"* * ,*+(H)-(*
%* 1*3$"(%*%#8
_]888^ * 1(,,70 ()3#"+"#3*3(4* %# $1* -*$,*/(%*%# #,3"$3$"*/ #)-0)3"*".> +#/0 -0)3"."(0 ,#$
-0)3#\%0 +"(4(/#5(*%0 #1 '*/L*, # %#,-0)3()$(%*%#, %#)3"0 %* 0C"* #> #1 \/3(1* *)./(,#> )*
-0)-#+670 %0 *)3(50 -0)-#(30 %# _0C"* %# *"3#` -010 ,#)%0 $1 3# 0$ ,#?*> %# -010 #,3#
3#
7/25/2019 A Querela Do Mtodo Em Psicanlise
11/13
%#+0(, %* %(,-(+/()* %0 -01#)3."(0> :$# 3#1 +0" 0C?#3(40 /0-*/(G*" 0, %('#"#)3#,
,#)3(%0, %# $1 3# *, -0)3"*"(#%*%#, #)3"# ,$*, )06N#,> 0$ * -0)3"*%(670 #)3"#
,#$, -0)-#(30,> +0%#10, #)370 ()3"0%$G(" 0 101#)30 %* ()3#"+"#3*6708 O$ ,#?*> 0
-01#)3."(0 "#-0)L#-# 0 -0)'/(30 )0 ,#)3(%0> * ()3#"+"#3*670 ,$"5# +*"* 3"*3*" #,3#-0)'/(308
e. $1 ,#5$)%0 103(40 +#/0 :$*/ * *C0"%*5#1 +,(-*)*/=3(-* %# 3#
%#4# #,3*" ,#1+"# +"0)3* * ,#" "#'0"1$/*%* +0" )04*, %#,-0C#"3*, 4()%*, %*
# 2 :$#
#/* ,# *,,#1#/L*> +0" 4#G#,> * $1 ,(,3#1* '(/0,@'(-0> *()%* :$# )70 '#-L*%0 -010 *
1#3*'=,(-*> 1*, #1 0$3"0, *,+#-30, #/* ,# -01+0"3* -010 $1* 3#0"(* %# -(H)-(*8 A*%*
1#)0, *+"0+"(*%0 %0 :$# -0)%$G(" /#(3$"*, #,3"$3$"*(, %# $1 3# +*"3# %# $1* ,2"(# *C#"3*> :$# )0, -0)4(%* * "#()3#"+"#3*670 %# ,(
1#,10 %(*)3# %# )04*, #4(%H)-(*,8
U,,0 30")* 0 1230%0 %# ()4#,3(5*670 #1 +,(-*)./(,# $1 1230%0 C='(%0>
-0)%(-(0)*%0 +#/0 -01#)3."(0> 1*, ()#"#)3#1#)3# 0"(#)3*%0 +*"* * ()3#"+"#3*6708
OC,#"4#10, :$# 0 1230%0 #,3"$3$"*/ %# i0/%,-L1(%3 0C321 ,#$, 1#/L0"#, "#,$/3*%0,
,0C"# ,(,3#1*, %# 3#
7/25/2019 A Querela Do Mtodo Em Psicanlise
12/13
1$)%0> 5H)#"0> -/*,,# 0$ #3)(* +*"* *4*/(*" *, %#3#"1()*6N#, %* 0C"*
]#3)0-#)3"(,10^8
90%#10, *50"* 40/3*" F, %(,3()6N#, ()(-(*(, ,0C"# 0 ,#)3(%0 +*"* "#-0)'(5$"*"
-010 #,3* #,3"*3('(-*670 )0, *?$%* *, %('#"#)3#, *C0"%*5#), 1#30%0/@5(-*,> +"#,#)3#,#1 B*-*) 3*/4#G 1*)3#)L* $1* "#/*670 %("#3* -01 0 0C?#30 1#,10 %# ,$*
()4#,3(5*6708 V# 301*"10, 0 3# # +0%#10, %(G#" :$# #,3*10,
+"(4(/#5(*)%0 0 $%&'()* ,('%-., # * +".3(-* %# /#(3$"*8 O-0""# :$# 0 ,#)3(%0 /(3#"*/
%#+#)%# %# $1* ,$,+#),70 1#30%0/@5(-* %0 3# 0
3# :$# #/* )70 2 -01+/#3* # +*"* 3*)30 "#:$#" $1*
+#",+#-3(4* *%(-(0)*/ :$# 2 * ()3#"+"#3*6708
!()*/1#)3#> ,# #)3#)%#10, :$# $1 3#
7/25/2019 A Querela Do Mtodo Em Psicanlise
13/13
* "#/*3(4* *$,H)-(* %# %(,-$,,N#, %# 1230%0 )* +,(-*)./(,# /*-*)(*)* 3#1 '#(30 *,
*)./(,#, %# 3# -$?* +"()-(+*/
-*"*-3#"=,3(-* 2 * %#,-0),(%#"*670 +#/* L(,30"(-(%*%# 3*)30 %0, -01#)3."(0,> :$*)30%*, ()3#"+"#3*6N#,> :$*)%0 1*(, %0 3#