36
Aprii 2008

Aprii 2008 - INTOSAI · .(iiij U«a j-jjl l.ia. jjj*M Jj\ J (JjVl Jj^l bijji.! J3 (UIJ fi*J r^^>VJ1 ' j*' liaJ—L-al jUa ( ^j JaU! UJI CjljU l JiU UJJ uil A^jjUl! .ij^l j.a aC-jl!

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    10

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: Aprii 2008 - INTOSAI · .(iiij U«a j-jjl l.ia. jjj*M Jj\ J (JjVl Jj^l bijji.! J3 (UIJ fi*J r^^>VJ1 ' j*' liaJ—L-al jUa ( ^j JaU! UJI CjljU l JiU UJJ uil A^jjUl! .ij^l j.a aC-jl!

Aprii 2008

Page 2: Aprii 2008 - INTOSAI · .(iiij U«a j-jjl l.ia. jjj*M Jj\ J (JjVl Jj^l bijji.! J3 (UIJ fi*J r^^>VJ1 ' j*' liaJ—L-al jUa ( ^j JaU! UJI CjljU l JiU UJJ uil A^jjUl! .ij^l j.a aC-jl!

^ j jJS ( ^Ull (rJljall iKuicj j i ^ U l j JJ IUJJ IC

a ^ j u i a jui i Aj£j i AAjiJ\ a i u i AnuAj, t > ^ j

^AAjJJ)i\ aJaJldlt Lljb'Vjitl i'';--^ j U

Ji-Ul l LWJJ

{ajl!>,Vl -DtoUt oLVjit) j^l_p J JIUJJ

j j j ^ l u ^ j i c U *

{; Si>.Vi sj^iJi obVjii) ^ u u .^ . IU

(5JSJJJVI aJaUl libVjJl ) j i j j l jJ j l i i jS

(jjJcUaJl (jjU,>*-*ll

( IU) ^ J i ( - l i i ^ i_uS-

( U l ~L;bi_j«VI) iJU, J i j l l i ,

I l*j_>j ~ (^bUJll jil£jiii i j j j j l

( U j i LJ fja - ( . j U j j U l 3_lj\jjS*jJ

IbJlUl icLajjjm fA jujA

\Ly^J') J " ^ LW*^

(!:ijj_jjaj j J j j j * tjjiui.ll t j j j j

( l*Ul) j^l-ijlJ^U J-cUil ^ U j U l

( AJSJJJH SJiiJl (ib-j/jlt) AiAJAii ai^UJt (_ijS„

SjlJf^l / ^UTrfl

(AJSJJXVI eJrUl tliLVjH) ( > U J b_>Jj"

(<!SJ.>-V1 SJaUl ^bVjit) j U J j j

^ U j j £ U J 'j*~ll (.yJUt f U:c-I

(JUJJjll (UidUtt fA i_dljail I jclj! iSi jjlljJjS JjJlJ ~

(Jjl ^.jiyJJ U^ 'l^^^y MJJ^ ' ^Ul (.r^^JI (^ifojj ij''^iji^ "

i i l U L J^ljJl ^ l j * l l ljl JAl i j ^ J j J j l j i JJ ' '4**!! J**^ ^ b l -

\\j ( j ^ j U l ^ ' ^ j * J t ^ J > J I

aLc- i j j f l t ( U u l l A j J J f r i l ^ ^ l ^ j l l A . ^ A A i J i M J I J i ^ J A L - n j j A —

JjW-ill i J i U I AjJJ^AAiJ^Jt i 4JUJS1 I '.< - i .Uil (_at_Jt i(^ l j^ j l —

lil jSll J Ja. £ j l i j l l JiiA i i - i j i j A (J41. J (JjU —

r U l (Ja-b i d iULU l <«S:k.A (JUJJJ ' i j ^ y JJJJJ! j ~

L jU ik 1 iljljl-uiaJl (JBJJJ I ( j . iU jS j b j l —

U l ' f J l U I J A U J f ^ i ^ l j * l ! ' JjS u ' j ' ^ "

Lj jS ( U^Ai^J ^ISjSl J A A iJt^JtijJA JJJS -JJJ -

AiA\ AJJJIJI J^JJAIU' 'VI-^' AAA,]JA\ jlt^ u^J ii^jUiUI J . -

. , U U t 3^1 ji.?^ I U U l

l y i j l s ^ ' "^i^jl i ' ''^ • o ^ j ' j j v ' j j ' j ^ LWJI ~

JJJJjll I f c i ^ i j a l J *J jS (>?.j ja. -

j_*j i j j l l j l ^ V I I t l lb j l^-JI I J A A iJaUJ liJiiUjiw ( j ^ j a j j l a j - i j l u —

( j i j j j j (jiuS ( 'i^lajl! . 1-' - o ^ J ' ^ J j ^ ^ "—^Ji ! ~

QjaUi A^iui (U>jll (^jiiLiii (-uU AUII jiiait 1 JJi ^ -

ijUilb 4..£.jjJ^\ SiaUl (Iljtj'Vjl] |iljJI LJiljJI ' J j t j j J tjJ^ -

;^jiaJl AJUI 4J13jU A^jiJ\ AUA

J ^ i JiA (35) . i M I 2008 (JJJJI)

a ^ j U l 4JUI A j l J i AJjjl l aJUl L A ^ J A ( 2008 - : ^Ult I J J A

JJUJ —;(C_jiM <^j jaLul ljlc- U j U l SjlUt j l i j l l ^ j j l l UaJI jiillJ

' (JjSfl ui>i j) j?j j^ ' ' { j y ^ ) j ^ j i ' ( U U J ) J j j f l ' ( I^IJI I u j j ^ )

(<jjU^lj i UjjJllj I AjjJSjytj ( SJJJJI (^UliU CIUJJQ j

u m i j ^ u 4JUJ11 l u i oj«;a.bu Vj-^ i 4.aiui ^ b ^ u v i j

i jLA iSliUll U«. j l l y U t j i a j j_^l aJUt (li..ijS jaj . (^jbjl jVt)

JIU J . Jj-jf,-.^l AJIUI 4.jl3jlt ( U b l j Lj l^l j^l (JAMIU C (^UJJJVI

.^Iji'^l j l j J j U l frb^j j tSi l j ftiji i j t l ^ J i l i t ^ l jV^Vl j ( i l j^ l

j l UnjJI jlaJ ( l i l ^ j D j j j U b QISJU V J ^JS ( j j i i ibU [j j^l

e.bj3/lj UaUt j j j lSj l l j ( I jVUb j J j U l d U j j i-J^jJ J . g i b U i

' . '"^ -.' aJ j^ jx l l J J J ^ l m S j i ^ t l ^ b j ) tJJJtJJJ (^Uoll ^ 1 ^Jl j J l

Ij^bll jljJjJl J c J i j a ^ i <a\A U U J I

u s Govemment Accountability Office, Room 7814,4410 Street, NW, Washington , D.C, 20548, USA ( Phone :202-512-4707. Facsimile: 202-512-4021, Email: [email protected]).

V j i i LUAJ ^ 1 (j'VtUl (jli ( u u obk <1UI ^tj^jiiiV t j k j j

J c iJLJl ^ l i j l i AJiaC U j > ^JU u t lilt J t UJJC. ^ja jiSl

J \ jlSaVlj i j LU i l Cj-VUt U l j j U j J l »^ J - ^ J ' f ^ ' £ l ^ l

J_j:k tUaliJ j l t A J U I ^^ j l t J U " i S Sjjia. ia-J b u (3l»JJ

^ ( IJVIUI JJ«J V J * tjft (JjlUt AJIJJIL U » U 1 *_JJJJ1 g-! jJ

CLJI ^JA-> (^ ^Ul l i j l j j i ! U I I OJSA'^I y/L> i j i t 5 i U l t J j J j

. ;_ij]l£j ^ l jJjJ ((.jU-JjiVI U i l o Jbit l j ( j jSjbi j (jjJllj ( fJUl

^3- jl www.intosai.org jjjS^i ^jJi J- LAA jjnj

[email protected]. ^ i U l

a ..ftii.all ajiiiJ (SJil ;jji.>K Jl (J«J^ i*i Ala-all OVli* ^--ij*^ I^J^J

. Sjlj'yi illLyAM j rj^ U I ;jJljJjjU]l jjJ-aUl (jJ.Il.ll 1 <lll JijAli

: Ajfljll CJIjUl j DjbaJI IJJVUII (_K»».? iy "-liUaji* J^J

Anbar Management Services, Wembley, England, and University Microfilms Intemational, Ann Arbor , Michigan, USA.

tf j'l-h all

2-1 ai^i kiAai\ 10-3 S j * ^ ' * u !

16-11 ^t-.^! I'^l^tiJl (diljjtU' Cii.y^ i^^ J^ 22-17 pUJt £iiaJt ^^ iAl j ; ! ! (OiK (i i i j j l

24 -23 a;(a.*Jlji«Vl a iU l yle fjJa AJIII 30-25 (|U>WI pUl

32-31 IDI *Ul 33 2008 f ^ j (^UjL-yi (ijlja.1

= i j j > - U -Sljall ' ^JJb_C j j t j j U — i l j JJIL . ^ ^ -U J I ( j l i j i l A.*is_o !_yMj I _yMja i_jjj_ja.jJjaill p U j j

\ j j ^ I fMJi U t j a l t 1 ju i l ja ^ U i

(JUJJ £ (libLjaJI i.a£ajJ i ^ j i ^ 5^_jSl ( (jiLSll S j j l i

Page 3: Aprii 2008 - INTOSAI · .(iiij U«a j-jjl l.ia. jjj*M Jj\ J (JjVl Jj^l bijji.! J3 (UIJ fi*J r^^>VJ1 ' j*' liaJ—L-al jUa ( ^j JaU! UJI CjljU l JiU UJJ uil A^jjUl! .ij^l j.a aC-jl!

JjsloJ .ibVI J jv^Ull QA S liLVI

Reflecting oh the Past and ^ Preparing for the Fiitiugp ^ jL

( J J U J V J (l'l t U l j j ^ ; '' ' '•' j j i j J i l l jU j l .Ijjt-j 4jj i. l j jaVI aA4 Jai. ' U l j ^_^.K^ J j c U U I b i l A"

i l l . ^ ^ j ( t ^ JS J i j VJ'. - ( G A O ) 4a.oj iJI U i U J l u U i j J j S j A S i j J i ^ S A Z ^ ' I

IJJ'LJ _ ; . ^ U ^ V j o j ^ J^iU j l £ G A O oW 1*^^ J ^ (^ 'T^JVIJ J U I l i iSAaUi ,1JUVJJ1

(1998 a'l c ' ' • - ' U t J U U '^:nc j ^ 1-j.i^.- 'ig-- ..>!J ^ i U i U V l U J A V I Ai l^ I J J U J ^ 5 ^

1-rt ''" a J \ j j i ^ j - i -^ l 'J!•>"") jA J j ^ V I - ^.'i^i j j j J U ^ J . j j , i - l ^^—lUil i_j j i i t U u L j

G A O 3 ; ' ' ^ ' l J a^ij l ' Jg *.- ;tjj g , . j j ^ j l i ^ 7T j n 'LLIU..; j J ^ ^ aY. J j j i a j j j^jijJ jS "" ''^ ''

Q . .«''..J t ^ic""i,.. all j ^ j k j j b J.I.--1 iiLA — 0 j U - o a j j . j n i j i g ii '.iA ' • ^ j L U " U A I I J - i3 • ""'"'"

i U j j u . A j J JJLI / J J £ J U J J - : G A O j ' - J j U t U ,j-lJ,l3 ( *\ jLJLl f c i_l3l j U j j l j j ^ J ! j j ^ .'..,l...'.Li

•i")\^ .t. j j J t j U J i J j U l -^Jfr*. y j J ^ j U ^ l - i ^ ' j_?^^ j 'h " I j J j t ^ ..liiS -lis ' ; J j . l i l ' ; - • -" i ^ j - l t j

^ 1 _L,jijVI U J i l o ,*-a ;.5-j§J^ j l i " U U l U j . 'U i .bUI i j j j t . I J I J U I J i U ^ U J J J V 'UaJ.o

. ^ L C I flljU ^_jil.g.j r ^ ' J ^ - ^ 3 _'' XB\ Q A O Jskl J t ^ L i

al C. wJ—-3^j.A^ ^ ^ U J J ' '"" '"'Ji~- b j j c 0 ,A .^'"v.^yl o.lt f - j j Ja JX ^_A ^ L j j i j J J i l < J a l o J t j ^ _ J J J U

jSj JUJ JUII JJJU

iZiLyjI! JJLJI AUJI LJIJJI

A_l J a U i L

' .^" '^ j u J L U C I J ..-j'l,^ ( i . jL iVj i l

.JSL

^ jkor- ^liij jUj JUIJIA.

^ j a U i U jL.^ 11 4 J U jSl j J j , ^ U J ^ J V U U - U j 1 ^ U (Uj j l l_3 A U U I U U ' L J U I

U J ] . ; KJt j >• I J L M j U ' i L -" - .,1 .IS j j a ' U l j a U l J J C ' J U I ^ y "l i 'w.a • _'• ••\- -'^ \.^"i\.^A

J A i J 0 •'"'! -"JT- J - J - ^ J J I > I - . I I ; j ' j C - j V l ( jJ.'i_l j' "J.O J ^ i 1.. 'l. U ^J-J.ILJ J a J j ' j l ^ j J I y

V J . ,_jU_9Jj!J ^. \ i4JI ^ u U J l ol£.b' i>l J J jjJ^>A J j l j S CJLLA L 1998 ^ U J.JUJSJV1

" A J £ Ai'yJaj j l j i i i U l i J j j U ^ J ^ J U i i c jJ^j*JaU'i ^ a l J U l i j j U L £ ^JAS l i ^ j £ i l J l j i

U k j U j j ^ ^ ^ j f l U l J j . i - ^ ^ - " SV'JLJ! " j - j ( ^J i AJ U U J I ^^-o-^ ^ "supreme" " J J I

JU . . ^ U J 1998 ^L^ y ^ U j i i i V i cj j l£ . ^ J U l ^ . < ^ j U ' u > ^ ' y ^ ' ^ ^ i c^-^ ts^J^'

j _ j i j j . ^ j - U i A—Ac J t , U V ^ j ^ ' U Jal ( ^ j i i J "^T^j L > j ' • ^ r ' ^ j JS l ^ U i j i ^ j *

'i £ . 1 ' j ^U.'./.'ii ail j l " ' .. a 'll Us ijjAUiJj.0 U ^Lil Aa!^ eioJ Cjl.cb""i->V' J t ^ jSj'^jlji

^^J jV^ A j ^ U J l j l j p JJS QA .UJt j-o - lU l U f ^ J 1

Page 4: Aprii 2008 - INTOSAI · .(iiij U«a j-jjl l.ia. jjj*M Jj\ J (JjVl Jj^l bijji.! J3 (UIJ fi*J r^^>VJ1 ' j*' liaJ—L-al jUa ( ^j JaU! UJI CjljU l JiU UJJ uil A^jjUl! .ij^l j.a aC-jl!

JJ—lc- «1—jjj (Lgl-ic. (_ijU!j giiiSjji. jlU laia cLuS jaa JlJ A-IJ . " itj JiUJ J AJLAA AMSA]

l.i__4 J U * J c jxSli J j c l V j ! j l (^UJJJVI CJJJUJ riliUaj J JC-Ut j l b] CJJJS Jfl3 (JiJ

.(iiij U«a j-jjl l.ia. j j j * M J j \ J (J jV l J j ^ l b i j j i . ! J3 ( U I J fi*J r^^J ' j * ' >V1

liaJ—L-al j U a ( ^j JaU! U J I C j l jU l J i U U J J u i l A^ j jU l ! . i j ^ l j.a aC-jl! ^ ^

. fiUaDjjt JJS Qa C j£ j j j AJ^JJIjbil A L ^ i_^Lii^n^\ (_5.l] .i^jJ f»JJjIj - (3^ 'UjU.a *UaJ.(i ^UaUl

<UJI j l i i l j uiali -illj JLiij^ljUyi ^JsUl J J I J U l A ^ UJJJ Q J \ Q\ UJ*UJJ J ^ J ^ <j)j

. CjVUaUV! O j _ ^ j ( (ji j U l J pba-Vl J ] J--a>illj (BftUl - i j ^ l j ' U j j U J I J^iU t>

y U Sj—-1 JjV (^J! j lS j cUatV! fJoAii AjUtjUyi <LUI ( ^ SialjJl L U Jaa (JlJl <UJj

Ua—jl i-jbUI AjajjI jUji^fl A u n i-...-.^ jSj .2004 ^b- CUuljj j J JLUJI J U J ^ V I j J > i

jJiJi—iJj (AjU^i—!| j__jjaj j ( jbJ l ^ l£ .a ^ J ^ j cS'-^J^'^' < £ j m i [ c * ^ LH^J^' jJa-jUI

(.JUJJJVI J C L_J^ 4-j1i ((CjiaJ 4 . ^ j QAJ . f i A c-Uil 2il£ ^^ CJLJSUI 3JtU.a j U i i j i^bVI

jjl j U j a j ( l^jiDliljjI J c J i l iJ l t4j|j USjlI J J ( i j^jal l oJi. QA fljIiUlU J=»,lc- JSU (e^UI

UjD .:ij,i-^j,ll ^ j j ^ Ijjjiiui CJJS jij .AJJJUJIJ (jiU Ua gjblJillj [jajj Ailc (jIJ j j ^ AJ

U J — u i V I ) Jn—Ul J n S A J J i x J l 2007 fpt l (ji-uiJS^i JAiJ:' (jC-jj-bjA ( J U J J J V I UJ j lU l

~l J.NA1 j ^ . i 1 , \,v ^ . '.A .1 , .1 »ll j l j j ,\a 1 ... I-V I aj j i l J1 IC .sll 1 a i (4-ulJJ 1 Ajlia q i—jl UJ'(L4 a A-llUI

(iUa—cV OJ—JUI j t i U l l j .0 J j j J I j j S j j i Li-aja j i j U i.s^lj ' L J U U I J i b i j j ^ • . . •" ^ i l j j i l j

. J J S U J I U L fU j j jV I

A—oAji U^jj t-^j^ j jV! [.jUjjjVl t-i-^.u.^l ( J1 jsVI Cy - ^ A^jimi j j ^ l J;^ j j

Uj__jJl JJLU OUI_J JJ^I JIJALUILJ UJSJ .JAC XIIJ Jl "AJ-UI UJ <bUJ| ojU!" UJIJU

J—uijjiV! C\ -^y^ U . "f^\ JjAi J JjLUl! " AA^ 'UJI jl jjl c^JlIj jjji-VI ^ iJjLUlj

y__i^ 1-1 jUL SJcUJlj frbVl i^ljj J ^ I j S ^ ij^ '^'•^ Uajill AJIJI UUI Sj^Vl ^^iAA

J j—J J 1^ [JUJI <J1|J1] JJI Sj^Vl t^UjiiV! JclU jl jLUl j-1 (AijaJl ^ j .^^Ui jic

Jjfl>" 1 j J j - l l l L5>U»11 t.y^ f».^l j * - ^ j ^ l (^} ' - ^ l J j i - a j l l ^ ^ J J ( j U l ^ ^ j ll^'S Jl^JUil

J^JIJ—cl ^j—!j ^ i U s ^ l j J • j j j J i b J I l^ j la j j j U J I C U . J-J J \ A J J l i ^ \ ( j j j j j « J I ^ U <U&

J J J S J — l l j A ^ J i U j a ^ i i c jJ.al j ( U ^ ( . J U J J J V I j j i ( Igj lr . c-LJI J S A J A J U I 4 , ^ a i i I j U l • J a i .

j j ^ l U l < u ^ Laj i_ iU:: .y i A U LIUS U .t- i l j i fcVl J l j (Ji-o Cf t ! *^ j b j c b u j U i j ^ j ^ i i - i j j j : ? .

i^—3 j ^ l ^ j Cy j U J J C j A J S J U O J (.1:JJI_UIJ ( A j> j ' l l _U iy i J a J i [.Jja aCJ j . 0 J-u)j.o Uuj^ ja^

J J — m l t ^ U j j j V I J J ^ j j r ^ ' ' o-l**-3Vl <al£ i j c j J j ] j .JaJjl l ^ - * . o j * l ^ T i o j J f ^ j ^ y i

iS^—i. j .0 U j l j a l *,My j ^ l LJl LS^ ' . " - ^i Cy J*-?-J l*^ 1 . ^ ^Ji?^ ' ^ ^ ' -U (_5JjJJil J . s u U l

.JlUl IJA

t#—") 't^^—"JJJVI <iUjJ j j j b l j ^ I j (_jjbUaI J U J j l j £ l j ( ( Ji-abo J U J JS J i j A i j U j i j

L)—* ^J-^l A^bUl . "'y " J (^Jjfa. 2-baljji ^IS-oj-j j j U j <j! (^-JJ ^ii'iblnll Cy ^ L S ^ j U I

j " ^ I " 1! i l i j?- W * ^ i U U . S J U J I a-ijU A^lajil A J J U U V I A U I J ' ^ J ^ A > ^ 1 ..I..,^\" J ! l i

j ^ j l .AJJ^UJI OSJJ^ J a£Uai. j j i jyj iSasjj j l JjJiil J J I dijl U I J ( iSxcJj -Uatjj-a J c

• f'l jjb Jji Jc (jUjiJVl JjaUo j j ^ UjAuS ( tdiJ ajU jjj .J^l (^gJc ^LaJI Sla

Page 5: Aprii 2008 - INTOSAI · .(iiij U«a j-jjl l.ia. jjj*M Jj\ J (JjVl Jj^l bijji.! J3 (UIJ fi*J r^^>VJ1 ' j*' liaJ—L-al jUa ( ^j JaU! UJI CjljU l JiU UJJ uil A^jjUl! .ij^l j.a aC-jl!

J U a U V I (J—?-jJ t b l l o j U j I j . 1 - ^ j ^ J

: j a jljUl Jc AA^L

E-mail: arint(a),tcu.gov.bt; Web site: http://www.tcu.gov.br

4 U I J S J J J A I U I u i ^ l j J l ijjusu

J J u . ^ i j U j j l I f l (2008 ^Ic J:.U J

— A — j j j ^ - U l ( j U j j . 0 AJJ -OJ I U C . ft LJJJ

U J U [ j t t -ai a J J j J S j l J J A U ) .v.nil J J J U

- U a j l ! j l i j l l ' . •"' • I i l c U l >oS A, iql.i x i

1 jcJjl—JJ ' ^ — ^ V j ejJS C l I j j .iSj .LiJ_^UV

j u C ajjiUll t . 5 U j i J j f l J A J J i J J . j b u J

(2007 t ^ l j jJ j* iJ J (J jw^ l J ja*Ul

J oC A C-JAAA (JUJJJ jJSjl JJJJ1\ TLltJi

j j L t j JJJIJ ( * U J ! ' '- j lsj l l J tti. [ j U ^ j j V l

a l j t j U A J ^ J A S J I J C J a i Q>\U". 5 .I.r-

.2010-2008

J U J V I , j - ? - j j Ajl-i ( C j b j l U l j j i . ^ j * l j

r^^Ull jljUI Jc jLj\ jJ^J </.<,,

E-mail: info(giriigikontrolLee Web site: www.riigikontroll.ee

^3Uk; ^ ^ j l j J l A J l j l J f i ^ i JI4UI

"^JUI 4jUk J j f ^ ^ 4J1^J11 ^ U J J

j j U l j j j j j l l f l 4 2008 f c JaU j ^

4 tS^.A ( j i u U J ( j l S nil [ j j i j j a j j J j J

Uj iS j i i w-oUjj s ^ h ^ j ' j ^ ' ^ ^ j i i

\ i i i ' l i a \g . iJ|l "i Q * L i J l A j b a . J 11? '«• - i c ,

j ^ •>• ^ I J U V I U J J U j . a |« j j i ! j L5J^O

( i lUi ^_^ J U J .AA<,^ A\ AAAJAI JbcVl

-^ • ••"' U j j j i s ( A X- . A\ j r t i ,> i C j i f t i j ^ y i

pui J c AAAJA1\ CjU^I A-iAA LU, J

( J j j j 7-JJ-3 («_<lUjj]l JL i j j - J ftJjJl *_o J

^ \ i j j l I l'l fli Jj j l b IJl AAJ U £ = U 1

j j q j ^ j "11 '..'"7- U c ( j U j ' '- j l i ( ^ U i i l

LJ a . j J U J . ^ I J j ^ l j f l j ^ ^ Jf iUlI

J j j j i II j b u j j i J a j J l C j U ^ p L c j p i - o l j j j i l

h 5_O1J4-__UIVI i j j ' " '• (jXuiaJJ ' ' U ^ J I

. 3 J U J 1 1 A X ~ . .

^ Si ( A U J I S J J U J I J l u ^ 1 AaUaVL i j

5 j l U l l J j ^ ( j—a '* o ^ a J l iJUg-uil

j j j 3 _ _ J ^ (C^J.^ 1 j J j U j l U c A-OIJOJUI

j a J i i A f j \ A j l i j l I U t J o a J

.(.jUjjjyij !jiiS±LUi j i \

J j . U <_. l3 j l3 L U x i l S j4 i .V l

( j j * - i £ j i J l j l ) J j w i S j j U l

^ oiajj U-l i < 2008 f c QA ' j ^ l

J j - n (TCU) ^ U i j l j J I ^ ^ I 5 j ] l

'L_oiaU '4 Uajjil AJJIJJUII I ' . " -'•"

j j U j U i j j j ] A j i i j i UUl 0 j ^ V i

UiU d jJ ('UUiVl.J ' j j * ^ j : j J l j l I

j j tuJU J j j iS j j J I U j * j j . Ul j iu i

^ rt\.^ .. I "* l'lir. . ^ fl . L I .^^.^ l l £ ^ VJLOJ!

J ^ j j J " ' J ' . ' j i j J J ' ^ ^ j ' j ^ l ^ l ^ j l l

<L—JaUI a-Ma !Jj . uJ—JiJJ ' j / ' j ^ '"

J j U j U l J j j ] <JUJ1] UUl o j ^ V !

J ( j j — U - j V l j ( J J j l j J I t^ i ' J

( M J J J - U J ( j ^ l j — C j j l l j ' ( ^ I j C j V !

*• J j j j j I j — o i l Jj j j i£__)JI c -U ja&l j

. , I * • •' ^ q I * 0T \ QJ

( j j i u l j "UJSUJI I 4 J J 1 J J £ U I f - ^ - ' '-"• j

J j l _ U j J''! .''"'"" j j l — a J ! •JajU_jt

U J C U U o l l j ' " ' t j . ' ' - ' I J L I I I — O J I J U I

Q i — l j A j ^ \ i . " iq l i> i—ul J—a J .A.—jiill

2000 1—c j—o A J U J I AjjlIi jSJt

. 2007 fc JA

J^j '^ l i AAJAAA j l j j j J i QA Ai=^i Cy -^-^i '-^ i ^ J 3

Page 6: Aprii 2008 - INTOSAI · .(iiij U«a j-jjl l.ia. jjj*M Jj\ J (JjVl Jj^l bijji.! J3 (UIJ fi*J r^^>VJ1 ' j*' liaJ—L-al jUa ( ^j JaU! UJI CjljU l JiU UJJ uil A^jjUl! .ij^l j.a aC-jl!

, ^ V \' J li ^ * >*> i l l A \ \ \ [ \ M i\f^ 1 n ^ J2 ^ rt 1 \ I J ^ ^ h ^ c

^j j j_L- iU ^ !yx.ls I j j J Q \ J J U I L _ U J S J

^ \ , 1 ^ . Q * L j J j i j l ^ I • . ll . I I >1 j j a-cj A - i uJi

j j jUJ \ a^C I iuil l^Jajl L>*^ j .'LgjJa-o

A ob l j l n U ^ j i i j ^ V I J J S *jla! j ^ A J U I

.^lijilj SjUil' JJjj J

M,n\l ^'-^ • " 1^ '^ '• Jaa (^^JJJJII ij JJ. IUl ll Jic J

j ^ ' ^ j ' i -^'l J U J J I U A ^ A J J - J U I ^ I j

j l i Jai ( ^UjljVl j-o-^j -aJ^iUI J::)!

A J U J I j j j a c j ^ . j - l i i J l l >jiJ.r> J J I j jJaC

A__ic, J l J-JUJI _S I ojJaCj cLiJ^JI i-uUojl

^ j i . i j _ : j j .^IJ_Jl!^n . I J U j U J U L A i l U I

JJ lc AJUJII JJ^ jUjijVi J-oC- Ac JAAA

j j j l _ _ i j ^ "'- J ( .Jj! o j L U I I j ^ j j j j ^

J 1*11 iSJc j.aA./s J . j i J o t j A j t O U i j U i i l

Q\ ' A ^ \ J ^ U U J J U J ' U J I ^ l ^ J j l J j ^

l_Jajl ^ J J J j J l j . ,_>a lU l j ^ U l pUa i l l

1 ; l . l l S j - * ^ ^ J ^ V l U U J I b b U o i

. (ASOSAI) .Ujil

^ J:U " • j - ^?^J - ^ ^ b - ^ J

JJ-Lul ^Ld * ^ J ^ J - 3 - 1 ^ - ^ ^ ^ ^ - > • '- isVl

. J j i j U U a U j - o ^ U i * j l j V i J iJJA. i

• . i"* ' • J U U V I J ^ J i k ^ b j i j U i Qa JJ j j J j

: U11 jljUl J c ^Ul JiUI J Ul j*ll E-mail: oaixiaicsux.iioy.'m Web site: wwv^'.cag.gov.in

. 'U_JJJ^V A ijj] A_i\Aji J c ^ i j 'd-^ii

J J J U UJJJJV ^ J J I ,_fficVl j L j - J l f^ jSj j

f J ~ ^ j ^ ^ ' ' . = j : ^V ; ^ j J j a ] l A U i j l

J—J j -o i 'i—T.Jiri^ ^ 3 B J U J I ^ V l A I U

, A J J J I I j j j J l j i c j U l j J l i i j V !

j — 0 t j j a j j i l c3=J^ Cy ^ ^ j ^ a j . : j c J S j

. : U ( G A S ) 'i i b < l j j i A j i i j \ j j ' ua . : i

U L I ^ J ^ fljl.^ J ' i j_>Jj.o ^ 1 I j U a j

JJ b AJJLSJ J L O C I .'t'o'i'i' j j . o j a j U j j i j

j U £ j . u- j i i i i A-^ jV i j ^ v i j -

^1 AUS j:iu > J uu ^ui u i ^ i

iU—a. JS (>AjU JJS JUt jjjiJ lfi-s-?-j

^ L ^ ftiji jjijU^ f j l ^ \ i j j j ^ Jc

U A j j j j l U U i J c A U i U J \ j e ^ j J i

j j — U C J ( i ' j U J A i I j j j ^ j l j ( G A S )

•j-"'i a'i , t a_u Ajl Jjj l i-'ii'"' "jU LA OJA ( a i 'i I '

j J J j j U l l Lll l i^>i. j r f , J j j J l » b l U J l

. l - jLjal ^ j J AjLaj i l U U l S j ^ V I

) J U s j i f i j , . ^ JJ u lL lb j l xJ l j - o i l j J ^

i^Ul! jIjUl ^ (GAS)

Fax: ++233 (21) 67 54 96,66 24 93 E-mail: [email protected]

^

AJ.U. >l£. iJk\ J - * a j j « - i

1 o b ii2J.cj 1-^lj.o J J JjJja J A J I j J C

J U I JLOJJ . 2008 J^j j j i iS J j i ^

a'—Jtli p I kaJI JAjJa d ju j i j U J l i ^ 1 J

C j b A _ ^ ^ J j . J i ^ J U ^ I j ^ J ^ ^ l

( J U ' J U J I ° j ' j _?^ r"^ 0 : ^ A A J U

t - L J ^ i ;b l r y ^ V o V u-J J ••,il' . U _ l j ^ U . A J U I L I J U U I

j _ _ « JJ *J I J J J.0 'CJSJ . j t i .oiJl J l j t i j j , l j

^ ^ \r,\\ A llll U _ l ^ ^ U ^ ' ^ U l

1 1 J J j U i l l I.II V

(IDBl Ujj ( ICICI UJ J ^:jJjAi\

( oLUI J c j x a U j A j J j ^ l A_i..tt*jijJl j

Qyl\ ^SLi <i\ljll ;_^Vl jl^aJl

LjijV ^ji ^bJl <JI^jJ! ^Ufl

.bUl

U (2007 1 - ^ ' -j j j U j ^ ^

^ ^ ^ j i . - j — s i j j i ( j i j > o j j ^

- J j - j i ^ ' ^ l * j : f ^ ^ '^JrHyV ^ J ^

j a j _ J ^ J l ^ j ^ J ' - ^ j j ^ j U c . 1 I j J

i j __ j j a ^ j A i a U l J.O j ^ ' ' " ^ -'.'I ' J•"•'r-

1—ib A — I j J J ^ U j l l J j b j i J c

^ < - o J i A j l i j l l U * ^ 1 ( G A S )

Sj&' in -11 J ^ l > ( G A C L ) ' - J A J J V

.-^1 v\fl n 4^^ CLfclj-a jJ M1 a j JLAC- ' > a " , j

. U j J i l V <J j J ^ U O J S J I

^—a A — o U I A j ' l j j l l . ^SJA. JaJlS j 3 j

j'u-nJi ,,p-^j ^ (GACL) Uj^V

i.lj^^>*.-i JS U J J J J V A J J J A - j ' t i ^ . j l ^ ' V l

J J JxjJ .Jj fi^ij ^ulifcVi S J J ^ ' L C ^

I I I J . ^ , ^ 1 . 1 n-S. L 1.^ . ' \^^jU . 1 . ^ ^ ' • . 0 1 ^ i j

CLiuoJ—iil • ' "^ - Jl SJUJ j . ^j b e

J'.—>>i J o J ' L U O U i - j j u u A j j ' i j i l

^ j L _ — J l _^ i t A J J U J I I ^ I j J l J J S J J a_oVl iJllUUii^ Q^^o ''"'; ^aU ..." l..;-.. , 5 jll

(IjUbi ^ j I ab 24 'iJ tl oSiA^lA

U j j L.1 OJ i i c o U U j j s V l j ' U V I

o j l j ^ J UlC- 'ijl - - ;t.-o '• J. - I l l IJ . U }fij

A J U J H ^ J A C V I j l ^ J I 3 U Jaa 2_aUJI

j j s a j o • -T^ j - ^ ;_s * j * W U U j u u

.2006 ^U

L5—^J '^s—"TA^V' j j ' ^ 1 j>- ^3JiJ

\ J U I " j a ^ y i j - -' J J J U I -Lifcj

j l — j U l ( j a t j ( ' U j a I • • - i j i l <jU_>li

jjJl jj ^U ^ UU AJlji Jc^i

j j - j j j V l A j ^ U J l j l j j J J i j * A U J I j . 0 j U l 1J4 ^ j j 4

Page 7: Aprii 2008 - INTOSAI · .(iiij U«a j-jjl l.ia. jjj*M Jj\ J (JjVl Jj^l bijji.! J3 (UIJ fi*J r^^>VJ1 ' j*' liaJ—L-al jUa ( ^j JaU! UJI CjljU l JiU UJJ uil A^jjUl! .ij^l j.a aC-jl!

lU jdS^

ijlijlj Jc'ii JI4UI •iJ.la^ U^J C)i^

iC ^ J a 'Un iuU

ejj.ujl I " ^ V| [<."...• I j j 3 fl . LlJ q^^A A^ J WJ. .^^ i

Jb la. A j l U l a j l j j J ' " I A C ja ' U U U

j J . nf"'.!! J A j U j i i a J ^ j ^ j - j j j •• -'"•' •'"''- •••

i__lUUj t A j j S j j l ja' j t j l t ^ J J J U I O j j l j

.A oUI A i i l j i l A J U AJUJII oj jb ; j J j

i j l j j j ojl i J I o j l j j . —S Uall .""ibcj

A a.jJ m U j j U ftJjiiUI U I J . i j . AJ'LJijll

A «_oU j 0 jb^a-UVI ^—a ^ j J j j l lSJ l

Sts.Cyril and Methodius in Skopje

.1989 j.b

' i '^ -1 j l . XYy\ ^ ^ ^ j j O b j U J i JLo J j j J j

: ^ J 1 j t j U l J c Aijjll AJUJ

E-mail:[email protected]. Web sile: v\ wvv.dzr.gov.mk

J ^ J J U 5-«Ujjj j ^Uid J k j j U j jwU j j

L

J' :• -. ^ J jV i , ^ j ^ - ^ ' ;T-oLjjjii J i t

.UU LT^J

Jlj»^

R-aUjJl jflTl

2007

AjUjii j l 1^ j ^ .2007 U j : i 'u

i i t J- 230 ^ J J : QA J \ J ^ \ SJIUI

(J—^ ^ I J J U J ^ I j ' - e * j : ! > ^ U J ^

,3—J J—a J . j i j j j j l J c ^j-aljj ^.Ai'iU

j j U s J l Q^LA .QA ?t.oUjjll IJA JjJjJ

( B_.__aj.oj obu i—jui

Uuijj£ J i i ib jJS JowJl

' I, --'I"' - - ' • • ! ' b u a A J J U I a j l j j -3 -Jajl

I ll V '.". 1' AJJA j . ^ fl 1 g '1.' 'LA 'OJC A-.OLA

.AUajll

<UlijJl (.^J^J U . ^ J:^J j ^ : ^

_}u U J - J j j l j j . o j *• A l J l j j c

U U j . 2008 : J ^ J J U A AJUJII

Ijj^if- ljJ.aU J jJ l j l £ • '.--"..'ll I j ^ Aji_^

j j j l ill A JS ^—a IJU ut UA;! J -»& j

f C j Oj .IjlJ ^ U a U . J j l-kUiVlj

^-a'JjJ KA

-a UUJI 5-oj£JI Jio 2007-2004

. U j J 11 J jSullj J^Jjil jJjUa J y "

J c JU^U^l J ^ J i ( I jb jLUl QA J J j J j

: ^J I jIjUl

E-mail: [email protected] Web site:wwA\'.jbaudil.go..jp/engI.

J . ^ 1 ^ ^ U j i l 'JJl 'a>?.Vlj

.A—jii^t ^ _ j i l ' Jc o j f r ^ l j ^ ^ j J !

jnJua • ' Xj\ . ; j j .^l -a.'jj .JltA..7i ja j

AJU C J U I J J J ( U j y i Ablj (jiJail

JJSJ -U IJ I J U U I J JJili Aa iU, J ja .

AJISJ J ( U b j L U l '_ia.jljjSj J'-a_o »

.*1JVI

j l , XTy\ ^ ^ JJ ^..IjLojUJt Qa J J j J j

j l j __Ul ^ — b A j lU l AJUJI! j l j JJ j

: U11

E-mail : bsairaq2@'vahoo.com Web site: vywv\^bsairaq.net

4.J1^J1I ^ jJaU J ^ ^ i j U j U i ^

' ',—"•> U i j j s jSift j j ^ ' j • -'i J u

15 s—3 tj-'-^'^l AJUJII jiil>.fi j ^ j

j j L - ^ j A \ ; i . , 11 'Oli ( 2008 I=IU

;j—a Aji-o io j ^ jic'jL Q A l £ j U j l

i j jJ " J j j JJS j . Jf-ill J IJ AJI JJ

; a . ' • " • ^ • j . ; * ' ' ' • •ill j ^ ' ' • - * " ' - . l l

j j j '__£ ^)Ul Jio U j l l ; J J I U J ^iUSj

JS ^jUUU AaUll J^j .2006 Ji^

f -li jJ—oVI J c U * . ,L...l'lJ U-S^ "^

J- iCj .<il j j j i l ^'il> ^ A j jU jSU

( J j j V l A j^bUl j l j JJ J i Cy A-laUt Qa J U I 1J4 j J 5

Page 8: Aprii 2008 - INTOSAI · .(iiij U«a j-jjl l.ia. jjj*M Jj\ J (JjVl Jj^l bijji.! J3 (UIJ fi*J r^^>VJ1 ' j*' liaJ—L-al jUa ( ^j JaU! UJI CjljU l JiU UJJ uil A^jjUl! .ij^l j.a aC-jl!

k J l j l J c ^ \ j l f U l ^ ^ U J O J I A ^ J

^UaftJl j UaSlUl J j j x j ( J j f j ^^.uJjJVl

^jSJl f»l\

(2007 J ^ c j j j * ^ j ^ c> (H1 j l l i ' j j i l ( ^

A JJJbil Aj j iaj l ! AJUJI I DJJIJ j * JS * i j

iajSj—a U y j j j j l Ajjj^-aaJ AJU j i l j i i i y f j

J _ J j . ^ U l pUaall J c AJUJILJ C^AJ ^ l i j

Jo—Ul J J U S A AJJIA J U J J I I Jaa t i j r '

J• ' ' f- • . " l " ' " ( . JUJSJV! J ^ ^ JUXJI JJS

i U l A^UJV! ^ ~ l j j J ' '- • . ^ j ' j j ^ -•° U 3 j j

A J J J I U ! O J U J ! Jbc-V l j J l i i l L5J1I j ^ j b

xjjjl JjJl ajUuij ( Ju 11- JUJIU AJjJ.0 J

"•I ... j U U i AULO ^ j^ j j i j j j j jVI j J J !

j ' I>• I ii'~j'' ij o Uj'vi (jA ojsm oJij

j J i j J !1 J4J c u (_gj]l j j U J l AJUJI jUal

U—JJJI Qj—ui i_JjJia a.al J U J I J JAijjJaJl

. (ASEAN)

j U _ ^ U l J.I1KJ U j j o i ( o j j U J l aJ& ' . n A j A i j

Jl a-0 J Ua (_j4JUJjJjVl j L j J I j (.5jJUI

. ( U U I J v ^ j ^ l j ' fLJl £ ^ ^ > i s ^ <J^j^l

J—iC (OJSJ ail aJ A Jj2^ J r ^ j * ' ^ Lff J

j j jiol (.5J-41 j U J j J I U j j l U j»UI t - i l j J I

J J U U B J £ J _ U 1 a JA J J « J J U Aiol j c i j U

i j ' i -•• j.(i j j j l j j i l j j j Ul_^>jiJ!j ( j b j U J I

ll J.OJJ- " J J

Inis I^SJI JSJ -SiJJ j^ l 2-" l j jJ l j ' U j U j l l j

j l j .0 j j U i l ^ U ^ JJV 'Ul J c j j j j U l l

.'UJJ__>JUIJ AJJJ ! AJUJII Uajy

A ll0j't fj'^y '• f j an j j j * j j j j j jU J j j l JJJSJI I

S J S J - — a j b _ j a j j J J ^ j j - a U u j j j j i A J J J

J a (_g a la—aa ft^ 111" j l U j * u ( i l t aAUj l l

*/i L.i'..., \ ft \ \ \ n , ' L U J U ^ J J A ^ i J i j i J l ( j S b ^ J l

1^ IcVl J J U I ( JIJJA f i j p - Ulc J U ! J

IJ 1 uIjJI JJajJl jJjUll A j ^ QA

( « ^ J U I A J U O ^^^JC Jaia ^L.oUjjiI jjyUSJ

A__JUJ]I 'Uaj l AAJ^IJA (_JJ1UIJ (aj&boj

j _ ^ a JJAVIJ J J U b j l v J l ba j J j jS j (_5ic

U l j__ j i J ! J J U A J U U J a^uul jaa tiilJ

A j ' . j .- Jlji^ul ASJJI ^ . . J . ..rij C j b j U J l j

j j j - i a ^ J ^ AlXjSa 'Li j . j j S j U i J I j j J

|")l ^ J"7- " re ^ ' ' .S jUU l j U j j J a U J !

(AJUJI U U I J J (jiaJU Ajj i jUa J ( ^ b l l !

p_alj J CJI—ajjUl j j S j U U I XJJOA jaa

i")! '••iy J X A QA JJJJlUiI ^ I j i U U (JJ^Jj

.AjLaC

(1 j j j j b J -^Uyi Cy C)^3i^^ J l i U J

1 j j J b j_j ic J—JSI j j S j U U l U j j ( j

j S b V l j * i J J U ! o j U j J ^ U j . i i L ^ l £ j

j l J j j S j L U I Jjia J j J j J S J J J .A.ol^l

,A..oja U j j i j ( J i jUo j 3 j TwUjjJI

j__S A _ A J J 1 U I Cjb—ajLUI U a j i j j S j

j .0 SJiall J::kS. AUaj i l AJUJ I I U u j i s i

. 2007 f c Cy J ^ j j j ^ 30-19

j j j j U _ J l j A J U I j j S j U J I C.U JSJ

((JJll—OAUII :A JUll J j j i l j - 1 JS j..a

(j^—''J J J * j l — J J i J ( ( j i b i i U — i l l j

(JJ ^•^J (1 " -JJjJ.alS J ( JAj-a i l j

A—JJjj.ifiT. J ( j U i a j l S J ( b u u j j j j i j

( U j j j l b j ( A J J U Sl Ajal ja j -aj j l l j V

( A J J J J U I A S L U I J ( J U J J ( (JOJJJUIJ

( J J U J3J .aUbsj ( j i L U j ( I S i V j ^ j

j__c 1'' IJ > • . 11 j U a U U j j j - i a AJil^

^^Uc ^ i l j i J U a - o ^ ^ (»*Jj lU

J j J l QA j S aj^j C j b j U J l b^ jJ j jSJ

l__iaj l j jSj j U . :u„a ( ( ^ j j U j j a .

i ^ j j 11 Uall j j U l l i ^ j l U b j L U !

i . j \ — U j J I ( U a j l l (josUl IAJSA J

U b j — U l JJJ.0 ( j J ^ b jJaJ l j J j J l j

( i jujAoji jS a j j I j Acjny.n] AjjLuUuV!

^ OPENING CEPJnUONV 0 ? THE

IT AUDIT COURSE (MTCP)

Welcome

IP

kJljl 5_wjjlii j liSJJl CiUjkJl Ua.j]_jJSj Js- ^ilji g-aUjj j QJSJLAA

(_j-iJjV! A A J J U J I j l j J J J i j ^ AiaJl QA J U I IJa f ^ j J 6

Page 9: Aprii 2008 - INTOSAI · .(iiij U«a j-jjl l.ia. jjj*M Jj\ J (JjVl Jj^l bijji.! J3 (UIJ fi*J r^^>VJ1 ' j*' liaJ—L-al jUa ( ^j JaU! UJI CjljU l JiU UJJ uil A^jjUl! .ij^l j.a aC-jl!

j i j . A J X J S J I J J I J J I I J i j - 1 Aj j ! j -J l J U j

*-al j- i j 3 j j -uV J U J I IJ4-J jjj ' i j*»^ll s j ^ j

A \ jS j j l q A J U J I [ j jajj lI ' " '1 'QJ AJLOC

,ilJl jjiajJj a-lia. AJJJJ^ JIJJI j j i j

J J U a iiV! (.s^JJ U b j l U I j j i JJ j J j

:^^Uil j l j U l J c J l = j \ AJUJI I .US.0

Fax: + 86-10-6833 E-mail: [email protected] Web: ww^^^audit.gov.cn

A J J J X ^ I AJJJXJI ASIAAI]

ISJAA AtUUl j ; ^ ^jlijU ^ ^ 1 jL^aJI

£>iiii

J. l ' ' j A iScll j * ^ A.0UI .^jJl |_lUo ( J ^ ' j

A__ijj«Jt A_S1UI ^^ -^ A A \ A A i l j J I ( U i o

j1 jSi J X U J I I ( J j i . 11 ll ^ U U V I A j j ^yU!

ja J . 2008 JaUi jgji J J^A1\ ^^JJAA

Q 0 ! J J _ C ^1—oiaVI J j j S j U U l (jiaU

^ 1 ajl l J U U A £ U I C j l j C J U J A ^ J J I

CJU—L-ajj i l j U j l J i l l j j j U j j j u a j JAWJ

J ) \ T1 A-oU-o '"f l^ ('1.0 jbaJI j jS-J j AijflSil

j l aJ J J S ^ J f J3j .a<iUSjI J AJ lj -ill j - i

.CjUtajl l l !J CJIJI JSJI j J j j AH-JUJ

4Jj.^l Jj^.iJl ^ia^i j AIjLUI

ASJLUJ !J3J Ajfiill UUl JJJI ^^UO C>*I1 jj

^ .,qr- JA jijt a_uiUll (.JUJSJVI JoJ^^a J

f^_c j—« Ji^ jy j*^ js-i J JJUJI J

U a - j l Ajiall j u I j J 'UJj JgUl J J .2007

b U J I sj__fr^Vl * . b ^ 3 j i J ^ J U I ^ U u V l

(J 4 J (J—UiJ I j j U l l IJAAA J J J I AJU j i l

A S I U I J t j i aS j ( j b c - j (CiJjSll j ( jJ ja-Jl)

A__Jai ( j o if-JA C J J U J I aJA '" '1^ ' - j i j

-2006 JU i I "< .sli J .*<-- j j j U

I.. lis 1 f'-jij U J U I l^jajAJ J n i j ( 2010

U j b U j j j A iji ( j j j j i a j j J J J J U "S-JUJII

.A j jU j i l J l aC^I SJJ2I. j U ( U AJUJI I

' " 'I .'I I-"'" Ujail ( J A J I AJai ( j l i U j A j j

C J I J — U I I J A_jJail J U J I Ajlajll j j j U

j — 0 J -_ j j J ! r t J yi iS^ i Cy ^J -^1

j j j -1 a j j A JUJJI A \X\\ J C CjIiUjajll

.Igjjl iS J l ^ j a .

C J I J — u t A—LAXA ( J J J 11 j x u U ja j

j - 1 A J j I j J ! Jjajj AjLaC i3^"^ iS^ AJJJJSJ!

.A J L U I J AJJSJJI AJ-IJSUI j j l j j i l J i

. I i l l • ,il 0 t j l J A I ^ l ^ ( Ja i j j j I ( ^ i j J q -.. ,1, q

j l — J a V I iJAu^ J JJa- j j ( ( j j aJ j l ! J b c l

JJIJJII CJU j l J-1 ci^*^ Jbcl J (jsmii

J .AJIIA A I U C J U I J J J A J J U J Aj-ijSaJl

Jjlj__ii a J.M r. U <UI J j i U l l J J U J J

[ j^Uio — »l_iUjll ' U J IAJJUJI ClUJA.^ ttJl

(J—i j - 1 AJ j I j J I JuaJj J c AJUJ I I J b c l

j J j j ] J I J C ^ I J f U U I — Ajj jSaJl JJ I JJ I I

JIJ__C1 A _ U C ( j i j J — U U j l I Jbc 'VI

—A__j j l j j | '"ll • — • -T^ 1 i j i . ^ ~ " O j l j J l

(Jjl iaJ (jjaj__j - A J LJUV ! iCiLaaJil [ j i J j

K L aUSI J—JC J i j i l i j jaJj — p J J l U l

S j j J , < U c ^ ^ U j l l J b c V l - A J J J J U I

^ J _ J — A J J J I J i QA A S J I U I J_ji-fflVI

f j j i V l A U J JVI ( j j a j _ j — C J U J U J I

-C i l j j i J i j A j jU j i i J J J U J I I —JJ IJJU

I'llajn^". - J J I J J U Ajj iUii l C J U U U I ijjaJu

A J U I Ajpbi oJlj — A i ^ U A JJUJ

AJJS JJIJSI U a i o j j U j i j — j j i j j j i i i n i t

(J U a j A JSJSJ A j U j l l j i a l i-a ajjfl'j

j j .0 Vl [ " l l l i «i- l l- C l b TI-* " l l ' I-, J J S J

J... AlA j j U i aJcllJl j j j j j j iU J Uaj l

J a j U J I U j j i J l c-jjJa J A_k-aU

L_lj ia jl__ajV a j J ! S j U i i l A iU- i

(J_U ^jUI Aai .j=yU .Uijjai J j ^

j _ j j x j IC—a O J S J J I a JA -- ••["i I. flj.i''^

1 jJl p l iaii! ( j 3 S J U j l l U iSUJl

•LSJJ-^V!

JUUVI i f ^ J i t C j U j i x J l QA A J J J J

: JUil JJUI JC

E-mail: [email protected](@aud it. gov .my Web site: www.audit.gov.mv

4jjtni1i Qjfi^\ ^JJJj *J

* j ^ ' ' AjLafi (JJ&J J j & J J J J J ^ - ^

Ua^jSaJl j J l j J l JJS j -a ^ j J l j J l

'...uSn aU (2007 j i ^ LWJU J ^ J

jjj-fl—11 A—jjjg-oaJ j l = j II A J U ^ I

(JUJ JJ^ JJVI JJJ! j*-ijj j i j ^ ^

JJIJJ ii (J—i j-1 AJjI j J I JUJ AJU-

j_^jl i U I f l j i j . ( j i i U l J Aj.i l jSJI

(UljJl (UU JJU Loja ?tjj-al JA (J\A.

j i ^ \ ( j U j i i <jiSji i l U S * J ^ u i

A—ajLi A JUSJ ^1—J! u-ial j J I U l U j

.JJjil

j i l j j ja [JjjJi l j i TTUJI p j j i i o j l S j

U j ^ j l S j .2005 f l c ^ a AJ J U l

A—aa.Ull CJ I j U I L>* a j U U V ! j A Aio

^ —k J u rt 1! t j Ja j i l AJUJI I U S J

CJI J j l j J I t3iJ=J AjLaC J c AJUJI !

j — J j j J j A—JjS jJ ! J J I J J U ! ( J i j - 1

I l y i JJlU J i i ( . I J U J J U J I J J J J U J I

. U /gJc ^U* J i r j j JU-Vl J IJ

^ _ ^ j V l A-luiUJl j l j J J J i j * A laJ l QA J U I IJA j*^JJ 7

Page 10: Aprii 2008 - INTOSAI · .(iiij U«a j-jjl l.ia. jjj*M Jj\ J (JjVl Jj^l bijji.! J3 (UIJ fi*J r^^>VJ1 ' j*' liaJ—L-al jUa ( ^j JaU! UJI CjljU l JiU UJJ uil A^jjUl! .ij^l j.a aC-jl!

Jji] • .• - l l j . 2 0 1 0 f c j - s j>J u l i j j U V I

JJSJ J aj Jaa ( C j b j l U l aJA U c J J I J-I*. 11

1 ^ JIJ—L-aj J j l ^ - i j j J J A J J J J M I ejiJJ

. J j j j l j ^ j : i U AJU j l i UU! S jf^S?! J c

(J i a. Cy e j U l ! ^•J* J c p^iUaV! jS.aJJ

wwA '.agsa.co.za /incosai)

i_jjja J 9^ ClbjiaUl J.O .^jJl jBjJ iS'^J

f-^ j l J i ( AJUJU Jc^l IA j l^^j Ujai

^ U j S j i U ,_g_oiJijl! ^ j J I j j ^ U Cy c l ^ V I

.2010 f.Ul

jl^UI t tuJ-il.ftUu ( 2008 jab JJjiS! JJ

Aj*_oaJI pUUI Uijja! vjU^ ^l^jll iJc^'^

AjUayi J U I Acj -^aJ j U . j .5 jU i A^Ul

. ((^1 i-ijjaVl ) ^ j i V l SjUU t ^ U j l i U

j . o j _^ JaJ A J J U J ! CJIJIJJUUVI jLis] C y ^ J

U j _ ^ ( 2 0 1 0 ^1—c j j j U U l c i b j S j V l

V J — u A_ jU j i i ^^—icvi j i ^ i I Vjihiiiij

J ( j U j j j ^ (.^Jjajjll j J a J I p U a l Uajjai

. 2009 f—C j i A i j — : ^ 3 j j U f_jjS AULO

JUa—JVI (J—^jj (CJI ojUall Cy ^j^J

^ b Uajjai L_jjjU AJUJU . ^ V l J ^ J I J

:c^l:illuljUl

E-mail: [email protected] Web site: http://ww\\'.agsa.co.za

(5 J i l l (JiJ it'iH (j11-i A^ <Ulj2 p j j U i

j ^ ^ Uiji CbUl AJUJU Jc^i jUJ! JiJ

. I J iSl i U I [ j i U l I_JJS.O * ^ A-al j J p J j ^

4 IJVI J S jJjSil a j j J l j - i ojlaUVI AJIOT.

A__jic JLJA ( J J I U (jjiUI J c Lg-Jc S J J U U I

u U j i j l j ( J j b i - i j cUJi j l j b b ( j j j jUi l j j j

AJU j l i J c ^ \ j l a > 11 ( J i j ^ b j j J a j aj

( ^ I j U u i V l U k U l A i J I ' j J c U i a l j

(A, . l U J j j <jJU! AJU j l i UUI i j ^ b l

J 2007 jU jJ j j j j ^ l J 1.^ j lJli j

f 1J .'^ 11 A_JaJ pUUlj (CjjjSllj j'^oA

A U I U J I CJIJI l i j y i J j a . AJC jai l A U i

( j o (J__S 9 J L A J S ^ A J I U I AjUjiU

i j iUil j j J l S p l - U l j ' . ^ j J l j f ^ j ^ j U

Jj_a t^UjULi ^ 1 £ j jUl i 2008

.AJUI AJUJIU AaljUJI UJUJYI

f-A J b U V ! J ^ J i U b j i j U l (j-1 . ^ j J j

: _ Uil j l jUl Jc AAA AiljJI US.a

E-mail: [email protected] Web site: www.gab.gov.sa

J - a j i J A i \ J . J J - J i ^ j - a j CiUl.liA_t.iiV I

j j j * i J l

Ju l , r. « uiUli J ." j^ 'Vl j J ^ ( .pu

( (J—Liabil aUI ,_5Ui jS jJiS-o J J U J I

J J ajU Uaj jal L -JJJU aUt u i l j J l U

(1 Jflj j i l ' J j U J j J i l j ^ 'Lob Cibj i j tA

L^JUI A JUJU ( j icVI b j l ^ j ( I ^ J J U J

f c j y j i j J I (_^UJSJVI J t n j i I aj. '->•'., ,.j..,

j l oil Jx^IjJ Cijil Jl i U J . 2010

-iaJ LUl Jl ocl A JUJU ^ IcVl

J ( j.>-uj. JA CJJJI IJ^ UIJIJUUVIJ

A Lj.io ^ CjjJjbal ( j J j j i l (iblj j i l j S j j i

.2010 j U j J J p j i k j l j a

iA-ujUlt ;_5UJSJVI J-1J3.0 JXA (jicI bSj

Jja 1 w Aja J-1 \ 1*^ 1 jal (.^ |i-%- I'jla ( ^."^

J U o U j ja-a i l aj i j i l J j a J jSj l i cUI

.(aJaUJl A J J J J I C j I j bV l j ( A J J J J U I

jJaUjll J Jac JA pUuVl J iUj

jjl—jji jjJiJj oi^A jjSjUUii j i ^

{Ji—a J .A—JUJU UUl ^jja.1 Qn

J 3 a A laail J J U I /jj i l G .V\l •.'•• J J J I

p l U k l ^ lj A oUll A i l j J l j l j J j

A J.J* 'I •L-X-j-iaUl (J ^ja'.-'tl (jJaJI

UiUJIj AjiUl AJU jil UUI I j ^

^ ^ u u i i ^ j j b U j ( t ^ U j j j V i )

4 AJJJI AJUJII Jja. jijjjH ^^J»1\

. CJJJSII J I j i c J3 j U a J I !!lLS j l S j

A oUl A i l j J l j l j J J J j U Ja j l S j

L-ujJ ji l A U CJI c U U ! J Ual l

J j j j l ,^JJi .AixJ] L-l AJi

( ^ j _ J x U l A - J U J U U U I i j ^

i s U U J Jac J A p U U V I j CJJJSII

A \y It AJJJJLUUI AJJJJI ASLUI J

J j J ( j J i j — a CJI J J a Aj- i j j j ^JJjJj

J—iia J-1 J j U JSJ .(_aJiJI j j l U l

j a jj_c JJ—a A-oUI A-iljJl j l j jJ

U l j j J J i J J U J ( A J A I J U I C J I J J J I I

^1 uil ^ Ir. AJU jil Jja JjAjJii

1 j a j l j j S j (_g l c A J U J I I J (al J I

J—J3 j ^ J J A J ! ^poU jJ j l j ( ^ b j U a i l

ftUs c V J LBJJJVI A J J S a j j b o

u l — a U a V I J j Ja j " J j a . ( . g U j j j V l

" ^ j - ^ 1

•*__jal jJl l .v. '\^t\ Q A j j i i a j - i J j U j

A a lUo C J I c b U l ^ a b ia i l A * U I

(1__^UJJ J L j i J n i i J i r C l b j - i ^ J

J _ J j CJLO l i J _ i j .AJC.jai l l ^ U I j

a l—J J J J J S I J^JJJ p U i a l U U b j a V I

J j a J U l A c j - ^ U 2 0 0 7

( 1 _ J J J U I J Jac [ j J l l j "AAwalaJr

^ ^ j V l A i u i b U l j l j j J ( J i j - a A i a U l j . o j U l tJA a a . j j g

Page 11: Aprii 2008 - INTOSAI · .(iiij U«a j-jjl l.ia. jjj*M Jj\ J (JjVl Jj^l bijji.! J3 (UIJ fi*J r^^>VJ1 ' j*' liaJ—L-al jUa ( ^j JaU! UJI CjljU l JiU UJJ uil A^jjUl! .ij^l j.a aC-jl!

< J S J ^ V 1 SjaLUJl LJuV^l

AIUI u i l j U i ULJ < U A U

AlaJJ ^jjjSJyi ASJJI J!li j« jlcl u

jSj \'Bj ^ jUl J'J2J jia (2008 jjiji J

oJ__aUl "'' jVj" fc i_-ia1 joS A1.^;.. Jt

A__LojSJi AJftijjJl r^ -' jUjj AS^jAii

(*LUj (GAO) AJSJJ-VI 'aJjUJi uUVjU

i/m".. J U J ( 2008 ^IJI 12 j - I jUc i

j _ _ l l j AJJ—i^J j J t_5J_-iaJI j J j l l j j U j J '

. Ul \ ^ I ._ i ^ , ,1 A . _jj.2 ^ 0 L b J J I ' ' &m VJJ

; J j •)' •.- ll J a i j u i a j ' l l aJA J L A C '

JJU j A cU-Q jjJj jA . fA

A al j j Jlll C i b l a j l l Q A J J J •UAIUI. I J J U

2 J \'\..^\ "lit...... 1 U J U Ua B J U J I UUVJH

• . ',,--' La j _ S j JJ*. ll j i .1 j a j . J j a j l ' j

Jlo AJSJJ-VI SJaUl UUVjli ^UI L J I J J I

. 1998 j i ^ y j * J

-'••'•,. "• 1 j S j j j J ! ^U ( A j i b U l » J U J U j

11., .^ 1.0 J i — ^ J A j j l J j J —3 QiA J U I

, ; -_ i a^U (GAO) U ^jJUill J j > U l

,A-jUiU b U Ual J.0 Cil j l u i

^ J J J l J j J '' !• •'" J-LLULJ < _ J j U j

SJ—-..Ul U-^Vjl' j-rUj >•—J jja Ji

a a I., fl ^ " 1 ^^ j * ^ • ial \A ^ 1A. ,M I A •s I V.0VI

•wj .Tij-.H IJiA J c A ^ j ' - i j U b ^ j U J ' j J a - o

a , ^ • .'"lU AJjLa j j c '*'•..' * jilkC. A ,.. ,-•> J j J

u js l jA j l j U i U a J a j J l C iUV j l I ( j U j j i j

f II * ]"'* 1 j j a j j l j J I j - 1 A-uL5 'vflj-ia j u ^uui

AjU J j I j j J J J U I r - j i - a J S J . r - j j J I ^ j j iUa

j j * l _ j i . * U U j l j l f - ^ , 5 — ^ ' ( T ^ J j % -

(•j,i • 41 G A O J U A J J I j j j o i V i j j i j i u v i

c j b j _ ^ j j j j j J G A O U a - J c Ji'UJl

• 1 - ".'. 11 AJ . j - Ja a A ^ j j u j i - J j S I j a j j . a J . 0

^^_L AUiaUUU ! in j j ^ j . J j j o V l

j j j i j l S j . •J i^ j j j^ \ ^ G A O Cib l j j i

^ U i '.nilJ j j j l a j l j j j l ' l—UII a j l j j

o j l J J J ( J J — J l a j l j j j l A j i i l j l l a j l j j j

^ j < ' - . | 11 O j J J11 U .-.>aj iA c l j j l l

J J ! aaJ l j (A i3 j j . i i il e j j l J j l A j j l j J l j

.AJJJU A.0UI AUjjiil J] Al'.jJay'Li

U k j U l ( j i j _ U I - I ' < " 1 A S U J I I J i j

oJ—C J i - i Ja JJJ . ' , j j l j ' . S . J - k j j J l

^ aa . U U l A-bjUl j y ^ j •.'•'-^''-

J j > - ^ 1994, 1993 ^

j c - V J J - " j l ^ U o a ( A J j j J I C i u U i ^

^^g-iiajll 3:JajJI U S * j«_o U 3 S J I C i ' i ! ^

.A - lU l C J U J J U I A j j j ^ ' L U J J I I

j - ^ j i i i j 1950 f c j ^ -uJI J j j i j

. U U l U i U U l j J j jUS Uj jUl l

J c J ' - k U y i j j ^ J J C l b j l j U t j . 0 J j j J j

: JUll j l j U l

E-mail:

[email protected]

Web site: www.nao.org.uk

lU-A -S^^—J (CCAF) AloUUU!

CJ—ata ja A....L...ijJl Cu.S j . p j jUoi l

J__jj-ul Jja JJJ AJJJII k^a-oljj uwijAJ

A_^' ia j l l U U J ! S > _ H - ^ ^ . ^ 1 j -

J j ' ^ 1 ** l^->jil ^T^^-Jj^ ^ J A S J U J I

. ^ j i S l t

J'-i-o—I^'l ^jJfiJJ C I ' — I J I J U I j j l - l i j j

i j __ j l cb ' . .U ^jUjl i J c V l j ' L ^ U

: JUll jljUl Jc

Fax:+-1 {758)451 75 94

E-mail: [email protected]

^.i^lftli AS1AA1\

Ju.lak jkLc- (Jd±a (JOJU

li (2008 j j i j i j ^ J

JSJ 1 ob "iii. ' l i l J' Ji^ (^

1 J . o j - a U l A S I - U J -JJajJI ; j ja '"ill

i l j J l • i Jlj . '• '-'j^i J I J J J 9 J - ••]

J A j .CjtjlL.^ AJuJ o j J > U ;_^a jJ l j

( .". ) t l . 1 OA. ] !• ••'! • e 1 ^ ^ "j q ^ J j ^ l l > .

J j l i A J I ^ J Aj- jaia j - j J c l i j (CJ l

AJJJ j.a b b jJjCc -IJLJ J O jjjlS

ASUJ i U l ^ U l j U l j J l .'• ~'^-^

, |B.laUl

( aJaUJi ASUJI ^\C j3^J-ij ^alj^Sj

A a'.S • '"'i •! ••• ~. aJ'L^LI JJJ JJUI ^ j j

^ X A J S j a U l l A S I U S A J . O J S J I J l j J l

. i_5jiV! ,»Ul p'uiaall ajj-al j * ^-Aj

jUjjil Ji jjjiijil («JjJ 'uJajl .ajijj

^ ^ ! AjUiilj -a,.liSl!j jU^iVl JJA

Cil—'-a-^'J j'j-^ >jaJiU UuiLuii Jc

. b j j l j - i u 5 > - V l

A jU j l t ' "< - ; j a J t ja JJJ J U I J ' L S J

ijaj-J jiiUU 1994 ^b J jl^ji

, ^ j V i A i jUJ i j i j j p i J i j * < U J | j * J U I ijA j 9

Page 12: Aprii 2008 - INTOSAI · .(iiij U«a j-jjl l.ia. jjj*M Jj\ J (JjVl Jj^l bijji.! J3 (UIJ fi*J r^^>VJ1 ' j*' liaJ—L-al jUa ( ^j JaU! UJI CjljU l JiU UJJ uil A^jjUl! .ij^l j.a aC-jl!

j 'Jb •AJA 'o-ic juji-JjSll j>bl IJAU JJ^OJ

J *j'+=^ - J i ^ J '-*1^ ' J_9 - ^ J • J j ^ '

CJ'JVJII J AJJJII U j J v l I j Ub'UUV!

.?r j l i i l j aJaUJI

i J'—aUV Ji^Ji U b j U i ! j - Jj j-Jj

: JUll j l jU l Jc GAO

E-mail: [email protected] Web site: www.gao.go

^ a a j l — ^ ^ J U J -3 LJLA i j j j L_U J

^ a A j l jJ l U j J j aj'ij CjbUUVi

.fTjUjl j eJajJI CJJV j l '

1 JbUV i ^e-ajj ULO jLtJI jj.0 JJ j J J

: J A j l jU l Jc GAO

E-mail: [email protected] Web site: www.gao.gov

^ GAO : J_Ul l ja j j b j J

a-^ J i - : , ]973^U_C j l ^ j a

' ' 11 -.11 a c- j j S - a A J U U ; • 1. ^'l ' i . .

jJ—C 1993 1—t .—a, . _j...i'i-aJl j

ajbyi j j j j 1 ,»Ul U ' j J3 Ijc-Ui-i

J A J Lltl J (Cj_Aj i ioaJl a j i j l q A jXwtb_J i

jja 1 999 U JA ., Iini oil JJj J

• j ' ^ ' J J ^ ' -J^J^ ^

' • ^ ' j l -'• ( A ".a I X J a j i a A j j i a j

—o ' l ^ l J J U fiil j a J J U U J J ' J J J

—a 1—OJ O J J V I J A ] « , ' L . U ' J A J J J J I

-j—IS J.OC J j j j l Sj ' ja U j ^ ( J i j

J i . j j l A J U I CJ'I j ' U I j i j JJ

,1—ol A J J ' U I — J ^ b l j .^ o j S U l

I j l j j l — J * j ' U U j o aJC- ^__^-jiJjSll

. ^ j i l J j C i - i j U b A J J I J I C J U ^ U A I

j 4 J ^ J I C J U j u a j « «

j j j j L J l

Qt^i

1 {jJ>S

XjAiC- A .tll i l l ^ U i a!^ JS 1 jA^'&A UJI_C. oUa OA

U-3J cLaJ j l c ^UH ^UjSiVl j^>J j-*.-U. JA AiaUl Cy - 2008 JIJ QJ\S JJC- ,i.Jaj fl

. j U l I j * J U ,.j'il4..il ^ ' j j j f j Jis A U . J .a'lU jya . jU l

(.lUiiJl

S J U J I <iUJl

J*Jlj#ll

J-OJ J l wuU

Ui&

JU^li

i j U j H

U U I

o^kUll ULV^It

£;>U>J1

SjUyi :I £;>Ja>Jl J s ^ j i l f rUUt j

^Ul j ^J l <.Jut :2 ^>Ma>Jl

J c frU c'JVi ^.jjt

;VI Aj*x'.aU' j l j j J J i Qa \y A J j U l 'JA

Page 13: Aprii 2008 - INTOSAI · .(iiij U«a j-jjl l.ia. jjj*M Jj\ J (JjVl Jj^l bijji.! J3 (UIJ fi*J r^^>VJ1 ' j*' liaJ—L-al jUa ( ^j JaU! UJI CjljU l JiU UJJ uil A^jjUl! .ij^l j.a aC-jl!

4j£jj.aVl bil&jJl UUVJI UajSaJl 4JfUUI (US^ ( r l j J j j J J ^

JaJ JJSUJ («UJJJVI C U U . 2001 JJJ^i J J jJ rU ( j •iS»UI J j i c ^ U J l 45U.^iJVI j J j - a J

.A.,JaJ-alj AJ^-UI jUil AJai j l jc l ' ' ''fl • J j J ajJc, QA Ulc

U J _ J I J A__Ul J J J U I C J J . 2004 JJJJSI J U«IJ1JJJ j tat 1 nil jJiC (>IJJI ^^Uj l iVI j J j - a J

.(JjJ*IJ J jJ.^J - U i U l Aj-sjll j U y i A-laiJI pba.yU (.^UjiijVI J cUacVl j j U j

1^1—uijjjVl CJ__JJ . 2007 jJ jUS! j J U u j£j,uii-a J JiSuulJI juiC ^ U H [ jUjSIVl j J j . a ( J

C J _ U J Ajajjl jU-j iVl A-JaJ! ij j. 'U aUjU ' aja-s." Q ^ i i'i .. A-ab CJI j U j I j L U J-oJ^JI J l IAJJJIJ

. jaJjJI J i Qa AJIC ASJUOJI

CJ—A p j JUj X uiIj (_5J__aj A_Uaj AJl j a j ^ I JIAJ j i ! Ajijjl! 'UaUl — (^ jUjiJVi ''"''•^-^" U J S

\cjj juSjtJ U ( iQaJii plaj Ails QA bbl ajU Jlllj t jjUl! CJUJTM 11 fij ( UljcVlj ( UUij^iUI

JUj jUjI Cy ~ AJOUUI AJ-UJIJII I^UJ JbcVIj ( AjcUja.")?! AjjUoiVlj AJJ-ILUI UUVl j-i U-JJ1J

'CJUJI (CJUI ?i.a.U]l ^4-Jll '• ^'-^j JlaJI IjA jl ? Ju 111 JSJ—Ulj Jjjjjj) (Sj^^ Cja CJIJJU Ciu! (j!iU

j—c Jjjj JA l^-UjU J JjVl J> jllj (A^sUl jU^l L^Jai JUJJ JJJJ jjJaJ J>1 Cy J^j^^

.AU j j ' . . - -^ "

4j^ja.>i31 f-(^jUJlj ^ ^U l

- A—JUI j A J I J U U ! J J J - |_5JjflJj!l l -Ja-o J n (2001 jJjjSl J UaUJI UUI AUi! l;lj<-^ J U

J^l jy-aj • AJSUI j l jcj AAAC J j*iibo JJUJ ( JJJJUJJ ftlSjJ a 'iq.jn.i (tUacVI * j " ^ ' JJSJ j l ' .i-^jj

J "11 'Lui JJJ (.5j_Ul Cibuj i^ j (.^UjiijAi AjtjjJ! (J*JI UUjAa_o Jj-u V j j (jJaJI (-lijj! Jaa (JiJ

(UjjSj ( J—ili USjjjj ( (A-OUI AJJUJSJJI JJUJ ) UUIj djjjjUj (jxJjl ajtj UUl A'.^IU jnJa

(SJajJI ASLUI j (Uu JJ AJJJJU-JI AJJJJI ASUJIJ JJOJIIJ ( ((.^U^^VI AAA^ ojjUa jjl*"' I Tl^jj^J

. (biajt UUI Ajail (juJJjS jjLajtJj AjaJI aJA j j l loJ I '\jSjj.aVl eJaUJ! UUVj l l j

j j i UJI L^J ' 'U Jaa ( AjaJl j U ^ I A-lai. 11 Sjj*-wi AcUa A U C UUl AJaJI AJ CJIJJ J A Ci j i l J j

J aJji-jJl •U-aJ yi UUjUjSJI j ( ( j jUi i l (jJaUi j U AjUil cUacV! j U Ulg-a.j Jc. Jjj^aUl

K j- ia. x J a l U j ( AJall 'LJa-U! * U j j j ( j j J j j j ( j c U j j j J I J J J J J J j C j p j U J U J I J I j j i i j j j j b b j J j ^ l

j_j J I I U U - a j L U I JJSjJ j * ftUacVI a j^ -aVI ^-yA. (jS-u!J I L J J J J ( J l j j j . j j U j A . .,.. j A j J ! c U a c V l

o J j a U J i U l j l a V l ^ A b a a U ! J ^ ^ j ( AoUtl l j . a ft j ^ i f l j l j j j x J b U j i u j (AJa i i l j l j c - l J ~j • •n

r i ^ I IJA (jc. A J S J J - I V ! a J a U ! C j U V j i i i»Ul l U l j J I j (AJa-lil ( J J J J ( J S J U J J J J J I J J C j a j . l^ ja

j ^ j V l U - ) U J i j l j J J J i C y ^1? "^' j - = J U I IJA a a . j j 11

Page 14: Aprii 2008 - INTOSAI · .(iiij U«a j-jjl l.ia. jjj*M Jj\ J (JjVl Jj^l bijji.! J3 (UIJ fi*J r^^>VJ1 ' j*' liaJ—L-al jUa ( ^j JaU! UJI CjljU l JiU UJJ uil A^jjUl! .ij^l j.a aC-jl!

j - 1 (J-uJ Ajaljaj-LJJ A J U O ( . ^ U J J V I j l ?tJaj..a J S U JSJJ L S ^ ' J "" j i ? ^ ' A A U I ^ ^ - i * ' —i flul Utui-o

I fl'jq jl A Ijjll - -^-^ jjc- jisJI jiUj ftUacVI JjJl jJJ aljUUl (jjiajj t^jljll J pUayi JXA

j - ^ ^ o J ^ _ i ( j 0 iftJJJ J bfl-a ! i b b j A U J I J j U i U i U l Ijj-aJC 2^*U1 IJA j l S jS j .AAibUSVI

Sl 1 ja.j] jJSil! Lg-otjilui! a j U j j ( i J j u i p U U l j i c J c UUl AJaill C i a l j (A^IJJII JJ-jj .CLUUIJJJ

J i ..^ j.0 JLUV! AjLac Jj j j jJ AJjjiSlI j j jUc u u jljcU Ci«U Jaa ( AJUI aj^jj (jS-Lo Ja i_gj-aal

— J uijjjX! ( jSj_i l AJaJaaU O b U U l J c j L w c ^ UajS biui AUUI CjJJaj . ^^j j iSiyi J j jJ l

J J ^ Jl «i! J j J j lc J j i . ^ J l A51J-IS — UUJJJII ^ i j l i j (AUll! U b U i a l j iA iojiSyi U l j - J ^ l

I j i l S j j J U l ((jj-ibUI (jjaSUl Qn A IJLUI U I J U J ! J- I U=LJI C j j l iU l j . UJIJ&J A J U J ^ AiaiJl

J AIAA OAA iljiUl J Jaa (JlJ Jj AiUa')?U .jUbbUl j!iU AjaJI jjiJ iJJAij AJjS jJj QjJAii

C l j j U J ia (l^i*C Jjg • •'•> Jat j . * j .ab JSU |_JUJ1I aUaJl J c Aiaii! J ja. O U j l U l j i l i AUIC-

^ ^ 1 J — i j t > ^ J )1 ch jWic-* ' t>4 V l ^ ( U j i j j U l AJ I I Jb AjjjlaJVl AJ I I j j S i j t AJail!

.AJUUVIJ ( A J U V I J (AiUjjJl j ' U j J ! UU l ! J l j^a..^ U j j j i CJUUXO J C JjA.aaJi ^biacVl

Jxl i jUs) JIJC'I J M U Ljl 6^.^! L}-* -UuiUi ' du ! :Jj>JU f jJI

(_jjb_aj lc ftUil JUA. JO A j i i U j l LgJbc-V j l iaj ^ - ^J J J (.S^J^*^! Ux-i (SJaill b j j j l a j Jjc

j.aC QA b b (jj-jiUjI J^A. 'A1\A1 CJJIS ^ gjll u J l j J l tdlji (j-aU abjAl c -Ul J JSj .(UaUl Cy ^-^-^Ij

A iSlj-i J c (iUacVI aJcbU Ajj lLJl U l j jU l I ,-A b j (j>lU'J j l ( jSUI j * Ul l J I J J ( (.jUjJjVl

1 oSj . j j j j U U I j (Jjl J l j j l l J AjJajil AjUjil a j ^ l AJUJ j l l aJj l jUl CjUjajllj UUUUVI

"AjiJUil CbUj A j j j j ^ 4-lai " l^U " oJaUl ASUOII aUI [ J B U I J l U l j J I j j j J j j ^ JjJ l 1^-Uaj

a j _ j ^ AjaJ!jl__.^y) UUJI UJ) 4UUI CUbj»Ul (2002 j U a i J J i j jJ l J jV l l ^ U b l j : i U j

A l'l ...yl Aja-lil j j j J j A-aj JaS ( p j iJajJl Jja, jjSaliil JkiiaJ Ja.1 j - o j ( t*lij Jjuj . A U I S Ajljj i i UUl

U l j AVIJ i^ JjAjaJl U i l j ' ^ 3 J ^ ' J cba^-Ji ( j j U U l j_aJjljUVl J-lJl- ^ 'J]I Jja, U j j a U j j l l AJIUII

•iS-iaii AjjjS (UIJAVI j ( | jU I SJJJU

h j j i I U^uJ!

V U U ^ j {_5UjjjVi '—JiU UuS •

? ^ U j J V ! j U a J j l^jUacV i iU j JV I 1^-UJ j i j l U l j -1 Ji l l C J U L U I p l j j i j > Ll •

V U J S J V (> (Ja^ V l^Uii JJ (^UjliVI ^ii=2 J l l CJUUUVI ( ^ b •

Y ^ j l U c j (^Ujjj!iU U j j i l a l ^ l J-A b •

^ j A . ^ 1 ^1^1

?(_5UjjjV! J-iC jUaJ aCJj J i t AJ.UIJJJ1I Oj-icVl ( j * b •

<*Ajjj> juoUc UUl s j ^ V I b j j j j JJI Ci lUol jJ! j l U j J I (c^ b •

^ ^ j V l U-iUoi! j ! jJJ J i j - AiaJl j - i J U I 1JA *a.j j ] 2

Page 15: Aprii 2008 - INTOSAI · .(iiij U«a j-jjl l.ia. jjj*M Jj\ J (JjVl Jj^l bijji.! J3 (UIJ fi*J r^^>VJ1 ' j*' liaJ—L-al jUa ( ^j JaU! UJI CjljU l JiU UJJ uil A^jjUl! .ij^l j.a aC-jl!

^ j a J l j U i V l U l J f t V l

I oa (A J c ftUj ? l j j i j J i - a j l ! ( _5UJJJV I J.al j j l l AJLgJl rc jU i l j ! A J J A J J I ^ U l l J b [A •

1 j-oL^ J^il i j a 1 flaja..,-. Jj (^UjjjVl (.^^U j l l (jUl aiis-J 'LiaJljUVl UIJAVI J

? A - U J l U " a - j j j l j

J l o U U j i J l j a J at i C j I j j i l l ftU J A j ?J l j j ] l jja->,"' j a J j J b o J S U A ^ . a j * U I J A V I J i l ' •

^Uf t l i i l ! . i c

Jj-ui J L_)jUU j l (.^Ua jl-laj J IgJK-'.U J J ( j U l e.^ju U I J A V I ( jc J J U I ! U i c j U j U J S •

? J j i U J l I a - Jja"

4 J « J ! (Jl.U»Vl

? ( c U ^ V I U I J A I ( j i jaU jS-aj U J S •

U1J__A! [J__jiaj U J _ _ ^ J J I j l AiSiA aJbl j l j l j c j J j ^ U U ( j l l A I U J V I J J b c V I J b La •

?(^Uj iJVI

Aj--_uiUVI l—UJlftl jajj lUUu i i l j 1Q •"' U i I '"jj^'t ( jUj i iJVI ^ j - .'' ' j l • _ '7- J J l l U l j i a i i l J t , b •

V U I J A S U ^jaja^"' »Cji b j j l j j i j

^UM^l DUJITIJ 1^4^JJJ JaC ^ I j JI Lil.lAVl ^-a^J J) J : ^ ! J^ U

(j'-i •; J AJJJ AUUO AJI AA.1JJ J3 (jil CibUiilj JaUI ujlja. JjJaJ AIUVI Jli ^IJaUl JXA Cyj

f. a J-U:. ( j J U l p U U ^ U^jVl jJ.9jJl J ^ j .^- laJ! eJ^Ji* J IJCU t j J I QA AjJ l l CJJS.J ( jUa.V!

( j J _ U l aJJxJ U I J A I AX-U U j J a j A J J J J ' bo^ U U U aJji-ui AJaill UJc ! (2002 f c A-nj J (jJaJ-^lj

UIJJ Ja3 (JIJ j.o AAVIJ • UbjUJI (JJUJ (AJ-JU-IJ)JI ojjall jjj^ (AJUA j^rjU^ JIJCJJ JJJU : j b

A__i jJ .* j i J w jo i iU ( j j a . J ! J J j U a j ( U i j ! ^ l l j l a — i^gUji i j l iU A a i j i J i (_3jljjil j - > a j l i U V U AJaJI

JJ lc AiivUll U l j - J j J ! ( j c a j j b U I U U j j j U i l j U U a j j l l J ] AaUjaVlj — ( j U j J I i U A j ^ l ClUSi iUl

. j Ja iJ I J J J I aJc l i l l A j j U a J l j A J D U U V I J J A A J A J J * ( J J U - I aC-Jj j l i ( j j U j l l aJA C J J J J S J . ( j j U I j a

j l I j iQ J i ^ (—aj-ji j S j J j J ! AJJJUJJ U U I 'Ga-iil j j i " "U i la j l ' " ' • ••j*j AJJJJJOJ j j S " 111 'UaaJ! j l ( U a j

. " ( J i i l u J I ( J J S U J J j—CaUl j j j J a j j J j A A j a J l j U ^ l A I j i . l l ( ja U j ^ l "

oJ_j j tJ U I J A I 'UJ i l i l j j J -• ' -"• U j j i j i . a J I J C I A ,.j -1 Aj-.aUJI Ajy \]\ (. \ . Ui-.t ( U S ( j l a U l j p Lojal JJLJ J

A c U a j c-biacV! c -V.^ aU ( Ua J J L J J I ( 2 0 0 2 f c U j j i J ( j j j f l j j l l ( j J a U l p U U l J i j . ( j U I

-*1 1" — i j j j f ^ J .A!DIJ1! UJJA^ I ( i l t j - 1 J a l j J S ^ . J J i l A i a U V l ( iUJSj U I J A V I J I J U ! J J « U I

j j j ' " •' U l j i a l U U ^ U J ^ j j a j c b U C b l S j U U a a ^ i U l ftUjj ^ j c a l j J I U j ^ (.bJacVl J c U j j - U I

• L y j ^ l

( A k i l l j ^ U j V l o J j i U l UUl AjJ i l j i u j j ^ (Ua J 2002 ^ b U j j i J j i u J l ^ U u V ! J ^ i U j

CJIJ pb_Ja.VI J i i CiaJa j j i t C i l t U U ! CiilS J j .AjjAjaJI U l I j A J ^ J J A - I ^ I U U U AU-Jalo

U j U J A AaUja! AjaJljUuYl AJaiil *_o L g j j j U J c f - U j J U i j j l l Ciajpal ( J U i l JjJjji J c .A_<Li

j ^ j V l UaibUl j ! j j j J i Cy l ^ i Cy -^-^l !-^ f ^ j 13

Page 16: Aprii 2008 - INTOSAI · .(iiij U«a j-jjl l.ia. jjj*M Jj\ J (JjVl Jj^l bijji.! J3 (UIJ fi*J r^^>VJ1 ' j*' liaJ—L-al jUa ( ^j JaU! UJI CjljU l JiU UJJ uil A^jjUl! .ij^l j.a aC-jl!

j:i__a2

Ual J a l j ( ( j - j U a J l J i j - 1 L_ua j j j J I A J J J I I ^ j U i J j ^ ^ J . Lg-uaJ ( J U J J J V ! OJJS ftU J c j S j J

j g _ U V l J ^ i U j . V J j - j V l A J U J ! ( j U j j i V l A J U O J j t a " J A J A-lai i ! S J J « U I J j ( V l J U j ^ l AJaJll

C j U _ j - a j j J l C J A U ! ( J l l j U U a J J jb i - i J [ j l * J j U i U i j i a U j a j J S U JjJaJI U j ^ l I JA ?iJJ-al ( A L O U !

Qi—i A suii UaJiJj '•j ^-^"' aJbj JIJSJ (ajjI^Jl-? Ajj. >n II JJj Aibjajj AjjJaJl AjjiJI ^j—'jil ^JJ

• (jJa-nilj AUI JJJJSUI

uVUfljVI UJOAI

4__U11 CJ__OU Jaa (AUJ J^j i l ^Uall AJ-JAI J^AA (JUJ j jSU j -U l jUVI bjl-.-;.".\t AUC jt Uja.j

. j,".;^ it j U l l j ASJUU—O jU-jJa J -aLg-ijjjJ A xmjAj AJJS J U J I Ai.iMi.i.i AjaJ! jUVI tj ")-. jjJ.ajJaij

JULo (jjLoU_o ftlSjJ KA (-ajl i i l (JjUJI J c j (jUjj jJJ J i l j l l (_$juiA J c — j U U I UljJaVI

P,Ua__cV! 0 j ^ V l J (jjaaUlj — j i j p * U l (jj-iJaUJl Uajl jUcVU AJaiSl Cjj i l JSj . J j j l l JjJI

.'Ulajll U b j S J Ajaliiiilj AJPUJI jUkU -byibVl JajJsUI J j j U j L)^'

JSJ .CUIUJ* J C Jjj-aJ! (Jal j-1 Aalja-a Ujia AjaJl " fl, ".lll ( I J A U J J V I f-jJaJI tii-al b j i c j

CJ_JIS t -.1^ A . 1 -N. tl jjS JI Cib uaJ UbUUl '1°'-- ajj .AaJjUa *LiAJal ( j l j J U , Jl aJjiU! '"'.' a

AJ.*! a i QA JJSI j j I U i (jjSjUlo KA •OaiJI DJjiJi.a A-iliU CU (JUJI JJJJJI J C (iJlJ J l AaU (illlJA

aa ( J U j J c o j i c j . GAO - U u i^Jl L S J ^ I J j . i l ! ^ Ib j l l ^ U j j J d i Cy I j W * j ^

QA JUal JjJj Ju aJ JSJ .liijAJj^i 'LoJaLo J ^UacVl ajg-aVI ^-JAA JC ^jjiJI ^ j j

QiAAJa J a JJ (jUcVI jjjtj JjJjl! J IJ •U! J (Ua. ( oj*Ul (jUjijiVI (jlaU jj^Ui IjL^a. 50 (jc

oj__j-a.Vl J ai r j * ^ U^a lAjj^jil A-kiJI J A£JUJ I JJLA AJUJI aJA U j j c . i j . UXi l l JjJjll

."AJJIJJI A k i l l J j A J ^ J ^ ^Ij CJJAU Jal" bojjij

J Ul (_5 jUo J c AjA*jijil JJC UbbUVI Jac c.U Jaa (AJJUI UUI AUUl CJUUUI J j Aibi>yUj

SJJJ.11 a J I J c j j u l l a a ^ ^ l A x a l j « U j ^ j j U a J j j l l j l a j l I ( j i j j l I I A S A ( J i j ^ IIU.I.^LHii l j l l j

J ^ I (ilJJ J J J J S I I J j a a l l J j « J j . U U ! AJaill ftUaci J-iLS J i j - A - J J I J J ] ^ c U a i y ^ J j J i ! ^ U U I

J l j J j i i i l U U j j ^ ^ J S J AJaill CblS 2 0 0 4 ^ b J A . 2 0 0 2 ^ \ c J a J . U U I Aja i i l Q A ^ ^ J 1 ! J J J J l

(J—1^ j ^ l J ^ * ^ J .A i a i i l aJj- i io J j j a J I ajSjil j U j UUaa.^i-1 J c J j i - a J I U j ^ ;.$ J j i Till ( j u i a J l

j l j _ j j a y 3 (CJjaJl! ( j j i l a J i j U U l p U U l j i c aj j i a - ( j ^ a J ! j U V I UU4.-,H AAAXJ Q A A A J j j l l

l ^ J i i j J i A j a i i ] AU^.aflJj A i a U A J I ^ < « . l j - i <-l J?.l U J J J J U J U V I ^ U a V l 1.JA j j J J2 j . 2 0 0 4

' b U — U l j t j l y i j.11 AJoUa Al- j , . -^ . A i a J l aJj-.o-i C-lUuoJ ( A J U I I 'fli,.-i"r ji J j .C IULJ IJJJ J J J | ^ J l

ftljVl Jj l—JJ A J U ( jJ - i ?• j j J a j j J I S J ^ U 1 g 'it I HI ( 3 ^ j J ) J ' - ^J j l l f j l ! a.'UJa.it U l j a a l ! j U j l l

CJI JSlt " ) o J A j A D J U J A J I U I o j ^ A j j I j S j i l A s U J I j c U U I AJaill j u n j J J C . i j . d j j U U l j

(J__ijj j C J U I AJUUI J.-1 J ojijL.a Cil j u i J a j i j b j j c : " " 5 PS " ftU U j a j LgU a J a l j J S I j J j l i j i iAaJI

(pain) ,JVl J l (perseverance) SJJIUI J ! (persistence) jlj*->V' J l (patience ) JJUI J*

. " 1 UjjJI jjSaj J ?Uu j l Jja

J j j V l AfuiUJl j l j j j J i Cy -W-*ll Cy .^^1 1^ f ^ j 14

Page 17: Aprii 2008 - INTOSAI · .(iiij U«a j-jjl l.ia. jjj*M Jj\ J (JjVl Jj^l bijji.! J3 (UIJ fi*J r^^>VJ1 ' j*' liaJ—L-al jUa ( ^j JaU! UJI CjljU l JiU UJJ uil A^jjUl! .ij^l j.a aC-jl!

( j j U j J l j <JUjJl :CiuuUjj J j j mil 'UaaJI ^ j

l j - _ ^ . j l U o I J ^ J j J l J l - i C j ( 1 J ^ J J ^ - l U I '-^'bi-- ^ _'' ^J J A r - j b J V ( j l U o ( I j a J j a ( J j a

i U l j J I j U U I AJaiil J J J J U I xJ j j LuLo j l o l j ! a J j J I CJJJJJI A a j j ^ J l A j j i U ! J U U ! ( J U QA J a U l

j J j a J ftUacVI J i j - 1 A i a i i l J c C j j j U j i l j AJ-U-IJJI UU iJU-J i aJcUl l I J J J J U J U i l A J J J - U l

J U-U—iU JJ.-1 AiUa " b J i l o ClJlS [ _ J U J J J V ! j l J j a j j J - i j .C IJJ IJ IJJJ J JS*bi l j J c (j-iUll [ J U J S J V I

A__ajaa. J c i j j j U o j l ojjJI CJJSI Jaa (Cijll JJJA XA AAA JSi t"'-. i.--!! l^ l j ( 1953 f c UUU

. A j a J l j U - j i y i A u-i. 11 L j j j j j KA " U c j j S j j l (jS-iJ b (JjaSl J l J j j - a j l l A J C J C U a j [ . j U j j j V I j !

I J A T ,'>> Cua. ( A - J a j j l Axa j^UI A J J L - U I ab l AJa i i l J J A A J a J . Q A U j a J j j Ijj"'! -^^ ' " "^ •" j E j

J J—uiU 1 J S J J J Q A ftUacI j - i ' U i U u V l j ( A j U j i l l j ( A j j j l a j V l j ( ' * J J J J ! U l i l l u ( J i jU l j -a ( j J a j J I

.A.ui l l j U j J J 3 4J-> AArtUi U U a j a - L o j (A j J j j tU I ASUj i l l j ( j j J I

J^jUUIj JaljSj-ijj 11 ^i^UI J Ja. JSU (^ (jjiSxJl (Ua (Ub ^^UaVlj (jjJll JUI jS: f J

JjJaJI aUI (jJ-aVl — J^J^ U!J» jjiS-^1 jl.^ AiiUa. Ajj-i'»aa jcUUj .Aiaiil JIJDI a aJiUl JA

( jb—ui jS jVl J- iJJ o j l i x j l J i t b b a j i i c (_jJijj a U j j C ja j l S J A t ••••'''11 a U I L-il j - J I j ( J U J J J ^ J

U it j J j j l U l A ajLo J — Lg-j f - _ i a j a j A j j j j j J a a j j U LgjI J c A ja iJ i U L - A J J J ^ J ( AjJa j f l j ^ U

^ "ill J J J U I j i k s u t*llJ J U ( ( j j i V I J j j J l L J J (JJ--a j c U U I J I J CJSV J S J . A k i J I J i n A S J U

j j "1J > ( J i Q A 1^-ajla J A I U I aJC JJ IJJ ( J i J JjtJ .AJIJJI I j j - i A-laiJI ftljl J j S U l ( j i w J I A J J L U C J I S

A__UL.aJI ftUa__cl pU—oa.U 1 j j ' i " ' a j j C u j j . m j AJaJ l ^ j i a J ( -lalaJt J a x j J j a j U i l U V I JA--U!i

, C l j b U AJI j j j j A J - I J - U !

^ b J l i S J & U H (jiLUjib - U u j^^JaJI

( j j - i U I j j a a j j l j . a JJc x ^ A J fill J JJC I j j g - a "Ja i i l ftUacI J j j ( A U i l t J i J i f U - i 'UU Aajil j - 1 ' T j j i j

J l l j J j J . J a J l l A-Caj-i aJjJaJl A ja iH ^ - ^ J . J " ^Jjl^jall a A j l j j l J j j l IJ IJJUUI I ( i l l J j ( j J ^ J j j l i j j l J i

(J UaJ LS ^ a J c b U l aAj l ja ju i l j j - i U l j j a L U l i § A Jas ( ( . j U j j j V l AJa-JiJl j j - i i J ^ A j c j i a i l l ' L a j J I

Q UaJ a l a j l j ( f -^ j*" J ^ U J " . " J j ^ ^ W Cy - L S - V ^ I j a U J l 'ULgJI ' U J U U I J J J H ' " i n ( A i a U l

A-__j«jjVI ( U I J A V I Cy U-IA J S A-uiUji ( j j - i b j j i a j - 1 A J - U J J ( j J a U l a l l ( .JJJUIJJJ a j j U o J j B j . " J a i i l

i j n n j J j ^ l ( "ejJal l ftU " 2 U j ^ l j U j i - J j U l l ( "A / lgJ l j i i ' - * J l " 1 U j ^ l j U j J j b j j l ! \ A- la i i i

j j A j j i j . V J j - J V l ^ j j l ! A -JaUI i 4 U J ^ I [ J U J U J J U I A J J J J I A S I U I J " A i j U l J j L u " 3 U J ^ I

j j j (JAuUl A U .K. 'll j j j o j ( j J a J l X.O A i a i i l J b c l J A j j b j - i l UlJA (JSl J U u ! a jU U a j l j j i U J l

J ...jl'.Ml A a U I A j b V I j l i U i l j L a b jJ- i lS A i a i i U A- i l j j l l j u i j - i U j j j ^ J J J ^ l ^ ^ J - U I A A V I

.A-iaaJl J ) j ; U J j j u i J ^ j b j a <j.a.% j J a J

^JaUt (jUaj J J^ TJ^ J-^M

A i a i i l j A n J A a i a U l A^jlgJI U j U i V l J j a I j J j a J A J U J V I U J A V I J U J ^Ja ( ( i i j U J ! J-iJ>a j ! i U

( j i J j V ! A ju iUU l j l j J J J i J A A i a J l j * J j J ! 1JA ^ j j 1 5

Page 18: Aprii 2008 - INTOSAI · .(iiij U«a j-jjl l.ia. jjj*M Jj\ J (JjVl Jj^l bijji.! J3 (UIJ fi*J r^^>VJ1 ' j*' liaJ—L-al jUa ( ^j JaU! UJI CjljU l JiU UJJ uil A^jjUl! .ij^l j.a aC-jl!

: JUll j U I J c ( U J A JS (j-uJa

J U c ji iU. (J-U ( JUJJJVI ftUocV rTi->fl A J ^ jijU* L U - jl-J^j JIJCI : 1 UJ^JI '

. ( www.issai .org j U l ) . JiuiSJl J I ^ J J f j l I j Uljj

j o A__Cj-iaJ a J j « _ - ^ j J U ( AJU j i l UUl ajfl^V! J SjJail ftU ' i—LUS jljj-aj :2 UjgJI •

"fljJiJI U U a l j J l J J j j A J J S J j a U I J U J ^ I

. J J J ! j j U l i A J J J J S J ] A S U |_3^iUajj A i a i j J U U l Aj^Ua A c U a :3 UjflJl •

. I ^ U I U A J U J I S J U J J L ^ U j l ^ 5jnjl^'nll AiSj^l Uj^iaii :4 (_ij^l •

J i o jjJlS JJC j U l ( AJUJVI UIJAVI J AaaaUll Ul jUiVl MAA j l U J lSl i j j j i j l! J c J j j -aai l j

. ( www.intosaijoumal.org) A1=U1 oJ6 j.o 2008 fc

J .a".. ii.»tl oUjb AJAHII

(j—o ' . ' Ill jia (AL-Uo AAAC j n a o j AjSj-iUjiU ' a• " AJaiJl j u l jJ^ J j A ) <JJjaJjlI j j i U J I j l U i a

al J l j j -Vl J l AiUa')/U ( U I J A I ftU^^j U j i | > J U Ulc AJaJ J J S U 4 U J ^ S j l j y i j J j jUl l A j J

. 2 0 1 5 - 2 0 1 0 aljcbU Aiaiil (! J '.'ll j^aJ i l jUVI l->Jl-l. " il JJJ-iJ ( ( ^ U J J V I U J J o j j L a j ( [ jUji j l iU

A \y lit aj_U]j U J UIJ .AJSJJ-IVI SJaUl UUVjll U U j J Jj-jiSJI j J j . a J UUl AJaill JjS-iJ aj j S j

a J i U _ U 1 gjSlj (j5—IjVl A-iail! A c U a AJLOC aSaj CJlS j l l J j i J pba.*)/! j j j U j i l ^ I ^ ^ J U J

(A_a^l J J UjAii J U J ! JjJjJi J i c ( A J U I I A J U J I Ajiia. (jjll ^LaJl J c J n U j j j i j ijtAi J S i UjUl

•• alll . 1*1 VI fI • • J J * j i i b a J S U jj-aJl j U V ! UU-;.-.!! j j j - i J A » J U J U I J . l ^ I J U I J A V I J ' ' S i ^ J j

(_5UJJJV1 ftUbcl ojl .lillll Uajl ajj U j j j i j .A-al^ jUaJ jJAJa J a l j J S ( U b c l i''ij 1->" U J J J U J J V I

CJI a j U o j Cj!iUj__a (juUfll j jo iUt A-Jaj J c AjJaJ! •Uaill j S j U j u i j . A J I U I j - i ft j a S a^-bSU

J j J Sl j 0 (J JJ -J I ^ j U i S oJjJai! U I J J U J I *--I Aaat j l a j j S i j Uajl j U U U J i U Uj .o i j .Aiaii!

. ajb'yi J J j j - J I AJaJ ojUa C U AjJjjjia J IJCI UIU ( J j a J J : l \ AUUI

CJA JJUI LUI^ Cy LWJ^ ^JJ ^-^^ t. ilk'n (_5U_^1JL-11 -_ajjl jUVl kjkVill Jjg-a jl QA ftcji Jcj

^ j — 11 Scj .AiiaJJl ^ U J I AJAAI J j a J J l J U a J JIUA ( J J S ( AJUJU UUI Sj^j.Vlj JIJSVI

A J a U j ^ j U l JUi l J l l ^ U j ajSj j ! J ( . ^ U J J J V ! oJcU.a J Aiaiil ^i^-Ji j l j S U ! (ja ((^.ajliJI

J c U U J ((f U J t ' j - • 11 J c j . J J J I I A U U U I . -."i- ^ j . a u a JJJ.0 L_lCjlSj ( TuUjlU A^.aj.0 a j j i a U

1—AJjlj-sj l^UlJa j j S j J j ( ^ U j j j J J * U l j ( J J U I j j i i l U U U A^la-a J ftUacVl o j ^ V l "JaiJl

. A S j U J l A-laUVIj C J U U I J U I J A V I j a J j - a J I j U l i_ijUU

drachd@gao .gov . : JUll j l j U l J c U j J U JLUVI J>?.JJ '*jji ( U b j k J l j , J J J J J

: JUll jljUI Jc AJSU! jUyi Aiaiil JS^JJ jja. J

http: / /www.intosai .org/bluel ine/upload/13estraplan.pdf.

( J J j V I AjiiibUl j l j J J J i j - a AiaUl (jo j U l !JA ^ L A J \ 6

Page 19: Aprii 2008 - INTOSAI · .(iiij U«a j-jjl l.ia. jjj*M Jj\ J (JjVl Jj^l bijji.! J3 (UIJ fi*J r^^>VJ1 ' j*' liaJ—L-al jUa ( ^j JaU! UJI CjljU l JiU UJJ uil A^jjUl! .ij^l j.a aC-jl!

^1 Ul dij(l Jljill ili: SAINT (>u) Jljill l i ^<

4 J J I J ^ I Aj l iJI 3nS- n ( j U (^J U l j ( j U ^ J U ^

( ( Self-Assessment INTegrity) AAI j j l i J i l l ^ ^ i sbV j U i i - J J U JA ( SAINT ) CJJJ-I

A bU A A! jiil (.^J JS-IJ •''—jliljll ftjl jj ^ jjUiU AjJilj^l AJUJII A X^ „ Ji j^ CjjjJa S!J1 J J

AAI jill Ulalli-0 (JjjJaJ AJJUJ! aijij aU! pUaill '" '1 ijj' jS.aJ ""•'••' aljl aljiUil J^Ai. QA J . aljjU-il

'»! JSJ AA! jill SJIJI (jjjjUJ '^1^ Jj^ Ub-ajj Ual! ''' 'j •" j j j .UlalUJ! JIJ U'I X\ 'ijUl iS-^j

iT..,. 1 AJ uiUVI CL5-il ^ ' J ' ^—IbijH ajAl La U j _ _ c j ( "CJIJI" j ( j^UJI ( JUI J c J I A IJA

• J a l j ajJ a j J ' " ' ' 'ar. ( J c ^ A j j J A^JaJ aJ b l Usj I g j U c j (b j j . -aUCj

Mj__ujji 3 I^IOAULO (.C-U j - 1 aUl pUaill AJI ! jJ jJJsUl l^la IjljsUuj oJaUui AJUJU U U I a j ^ V l j

a j b ! A _ U ^ i A J U J AAI j J l j l a U o ^UJSJ J A J U J I I UUl a jf l-^Vl CjJui J c b J JSj .A jsUi l l j A J * . U J 1

.AAlj i l l

iA l jJ l l ^ j * i *

Ulaj-a__oj (A__a]jUiI ul 3JJ*J1I (jo JjUl aljijUl UIU iJJAJj . Ajiljill aj^ia JjJaj JgUI Cy O^

( f tUi i l l j (Sj—i-Ul i J ^ ' i L CJUJJ - U J L JJC i^JjJj ( in-tangere A U J ^ I AJSII J- I JU-IO AAI j i i !

alj_jaVl j a j j a J l b j j a . j ^ U J J ( jb i l l J J i l i J u l u s AAI Jjll j ^ j j ^ j . ( jUi l l j c J U J V I J

1 UUJIJ 1 i l j '• . M b j ^ J U J AAI j j l l a j ^ j l i ( jUJI IJA J J .A.0UI U J V I J SJJAJI | j ! iU! l ! aUl

.AAI j j i l U laL -U U b J j Uuij.a LflJJjJ Uaj l i."I'lJin a J i U u j . A i l i j i l j ^^^ilA^L JaJjJ

AA! j j l ! A-uU j c A j j . AJIJJ! AjaaJ J J J j j jU l l (jUiJa . jJljaJI j 'UaJVl jJij.'U Uaa j j j J V AJIIjill j

1 0 tjl 1 j j i k j i p J J J AijflSlI CUI ja .y i |_5-iJ ^JJflJ! J c (_iaj ( AjaU QA . * j J l j * U i ! QA J a J i J j

1 a J -a" j l ! j^jU I—Laj ( t i j i l AjaU Qa J . (p J j U l f t l j a j ) AA! j i i U A U O J b c ! i_jlSjjU ! j - iU

. (•• ''-l|] A__JS!)UI J J C J u l i_jlSjjt J c ( j j i l a j J I j a a j JB UUji-Q AJI QA j - a i i J I (Ja.1 QA I^-SUJIJJ

j__c «j! ill jji_i3U! r;!l.jal AalSi jV JJ (AJCU JJSI AJV -kia j J . »J-ili Ajjlji e.'^ fn jl ^J-^jj

.A-xlo AaiSj QA JJJSJ j jSt J t , AjfLiUl J J C C J U J J - U

( U U U u i U y i f i j j b J i

tA ilr.J .LgjAljJ (J-aaii S j j U J i J i l l^ jJ j ' U ^ l J c t-^Jaj . j l j aJjSiJ a!jl -A — j I U I j>jj2jJI •

(Igit—Ja J aljC ( jc AJJ^I (. i. i 'i l^XlU Q A J , ( j U a J J ! U l j j i j ftljl J c J-ilnJ aAjSjlI j j i

.1^1 jJ3 j j u i a j j AJaSlI J J U I jt,...' ( d U ^ j j l l aJjij Cy UJJ J " U^-^J

I A__iUa j l AAI J j l l ClUiU-i JjLaj L.,'c .1 im.AJ J j . x U I j a J A-^jajJi ^ A —JLJA// _faJ - iAj j I I •

JUai (-JISJJ! J j A^J>JI j k l a J j j i-JajUl Aa,jl JjJaJ J J IAAI j j i U A l i - i JUal ( U J J - I ( p J j

.t j i l j j k U J l j ^ U.>ill A^a-jt A ^ U o J c ^*Ugil C i l j i A j j t i i j (AA\ j i l U A U O

JjjVI AJ-JUJ! jljjj Ji j-1 A-laUl QA JUI IJA j ] J

Page 20: Aprii 2008 - INTOSAI · .(iiij U«a j-jjl l.ia. jjj*M Jj\ J (JjVl Jj^l bijji.! J3 (UIJ fi*J r^^>VJ1 ' j*' liaJ—L-al jUa ( ^j JaU! UJI CjljU l JiU UJJ uil A^jjUl! .ij^l j.a aC-jl!

Ajb! j i l l AJ-IAU igCJi a j U j J ( u u ) JaC A A J J CU^JJJI Jai .'AjtljjJI <iAAU ji l iJI ( j C j l o j b j •

. jjjS jil CllJ AAI jill AJAAI Jja (jjSjUUl! '" 'i • "'*!'' - CJlSj c

1 at - 4 A I J I L COLAJ JLLAAI ij^jjuM AJLII I£1JIM QJSJ U ic J J j Q I UJC L-IAJ IJL U U •

J .5 lil j i lU J i ^ y i j k U o A^Ua J "Ua l^jlc L_JaJ b AJjgJl U*J J J U ! AJJjj (Ua^jj!

(Jjiii 11 jU__J UU-ajjll j J j J ^-Uj j k U o (_5 !jJ .Ul' 'l QA j jS jUUI jSU AJJI J j i ! J j U

. j k l i J l iJl3 j.a (Uii i lU AiiaSll

CJU .AjLta (JaC Ajai / jJjflJ CJU J-iC A-i j j l J^Uil rLJjA j lS — UtJ ^AC AIA. / J J J ^ •

r - j _ U j__aj . - j " l ' j j ] l ( J U - O J J A C U O Cy j jS j u . i c j l J A J j j j j J I j J J U I I t _ i j U I U l j u i l UV l i . ^ U a J c Ajj^l a j j i a j J J j J A j j j j j j l U b l j a y i J lUl (-.laj J x a j l j ^ J d j ^ l

. ^A! jjlU J iUy!

U U J f i 4J i j j cy U u i j ^

j j JJ 1 JjJaJI . J a l j ajJ a j J JoC ' U j j J j U j - i lg.- i l j iUl ?tJjJajj aj J l j a Jjll alj| ^ A Ciiui aljl

.Ajjbu-a A.i I A J A j a U o AUa, J!-U (ja Cj.ojq JJ'IJ U l j a j Axjjt QA UL-U JJSJJ . -U lU ! U l j l a i

U U J f i ^ j j 1^1^ (lUajC JiU Ciljk^I : 1 J J A J I

•UrfJl u l j l a l

U l f t l j a j JiSVi .1

AiJj, i- i j'i'sVl ' ' ' ' I 'b- l t j l i l i l . 1

Ajjoiliii-. j * ^V l l-ll \l,nTll Aftil j l l ! j k U - 1 Jil-(1 .CJ

A U J I I jkLUaJI jU"i;\l . U

Ajil jil! SJIJI aUaJ AjUa L^U ^\\<s

J —11 5 U i j j>j«' l* A r l , , - . 1

A'8.0- J c "A'Vt^j JJJSJ JIJCI .i_J

( JAJ I ' ^ J J -JJ°"'

JJJILAH » i ^ j

1 jjjUal! aJaj

2 jjiiUail oAaj

3 (jtiyill o j ^ j

4 (juUill oJaj

^<.iKll

' U A U U I

2_a:UI UJ AjjiUllj AJJV! UftljaV! JUC j . J j V l Sjki l ! . CJI^Ij^Vl J JU : t l o^\M Sja.j

^ Sl IjJl u i j j AJJJUSIJ AJJVI UlftljayU A J U JIJCI AJ^! J C i-jaj (JIJC^I AJLC J ! l i j . Ajj^U

.A-Ua aJcU Cy t>-lkjVl j-1 JlJ JjtJ A-i j j l l jS-y Ua .Ajij j i l j ic J i JjJ^UI UJjUI

J —AJUJU—ail aJ U ftiJ^j J J ( ajkiJ! aJA J . ' U W U A j ^ i Ub lU l jUUl :(_j 1 (JUIUAJI S ^ J

j j S j U Jl j U U j . 1 1 ajiaaJI J Aa.jU! Uftl j^VI MAAI -AA!ji lU Aii_<i JUaV J A J I A A J U U I

CJIJ jkl iJI JjJaj tJiJ Jsu jUo^U •"••-'j i-Ua-j AjuiUa. jjSV! ULUf- CC^I jl jJjUtll AJLJJI J

. U 1 Sj ia i i l AxjUll a j i aJ I ( J ^ j j i A 5 ! ^ 1

Jiljii U-iUUt jljJJ Ji j-1 A.UJI QA JUI IJA ji.a,jj \ %

Page 21: Aprii 2008 - INTOSAI · .(iiij U«a j-jjl l.ia. jjj*M Jj\ J (JjVl Jj^l bijji.! J3 (UIJ fi*J r^^>VJ1 ' j*' liaJ—L-al jUa ( ^j JaU! UJI CjljU l JiU UJJ uil A^jjUl! .ij^l j.a aC-jl!

J U a j S j _ J a i J ! aj__4 J - U w U t a J jSV l U U I U U A\h ' \ r , ] \ AJb\Jl \ j J s l w J J U iC i 1 J i i o l i S i i J

• ^ J l l UUIUI - ^1 jiiU JClil JUaV A U I J jklUo JUJI Jjiui J c - AAI j i l ! j k U . j jS jUUl

. "U j j iUa j i S V l 1^1 j U c l J c (—1 1 a j i a i i l J U j U i !

2_t^aii-> igA j . ftljui J ^ J c ( J U l j J a J I pg'l- l l ! J i L A J a Aaj j j t .a J i A ^ U U I U l f t l j a ! ( j U U - a i j

.2 f j J j j J l J

U u U m Cilp-lja.) (_UUu :2 Jj>ull

U \ j ^ t ^ i UVbJ.j i i j i iU ^ijlill JUaVl/ikiu^l/UVbUI ^^•^^fij K—J(db&-

^ouum.

U J J U O — O 1 J.iJJ ' '• f ' y " - ) ' . ^ ' J J U I > J J J I J t i U l j j J a (CJ IJJJSJ

J j a l ( I _ J U 1

^""l'^T^^^ ' f f l " ' ' '"'K" ( C l U l k ( C l l f t l k c

A j i b ^ b j (?Ua t U l j I ^ ( * i U (t l iUja-a

('4jj..a U ^ U b - j j A d^ I ( j U U l j t j a i J i-j-^ 1 j ' l

A j J j l j J b c l ( ? u j U a j

(J jUj ic . ( f t U a i ( A a a j b (SUabo ( J J a j ( A J S I J * ( U I J I J I

(UlU-aU Ax jSJl j j j ASIU

JbcVI J /UJUJI J

j a U

C j U a j

I j ^ l

L>'=">

Cjlftljal

C l U - l ( ( J J U J CUJJJJ U b j U o ( ' U J jp i j j b j U o A x b AJSIO a j b j

fJl UjjUax (UIJSISX (Ulj^ib (CJUJIJX J U (Ajjaj J u Jl^ol

; j__^-a l <A , . . ' i j ^ - J U a _ J ) J U a — j J!Xg"h.iitj o j l j j ( C i U j U i b

( L - J J - U I U

J L j a J

J J U I U a J J . A A I j i i U J i U l A j l b j a V U a j J W J i ( j U U a i i l J l j j x J S l j l J a . l j l ^ ^ J ! U l f t l j a . y i

A__j-bjC J — J S I J_A J l j j i ! ^ j i ^ ( J i l U l ^ j j ^ ( J ^ U l f t l j a y i j . A j u i U U l -Jja"' ( j j jx^aic. J U J V !

A U U J I Ulftlj_^p^ AJ«_JIJ JUl JlJSj . JJSI uU j i x j ^ j a j j ja. j i I j U AAI j j iu JiUyi CJVUI

.'Ua A-ob Jjj^aU

AJjjta U j j l a j A J a J j J I J - i t j J I ( j^axj j U ( A J L U ! j l A iJajJI Qc A J J J U I I I ' ^ J J J U U I J j A i U a y i j j

. A j j j j b U l j x J^ j i J l l J - i l j J l J c Al ixU A J U 3 J j J a J ! . A J U I U U ! J I J Q A JUJi j l [ j S - U I

^ j j jV I U-"bJl o'^ji^ (Ji Cy ' 1=^1 Cy -^-^i ' ^ i ^ j 19

Page 22: Aprii 2008 - INTOSAI · .(iiij U«a j-jjl l.ia. jjj*M Jj\ J (JjVl Jj^l bijji.! J3 (UIJ fi*J r^^>VJ1 ' j*' liaJ—L-al jUa ( ^j JaU! UJI CjljU l JiU UJJ uil A^jjUl! .ij^l j.a aC-jl!

<UwiUUl (jA : u j J l i JjaljJI :3 J j ^ l

j U a j J I j ajbyi

( j . f l b j j V l j x 'Ula Aja j i J a l j (J -r-^ ." (JJS Q A S J I J I

(JxJI Aab l j x - '^ "'• C j L U - U a j j S U j j j i l a j x

j j i k j J ! i - J ^ L>^ ( ij> (>> ftV j

^..^jki-ll JSJ^I

^ &J3 aj a J J ^ x VIC ^ - lU j q 'AAJLJI Ja aJaa

AjjtiUI ( JJUJ I A-uiaUJ j b V l j l (JOjli j j Uc

JxiJI ' ' jufk

J ]9'i" (JaC I Aaikx UUa^Ua

JaJll

ajijLx A In ijitiy Ajb U l E U

'*Jijjui j l JxVl ejjj_<a3 ( J l b j j J x /ajjij-sa AUA

(AJJUJ Jbc l ) (J-aUj ab pUaa aL^ (Qa JaJi

J—jjli j l (j—SUI j a Ljjl Vj (I^IJ J * J ^ 1 j j jialUx CJJU Jt, o!ibl o j jSU l (JxljJI j l j j a J j

. J!iUyi IJA (Jix ( j i i l j ) l U l j C j Ail j i lU J!lUj U V U U jJa A J U U I j x

J—Si Aiji—JJ 'L—AI j j j k U x J J U J j x j jS jLuJ I j S J ( j k U J I j AJJJUUI J J ^ U J U J I a l j iUiUj

.ftl jal JS! oJJaJI j k b U U AXJU JIJCJ tiil j JJU J J . A J - I U U L J J U ftija]

(j_—0 AJ.JI—jjjil AAI j j i ! j k U x j U i ! J J (aJa.jl! oJA j-uJa .^UJjH JJSIAJI j l J ^ l : ^ 1 j-tUfiil B I U J

j k l a U l ^ I j j ) J JaS j j S j L U I Cy 'a ' , ' " ! ' ' ' ' f j H Jal^iil J c ftU J . C i l a j i a i i l i j x oJxUxl l A J U l l

.jL^Uiil J ja t^ijll J ^ba.j J l J^j i i l ! ^ j .ftlj=.l JSl J j V l UUJl JcV l

^ J x ^ U i i ( j x j j S j U U l j S - ^ ( oJa j l l oJA (jxj-Ia . 4 j b l j i i l S J I J I A L ^ A J U £ ( ^ J J AJJAJ :2 j -ubAl l O ^ J

J—aC j ! — k l i l i i i—UI •••... v-i,-....! . i j ^4M-^1 ^ ! j j * j l .^ j f l ^ l f l . ' - - ; KA U ^ J l l A A l j i l l U f t l j a . 1 ©ft US

J a j ( J j j i ! J i J l j aJ iaU! a-aVl i j b CjUgJl J a x i ( J i j x a j U l A J I J J I J J J U J I J C ftU Aji! j i J l U y u

J S u i J I J (JO^ J ^ b S A-uUJj j j j U c U j - l u u C la - j J i l ( j i l j Acj-ia_o S j U A x j j l (j-u-ia al iaJl a U

. 1

J J j V l U U J U J I j l jJJ J i j x AisUt (jx JlUl IJA J J 20

Page 23: Aprii 2008 - INTOSAI · .(iiij U«a j-jjl l.ia. jjj*M Jj\ J (JjVl Jj^l bijji.! J3 (UIJ fi*J r^^>VJ1 ' j*' liaJ—L-al jUa ( ^j JaU! UJI CjljU l JiU UJJ uil A^jjUl! .ij^l j.a aC-jl!

kx \ j l \ ia^Ja ^Uij :1 jL^iSI

<Ulc iajljJa

AJJJUJI JaC j U l

7

j U U J l /d 1.,il,,1-, tl j , u - .

JJJUX J a i

8 AAljill 'IJXAU fj^j

9 ajUyi J j b

10 5ngl! Aalij

11

2 AiLa Jajl.Ua

^ U ^ ^ Q ^^^LA 3

AxiajlJ CJUJ JUL) 4

A iU IJ AJUJ/ U J U O 5

j o l

j i U l l j j U i V l

6

12 AAljill CJUIUX A J U X

13 AifbU!

14 U U J I J A i l j J !

j uU i ! I "c^ 1 AfljO-JI Ja j l j jU l i"l,jirt>.-i . i j . (Cj l f t ! ja^ l j AUaiVlj ^e-uiUl (JSJIJ JaJJ U U - a J I A.U,aj U Uaj (^yb A J U J I Jajl J J U I

AjUaUl j i jaUJI j>x UajLi aJaj j l (JJx / - " j I J b AxUI -lajIj-UI Aja Qi ' i - \ C j U j x a J I j .AjjgJl AflLsjj ((JxJl j a ( J j U l J c

, Aiiaiil a

?t^j__o ,1P CJU J-JU J . Jalaj -^g-t'ifi JZxi. Qa Ljlftlja.yi 'J^-^l AJJUU ajijll JJiU ja jjSjUiJI jSJ JxJI 'UJJ [JXAJ

.4 J jJaJ! J (jJJx jA bS Ai!>b UlJ j U i l J J J U X J C iU jUx '^JOj! (jx ( 'alrn ( b Ja. J j U , ,.•. J<'<- ^"

( J j j V l AjjjiUUl j l j J J J i j x AiaJt (jx J U I IJA |aj>,jJ 2 1

Page 24: Aprii 2008 - INTOSAI · .(iiij U«a j-jjl l.ia. jjj*M Jj\ J (JjVl Jj^l bijji.! J3 (UIJ fi*J r^^>VJ1 ' j*' liaJ—L-al jUa ( ^j JaU! UJI CjljU l JiU UJJ uil A^jjUl! .ij^l j.a aC-jl!

AAI j i i l J M U L 4 i i )uJ l j l J l V ! j j j U a j A J U I I U L J U X :4 J j ^ l

• • • : j i # ^ i

(jioilix JIUA j a j j Ajt Jc! V

r 1 ••' ll a y. f.^\\i 'iA — ttj Aj l J c l

AaJax JJC (j j j j l ix i l j l j i j c t

. .1.1 '10,1 i-^lIt * — AJ AJl J c l

(JtLljliJl (jUaJ aJ 'UU j i j c !

AlUa ( J W J I U I CiilS (jj ^ i V

(jiujlix ( ^ U A J > J J "U! J c l

(jiUjli-Jl ( J U J J J AjU jaiici

AiUi (juJjlixlI j l ^a""-l

^ffjUUl

1

2

3

4

j! 3 tUl li^l JOAO 1 AJUU J .(-_ijiiUI aJajil (jjUx jA (jjUx Jc! jU (IJUI (Ua Cy

J . ^ J 1 " ' '"-- U j i J a j JS l tdU ?tJi-aij . ( j jJaj l l AJJU J J C J ! 'UXAI JSI j j S J (jiiAjbnl! (j-axj

.uUjijVl AIJU ajj bjjc jUcVI (jjwj JIJ •JiUj i_ijiiUI jJ! Jj ajajll IJJJAA

(j j_-j A_£lUI J IJ (Jill jail SJ__aj (juSJJ . J ^ *Ua i j J J j i j ftjlj] ' • ' r^J 13 j ^ W ^ l U l i k j

j j i n i aJl ( j l jA A...a; ^ j k j i j A J l j J l j . (2) j i i j j l i J l j (CJ 1 ) Uuibua. JJSVI U l f t l j a ^ l

U k Jia ((i l i j i L u J . i ju 'U jSSVl J b AjuiUa. U l f t l j a y i JiSi J » U A J X O JJSVI J

iUil (JSuj U U j i a J I aJAj .(jjLjjliJl aAi (3J . ' " ' ' J j J ' " ' * ' ' ** Ufi ^ J - * ^ t.ajS ^ I j ^ l j J ^ j U J !

.ajlj')f! (JxC A i a i j J j j l j J

A jUyi j jSjUi Jl j x U k (CJui JxC AJ^JJ AJI^ J . JU ! 'U i j j *u i j :4 i>uljAll 6 i * j

.l^tj (JxJI A_ujjj -Jja" < '° ''j^ ' AjluiV! j)x Acjx^x Jc

^ j J l /jLuJl (3*10^3 '"''•" b\Si

A__oSa.A J U'x a J a l j j ( I j j l jA J l^ijx-^ Jac J l l Cuui J A C J J J l^Jc U j U l J & UUi l l

j l—J C y j L U ^ J ' C y j ^ J J J ^ i*^ (Jj-aljU ^ U j J j J J U Usfaa ClilS Lgj-iai 'UJ i i j ^ l AJU j l l

( J i j • "J . j J j i V I (.^U_^V! ftb-acV aUx j j S j j j i I" ' ' • ••_• A al." nil a jAlaJl j (J ib j l xJ I J j U

J U U J CibajaJI jjx Jj jJl j jaj j J aJU JJSI j jS i ja [.Jji! AjjjjU U j j jU JJUJ (jUa

• . " J " " aljiUuVl j U Ujail JSJJU ( jaJ j . ( J j i l A J U J 'LU3 U U J J J abVI JJ.'U" A j U i (.^Jx

n j SJ ' '°J • •IJ ( j j j i l U l j j i j x aixjil jSxJ t QA Jjiau U j u i AJUJU UUI a j ^ ^V I (jJJ '" ' '•" '

. Ig,'.iiS'i SIJVI J C UUjaiajil QA J j j J I i>bt J U J I

7-JJ Ajli (SIJV! a l j i U l A j j a j j f-U-jJ J j L ^ j ^ j lSJJ j j l (CJui J j a . ( J b j k J l j x J j j J j

j l [email protected] : J l Jl j l j Ul , lc U j J l J JUa :Vl

idehaab(a).rekenkamer.nl

(B—a a u j A n i j A U j U ' d f t l j a l CjLjjSa '. J j \ J pb?-j j (CJUJJJ ( t J l j j l U " Jbajl j ia j l 1

. (^Uj j j jU AAAAAJAJI AkJ l ^jJ-ii J j a ' ^Ual CjbjUa J c J j - ^'I JA} QA IQ A^JUI

j^yJJjVI A J U I U J ! j l j J J J i j x AiaJt j x J U I IJA ^ j 2 2

Page 25: Aprii 2008 - INTOSAI · .(iiij U«a j-jjl l.ia. jjj*M Jj\ J (JjVl Jj^l bijji.! J3 (UIJ fi*J r^^>VJ1 ' j*' liaJ—L-al jUa ( ^j JaU! UJI CjljU l JiU UJJ uil A^jjUl! .ij^l j.a aC-jl!

^p^ cfi oO

^. O Q

Ujjijlu.VI AJUI

( ^ U j J ! J ^_^i^ l j U V l Ji jK%"ll j j J x t U j j j U l j J U j £ J A J

(J'L__UJ jS iV i j U ^ a J - f'l j ' l^ . 'Vl UjU-v"ill J j j x ' _ '. ^ ' ' - ' " " ' - I . " ' ' Jaa i U i x J j j J l U j a J LoS

al gJi J j j i I.J4i j i i i V U a j i J l J ^ U j l U j j a j J t V ; j j j ) j . ( U U J I ^ U U l j U ,»_uiljil

J .^aSlo J a l j J £ ^ix J j a j j U J l ' r l U l U J l i 1 J x C J ,-w- - "ll J l J .Axj'Jill U i U l l C i l j j J l

U J a i i J A U a J I oJA J J l j J y C ^ u a i - i U J j A 'l^Jjta ^ J l J> °V I j J J j x j U ( t d i j J c ftU

J . , a a j J l C i l j a U U U ^ I j J'l-i-Ul J c A J J J I t U l A l i U J U a U l I j J x JaV A j a J l j U V I

A U-11 J c t l j . Ja l ' U U a i l ^ U J j U l IJA (JjajJ .UaljAl i j j i a j j U U l j U V ' j j . ' U a U U

JiU j l ^ J J ^ ' - ^ ^ j .2007 J o j jJ 'S _yU. 2005 j j J j a C i j j u i J i j "AjaJl juyi

J JjkJl J^--i J A J J J U l j a l J c Aa.jJl J l l : j S j J J U J - J S : "i JS ' '"^--j IAJA J j x J l 'JA

Q a , ' I r -V i J c a i 0 j J ^ ^ • ^ ' a U l l J _ J ^ • A J J - O J j i S i •-• j U ' i j ^•,... J j t A J a i j ) ^ J i U ' o b j ' - J

' .X'\ U l ^ l J J U J I jjan-.'.l i-JuiaCa J^iU j x ^ I j j j j j - U ' IJA j j ^ J ^ j xx ^Jjl ^Sla d! iU jx

L_lJjUl1 j j U i j S

CS—'4 - L S ^ r*^j r*- ' j ' - J* ' • ' • J ^ 3 J i j S l j

U _ _ i a ( T H j j j J I J A J U J U J c V l j W J l J J x c l

ej ' lg j J oa.1 U J l j - 1 9 8 6 f c J i x J x J ) U J J

a 5 IC -kJa ll C : ' - i J ^ J j l ' - " j l A j i j iO t Q A j j j l a J l

J l o ^ ' . a - x U j J I J ^ J J . J ^ A A J I J J J j ' u -aJsV l

( I j — J j t x 1 a b ' u — u ' . a - o j ' i s J x t j j l i j j ' . S . A j J l j

J j l C i i l S J i U j . A J ' •,--. -' j j S J j A ...... j . ^ dJ . " I ' l K j

J £ j , i > . k ^ D ' U C J S '_oJJC j i U l A J ^ J J j l j J

ft' jiil ^ j 11 jc'i uil .-••,<; . ' - i j - AJIJJJVI U i j U l

CiJ j j ^_5-JU J j i l l fUSx j j . J x J i CiLkj i jJa CJI j ia

j Sl ^ I Cl ii. — AJ uUJij ^ .''ijll Aji^ J

j__iC C j b J Jajx U l U j j ' j U j j l i J I OLCJ—sajJI

. j'JaaVl sAlA J c A i j l b

^ ^ J j V i U U L U I j l j J J J i j a A U U I j a J U I IJA jia,JJ 23

Page 26: Aprii 2008 - INTOSAI · .(iiij U«a j-jjl l.ia. jjj*M Jj\ J (JjVl Jj^l bijji.! J3 (UIJ fi*J r^^>VJ1 ' j*' liaJ—L-al jUa ( ^j JaU! UJI CjljU l JiU UJJ uil A^jjUl! .ij^l j.a aC-jl!

J! i j ! Ji Cua ( Jj_^jj-i J ''"-'"11 J^'C a^Uil ( . jUjSiVI j J j x j J a a ! j l AjajJaax CjS J j

A UA.lt j ! j c- A k^U A _ j J J J S U J J I ja — (^gUjjiVI ^ J I J J ^ b S j ia i j l U j l ja l l

j x^ l J j i j ' • j U alxjAU (ilij UXJIJ jsa (^JgJl (JxJI J ftlSjutS Ul AJUIUJ .AjaJl^^Uiyi

Cl j is ( i j U J I J c jAJU ^j.t>)a J jo j . ( . JUJJJV! J C Ija. ab j ^ U AjaJl j U ^ l AJai-U j U

, J.o"..,. nil J tJisJ J u a i j i j l J x U j I j . Ill'l (JuJajj j j j i a j alajU OJJjS a j i a i i l l Hii J9 <UUJ1

U J U I aj_g.ablJ A J J J I J J J U J I J X C j l k l J c U jso l l J c aSjtUil j l J j l (JUJI JJJU J C

aSjjlui UuS j (AJJUJII U I J U J I J UJJJUO J j Ajt,ja, lUI ' ^ .a j l l aS^ j j jo i (UJS j j j U j AJUJU

I j | JSJDI bS ( j j j i j j J J A . A J ^ I UajUj J J J 4JXJ«-11 < J J U 1 I A £ U ! A J I J Aj-iUaJI AISJ^I

? AjaJl j U y i AJaill U a U j l AaUj jA I JA ( JU l j l k l j l

( ( - a J l j j uiV! k j k u l l jJJx t..Ji.ifflJft J j p l U J ^ J H j j A J j a j j S l V j l J l x ! j l U a U ! V

( ^ j J J c l J . j l j j l ! j -a j U ! (^U j i iV I J J U ^ ^ J U I j U y i Aiai i ! (_pUajl ^ j AjlJ C i j l l J j

JJSJJ . i U l j ( aJaU! ASIXXII a b [_^Jxj L-i l jxS b b j j j i i c JJU JCUJ j^^jll j j J J j j > j U l

L ^ J U J . O J U J LJ a IjjJa. U a i a j V I J j J J ( ^Jll AJSJJXVI eJaUJl UUVjU ^ U I U I j J I ( j S j

A 'lb jS-y V b l J ISjJ Jal . ( j j J I JO J c ( j U j i j I i U A J J U I b g j b j i l jJjSil al j U V U J J J A

. a ^ j j j IjlxC J-..9ljJ j l U l c j jAJJj (IXJIJ aUJ! j-jJaxj IJSA ( jSl j "* j f l " "

g 3 J L J J I juJc ^L-jiUil (_2UjSiVI Cy f 'J^^J '^ J ^ ^ j J ! ° .^ I ^JJAC J Aic U J - U I J j l b

( j j U l JA J c p j J a j J l J j a aftU U L i S U U i c Jal .Ajili l iUVI ( J J J U I I A ^ J J C J ((JijxSJl

AJDJU UJVI JJ—a. A a j j JIJCJ j a AJpJl J J J U J I AJaJ ( jc AaUJI Ajcjail AjUSl U i S J JBj .

ISSAI 10: Mexico Declaration on SAI - t^l—uijSiVl jJij—* i^—i 1 cv:' fU j l i j

i^j—l\j .A—atiix ^Iji J AJDISUVI JI Aa.UI (jjj uljia j U JlUi . Independence

JjJ—11 ( j i u u U A J U U JiJS ( j J JxVl j U AajUil J J ' tr fJJj j x i AoS llaiuiV! j l (jiaj UxlUx

a j l j j Q—a Ift j - H ^ AJUJIS J c V l b j l ^ J U J ( U a l ^ J j l ^ J (J=- J i J ^ ' ^ J L U - H ^ cj^l

j _ A J U I J i U U V l J . ( ^ j i i J J J I U J U JlJS j x V l J l j j V Jaj ( I j i 'Ui i i l ^ J a U j i AJIUI I

j__A '"'I aj. n AJI j j J pJUjl! J j i ^ j d j ^ l j " U l ^ J ( J J U U I j U U l Aj ja. ( jS l j ( J ^ J J J J ^ ' . i''l

a_J j l aSl jJ j aSikUx JAiJa A.XJJSJJ ( jUxJ ! IjA aftlj3 J c T ^ - ^ •••! ^J j ! J • U^ail Axb A.— I \

. J i J a j U ja I jJ jS j

aj__aj IC—Aj UU! AJa-UI i jac J j a j jUaa t ib i j A Uj jo i ' j j -a j JJc J i j i o H JJJJAC J j

. l ^ U a c l a l j j bS J i U J ! j a J ajij lI JJJJIJ (AxjUlt AjaJl j U ^ I A-laail j l j c ^ U

j l ...j"^'Mt A j a J l j U y i ' ba i l ! ( j J U A J J U J ! JJxVI J j ^ Cjb J U l QA J j j J I J c Jjj-<aaJ

[email protected] : J j j i S l V l CJJJJJ J C ^ JUU^l ^US-u

J J j V I AjuiUJt j l j JJ J i (jx AlaJl QA j U t IJA ^ j J 24

Page 27: Aprii 2008 - INTOSAI · .(iiij U«a j-jjl l.ia. jjj*M Jj\ J (JjVl Jj^l bijji.! J3 (UIJ fi*J r^^>VJ1 ' j*' liaJ—L-al jUa ( ^j JaU! UJI CjljU l JiU UJJ uil A^jjUl! .ij^l j.a aC-jl!

j j a u i l j ^^. jUo 'X1, | j j : i ' i i iuall U*]! ^ ^ \ j ^ j l ^ ^ l j d i y S ^S^J-

1—JJl A—iail l j J — u i j J i i U o j l j y i j (_1__JJXJ11 A j J (Ji:ujJal t 2008 ( j l j l j x JJ!JC x-iLA J

(j i i laJI J i QA CilSiji J l ! UUl AJaJJ J j V I p b U V I J * J l J j l S j . j i j u i l j J JxVl ajiL-aall

.2007 *b j_iU j j j U J JjuSJI J JLUJI j juuUl j *-jUil AcUul J i jLAjnil (^JjiJI

; U J ^ J l j j ( o j l j y i j J j j - J ! AJaJ A1U„ 0 ' - " UaUi l AjJlt JxJ i j

UU! a j ^ V l U l j j a JJJ»J AajUl JJJ I I j a J j j x j J c Jjj-taaJU ( j l U r J ^ j l j c l •

.(_^UjJJ^ ej j i l l ftU p j j U ACJJ ftUjacVl ^ISjU

. 2015-2010 ^aljcbU t^Uj j i^ i i A J U I j U y i A U J ! CiUa3 •

J A (|J j k l u l j J tflt'inll ^ U ^ l j L U I AJUl! ^ U a P l j d j l J V l j J j > u i l SiaJ

JjJ—11 jJxUil ( j j i l j x l l SjCjJI ( a j l j V l j JJJXJII AJal (JuJJJ ( Ajaall AxUI J j J I J U x A-aj jS j

( ( 1 Uj__jJ! / AJ^I JJJUJI AjJ (_Uj ) JjUJ! : ^ j UaUl AjJil Jj aU(mi AJUII

jjn—JJ) J—i^l ((.jUjliVl AUu ajjUxj ^tjjjil! ( (2 Uj^l / ojJall c,U AJaJ jUj) 4-ijUI

UJ—^I I ajljVlj JJJUI AjJ (jAj UU) aJaUl CJUVJI! ((3 UJ^I / CibjiUl JJU AAAI

(_JJU1 j i—UJVI k j k.^"^l! j j J o j 0 I.l l k J3j . ((.jUjjJ^iU AxUll A J J U J S J I ) b u J l j ( (4

( j j i l j J j l aJ a U I ClUVjl l j-0 -Uaall AxUI J J J I U k j .AJaJll J I aU- iJVl biaji (_5U Jj!iU

.AjJll

U__i A S J U J I " j l j i c Cia j A-JaUJI A S J J SJJJXX 'b ta l jx A . -fl - tl A'.-til J b c l A_oUi J j l S j

j j—J AJtU—Jl j b — C a j (ftbVI (jJ-x—Uj ( A J I U ! j j j j t J j ( j b i l l AailSx J j Ajxi j i l J j ^ -J I

i — J U J U U U I ajg.a.!iU a j j i i ! ftU JJJJ«J U j g j Aajbil J j J I Acjxa-x ( J j j l l J i J l ( ( ^ U J J J V I

^ l U j J a U J j U J J L J J I J U I p lUa l ( J ^ aJjuJI a JA JIJCI J jS j . "AJAJJUJIJ A J I U I

J j UU ! AJaJll ftUaci j U I JSJ . ( j k i - i l j J JJjJ-il! plxja-V! J ! l i A;.-Ill t b a c i J c l ^ j u j j i

J — u i j i i V ! (jJJ J j - s l j U l j I j J ! ajiii J ag 1 in U j j i j aAlij a j S j J 'oJclill (JSUui a J j j J I j l

. A U U I A c j x a J l j

J ^ J ^ i " U i U J l j l j J J J i j x A iaJ l ( jx J j J t IJA jaa.jj 25

Page 28: Aprii 2008 - INTOSAI · .(iiij U«a j-jjl l.ia. jjj*M Jj\ J (JjVl Jj^l bijji.! J3 (UIJ fi*J r^^>VJ1 ' j*' liaJ—L-al jUa ( ^j JaU! UJI CjljU l JiU UJJ uil A^jjUl! .ij^l j.a aC-jl!

.2015- 2010 (»UJ (^U_u.jiiiU U u l j u y i A J U I UU! Ajali! CUSU jia ((JlJ J l AibbVU

UU-;. ll J j a . I j J j i j [ . j U j j j l i l l (-.aJl j U V I UjU.^"II j j J x ( f - j j j U l ( j J j j i j S a J j J I ClxJa U j j J j

•iq-j •.• i j j l ! ( j j j j U ! ( j U j S i V l JxJJx J j a J i U ( j l l j c U a J l j U y i AjaiJI ( ^ j j a j J j Aj.alj l l

JJ JU AUJI (UJU J lg,'b>U.rt jU UUl AJUII Uilcl jij .2010 ^b lUJl <-rijJA J -1 UJ

jjjUaj (_-i jU—^U! JiAc jlJJU jlJlilj (jijll J ^Ua^Ij jjlUl! (^ijjxj j»! jilVI Jc

. ( j L i t j j i l A A A 1 \ A j aJ l j U y i AJai i l ( J f i j

J ' l • •. ' j (J ' • - A - i i iUJ a j b y i j (Jjj-aoll A-iaJ ftUac! A-oJa! ( ' U a U U l A-JaJI ftl^UjI J u j

( ( jU j i J^ J U ! lUajJIj (ejj l jJU AJJJU! AJUIX ciilj J bj ( (JUJJJVIJ 'LUOUII AJXSUI

^ 1 -••- --l J U J J J U I JiJl jU J.U! (jjxVl ^ j ^ jaj .UUI AjJl J jV l ^UUVI ^ U j •J i-f J ''• J 3 j 11 • xA ab i - a iV l j U j J j j j j J j i ! ( jUig-x ( jJxJaix j l j ' j j ! ^ * j J a * S ^ U j J V I

0j__^Vl j x ) AJCJUI U U A U J I J AJJIJI UI j j j i j i l jU b j ix ; jjUjj^Hi U U J I ylU Usjx

( ^Uyi J J U J L-JU J l (CljjSllj lUj jSj ( AjJjaUl AJJJJI ASUJI QA JSl AJUJU UUI

i ' J '" " Ua—j l A__iaiil C U a U j .C j l i i i l l J j a l i i j l j U l j l j j y i J a j U j J Lg-juxa. Cugj j i l

- U U l j i a V ! (»Jjij c U * J "^-^rlc C i i a l j j A j a J l j U y i - U i J I j J J J X J I I

[email protected] Jii i i l j l j U l J c JUUVI ija.jj (CjbJUl QA JJJJJ

(FAS) AJUI h \ l j [ j A i k U l u ibUi jVL 5^laJl AjejfiJl AiaUl

2008 IP SAJ.!^ IJ& ^

( jV! (.s_JU cUSU^l J l ! (ISSAI) AJUJI UUI aj^^iU ^JUSI AJJJII jyUJl JUCI JJU

U J UJJ t J J J S J a U U A J U I A J U J I U A a k U l C j l j U j y U U a L J I A jCj id ! A j J l l J b c l C i U a l j J

:2008 ab (jx JjVI I- 'fl(- 'ill J )U (jjliija j U J jSAa U

s o o fS ( j LS-ly^^ i J j S j J I jlojLA U j l U I C jLk jaJxJ A A ^ U J I ' J J l AJaiil U a J U j i J i •

AJLOI CJIJLJCI -CjLjyi cjib : 501 ^j Jj-JI cJjAll JLAAJ i "djl^yi <bl " JJA

.aJ-lax J j j J

<ALJ/ (.^JLAIIJ LJIJA yi :200 LJJ-^I CJJ^^ J :}*- (j-aU! ftl jUl l C^j UaJj ^ j jA "

•,L-g^l JJ u :2I0 f^j (Jj^l (JJ^AJI JIMAJ t <JLJI IAULJI JiU? AAAC aSU jJI

Qj XJ Uuyi; J Lin Us JlU/ AJJJAA :240 AJ JJ-JI C^JSJJI jU-ij t ^^Jl

^ sj jjj—'/ (jjsjji JIMAJ i^jui CJULJI ijj^ -lie Jc i^iSjji iSiyiAj jLucyi

. <JiJI CJLLJI (JAA jjc AxUy/^j QjlJU CjljUk.1: 250

U U i a ! i U l J c J j i - o J I j U u j j j a jJ ' L u i j b J I t . ! j L k j a U j j j k J U U I A j J l ! a jS j j l A a j l j j

. Ajuill a^A AJLJ _a IJ I f\'^

J ^ j i i A J J X U J I j l j J J J i j x A iaUt Q A J U I IJiA a a . j j 2 6

Page 29: Aprii 2008 - INTOSAI · .(iiij U«a j-jjl l.ia. jjj*M Jj\ J (JjVl Jj^l bijji.! J3 (UIJ fi*J r^^>VJ1 ' j*' liaJ—L-al jUa ( ^j JaU! UJI CjljU l JiU UJJ uil A^jjUl! .ij^l j.a aC-jl!

AAAH AJJIMIIIIIIV! Ajj^l A^jUJ SJJJ^ UUUIJJ iji ,JJ^ J iAjm

Jc a^jUUil jSxj jyjll j j j U u J l (jx UalS Ijjc UIU FAS AjJl AJJUUXVI A'jgll J U

Aj-aU Ulc j U J j l 'U- i jbJ I ClUajaJxj A_i_aU Ulc j U i j l U i ftljjij ( j j j « - a j x ft!Jii j j U

a J j _ _ U I UcliSJI F A S aJaJU U j U (tilJJl UJJJ . ( l A A S B ) A J J J I ! i j i j j i l j y U j J ^ x J

( j i aJjJa C l b j J j j AJI aJJli J j (_JUJJV1 A-OUX J C J J ( j i U J J J I J ( 'Uj ia. jJ l AJJ^I (_5ji UIU

Jj*^a all ,j«U FAS J l j i !ila (JIJ A-oj .2010 fib J . i»jiii J A ajbl! (jUjSiVI j a j ^

.uil..lb xll jJU* jx Aj-aUj ( Lgjljjj-ix jLU AJU jil UUI aj^-aVl (jx CLUJ-I JC

J j ^ j U u J j^fl''i'>"i A j j U U i V l A J ^ I

J j V I JgJ—11 J Jjfi-Sjlu.- J J j j j J p U i a l JaJ A j jU iUV l AJJ^I ftUacl J j a j cJ I Clg-aj

AJJUJ£—UJ J i b U j — a I—^Ua-g-Jxj A—iaJll (Jxc Cj l f t l ja l j a^-Jjiu U j ^ J^^J j 'UI IJA j}x

l U j U l j ( I S j j U i j S j ( ( jU l iUU l I j ( J U J J J J I (jx JS QA ftljJa p b U VI jCaa. jS j . p j j U l l

J J jj-x.-^ J tA-ijjj»..ui 11 A J J J J I A S I X J I J ( j J a i l j L jU i iSUl l j t U j j J b j ( j l U i j l S j ( U u j j j j l j

. I j i C j I j ( U J J I (_ j j j a j ( J U j U l

jJjfSjU J 2008 JIJ jjJli J ("^UUl JiU AjjLiUVl AJ4JI f.\jiS

2008 f f i J AJC-jail A ^ CiUUUl

J_U j x L iij.;->'i.ii! LSJJIJ (2008 J U J 9-8 •ajiall J i U J J J J FAS AJUI pbu l j i l jac

Ail LiayU . AJaiil J b c U AaUJl UUaill j x JJC A U U J S jaJ j l ASJXXU j l a j i AJUJI I UiSx

. I g br . U f t l j a j j A-iJll i J j b j j i U aJJSJ U j ^ jJ iJ J ftljjaJI j x ACj.-ia_o ,JLxlal Jaa (t*llj J j

.AjCj i l l AJail b U U ! i J j j l i AJUJU J c V l j l ^ - J ! ' °J''-^""J U J J J (2008 a b JJjjSl J j

: JUll j l j U ! J c FAS AJJUJSJJJ J U J V I ^ ^ J J C ibJU! QA JJJXIJ

Fax:+46-8-51714111 E-mail: [email protected] Web site: http://psc.rigsrevisionen.dk/fas

^^^.JJjV! AJ..11UJI j l jAJ J i (jx A laJ l (jx J U I IJA a,a.jJ 2 7

Page 30: Aprii 2008 - INTOSAI · .(iiij U«a j-jjl l.ia. jjj*M Jj\ J (JjVl Jj^l bijji.! J3 (UIJ fi*J r^^>VJ1 ' j*' liaJ—L-al jUa ( ^j JaU! UJI CjljU l JiU UJJ uil A^jjUl! .ij^l j.a aC-jl!

A-UJJI AJ ISJ I i}js^ i j ' ^JJJ^^ J - * A P ^ O nl AA^LA AJC J ACj^A-a

A j x j U l A—JJuU! Ci j l—i-a ( U l j j U U I j CiUaUJI (jx A U U JKJJ (2006 j l j j J j U J

j ! J J c p j l u i i f i j l J J3%jrtl! U j l ! l ^ b j a l J A A A AJUJI ! J j a . t j U j j j J l (JxC A c j x a J

( A_^JuJJI U j l j _ S l l _g lc A J j U ! J IJV I J C AJUJI I J j a . U a U AJC J A C J A A ^ ' J J S J ^

t l i j i l J AjCji l l AJaJl ( j j i l j J j . " A U J I CCUaal! A J I j l j ( A J J U J U i ! j c A J J U J ! C i j I j S i l j

(UUil ( U I j i Cy J ^ AJU j l i UUl - i j^Vl fb l^Uacij (UjSi AJJJ AouiUJ! (JIAA JbJI

. jJJJjjjVl (jjaaU! AxSajij ( Ijuijjuij (USUjU ((^—ijjl! JUJV! dJiljJ ' j l . ^ j ' J !

A J J J J J V ! J J J U AJUJU U U I a j ^ V l ^ j - ; - •^i '.i^-j Ajli ( AJC j i l ! A c j x . U l U t a j J I J j i J U a j j

JiLA Qa J l J j AjCjfiil AC jxaJ I ( j ^ U U i l jxjJa U j l l J J U U ! J C A I U A J U J ftljr^l J c

(JJLUJ ' U O I J U I -bejUJI J j ^ U j ( C j l j U j y i J UU.£ijlill j l j c j j 1 ASj±uLa A A I J J b c ) U J J

J ' - "J jJ^ l j LS' UJJJJVI J aC (OUJA KA J U U V ! J J U J J J j i J j (A1J .U I J J J U X I I J t - jJUV!

.AJJJJII AJUJJI j U J c i j i V I

AS _a (3^J-Ji J b c l J AJC j i l l A c j x a J ! AiajJI (JUai A - u ^ l AJJUJII UUgJI U j J jS j

ai.i^i—Sl a—>U! ftj__Ca J J J J U I A-aj J c j ( ( J j j i j U CjbUJi l j x A J U J ! Jj^Ja J I j xV

J a U J I j i V J i ! J j S J l l j ( j k l i J I j I S j U U I C iU jaJ I j (AAaUSl (ilti J AJIJJJI U J C U U I

a A J A—JCjal! **—Cj-iaUl (jx ftUac! A U j ^ U j l ! J U l IJA J J j U j i j . J j j J j U A J J U J

A aSa-oj ( I j u i J j j j j ( U S U j U j ' y ^ j j l ! j b J V l j ( I j i l j J j (U l jS l j x JSJ AJUJU UUI e j ^ V I

UuUV ^ U j U 5—IcVl jWJl Jlo U U l AJU j i l UUI S j ^ V I JlJSj ( j j j j j j jV l j i a U l

. I j i i j A j

lem - I?* ' . ^r^^^ i^ (.

• • i \

> •

I • I ;. --'« • • ( ^U j j J l 2 ^ j i l l 4 i J l o^lUl £UUV1 J j jS jUi j (2007 Jj l j j l i £.Ua.! J jjSjLUa

i -^ J

A—JjA-i ,^^ JU! Acj-iaJ jJcUa! UiljSjV AJU jll JcVl jWr^l UUsUiI (2007 fc J

ajCJ a j j i l U l J a l j j j U j l l (JxJl J CjSjUi j l l a j ^ V l J i j (jx A J U (.gJjl Cua ((-US

( jU l l p b j a V I J i U j . J J J I P j j J J l I—lajxj aJaUl A J k j i l AjUji! J b c l ?JU j L U U l j l

:bJSj& J l J U j t j j U j i i i A J I ^ I ^ U i l l j j S j L U I j ^ L (2007 ( 5 - 4 QA i j A J ^ U j i^cJI

al—c j S l J J Ja^Ul X J U ! L^ l -^ j j j^ l J ^ ' j ^ J j ^ "J '""'J A j i j i j j U f t l j a j j J j U J I j j j i l i !

U J J V I A J U I U U I j t j j J J i j o AkU t j x J jJ t IJA aa.j j 28

Page 31: Aprii 2008 - INTOSAI · .(iiij U«a j-jjl l.ia. jjj*M Jj\ J (JjVl Jj^l bijji.! J3 (UIJ fi*J r^^>VJ1 ' j*' liaJ—L-al jUa ( ^j JaU! UJI CjljU l JiU UJJ uil A^jjUl! .ij^l j.a aC-jl!

J JjAJ a J Jlil..-. X J!J—cl_i ^ jl J j V I C lUbUI jjJa-a ^ j i U J J J (J_J-JUJ ^ • ••"' - AjUaJj .2008

( j j 1! ajlaJl AjCj i i ! Ax- jxaJ! pUual J i A . 'Uc A i j b x U ! J c Jj j -aaJl aU.uj J A j ( J j U x

AjLilui—ol! A—jCjil l A c j x a J I A U U il AJaU aJj j l Uaj l ^ I j i i j .2008 f c jU l J Jajsjjx

. ^ U a V l IJA J I ^ I U J U V l f i U J U I J (AJJUJJ! l ^ b c l J l J J LxJ ( 2 0 1 1 -2009 f . l j c ! ^

- ; ; j ' ' ' j—ox A—jUjl l 1—JJI " a j ^ V I Ails j j U J c J j j - a J I J j A jCj i l ! AC jxaJ l ^.-.ynj

. (gj: .Ujyi J (.JJjiil jJ-iVlj ( AJSUJI A jba j A i a J j J l 'UJUJI ! J j U U t J aj j jS U b U f t !

j l j — j j ! J c AjcjaJ! A c j x a J ! AJJUJSUU J U J V ! ( j ^ j J U b j l x J I j x J j j J I J c Jjj..aa-il j

:JU1!

Fax: :+38 044 2342030 E-mail: [email protected] Web site: www.ac-rada.gov.ua

u u i ! Aj l i j l ! Jja. ( ^ U j j j J l I ( ^U j j jV l p U ^ l

A JaJx j—C j j — U U '.SjU—a 1—cL-ual J j j S J ! ' \ J J J U J I j l j J J ' al •'--'• •'! (2008 JabuJ J

JUJ .AJJJ! AJUJI! JUX J AJUJU UUI ajg-aV! CJIJUJ JJJ (JaJ (jUjjjJI j (.^UjjjVI

.Aijj 1 7 CiaJSj ( plxlaVl J AIJJ jijUj jLn Qa JJj LJSJA

CijjSli j Sifi i^'A U U l Ajl i j i l J J A ^ U U I J i U t j j j j j V l i j J j J ! J J J ! J j j S j U w

: AJIUII CjUxajJ! JIJCI pUJaVl J i U J j

AaJjU! j j j J l I j c A J J J L U I ("il'i.igJiJ i AJUJU UU! ajg_a.Vl j j J j j U i l t • JT- '

-AJJJJ! AJU j i ! '"'1 r ^. X ta ^ J J '''i~- AjjjJI (Cl aaJ! jS! vo q (AjJU

ASjJJx AJJUJ J b c l J A S J U U J A j j j j j V l j A J J J J I A J U J U UUI a jg-aVI a j c J t. i>j

.^UJAVI U J AJJJI UUmi jUij

J "I-- A C j x ^ x J l — o c ! u u Q A oj l i lu iV! If- A j l i j i j b U l " j g ^ V ! J x J i j ! ' '•• •

.A -uJ ! A J U J I U U a U ! L ^ U J J V I

.ASj lu io ••*J'J' ' * j i ^ ! j x pLx l j j J U J ( J A J U J B U U ! ajg-aV! j j U j j j ! i_

J ^ j ' ^ i U i U U ! j l j J J J i C y A i a U l j o j U l IJA a.a.jJ 2 9

Page 32: Aprii 2008 - INTOSAI · .(iiij U«a j-jjl l.ia. jjj*M Jj\ J (JjVl Jj^l bijji.! J3 (UIJ fi*J r^^>VJ1 ' j*' liaJ—L-al jUa ( ^j JaU! UJI CjljU l JiU UJJ uil A^jjUl! .ij^l j.a aC-jl!

(U-JgJ! U l j j i l t Lg-ijj UJ AJJJJJVIJ AJJJJI AJUJU UU! a j ^ V I JJUJJ j l <—la-J

Aj'lj'll C J I J J J J I J ( AJJUJJ! U I J U J V ! J (AJJJJI JJJUJHJ

. AJUJU UUl a j ^ V l jJJ AJJJI AJUJII JbcV ojJajlI UUa.l jJl J U J L_iaj

, A-oI J L I J J I A-lxJjll A l'l l-l ttll 1 "ll I— nl UJJJVI ' L U J I A J ^ Jl iVaC j k l J X A J Q J ('jl (—laj

..lk"'"' 'C—utaU I" '1 •' •' ••. Jjajji ftljji j l j J j U U x A-jUjii UU! a jg-aVI aJaJU j i j

. 'bJU (JIJU A . . -.-^"i., Cil j U

: JUll jljUl Jc JUJV! ^C->JJ UbjUJl Cy ^j^j

E-mail: [email protected] Web site: http://wwAv.audit.kuwait.net.

J j j V l AjiJibUl j l j j j J i Cy A iUt j a j U l IJA j j 30

Page 33: Aprii 2008 - INTOSAI · .(iiij U«a j-jjl l.ia. jjj*M Jj\ J (JjVl Jj^l bijji.! J3 (UIJ fi*J r^^>VJ1 ' j*' liaJ—L-al jUa ( ^j JaU! UJI CjljU l JiU UJJ uil A^jjUl! .ij^l j.a aC-jl!

A_ftiaU31 L ^ ^ J l LU*J1 I j i ^ AAjjaVl A^ i i aU l j / ( i U j l ^ l AJUJ S J J U r^J l^ i j^^ IkS^A \ ^ ^

J j ^ JAC AJ I IJJJ dj .^1 ^ U UUlua.1 JUJAJ A A ^ I J J IC'Lu^l ^l.i&aj AJJJ^JV IJ

j_faUljluVl J a j k ^ l

, ' ' ^ ^ ^ - ^ '

a.4U_i ^LLUejjyi ftLu/ OJJAJ i,-^l^t U"

^ I j J j (JAC JLAA ^ CJIJAAJAAII

(_0l uiJUyi < -ix-ij OJJL

aJaUl < 0 j j l »JUj ( IDI) (.jUjjiVI 'UxJ a j j U u j ic (2008 J j ^ j ^ Jkx J ^ - - - . (_ . 3jj/__i^ Jj-~^ -^JAJI ^yiiui,yj

JAA J i l ) AFROSAl-E ^ j JuVk AikUl! AAUIUJIJ AJIU! AJUJI UUl i j ^ SUjVl ^ ' - ^XLI ^ filsJIj jL^jjjyi-liAJj

^ J ^ A_«^ljx ^UUal (A—ilUjJlj j j ikUl! jJ jWJI j (AJJJUVU AikUJI 21 UI Sj^Vl . .n...-- ___ JJI U/j—13 j y . a j x U i x

(I i j j i j j J ^ i 'J* J ( f f U l j U V l . k i k i l l l J j a JxC A-i J j j ( C B N A ) ajJall ftU C J U U U I " • • - - " " • " ^—SJAJ/ JiJl <IAAJI Ln/Jju^y

a-i—jfljj - - aJ l j b ju iV l JaJ k i j J ! ?txUjj ja jJa AcjJ QA UlUJI CjJaJI ( j ] j j l S j , Uflj J l *—iji^ '" " ' •" .. 1^ . _ „ . . ^ ^^^^^^^ SjJil^—nJi_^—JjjjSiyi

(j—a (J S QA j j-aJl j U l UjU--'i J.ac ( j J ( j U J ! jJJ* J J j U JBj . ajJaJI ftU (JlUUa! jluijjjyi

A^^i^ljJ! ^Ual JiUj .Uoljj ((^jXJIj iLjn^ij (jiLUj 'Wjr^V AJUJB UUI Sj^V! http://www.idi.no

IjxU jJllj (CBNA) "ajjill ftU uUlUal fujaj" jjjii jjSjUUI ^ja ^Ul AULU JXUI JA

ftl J—laJ (jjJialj—a j — o I j j J j I jai j JS J • a ^ j ^ I J U j j a l j i l UULJEJI! J C ftU OJIJCU

J " I " A _ U j j ICJ-1_JC( p U U a V l ftl^l J*Jj - J J J J C ftU aA jJ j l i j JJJAJJ I j x U j (jjji-iLixj

->j"'!j1 uiVl -isu—kaJI ^ j j J J c ( JU l ( Q j C i j j u L^XiU j x j l l j ,_yaUljUVl UjU-:>"ll

J !J-_CI ; J _ J ( C B N A ) j j j i j j i l j iU iL b^^l I j x U j . J i ( j U j J V I / ( j U j J V ! U i J S J J L U

"UUJl j i uiyi kk^^l l JIJCI QA J A A i Q j CJAn j l ^ j i j j . U j ^ V U U J J ! j U V l U l j j u i x

.'CajLall J ^ I A J J I j j j JaC J .Tg^joV

j U j j j V l / ^ U j i i J V l A U J B J J U j j j U j j U J U CiUUbiVl Jijjfll J j & 1 J a ^ A J i j j

I—JUI 0 J _ ^ J O U A J J J J ! ACjxaUl (jjjfljjJl [ j J a J I ( j jL-a (2007 j U J . l U J ! A c b U l J

-iSl ( U a ( ( j U j J j V l j (.gUjj iVl Ajxjij e j j b o ( jJ jb J j j J j i C lUUa l a j U ptxUj j J c AJUJU

a j ^ ^ A H J JJSI! J J—J l I j U a i J .pixUjjll AJaJjl J A S J U J I J agjJCj 1 j lg-a a j U 'UJJ-I

i_jj i J I J (JJ"lir. JS J J V I J X J I AJJJJ Ci i lSj • j jJJjx Ig-uiJ A U J J J I Jac aJJ Uj*x3 A S J U J I

i_-ujj J ajj . A.^lrUx ajg-al (jjU jx LSjUx juiUj juy (2008 (22—13 (J ajiall JXA

J J J ( J i U U a l -JJl" (JxC j l k l a t j a j u i U U U U j a V l - j j ' ° " A J I X C J C J J U X X j l ^ - a (JS J a ( j j J

( J j J (J S J c f - J a j ( A U J J I I ftLjJJl J J U J . A J J J J I e j ^ V l U j j l a l Laa j 1 ga j j < " J a j U a l j l j

J " - l l A u J j J (.5—a a j i i u i l j A ( J U l j l k j j U J J V I a l j i j u i U a j l g . U a j j i J ! ftU -J ja" ft!jaj

-J j'a" J - a A j U j U 1 J U ! e j _ _ g - a V l j C j j £ x x J l j * i l j l b S . U U U a l a U j J J j a i j l j c l j

. ^ u b i J U a! j J V l A J X C J^-u iJ U J J J C l U L u a V !

(^L-ujIuVl ^—;UJ ^j>lU j ^ b oJjJI . ^ I J JUa J S'UJ-IJII ^ l - '^^V JaJauil pU^Vl

(5Uj«Vlj

a AJUJU UUl a j^-aVl j x J J U I j i j c ^^JaU! aUll Cijjal j l l (CIULLUV! U b U '"'a"*-:

a-J -jja'tl UUi J c ftUj .AJJUJII l^bcl aJja JJSU A-Jajl ( J J U J j ^Ua j J U A J A H Aiiaio

j-__a oJj ail Jj£U JUo J L_ijjJ jjJU-ait pLua.! jac J j .AJUJU Ulc aj^a.! a j U JjJaj

(jJJjV! Ajjjil-aJl j l jAJ J i j a AlaJl j x j U l 1JA i ^ j 3 1

Page 34: Aprii 2008 - INTOSAI · .(iiij U«a j-jjl l.ia. jjj*M Jj\ J (JjVl Jj^l bijji.! J3 (UIJ fi*J r^^>VJ1 ' j*' liaJ—L-al jUa ( ^j JaU! UJI CjljU l JiU UJJ uil A^jjUl! .ij^l j.a aC-jl!

(J—lj Ua^j^l Cy tJiJ^ ^-U^^ -^j • 2008 ( 18-2 j l j l J Ajjx-ill A U ! JJXJJJ! J V Ajjj^-aa

aJjaJI JJSU J J A (jjCjjuiI A^ljJ JaC A j j j j A_ijjjJ j l jx -j - • r-' ' ' j T ( p jj-iajx ftljji S-"!-

(Jjjjoi J (- 9 ag-ui—JiJl (JJ—Slj eJja JJSU JJJJ aJjjxx J c j l j J ! '"'b"'^*l j i j .AJJUJ Jbc!)Ll

aJjall JJSU aJIJJ ^liaj J c (JJJI JxU U j u i j .AJUJU UU! a j ^ V ! J aJjaJI JJSU UUaljx

(Jj^m jJ A J X C U I J J ! j Jl I h" J U j - j i j ( U U j b J I J j Jaa l j ( U j U j y i j ( ( A Q M S ) ( j U j U L i

. aJ jaJ ! J J S U C j l f t l j a l i j j . 'U "

.v.lc".Tlj A l l u J I J J U U ! J J A ^^HHA n ^ U j j j j i ^ S i i J M M Q A j j j k l H 4JaJ p U ^ I

AjaJil j i Ulj A ki jlj—cj J (jUjjlSil A-Jaix j*_o jjUjjiVI ^J-^U ClJjU (2007 fc J

( j l LUJJJVI A j U o j j l — i x Ju l—a ' j j l U U J ac i j j \ i j j S j i i l Ac JAAA p U a l J«J j .Aj-Jaj

S j c b ^ _ o j A k i i ! ( ^ U j j l S l l j ^ ^ l j U V I JaJaUl I A j J C j l xSU l ( 2 0 0 7 j J j j S I J ( j U j j l S l I j

A iaJ CJ oU (2008 jljl^ J J . (^UjijVl AJXJ ej jbaj aJaUI ASIOJI (jjkjJ! ^ I 5 j USx

5^Uj .2008 I—»1 AJIXC Aiai CJJCIJ Ajaj! j U y i Akil! A*a.ljxJ ( -ojiSyi ^-j-iui^Jl jJjkj l l

1 aaj ( f t l j j Jl j l—JSJ j jxUi l j j f ls j j ] j -JaliJU AaUJl J J U U I J ja . ajala ^ U j j jac Uaj!

. / C1,.,.] 6 i lsi l Aj^Jjt \ 11 .IJ I A t-— ll , fl iiU.% Aa . a. .. rti

( ^ U j l P ^ I * '•''^ - j U a j j b J l j ( ^ U J J V I A J J J S J J L A

I J X J U J U J J U I I U I J - ^ V I A J J S U I AJaJt j ^ V l J t ^ U j i i V l A U u S J J U X j c j j £ x x j i j i a

( ( oJa j J I A S L U I ) ( j U j j J ^ A J I J J I ^ J J I J A C j l k j J j a U U l AJaJl! p U i a ! : \ ^ J ^ a A j j j l i i

A ^ ^ j j U V U A i k U l ! A _ _ i i j J V ! J j J _ J l A J U J I I U U I S j ^ V I A J U J A J X J U I A J ^ , I U 1 ^Uia.1

( j J a J l a j b y i j (JJJXJI I A-iaJ p ' b j a l j t ( j S i U j x ) ( . J U J J J J U L - y j j J l AJaJ p U a l ( ( U l j U j j )

. ( A J S J J X V I eJaJJ l C J U V J I I ) ( . ^ U J I J ^ ^ J j i J i l

( 5 U j I ? i f I A U J O J J U A J J L ^ J V I

^_g—ajj ( ( f i l—u i j j iV ! A — o U B j j l — i x pUil Q A J J U I I JA J A a j j i U I J j U J l QA ( j i A- i^UJ

U U J I j I j U ! J c ( J U J J V I A J U a j j U x j J U J V !

++47 21 54 08 10 : ^k^\ fj

[email protected] : J j j ^ l J^jJl

www.idi.no : j j j iSJy i ^jijJI

J ^ J ^ i A iuUUl j l j J J J i j x A laJ l (jx j U l IJA aa.j j 32

Page 35: Aprii 2008 - INTOSAI · .(iiij U«a j-jjl l.ia. jjj*M Jj\ J (JjVl Jj^l bijji.! J3 (UIJ fi*J r^^>VJ1 ' j*' liaJ—L-al jUa ( ^j JaU! UJI CjljU l JiU UJJ uil A^jjUl! .ij^l j.a aC-jl!
Page 36: Aprii 2008 - INTOSAI · .(iiij U«a j-jjl l.ia. jjj*M Jj\ J (JjVl Jj^l bijji.! J3 (UIJ fi*J r^^>VJ1 ' j*' liaJ—L-al jUa ( ^j JaU! UJI CjljU l JiU UJJ uil A^jjUl! .ij^l j.a aC-jl!

^ .=.,jOS='^1DdS2='^'-