Upload
elder-lima
View
31
Download
0
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
INTRODUO TEORIA DA DECISO
AUTOR: LUS FERNANDO SCHUARTZ
ROTEIRO DE CURSO2010.1
3 EDIO
SumrioIntroduo Teoria da Deciso
1. INTRODUO ............................................................................................................................................................................ 04
2. AULA 1 - O DIREITO E AS SUAS CONSEQNCIAS .......................................................................................................................... 05
3. AULA 2 - DISCUSSO DO CASO GROOT BOOM ............................................................................................................................. 18
4. AULA 3 - ELEMENTOS DE TEORIA DA DECISO .............................................................................................................................. 33
5. AULAS 4-5 - DECISES SOB INCERTEZA ........................................................................................................................................ 37
6. AULAS 6-7 - DA DECISO INDIVIDUAL DECISO INTERATIVA ....................................................................................................... 43
7. AULAS 8-9 - SOLUO DE JOGOS NA FORMA NORMAL: DOMINNCIA E EQUILBRIO DE NASH ........................................................... 51
8. AULA 10 .............................................................................................................................................................................. 56
9. AULA 11. EQUILBRIO DE NASH PERFEITO EM SUBJOGOS .............................................................................................................. 80
3FGV DIREITO RIO
InTRODuO TEORIa Da DEcIsO
3FGV DIREITO RIO
INTRODUO TEORIA DA DECISO
'(7%*3&*503*0
INTRODUO AO PENSAMENTO ESTRATGICO
\2/4%)2/
&TUFDVSTPVNBJOUSPEVPJOGPSNBMUFPSJBEPTKPHPTWBMFEJ[FSBPFTUVEPNFUEJDPEFJOUFSBFTDBSBDUFSJ[BEBTQFMBJOUFSEFQFOEODJBEBTEFDJTFTEFTFVTQBSUJDJQBOUFT
EJSFDJPOBEBBFTUVEBOUFTEFHSBEVBPFN%JSFJUP0PCKFUJWPEPDVSTPBQSFTFOUBSBTOPFTCTJDBTFBMHVOTNPEFMPTTJNQMFTVUJMJ[BEPTFNUFPSJBEPTKPHPTGBNJMJBSJ[BOEPPTBMVOPTDPNUDOJDBTFJOTUSVNFOUPTEFTPMVPEFQSPCMFNBTEFEFDJTPQBSBVTPOBEFTDSJPFBOMJTFEFTJUVBFTKVSJEJDBNFOUFSFMFWBOUFT
&YFNQMPT FTQFDmDPTVUJMJ[BEPTOP DVSTP FOWPMWFSP DPODFJUPT KVSEJDPTEF DPNQSFFOTP SFMBUJWBNFOUF JOUVJUJWBDPNPPDPODFJUPEFDPOUSBUPFPDPODFJUPEFSFTQPOTBCJMJEBEF4FSPVTBEPTUBNCNWSJPTFYFNQMPTEFBQMJDBFTEBUFPSJBBSFMBFTFDPONJDBTQPMUJDBTPVNFTNPQFTTPBJTBmNEFJMVTUSBSPBMDBODFFPHSBVEFHFOFSBMJEBEFEBTJEJBTFEPTNPEFMPTJOUSPEV[JEPT0DVSTPQSFUFOEFBNQMJBSUBOUPFNFYUFOTPDPNPFNQSPGVOEJEBEFPRVFPTBMVOPTKUFSPWJTUPBSFTQFJUPEPBTTVOUPOPNCJUPEPDVSTPEF.JDSPFDPOPNJB
5SBUBOEPTFEFVNDVSTPJOUSPEVUSJPFEFVNBBCPSEBHFNJOGPSNBMEBSTFOGBTFBNUPEPTFUDOJDBTEFFOTJOPRVFJOEV[BNVNBDPOTUSVPQSPHSFTTJWBEFDPODFJUPTQSFGFSFODJBMNFOUFQPSNFJPEFFYFNQMPTTJNQMFT
CFNDPNPPEFTFOWPMWJNFOUPOPTBMVOPTEBDBQBDJEBEFEFSBDJPDJOBSFTUSBUFHJDBNFOUFFOPoQSJNBSJBNFOUFoEBDBQBDJEBEFEFUFPSJ[BSBSFTQFJUPEFJOUFSBFTFTUSBUHJDBT"MNEBTUSBEJDJPOBJTBVMBTFYQPTJUJWBTFEPSPMFQMBZPDVSTPUBNCNDPOUBSDPNBVMBTEFEJDBEBTSFBMJ[BPEFiFYQFSJNFOUPTwWBMFEJ[FSFYFSDDJPTEFTJNVMBPEFQSPCMFNBTEFEFDJTPJOUFSBUJWBB'(7QPTTVJVNMBCPSBUSJPFTQFDJBMNFOUFFRVJQBEPQBSBFTTFTmOT/PNFTNPTFOUJEPBTFYJHODJBTQSWJBTFNUFSNPTEFDBQBDJEBEFMHJDBFEFBCTUSBPFQSJODJQBMNFOUFDPOIFDJNFOUPNBUFNUJDPTFSPBTNOJNBTQPTTWFJT
0DVSTPQSFWBTTFHVJOUFTGPSNBTEFBWBMJBPEVBTQSPWBTFTDSJUBTFFYFSDDJPT"OPUBmOBM/'TFSJHVBMNEJBQPOEFSBEBFOUSFBTQSPWBT1
F1
DBEBVNBDPNQFTPJHVBMB
FBNEJBBSJUNUJDB.&EBTOPUBTEFFYFSDDJPTDPN
QFTPJHVBMB
PVTFKB
0DPOUFEPEBTBVMBTFPNBUFSJBMEJEUJDPSFMBUJWPTEJTDJQMJOBGPSBNFMBCPSBEPTEFNPEPBRVFPBQSPWFJUBNFOUPTBUJTGBUSJPEPDVSTPQFMPTBMVOPTJOEFQFOEBFNHSBOEFNFEJEBEPSFDVSTPBPVUSBTGPOUFTEFJOGPSNBPoTPCSFUVEPMJUFSBUVSBFTQFDJBMJ[BEBFNUFPSJBEPTKPHPTFNSFHSBEFNVJUPEJGDJMBDFTTPBQFTTPBTTFNBMHVNBGPSNBPNBUFNUJDB0TBMVOPTNBJTJOUFSFTTBEPTOPPCTUBOUFQPEFSPCFOFmDJBSTFEBMFJUVSBBEJDJPOBMEFEPJTMJWSPTJOUSPEVUSJPTiJOLJOH4USBUFHJDBMMZF$PNQFUJUJWF&EHFJO#VTJOFTT1PMJUJDTBOE&WFSZEBZ-JGFwEF"WJOBTI%JYJUF#BSSZ/BMFCVIUSBEVPCSBTJMFJSBEJTQPOWFMOBCJCMJPUFDBEB'(7
Fi4USBUFHZ"O*OUSPEVDUJPOUP(BNFFPSZwEF+PFM8BUTPO
/'11.&
4FGV DIREITO RIO
InTRODuO TEORIa Da DEcIsO
4FGV DIREITO RIO
INTRODUO TEORIA DA DECISO
'(7%*3&*503*0
\!5,!
0%JSFJUPFBTTVBT$POTFRODJBT
0PCKFUJWPEFTUFDVSTPBQSFTFOUBSEFGPSNBNFUEJDBVNKFJUPEJGFSFOUFEFPMIBSP%JSFJUPBTOPSNBTKVSEJDBT
BTBCFSPPMIBSBQBSUJSEFTVBTDPOTFRODJBT)WSJBTSB[FTQBSBRVFSFSNPTJTTP"MHVNBTTPEFOBUVSF[BFYUFSOBBP%JSFJUPDPNPQPSFYFNQMPPDPSSFRVBOEPVNQPMUJDPDSJUJDBVNBEFUFSNJOBEBOPSNBEP$EJHP1FOBMQPSOPTFSFmDB[OPDPNCBUFBVNDFSUPDSJNFQBSBQSPQPSFNTFVMVHBSVNQSPKFUPEFMFJEFTVBBVUPSJBRVFTVQPTUBNFOUFSFTPMWFPQSPCMFNBPVRVBOEPVNFDPOPNJTUBSFDMBNBVNBBMUFSBPEFQBSUFEP$EJHPEF1SPDFTTP$JWJMDPNPVNBNFEJEBOFDFTTSJBQBSBNFMIPSBSBQFSGPSNBODFEP1PEFS+VEJDJSJPFQPSFTTFDBNJOIPDPOUSJCVJSQBSBPEFTFOWPMWJNFOUPFDPONJDPEP1BT
"TPVUSBTSB[FTQBSBRVFSFSNPTFTUVEBSBTDPOTFRODJBTEFOPSNBTKVSEJDBTTPEFOBUVSF[B JOUFSOBBP%JSFJUP1PSUBOUPP%JSFJUPCSBTJMFJSPFTUSFQMFUPEFOPSNBTRVFUNBFTUSVUVSBEFQSFTDSJFTEFPCKFUJWPTJFEFNBOEBNFOUPTOPSNBMNFOUFEJSFDJPOBEPTBSHPTEPQPEFSQCMJDPFNHFSBMNFNCSPTEP1PEFS&YFDVUJWPNBTUBNCNEP1PEFS+VEJDJSJPRVFQSFTDSFWFNBSFBMJ[BPEFDFSUBTmOBMJEBEFTDPNPQPSFYFNQMPPiCFNEFUPEPTwBiKVTUJBTPDJBMwFUD0BSUEBi-FJEF*OUSPEVPBP$EJHP$JWJMw-FJEF
JMVTUSBUJWBNFOUFBmSNBRVFiOBBQMJDBPEBMFJPKVJ[BUFOEFSBPTmOTTPDJBJTBRVFFMBTFEJSJHFFTFYJHODJBTEPCFNDPNVNwPBSUEB$POTUJUVJPEFFTUBCFMFDFRVFBiPSEFNTPDJBMUFNDPNPCBTFPQSJNBEPEPUSBCBMIPFDPNPPCKFUJWPPCFNFTUBSFBKVTUJBTPDJBJTwFUD
/FTUFTDBTPTVNBBOMJTFNFUEJDBEBTDPOTFRODJBTEFVNBEFDJTPKVEJDJBMRVFBQMJDBVNBEFUFSNJOBEBOPSNBEFEJSFJUPDJWJMQPSFYFNQMPVNBOPSNBRVFEJTQFTPCSFPDVNQSJNFOUPEFVNDPOUSBUPPVBSFTQPOTBCJMJEBEFEFBMHVNOPDBTPEFVNBDJEFOUF
PVBTDPOTFRODJBTEFVNBUPOPSNBUJWPEPNJOJTUSPEB1SFWJEODJB4PDJBMFTTFODJBMQBSBTBCFSNPTTFBEFDJTPPVPBUPOPSNBUJWPFNRVFTUPEFGBUPTFSWFNQBSBJNQMFNFOUBSBmOBMJEBEFPVPPCKFUJWPRVFEFWFSJBNKVSJEJDBNFOUFJNQMFNFOUBS%FGPSNBEJWFSTBBPRVFPDPSSFOPDBTPEBTSB[FTNFSBNFOUFFYUFSOBTBHPSBBBOMJTFEBTDPOTFRODJBTFTUBTFSWJPEFVNKV[PBDFSDBEBWBMJEBEFPVEBBEFRVBPKVSEJDBEBEFDJTPEPKVJ[PVEPNJOJTUSPFOPoPVOPBQFOBToBDFSDBEBTVBFmDJODJBDPOUSJCVJPQBSBPDSFTDJNFOUPFDPONJDPFUD
2VFTUPQBSBEJTDVTTP-FJBPUSFDIPBCBJYPSFUJSBEPEFVNBFOUSFWJTUBDPODFEJEBQFMPNJOJTUSP/FMTPO
+PCJNEP4VQSFNP5SJCVOBM'FEFSBMFSFTQPOEBJTFPBSHVNFOUPPVOPGBWPSWFMBOMJTFEFDPOTFRODJBTQFMPTKV[FTFJJTFBmSNBUJWPTFFMFTFSJBVNFYFNQMPEFSB[PFYUFSOBPVSB[PJOUFSOBQBSBBBOMJTFEBTDPOTFRODJBTQPSQBSUFEPTNBHJTUSBEPTCSBTJMFJSPT
INTRODUO AO PENSAMENTO ESTRATGICO
5FGV DIREITO RIO
InTRODuO TEORIa Da DEcIsO
5FGV DIREITO RIO
INTRODUO TEORIA DA DECISO
'(7%*3&*503*0
"BOMJTFEBTDPOTFRODJBTEFOPSNBTKVSEJDBTQPEFTFSBMHPNVJUPTPmTUJDBEP"DIBNBEBiBOMJTFFDPONJDBEPEJSFJUPwUBNCNDPOIFDJEBDPNPMBXBOEFDPOPNJDT
QPSFYFNQMPVNUJQPEFJOWFTUJHBPRVFVUJMJ[BJOTUSVNFOUPTNBJTPVNFOPTBWBOBEPTEFUFPSJBFDPONJDBOBEFTDSJPFOBQSFWJTPEPTFGFJUPTEFOPSNBTKVSEJDBTQFSUFODFOUFTTNBJTEJGFSFOUFTSFBTEP%JSFJUPEJSFJUPDPOTUJUVDJPOBMDJWJMQFOBMQSPDFTTVBMTPDJFUSJPFUD
BWBMJBOEPUBJTFGFJUPTTFHVOEPPDSJUSJPEBFmDJODJBFDPONJDB.BJTGSFOUFWPDTQPEFSPDVSTBSVNBEJTDJQMJOBFMFUJWBRVFEJTDVUJSFNOWFMJOUSPEVUSJPPTGVOEBNFOUPTFBTBQMJDBFTNBJTJNQPSUBOUFTEBBOMJTFFDPONJDBEP%JSFJUP/FTUFDVSTPEFi*OUSPEVPBP1FOTBNFOUP&TUSBUHJDPwOTOPTMJNJUBSFNPTBFTUVEBSBTEVBTQSJODJQBJT GFSSBNFOUBTUFSJDBTFNQSFHBEBTFNBOMJTFTiDPOTFRVFODJBMJTUBTwEP%JSFJUPEFEJWFSTPTUJQPTOPBQFOBTEPUJQPiFDPONJDPw
RVBJTTFKBNBUFPSJBEBEFDJTPSBDJPOBMFBUFPSJBEPTKPHPT
%FRVFNPEPFTUBTEVBTGFSSBNFOUBTGVODJPOBN 7FKBNPTBOUFTEFSFTQPOEFSFTTBQFSHVOUBRVBMTFSJBBFTUSVUVSBEFVN UQJDP BSHVNFOUP DPOTFRVFODJBMJTUB/PSNBMNFOUFPT BSHVNFOUPT DPOTFRVFODJBMJTUBT BQSFTFOUBNEVBTGBDFTPVEJNFOTFTRVFTFDPNQMFNFOUBNBTBCFSVNBEFTDSJUJWBFBPVUSBOPSNBUJWB2VFTUFTEFTDSJUJWBTTPBRVFMBTSFMBUJWBTBPTFGFJUPTEFOPSNBTKVSEJDBTTPCSFPDPNQPSUBNFOUPEPTJOEJWEVPTEJSFUBFJOEJSFUBNFOUFBGFUBEPTQFMBTVBJNQMFNFOUBPFRVFTUFTOPSNBUJWBTTFBQSFTFOUBNDPNPBRVFMBTRVFQSPDVSBNJEFOUJmDBSRVBJTTFSJBNBTOPSNBTNBJTBEFRVBEBTQBSBBSFBMJ[BPEFDFSUPTPCKFUJWPTEFmOJEPTDPNPTPDJBMNFOUFEFTFKWFJTUPNBOEPTFBDPNPEBEPTPTFGFJUPTFTQFSBEPTEBTNFTNBTOPSNBTTPCSFPDPNQPSUBNFOUPEPTJOEJWEVPTEJSFUBFJOEJSFUBNFOUFBGFUBEPTQFMBTVBJNQMFNFOUBPJFUPNBOEPTFBDPNPEBEBTBTSFTQPTUBTEBTDPSSFTQPOEFOUFTRVFTUFTEFTDSJUJWBT
1PSFYFNQMPTFFTUBNPTJOUFSFTTBEPTFNFTUVEBSPTFGFJUPTFTQFSBEPTEPSFHJNFEFSFTQPOTBCJMJEBEFDJWJMJFBTOPSNBTRVFEFmOFNRVBOEPFDPNPBMHVNSFTQPOTWFMQPSEBOPTDBVTBEPTPVUSBQFTTPB
UBMDPNPJOUFSQSFUBEPFBQMJDBEPQPSVNEBEP5SJCVOBMTPCSFPONFSPEFBDJEFOUFTEFUSOTJUPOVNBDFSUBSFHJPFTUBSFNPTGB[FOEPVNBBOMJTFDPOTFRVFODJBMJTUBUJQJDBNFOUFEFTDSJUJWB1PSPVUSPMBEPTFFTUBNPTJOUFSFTTBEPTFNTBCFSTFVNBNBOFJSBFTQFDmDBEFJOUFSQSFUBSFBQMJDBSBTOPSNBTRVFEFmOFNFTUFSFHJNFoPVNFTNPTFFTUFSFHJNFFMFQSQSJPoPVOPBEFRVBEBFNWJTUBEPPCKFUJWPTPDJBMNFOUFEFTFKWFMEFSFEV[JSBPNOJNPPONFSPEFBDJEFOUFTDPNWFDVMPTOBSFHJPFNRVFTUPFOUPBOPTTBBOMJTFDPOTFRVFODJBMJTUBFTUBSTFOEPEPUJQPOPSNBUJWP
&NVNBBOMJTFDPOTFRVFODJBMJTUBUBOUPBTBOMJTFTEFTDSJUJWBTDPNPBTBOMJTFTOPSNBUJWBTTPGFJUBTQPSNFJPEFNPEFMPToNBJTPVNFOPTGPSNBJToEPDPNQPSUBNFOUPJOEJWJEVBMFEPTJTUFNBKVSEJDP.PEFMPTTPSFQSFTFOUBFTTJNQMJmDBEBTEBSFBMJEBEFRVFRVBOEPCFNDPOTUSVEPTQPEFNDPOUSJCVJSTJHOJm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oJODMVJOEPPEPKVJ[oQPEFNTFSNPEFMBEPTQBSBPTmOTEBEFUFSNJOBPEPTFGFJUPTBTTPDJBEPTBVNBEFDJTPPVOPSNB KVSEJDBDPNPTFPT JOEJWEVPTFOWPMWJEPTBHJTTFNSBDJPOBMNFOUFJFEFGPSNBBSFBMJ[BSBPNYJNPPSFGFSJEPPCKFUJWP
1PJTCFNVNBBSHVNFOUBPDPOTFRVFODJBMJTUBUQJDBDPNFBJEFOUJmDBOEPEFRVFNPEPVNBOPSNBKVSEJDBBGFUBPTJODFOUJWPTEPTTFVTEFTUJOBUSJPTQBSBBUPNBEBEFDFSUBTEFDJTFT6NFYFNQMPTFSJBVNBBOMJTFRVFCVTDBDPOIFDFSPTFGFJUPTTPCSFPTJODFOUJWPTRVFBTQFTTPBTUNQBSBDVNQSJSDPOUSBUPTRVFTPPTFGFJUPTHFSBEPTQPSVNBOPSNB KVSEJDBRVFEFmOFDPNPTFSB JOEFOJ[BPRVFBMHVNEFWFSQBHBSBVNBPVUSBQFTTPBFNDBTPEFUFSEFTDVNQSJEPVNDPOUSBUPRVFGPJDFMFCSBEPQPSBNCPT"QBSUJSEBTFHVFBBSHVNFOUBPQBTTBOEPEPTJODFOUJWPTEPTEFTUJOBUSJPTQBSBVNBQSPHOPTFFNSFMBPTTVBTGVUVSBTEFDJTFTBRVJRVFWBJTFSEBEBOGBTFQSFNJTTBEFRVFPTJOEJWEVPTTPSBDJPOBJT4FPTJOEJWEVPTTPSBDJPOBJTFOUPFMFTJSPSFTQPOEFSBTFVTJODFOUJWPTEFGPSNBBSFBMJ[BSBPNYJNPTVBTQSFGFSODJBT/PFYFNQMPEPDPOUSBUPTFP
INTRODUO AO PENSAMENTO ESTRATGICO
6FGV DIREITO RIO
InTRODuO TEORIa Da DEcIsO
6FGV DIREITO RIO
INTRODUO TEORIA DA DECISO
'(7%*3&*503*0
JOEJWEVPGPSHBOIBSNBJTDVNQSJOEPPDPOUSBUPRVFPEFTDVNQSJOEPQPJTBPEFTDVNQSJMPEFWFSQBHBSVNBJOEFOJ[BPBQSPHOPTFTFSPJOEJWEVPDVNQSJSPDPOUSBUPDBTPDPOUSSJPPVTFKBTFPJOEJWEVPGPSHBOIBSNBJTEFTDVNQSJOEPPDPOUSBUPRVFPDVNQSJOEP
FOUPBQSPHOPTFTFSPJOEJWEVPEFTDVNQSJSPDPOUSBUP
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
&TTBTQFSHVOUBTFODBNJOIBNBBOMJTFQBSBVNBQFSTQFDUJWBOPSNBUJWB%FQPJTEFTBCFSPTFGFJUPTBHSFHBEPTHFSBEPTQFMBOPSNBDBCFQFSHVOUBSDPNPEFWFNPTBWBMJBSFTUFTFGFJUPT/POPTTPFYFNQMPTFPTFGFJUPTBHSFHBEPTEBOPSNBRVFEFmOFJOEFOJ[BFTOPTDBTPTEFEFTDVNQSJNFOUPEFDPOUSBUPTTPUBJTRVFPTJOEJWEVPTEFDJEJSPDVNQSJSPTTFVTDPOUSBUPTEFNPEPRVFPTOFHDJPTRVFBVNFOUBNPCFNFTUBSEPTJOEJWEVPTQPEFSPTFSSFBMJ[BEPTFOUPQSPWWFMRVFBWBMJFNPTFTTFTFGFJUPTBHSFHBEPTDPNPQPTJUJWPTPVTFKBDPNPBMHPBTFSCVTDBEP4FFTTBGPSBSFTQPTUBFOUPUFNPTVNBCPBSB[PQBSBKVTUJmDBSBOPSNBFNRVFTUP$BTPDPOUSSJPUBMOPSNBQPEFSTFSDSJUJDBEBQPSQSPEV[JSFGFJUPTRVFOTBWBMJBNPTDPNPOFHBUJWPTPRVFQPSTVBWF[TFSWJSQBSBGVOEBNFOUBSQSPQPTUBTRVFWJTFNBTVBNPEJmDBP
/FTUFDVSTPDPODFOUSBSFNPTOPTTPTJOUFSFTTFTFNFTUVEBSFNOWFMJOUSPEVUSJPPTJOTUSVNFOUPTUFSJDPTNBJTVTBEPTFNBOMJTFTDPOTFRVFODJBMJTUBTEPUJQPEFTDSJUJWP&TTFFTUVEPTFSPSJFOUBEPQBSBBTPMVPEFQSPCMFNBTQSUJDPTOPTRVBJTCVTDBSFNPTBOBMJTBSEFRVFGPSNBBTOPSNBTKVSEJDBTBGFUBNJODFOUJWPTFQPSFTTBWJBJOnVFODJBNBTEFDJTFTUPNBEBTQFMPTJOEJWEVPT
2VFTUPQBSBDPOUSPMF1FOTFFNVNBOPSNBKVSEJDBRVBMRVFSRVFWPDDPOIFBFUFOUFJEFOUJmDBSVNHSVQPTPDJBMSFMFWBOUFQBSBBEFUFSNJOBPEPTFGFJUPTEBOPSNBFNRVFTUPTPCSFPCFNFTUBSEFTUFHSVQP
5FYUPTVHFSJEPi0$PNQPOFOUF+VEJDJBMEPT4QSFBET#BODSJPTwEF"SNBOEP$BTUFMBS1JOIFJSP
INTRODUO AO PENSAMENTO ESTRATGICO
7FGV DIREITO RIO
InTRODuO TEORIa Da DEcIsO
7FGV DIREITO RIO
INTRODUO TEORIA DA DECISO
'(7%*3&*503*0
*7o0$PNQPOFOUF+VEJDJBMEPT4QSFBET#BODSJPT
"SNBOEP$BTUFMBS1JOIFJSP
*7*OUSPEVP"SFGPSNBEPTTJTUFNBTmOBODFJSPTFTUFOUSFBTRVFNBJTBWBOBSBNOB"NSJDB-B
UJOB-PSB/PPCTUBOUFFTTFQSPHSFTTPPTQBTFTEBSFHJPDPOUJOVBNBBQSFTFOUBSCBJYPTOWFJTEFJOUFSNFEJBPmOBODFJSBJODMVJOEPCBJYPTWPMVNFTEFDSEJUPQBSBPTFUPSQSJWBEPRVFDPNPQSPQPSPEP1*#FTUPNVJUPBCBJYPEPPCTFSWBEPFNQBTFTEB0&$%#FDL/PTVSQSFFOEFQPSUBOUPRVFBTDPNQBOIJBTMBUJOPBNFSJDBOBTDPOTJEFSFNBEJmDVMEBEFEFBDFTTPBPTNFSDBEPTmOBODFJSPTPNBJPSPCTUDVMPFYQBOTPEFTVBTBUJWJEBEFTFNQSFTBSJBJTGSFOUFEFPVUSPTGBUPSFTDPNPJOTUBCJMJEBEFNBDSPFDPONJDBJNQPTUPTFWJPMODJBVSCBOB(BMJOEP
&YJTUFNEVBTFYQMJDBFTDPNQMFNFOUBSFTQBSBPCBJYPWPMVNFEFDSEJUPQSFWBMFDFOUFOB"NSJDB-BUJOB6NBFOGBUJ[B B JOTUBCJMJEBEFNBDSPFDPONJDB FPT FMFWBEPTEmDJUTQCMJDPTUSBEJDJPOBMNFOUFPCTFSWBEPTOBSFHJP1BEJMMBF3FRVFKP(BMJOEPF.JDDP"PVUSBFYQMJDBPBUSJCVJPCBJYPWPMVNFEFDSEJUPGBMUBEFQSPUFPEPTEJSFJUPTEPTDSFEPSFTFBPTEJSFJUPTEFQSPQSJFEBEFFSFHSBEBMFJiSVMFPGMBXwFNHFSBMBTQFDUPTRVF UBNCNDBSBDUFSJ[BNCFNB"NSJDB-BUJOB -B1PSUB-PQF[EF4JMBOFT4IMFJGFS F7JTIOZ#FDL(BMJOEPF.JDDP
0#SBTJMJMVTUSBCFNUBOUPBTTJHOJmDBUJWBTNVEBOBTFYQFSJNFOUBEBTQFMPTFUPSmOBODFJSPEFTEFNFBEPTEPTBOPToDPOUSPMFEBJOnBPQSJWBUJ[BPEFCBODPTQCMJDPTBCFSUVSBFOUSBEBEFJOTUJUVJFTmOBODFJSBTFTUSBOHFJSBTNFMIPSJBEBTVQFSWJTPFSFHVMBPEPTFUPSmOBODFJSPFUDoDPNPBGBMUBEFJNQBDUPEFTTBTSFGPSNBTTPCSFPWPMVNFEFDSEJUP6NBFYQMJDBPDFOUSBMQBSBFTTFTCBJYPTWPMVNFTEFDSEJUPPBMUPTQSFBEDPCSBEPQFMPTCBODPToFNPTTQSFBETFNPQFSBFTDPNQFTTPBTGTJDBTFKVSEJDBTmDBSBNFNSFTQFDUJWBNFOUFF%FGBUPPTTQSFBETCBODSJPTOP#SBTJMFTUPFOUSFPTNBJTBMUPTOB"NSJDB-BUJOBFBUJOHFNNMUJQMPTEBRVFMFTPCTFSWBEPTFNQBTFTEFTFOWPMWJEPT"GBOBTJF-IBDFSF/BLBOF
$PNEJTDVUJEP FOUSFPVUSPTQPS"JUI
1JOIFJSPF$BCSBM F-BFWFOF.BKPOJ
B JOFmDJODJB KVEJDJBM o FOWPMWFOEP BNPSPTJEBEFEBTEFDJTFT P DVTUPEFVTPEB+VTUJBFPSJTDPFNCVUJEPOBGBMUBEFJNQBSDJBMJEBEFFQSFWJTJCJMJEBEFoVNBDBVTBJNQPSUBOUFEFTTFTBMUPTTQSFBET"JUIFTUJNBRVFEFBEPTQSFBECBODSJPOP#SBTJMTFEFWFJOFmDJODJBEPKVEJDJSJP1JOIFJSPF$BCSBMNPTUSBNRVFDPOUSPMBOEPQBSBPFGFJUPEBMFHJTMBPFEFEJGFSFOBTEFSFOEBQFSDBQJUBPCUNTFRVFBRVBMJEBEFEPKVEJDJSJPBGFUBTJHOJmDBUJWBNFOUFBRVBOUJEBEFEFDSEJUPCBODSJPOBFDPOPNJBNFEJEBQFMBSB[PDSEJUP1*#-BFWFOF.BKOPOJNPTUSBNRVFDPOUSPMBOEPQBSBVNDPOKVOUPEFDBSBDUFSTUJDBTEFEJGFSFOUFTQBTFTBFmDJODJBEPKVEJDJSJPKVOUPDPNBJOnBPPQSJODJQBMEFUFSNJOBOUFEBTEJGFSFOBTEFTQSFBETEFKVSPTFOUSFPTQBTFTBOBMJTBEPT
*70+VEJDJSJPFB1SPUFPBPT%JSFJUPTEPT$SFEPSFT/P#SBTJMBNPSPTJEBEFEPKVEJDJSJPQFSDFCJEBDPNPPQSJODJQBMQSPCMFNBOBDP
CSBOBKVEJDJBMEFFNQSTUJNPTJOBEJNQMFOUFT"NFTNBBWBMJBPPCTFSWBEBFNSFMBPBPGVODJPOBNFOUPEBKVTUJBFNHFSBM1FTRVJTBDPNFNQSFTSJPTNPTUSPVRVFEFMFTQFOTBNRVFPKVEJDJSJPUFNVNEFTFNQFOIPSVJNPVQTTJNPFNSFMBPTVBBHJMJEBEF1JOIFJSP6NBPVUSBQFTRVJTBNPTUSPVRVFEPTNBHJTUSBEPTCSBTJMFJSPTTPEBNFTNBPQJOJP1JOIFJSP
%CONOMISTA DO )0%!E PROFESSOR DO )%5&2*!S OPINIES EXPRESSASNESTE TRABALHO SO EXCLUSIVAMENTEDOAUTORENOREmETEMNECESSARIAMENTEAVISODO"ANCO#ENTRALDO"RASIL
INTRODUO AO PENSAMENTO ESTRATGICO
8FGV DIREITO RIO
InTRODuO TEORIa Da DEcIsO
8FGV DIREITO RIO
INTRODUO TEORIA DA DECISO
'(7%*3&*503*0
"NPSPTJEBEFEBKVTUJBQSFKVEJDBPTNFSDBEPTEFDSEJUPEFUSTGPSNBTEJGFSFOUFT1SJNFJSPFMBUPSOBBQFSTQFDUJWBEFVNBBPOBKVTUJBNVJUPNFOPTBNFBBEPSBEPQPOUPEFWJTUBEPEFWFEPS%FGBUPBMHVOTCBODPTBSHVNFOUBNRVFIEFWFEPSFTRVFQSFGFSFNRVFBFYFDVPEBEWJEBTFKBGFJUBOBKVTUJBQPJTFMFTTBCFNRVFJTTPJSBMPOHBSPQSB[PQBSBQBHBNFOUP.FTNPQBSBQFRVFOPTEFWFEPSFTBQFSTQFDUJWBEFDPCSBOBKVEJDJBMEFVNBEWJEBNFOPTBNFBBEPSBEPRVFTVBJODMVTPFNVNEPTDBEBTUSPTOFHBUJWPTSFHVMBSNFOUFDPOTVMUBEPTQPSDSFEPSFTFDPNFSDJBOUFT0VTFKBPTCBODPTBDSFEJUBNRVFQBSBFNQSTUJNPTOPNFSDBEPEFWBSFKPDBEBTUSPTOFHBUJWPTDPNB4FSBTBFP41$TPNBJTFGFUJWPTFNHBSBOUJSPQBHBNFOUPEFEWJEBTEPRVFPTUSJCVOBJT
4FHVOEPBNPSPTJEBEFSFEV[TJHOJmDBUJWBNFOUFPWBMPSEBTHBSBOUJBTDPNPQSPUFPDPOUSBBJOBEJNQMODJBFNBJTHFSBMNFOUFEJNJOVJBSFMFWODJBEBQSPQSJFEBEFEFBUJWPTDPNPVNBHBSBOUJBJNQMDJUBQBSBPTDSFEPSFT%FTUBGPSNBBJOEBRVFOPSNBMNFOUFPTCBODPTWFOIBNBPmOBMWFODFSVNBBPEFDPCSBOBKVEJDJBMRVBOEPJTTPPDPSSFGSFRFOUFNFOUFOPFYJTUFNBUJWPTQBSBTFSFNFYFDVUBEPTFQBSBQFSNJUJSBSFDVQFSBPEPDSEJUPoEVSBOUFPQSPDFTTPPEFWFEPSDPNVNFOUFBCBOEPOBBTHBSBOUJBTRVFUFOEFNBEFQSFDJBSTFSBQJEBNFOUF"MNEJTTPFNNVJUPTDBTPTRVBOEPVNBEFDJTPmOBMNFOUFBMDBOBEBPCBODPJODBQB[EFUPNBSBHBSBOUJBPVPTBUJWPTEPEFWFEPSFNGVOPEBQSFGFSODJBEFRVFHP[BPmTDPoRVBOEPPCBODPMFWBPTBUJWPTEPEFWFEPSBIBTUBQCMJDBPmTDPDPNQBSFDFFmDBDPNPSFTVMUBEPEPMFJMPi&YJKBVNDPMBUFSBMJHVBMBWF[FTPWBMPSEPFNQSTUJNPRVFEFQPJTEBEFDJTPKVEJDJBMBHBSBOUJBWBMFNVJUPNFOPTEPRVFBEWJEBw&TUBBmSNBPGFJUBQFMPHFSFOUFEFVNCBODPFYQSFTTBBWJTPEFRVFBTHBSBOUJBTSFBJTTPGSFRFOUFNFOUFJOTVmDJFOUFTFYQPTUJOEFQFOEFOUFNFOUFEFRVPTJHOJmDBOUFTFMBTQBSFBNFYBOUF/PNOJNPPWBMPSEPDPMBUFSBMOPBDPNQBOIBPWBMPSEBEWJEBFNQBSUFDPNPDPOTFRODJBEPBDNVMPEFKVSPTFNVMUBTQPSBUSBTP&UBNCNIDBTPTFNRVFBTHBSBOUJBTTJNQMFTNFOUFEFTBQBSFDFNFORVBOUPPDBTPFTUTFOEPKVMHBEPPVFNRVFPTEFWFEPSFTWFOEFNPVUSBOTGFSFNBQSPQSJFEBEFEPTBUJWPTEBEPTDPNPDPMBUFSBMPVMJTUBEPTQBSBBQFOIPSB"JOEBRVFFTTBTPQFSBFTQPTTBNTFSSFWFSUJEBTOBKVTUJBFTVKFJUFNPJOGSBUPSBQFOBMJEBEFTFMBTBMPOHBNBJOEBNBJTBEVSBPEPQSPDFTTPKVEJDJBM
%FTUBGPSNBPTBUJWPTEBEPTFNHBSBOUJBBVNFNQSTUJNPBJOEBRVFVNBTQFDUPQPTJUJWPEPQPOUPEFWJTUBEPDSFEPSTPWJTUPTQSJODJQBMNFOUFDPNPVNJOTUSVNFOUPEFQSFTTPTPCSFPEFWFEPSRVBOEPEBFYFDVPEBTHBSBOUJBTi2VBOEPPDSFEPSmOBMNFOUFDPOTFHVFSFUPNBSBHBSBOUJBFMBKFTUUSFNFOEBNFOUFEFQSFDJBEB"HBSBOUJBFOUSBOBOFHPDJBPNBTFMBOPUFNVNBVUJMJEBEFQSUJDBDPNPUBM&MBNBJTVNBDPJTBUFSJDBwBSHVNFOUBPEJSFUPSEFVNCBODPDPOTVMUBEP"FYDFPPDBTPEPTBVUPNWFJTFNRVFBSFUPNBEBEPWFDVMPCBTFBEBOPJOTUSVNFOUPEBBMJFOBPmEVDJSJBNBJTHJMFFmDB[*TUPTFSFnFUFFNTQSFBETNBJTCBJYPTQBSBPmOBODJBNFOUPEFBVUPNWFJTEPRVFEFPVUSPTUJQPTEFCFOTFNPTQSFBEEFKVSPTQBSBPmOBODJBNFOUPEBBRVJTJPEFWFDVMPTGPJEFDPOUSBQBSBPmOBODJBNFOUPBRVJTJPEFPVUSPTCFOTQBSBPDSEJUPQFTTPBMQBSBPDIFRVFFTQFDJBMFQBSBPEFTDPOUPEFEVQMJDBUBT
5FSDFJSPBGBMUBEFBHJMJEBEFDSJBJODFOUJWPTQBSBRVFPTEFWFEPSFTVTFNPKVEJDJSJPDPNPVNBGPSNBEFQPTUFSHBSPQBHBNFOUPEF TVBTEWJEBT/BQFTRVJTB TVQSBDJUBEB DPNNBHJTUSBEPT FTUFT GPSBNQFSHVOUBEPTTPCSFBGSFRODJBDPNRVFJOEJWEVPTmSNBTFHSVQPTEFJOUFSFTTFSFDPSSJBNBPKVEJDJSJPOPQBSBSFDMBNBSVNEJSFJUPNBTQBSBBEJBSPDVNQSJNFOUPEFVNBPCSJHBPFYQMPSBOEPBNPSPTJEBEFEBKVTUJBFNEFDJEJSFGB[FSWBMFSTVBTEFDJTFT$PNPJMVTUSBEPOB5BCFMBPTNBHJTUSBEPTDPOTJEFSBNFTUBVNBQSUJDBGSFRFOUFFNDBTPTRVFFOWPMWBNPQFSBFTEFDSEJUPRVFmDBNBUSTBQFOBTEPTDBTPTRVFFOWPMWFNRVFTUFTUSJCVUSJBTFGSFOUFEFDBTPTEFJORVJMJOBUPUSBOTBFTDPNFSDJBJTFDPOnJUPTUSBCBMIJTUBT
INTRODUO AO PENSAMENTO ESTRATGICO
9FGV DIREITO RIO
InTRODuO TEORIa Da DEcIsO
9FGV DIREITO RIO
INTRODUO TEORIA DA DECISO
'(7%*3&*503*0
"QSPUFPMFHBMDPODFEJEBBPTDSFEPSFTOP#SBTJMCBTFBEBFNMFJTTJNJMBSFTTRVFSFHVMBNFOUBNPNFSDBEPEFDSEJUPFNPVUSPTQBTFTMBUJOPBNFSJDBOPTFFVSPQFVTRVFUBNCNBEPUBNPBTTJNDIBNBEPTJTUFNBGSBODTEFDJWJMMBX&OUSFWJTUBTDPNCBODPTNPTUSBSBNRVFBQFTBSEFDSUJDBTBBMHVOTBTQFDUPTEFTTBMFHJTMBPTVCTUBOUJWBoDPNPQPSFYFNQMPBMFJEBTGBMODJBTBRVFTUPEPBOBUPDJTNPFUDoFMFTBBWBMJBNEFGPSNBSFMBUJWBNFOUFQPTJUJWBOBNFEJEBFNRVFFMBFTUBCFMFDFDMBSBNFOUFDPNPPTDPOUSBUPTEFWFNTFS SFEJHJEPTDPNPDPOTUJUVJSHBSBOUJBTRVFUJQPTEFQSPDFEJNFOUPTTFHVJSPQBQFMEPTKV[FTFNDBEBQBTTPEFVNQSPDFTTPEFSFDVQFSBPEFFNQSTUJNPFUDBMFHJTMBPQSPDFTTVBMQFSDFCJEBDPNPNVJUPGBWPSWFMBPTEFWFEPSFTFFTQFDJBMNFOUFBTVBBQMJDBPQFMPKVEJDJSJPRVFFMFTSFTQPOTBCJMJ[BNQFMBGSBDBQSPUFPBPDSFEPSOP#SBTJM
&N QBSUJDVMBS PT DPNQMFYPT QSPDFEJNFOUPT MFHBJT RVF SFHVMBN B DPCSBOB KVEJDJBM EF FNQSTUJNPT TPQFSDFCJEPTDPNPBQSJODJQBMDBVTBQBSBBTVBNPSPTJEBEFBPQFSNJUJSWSJBTGPSNBTQBSBTFBEJBSVNBEFDJTP0TQSPCMFNBTDPNBMFHJTMBPQSPDFTTVBMOPTPFYDMVTJWPTEBTDPCSBOBTKVEJDJBJTEFFNQSTUJNPTOFNUBNQPVDPTVBTDPOTFRODJBTFNUFSNPTEFNPSPTJEBEF"TTJNPTNBHJTUSBEPTFOUSFWJTUBEPTQPS1JOIFJSPBQPOUBNRVFFNSFMBPNPSPTJEBEFPTQSJODJQBJTQSPCMFNBTDPNPWJHFOUFPSEFOBNFOUPKVSEJDPCSBTJMFJSPTPRVFFTUFQFSNJUFNVJUBTGPSNBTQBSBTFBEJBSVNBEFDJTPFRVFIVNONFSPFYDFTTJWPEFJOTUODJBTBRVFTFQPEFSFDPSSFSFNDBEBDBTP2VBTFEPTNBHJTUSBEPTDPOTJEFSBNFTTBTDBVTBTNVJUPJNQPSUBOUFTEBNPSPTJEBEFDPNPVUSPTDPOTJEFSBOEPBTVNQSPCMFNBSFMFWBOUF5BCFMB
INTRODUO AO PENSAMENTO ESTRATGICO
10FGV DIREITO RIO
InTRODuO TEORIa Da DEcIsO
10FGV DIREITO RIO
INTRODUO TEORIA DA DECISO
'(7%*3&*503*0
0DVTUPEBDPCSBOBKVEJDJBMPVUSPQSPCMFNB6NBEWPHBEPEFGPSBEPCBODPDPCSBFOUSFFEPWBMPSSFDVQFSBEPNBJTPSFFNCPMTPEFEFTQFTBTFORVBOUPPTBEWPHBEPTEPQSQSJPCBODPSFDFCFNVNQBHBNFOUPRVFWBSJBEFBEPWBMPSSFDVQFSBEPEFQFOEFOEPEPFTUHJPEPQSPDFTTPFNRVFPFNQSTUJNPSFDVQFSBEP&N4P1BVMPBQBSUFRVFJOJDJBPQSPDFTTPUFNEFQBHBSDVTUBTKVEJDJBJTEFEPWBMPSFNRVFTUPNBJTRVBOEPTFEPSFDVSTPBVNBJOTUODJBTVQFSJPSNBJTQBSBBBPEFFYFDVP0TDSFEPSFTUNEFQBHBSUBNCNQBSBSFHJTUSBSEPDVNFOUPTQBSBRVFPPmDJBMEFKVTUJBOPUJmRVFPEFWFEPSFPVMJTUFPTCFOTQBSBQFOIPSBFUD6TVBMNFOUFBQFOBTFNDBTPTFNRVFPDSFEPS UFNBEWPHBEPT USBCBMIBOEPEFOUSPEBFNQSFTBFPFNQSTUJNPTVQFSBVNDFSUPQBUBNBSDPNQFOTBGB[FSVNBDPCSBOBKVEJDJBM1BSBVNQFRVFOPFNQSTUJNPFNHFSBMOPDPNQFOTBSFDPSSFSKVTUJBQBSBUFOUBSSFDVQFSMP
/PDBTPEBNBJPSJBEPTFNQSTUJNPTFNRVFBDPCSBOBKVEJDJBMOPOFDFTTSJBFNQSTUJNPTTFNHBSBOUJBTEFOPNYJNP3
PTCBODPTVTVBMNFOUFGB[FNVNBQSJNFJSBUFOUBUJWBEJSFUBEFSFDVQFSBPFTFNBMTVDFEJEPTUSBOTGFSFNPDBTPBVNBFNQSFTBEFDPCSBOBT&TUFPDBTPEBNBJPSQBSUFEBTPQFSBFTEFWBSFKPQPSFYFNQMPDIFRVFFTQFDJBMDSEJUPBPDPOTVNJEPSFNQSTUJNPTQFTTPBJTFUD"TFNQSFTBTEFDPCSBOBDPCSBNVNBUBYBEFTVDFTTPFOUSFFEPWBMPSFWFOUVBMNFOUFSFDVQFSBEPVTVBMNFOUFNVJUPNFOPTRVFPDVTUPEFVNBBPKVEJDJBMQBSUJDVMBSNFOUFOPDBTPEFQFRVFOPTFNQSTUJNPT&TUBFTUSBUHJBUBNCNQSFGFSJEBQPSRVFPTEFWFEPSFTRVFDPOUSBUBNQFRVFOPTFNQSTUJNPTHFSBMNFOUFOPUNCFOTQBTTWFJTEFFYFDVPEFGPSNBRVFBPmNFBPDBCPPCBODPQPEFOPUFSNFJPTEFSFDVQFSBSTFVDSEJUPNFTNPRVFWJUPSJPTPOBKVTUJB
1PSmNPTDSFEPSFTBSHVNFOUBNRVFVNKVEJDJSJPNBKPSJUBSJBNFOUFGBWPSWFMBPTEFWFEPSFTPVUSBSB[PEPFOGSBRVFDJNFOUPEPTEJSFJUPTEPTDSFEPSFTFTUBCFMFDJEPTFNMFJ&TUBQPTJPWBJBMNEBJOTBUJTGBPRVFTFFTQFSBSJBEFVNBEBTQBSUFTRVFTFWEFVNMBEPEBEJTQVUB"PDPOUSSJPFTUFTVQPTUPWJTBUSJCVEPUFOEODJBEPTKV[FTEFVTBSTVBQPTJPOBCVTDBEBSFEJTUSJCVJPEFSFOEBFBUJWPT
6NBWJTPRVFGSFRFOUFNFOUFTFBSHVNFOUBTFSBEPUBEBQFMPTNBHJTUSBEPTBEFRVFPKVEJDJSJPOPBQMJDBBMFJNBTHVJBTVBTEFDJTFTQFMPPCKFUJWPEFiKVTUJBTPDJBMw1JOIFJSP BOBMJTB FTUF DPNQPSUBNFOUP DIBNBOEPPEF iQPMJUJ[BPwEBT EFDJTFT KVEJDJBJT&TUFOEFOEPTFQBSBBMNEPTNFSDBEPTEFDSEJUPFTUFUJQPEFDPNQPSUBNFOUPGSFRFOUFNFOUFSFnFUFVNBJOUFOPEFGBWPSFDFSHSVQPTTPDJBJTFPVFDPONJDPTNBJTGSBDPTDPNPUSBCBMIBEPSFT FQFRVFOPTEFWFEPSFT PV TJNQMFTNFOUF BT JODMJOBFTQPMUJDBTEPNBHJTUSBEPFNSFMBPBPDPOnJUPFNRVFTUP
%FBDPSEPDPNBNBJPSQBSUFEPTNBHJTUSBEPTRVFQBSUJDJQBSBNEBQFTRVJTBEF1JOIFJSP
BiQPMJUJ[BPwEBTEFDJTFTKVEJDJBJTBJOEBRVFVNBSFBMJEBEFOBKVTUJBCSBTJMFJSBPDPSSFBQFOBTPDBTJPOBMNFOUF"JOEBBTTJNVNRVJOUPEFMFTWFTUFUJQPEFDPNQPSUBNFOUPDPNGSFRFOUF5BCFMB"JOEBRVFOBBVTODJBEFCFODINBSLTJOUFSOBDJPOBJTTFKBEJGDJMBWBMJBSTFFTUBTTPQSPQPSFTBMUBTPVCBJYBTFMBTTPBMUBTPTVmDJFOUFQBSBRVFBiQPMJUJ[BPwEBTEFDJTFTKVEJDJBJTQPTTBTFSDPOTJEFSBEBVNGBUPSJNQPSUBOUFQBSBFYQMJDBSQPSRVFFNBMHVOTDBTPT KVJ[FTEJGFSFOUFTDIFHBNBEJTUJOUBTEFDJTFTTPCSFDBTPTNVJUPTFNFMIBOUFTPVNFTNPJHVBJT
0ARA DISPUTAS ENVOLVENDOVALORESACIMADE SALRIOS MNIMOSA TAXAMARGINAL PARA OSVALORES ACIMA DESSE TOTALCAIPARA
INTRODUO AO PENSAMENTO ESTRATGICO
11FGV DIREITO RIO
InTRODuO TEORIa Da DEcIsO
11FGV DIREITO RIO
INTRODUO TEORIA DA DECISO
'(7%*3&*503*0
1FSHVOUBEPTTPCSFRVPGSFRFOUFNFOUFBQPMJUJ[BPoEFmOJEBDPNPBUFOEODJBTEFDJTFTKVEJDJBJTSFnFUJSFNNBJTBTWJTFTQPMUJDBTEPTKV[FTEPRVFVNBMFJUVSBSJHPSPTBEBMFJoUFOEJBBPDPSSFSFNDFSUPTUJQPTEFDBVTBTPTKV[FTJOEJDBSBNRVFBQSJWBUJ[BPBSFBRVFUFOEFBTFSNBJTJOnVFODJBEBQFMBWJTPQPMUJDBEPTKV[FTEFBDPSEPDPNEPTFOUSFWJTUBEPTOFTTFTDBTPTBiQPMJUJ[BPwEBTEFDJTFTNVJUPGSFRFOUFFORVBOUPEJTTFSBNTFSBMHPGSFRFOUF5BCFMB"DPNQBSBPSFMFWBOUFQBSBPTmOTEFTUFUFYUPBHSBOEFEJGFSFOBFOUSFDBTPTOBTSFBTDPNFSDJBMFEFNFSDBEPEFDSEJUPEFBDPSEPDPNPTNBHJTUSBEPTBQPMJUJ[BPTJHOJmDBUJWBNFOUFNBJTGSFRFOUFFNEFDJTFTSFMBUJWBTBMJUHJPTOPNFSDBEPEFDSEJUPEPRVFOPTSFMBUJWPTBPQFSBFTDPNFSDJBJT
INTRODUO AO PENSAMENTO ESTRATGICO
12FGV DIREITO RIO
InTRODuO TEORIa Da DEcIsO
12FGV DIREITO RIO
INTRODUO TEORIA DA DECISO
'(7%*3&*503*0
"iQPMJUJ[BPwEBTEFDJTFTKVEJDJBJTQPEFSFTVMUBSDPNPPCTFSWBEPBDJNBEBUFOUBUJWBEPKVJ[EFQSPUFHFSDFSUPTHSVQPTTPDJBJTQFSDFCJEPTDPNPTFOEPNBJTGSBDPTEPRVFBPVUSBQBSUFOPMJUHJP0TKV[FTGSFRFOUFNFOUFEFTDSFWFNFTUFDPNQPSUBNFOUPDPNPVNQBQFMTPDJBMRVFPKVJ[UFNBDVNQSJS&TUFUFNBGPJFYQMPSBEPOBQFTRVJTBDPNPTNBHJTUSBEPTRVBOEPTFQFSHVOUPVBFTUFTTFDPOGSPOUBEPTDPNBOFDFTTJEBEFEFPQUBSFOUSFEVBTQPTJFTFYUSFNBToVNB"TFNQSFSFTQFJUBSPTDPOUSBUPTJOEFQFOEFOUFNFOUFEFTVBTSFQFSDVTTFTTPDJBJTFBPVUSB#EFDJEJSEFVNBGPSNBRVFWJPMFPTDPOUSBUPTOBCVTDBEFKVTUJBTPDJBMoQPSRVBMEBTEVBTBMUFSOBUJWBTFMFTPQUBSJBN"HSBOEFNBJPSJBEPTNBHJTUSBEPTSFTQPOEFVRVFPQUBSJBQFMBTFHVOEBBMUFSOBUJWB5BCFMB
&TUBQPTJPNBKPSJUSJBEBNBHJTUSBUVSBDPOn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
"QSPQPSPEFNBHJTUSBEPTRVFGBWPSFDFNBBMUFSOBUJWB#iPKVJ[UFNQBQFMTPDJBMBDVNQSJSFBCVTDBEBKVTUJBTPDJBMKVTUJmDBEFDJTFTRVFWJPMFNPTDPOUSBUPTwOBRVFTUPBDJNBBQSFTFOUBEBUBNCNWBSJBEFBDPSEPDPNBSFBEPEJSFJUPBRVFPDBTPTFSFGFSFTFOEPNBJTBMUBFNMJUHJPTRVFFOWPMWFNPNFJPBNCJFOUFEJSFJUPTEPDPOTVNJEPSSFHVMBPEFTFSWJPTQCMJDPTRVFTUFTUSBCBMIJTUBTFEFQSFWJEODJBTPDJBM5BCFMB1PSPVUSPMBEPPTNBHJTUSBEPTTPJODMJOBEPTBGBWPSFDFSBPQP"iPTDPOUSBUPTEFWFNTFSTFNQSFSFTQFJUBEPTJOEFQFOEFOUFNFOUFEFTVBTSFQFSDVTTFTTPDJBJTwRVBOEPPMJUHJPFOWPMWFRVFTUFTDPNFSDJBJTEFDSEJUPFJORVJMJOBUP/PUFTFRVFFTTFFTTFODJBMNFOUFPNFTNPQBESPPCTFSWBEPOB5BCFMBQBSBBGSFRODJBDPNRVFPTKVJ[FTJEFOUJmDBNBTEFDJTFTKVEJDJBJTDPNPTFOEPiQPMJUJ[BEBTw0RVFQBSFDFSFMFWBOUFQBSBBBOMJTFFTQFDmDBEFTUFUFYUPBQSPQPSPNVJUPNBJTBMUBEFKVJ[FTRVFTFJODMJOBNQFMBQPTJP#FNEJTQVUBTFOWPMWFOEPUSBOTBFTEFDSEJUPEPRVFOPTDBTPTRVFFOWPMWFNUSBOTBFTDPNFSDJBJTFNHFSBM
INTRODUO AO PENSAMENTO ESTRATGICO
13FGV DIREITO RIO
InTRODuO TEORIa Da DEcIsO
13FGV DIREITO RIO
INTRODUO TEORIA DA DECISO
'(7%*3&*503*0
0TDPOUSBUPTTPGSFRFOUFNFOUFVNBGPSNBEFBMPDBSSJTDPTFYBOUFFBJODFSUF[BTPCSFTFFTUBBMPDBPTFSSFTQFJUBEBFYQPTUSFEV[FOPSNFNFOUFBVUJMJEBEFEPTDPOUSBUPT&TUFPDBTPFNQBSUJDVMBSEPTFUPSmOBODFJSP$PNPPCTFSWBEPQPS4UJHMJU[Q
iFOGPSDJOHDPOUSBDUTUSBOTGFSSJOHTIBSJOHBOEQPPMJOHSJTLTBOESFDPSEJOHUSBOTBDUJPOTBDUJWJUJFTUIBUNBLFUIFNUIFACSBJOPGUIFFOUJSFFDPOPNJDTZTUFNUIFDFOUSBMMPDVTPGEFDJTJPONBLJOHw/FTUFTFOUJEPTFPTKVJ[FTSFJOUFSQSFUBNPTUFSNPTEPTDPOUSBUPTEFDSEJUPEFQFOEFOEPEPSFTVMUBEPFGFUJWPEPTFWFOUPTFYQMJDJUBPVJNQMJDJUBNFOUFDPOTJEFSBEPTOPDPOUSBUPFTUFTQPEFNQFSEFSTVBVUJMJEBEF
$POTJEFSFTFQPSFYFNQMPPDBTPEPTDPOUSBUPTEFMFBTJOHDPNDPSSFPDBNCJBMFYJTUFOUFTBOUFTEBEFTWBMPSJ[BPEPSFBMFN1PSRVFFMFTUSBOTGFSJBNPSJTDPEBEFTWBMPSJ[BPEPCBODPQBSBPEFWFEPSTPCSFFMFTJODJEJBVNBNFOPSUBYBEFKVSPTPRVFPTGB[JBBUSBFOUFTQBSBPTEFWFEPSFT.BTFSBFWJEFOUFRVFBEJGFSFOBFOUSFPTKVSPTQBHPTFNDPOUSBUPTJOEFYBEPTBPDNCJPFBRVFMFTCFNNBJTBMUPTEFDPOUSBUPTDPSSJHJEPTQFMBJOnBPFSBVNQSNJPRVFPEFWFEPSFTUBWBSFDFCFOEPQPSBTTVNJSPSJTDPEBEFTWBMPSJ[BP2VBOEPPDPSSFVBEFTWBMPSJ[BPQPSNPTDPOUSBUPTDPNDPSSFPDBNCJBMTFNPTUSBSBNNBJTDBSPTFPKVEJDJSJPEFDJEJVRVFPTEFWFEPSFTQPEFSJBNQBHBSTFVTFNQSTUJNPTDPNBNVJUPNBJTCBJYBDPSSFPQFMBJOnBPBEFTQFJUPEFPTCBODPTUFSFNEFQBHBSBPTDSFEPSFTFYUFSOPTDPNDPSSFPDBNCJBM0VTFKBPKVEJDJSJPSFEJTUSJCVJVFYQPTUBTSFTQPOTBCJMJEBEFTEBTQBSUFTFNEJGFSFOUFTFTUBEPTEBOBUVSF[BBOVMBOEPiVOJMBUFSBMNFOUFwBEJTUSJCVJPEFSFTQPOTBCJMJEBEFTBDFSUBEBDPOUSBUVBMNFOUFQFMBTQBSUFTOBIPSBEBDPOUSBUBP
"MHVOTCBODPTWFNFTUBUFOEODJBEPTNBHJTUSBEPTWFSFNTFVQBQFMDPNPTFOEPPEFQSPNPWFSBKVTUJBTPDJBMFNMVHBSEFGB[FSSFTQFJUBSBTMFJTFPTDPOUSBUPTDPNPVNQSPCMFNBDSUJDPEPKVEJDJSJP.FTNPRVFFTUFQPTJDJPOBNFOUPTFKBNBJTDPNVNOBQSJNFJSBEPRVFOBTFHVOEBJOTUODJBFFNBMHVNBTKVSJTEJFTEPRVFFNPVUSBTFRVFFMBTQPTTBNTFSSFWFSUJEBTBQFMBOEPQBSBPTUSJCVOBJTTVQFSJPSFTFMFQPEFFOGSBRVFDFSTJHOJmDBUJWBNFOUFBQSPUFPBPTEJSFJUPTEPTDSFEPSFT1BSBBQFMBSBPTUSJCVOBJTTVQFSJPSFTPTDSFEPSFTUNEFHBTUBSDPNBEWPHBEPTDVTUBTKVEJDJBJTFUDFFTQFSBSVNUFNQPQPSWF[FTMPOHPBURVFVNBEFDJTPTFKBUPNBEBEFJYBOEPPTFVDBQJUBMQBSBMJTBEPOFTTFQFSPEPFmDBOEPWVMOFSWFMBWBSJBEPTUJQPTEFRVFTUJPOBNFOUPTQFMPTEFWFEPSFT/PmOBMPCBODPQPEFWFODFSPMJUHJPOBKVTUJBNBTQFSEFSFNWF[EFHBOIBSEJOIFJSPDPNJTTP
&TUFUJQPEFBUJWJTNPKVEJDJBMCBTFJBTFFNHSBOEFNFEJEBOPTBNQMPTEJSFJUPTTPDJBJTFJOEJWJEVBJTJOTDSJUPTOBDPOTUJUVJPEPTRVBJTPTKV[FTQPEFNEFSJWBSBSHVNFOUPTQBSBEFDJEJSFNDPOUSSJPBPFTUJQVMBEPOBMFHJTMBPFTQFDmDBTPCSFVNEFUFSNJOBEPBTTVOUP*TUPFBFTUSVUVSBNPOPDSUJDBEPKVEJDJSJPCSBTJMFJSPEPBPTKV[FTHSBOEFnFYJCJMJEBEFOBBQMJDBPEBMFJ"TTJNBKVSJTQSVEODJBFPTQBESFTEFEFDJTPEPTNBHJTUSBEPTQPEFNTFSUPPVNBJTJNQPSUBOUFTEPRVFBQSQSJBMFJGSFRFOUFQPSUBOUPRVFRVBOEPVNBOPWBMFHJTMB
INTRODUO AO PENSAMENTO ESTRATGICO
14FGV DIREITO RIO
InTRODuO TEORIa Da DEcIsO
14FGV DIREITO RIO
INTRODUO TEORIA DA DECISO
'(7%*3&*503*0
PBQSPWBEBQBSBiDMBSJmDBSwDFSUPTBTQFDUPTEBMFHJTMBPPVNVEBSBGPSNBRVFPTKV[FTUFOEFNBEFDJEJSPTCBODPTPQUFNQPSFTQFSBSRVFVNONFSPHSBOEFPTVmDJFOUFEFEFDJTFTFTUBCFMFBB JOUFSQSFUBPEPTNBHJTUSBEPTTPCSFFTTBRVFTUPBOUFTEFFTUSVUVSBSFNPQFSBFTCBTFBEBTOFTTBOPWBMFHJTMBP6NFYFNQMPEFTUBBUJUVEFBMFJRVFDSJPVP4JTUFNB'JOBODFJSP*NPCJMJSJPFTUFOEFOEPPVTPEBBMJFOBPmEVDJSJBQBSBPmOBODJBNFOUPJNPCJMJSJP
"JODFSUF[BOBBQMJDBPEPTDPOUSBUPTJOUSPEV[JEBQFMBJNQSFWJTJCJMJEBEFEBTEFDJTFTKVEJDJBJTUFNPVUSBTDBVTBTBMNEBQPMJUJ[BP/BQFTRVJTBEF1JOIFJSP
WSJPTBTQFDUPTEBGPSNBFNRVFPKVEJDJSJPPQFSBGPSBNBQPOUBEPTQFMPTNBHJTUSBEPTDPNPDPOUSJCVJOEPEFGPSNBSFMFWBOUFQBSBSFEV[JSBQSFWJTJCJMJEBEFEBTEFDJTFTKVEJDJBJT4PEJHOPTEFOPUBFOUSFFTUFTBTEFmDJODJBTEPPSEFOBNFOUPMFHBMFKVSEJDPUBNCNQFSDFCJEPTDPNPDBVTBTJNQPSUBOUFTEBNPSPTJEBEFKVEJDJBMPSFDVSTPGSFRFOUFBNFEJEBTMJNJOBSFTFBUFOEODJBBRVFBTEFDJTFTTFKBNCBTFBEBTFNEFUBMIFTQSPDFTTVBJT&TUFTEPJTMUJNPTTPGBUPSFTRVFTFSFMBDJPOBNBVNQSPCMFNBMFWBOUBEPQPSWSJPTNBHJTUSBEPTFOUSFWJTUBEPTRVBMTFKBRVFDPNVNRVFBTEFDJTFTKVEJDJBJTOVODBDIFHVFNBDPOTJEFSBSPNSJUPEPDBTPFNTJ0VUSBTDBSBDUFSTUJDBTEBGPSNBDPNPPKVEJDJSJPPQFSBUBNCNUNJOnVODJBTPCSFPEFTFNQFOIPEPNFSDBEPEFDSEJUP1SJNFJSPIEJGFSFOBTJNQPSUBOUFTOBGPSNBFNRVFPKVEJDJSJPPQFSBOPTWSJPTFTUBEPTFNFTNPEFOUSPEFVNNFTNPFTUBEPBRVBMJEBEFEPKVEJDJSJPQPEFWBSJBSEFVNBKVSJTEJPQBSBPVUSB4FHVOEPPKVEJDJSJPDPNPRVBMRVFSPVUSBJOTUJUVJPOPFTUMJWSFEFQSPCMFNBTEFDPSSVQPFJOnVODJBQPMUJDBRVFTPQFSDFCJEBTDPNPNBJTQSPWWFJTEFPDPSSFSFNDFSUPTFTUBEPTEPRVFFNPVUSPTFUNPTJTUFNBmOBODFJSPDPNPVNBMWPGSFRFOUFWFS"JUI
5FSDFJSPPEFTFNQFOIPEP KVEJDJSJPQPEFSJB TFS TJHOJmDBUJWBNFOUFNFMIPSBEPDPNSFGPSNBTEFHFTUPPSHBOJ[BPFBQFSGFJPBNFOUPFNDFSUBTSFBT%FVNMBEPPDPOIFDJNFOUPEPTNBHJTUSBEPTTPCSFDPNPPNFSDBEPTmOBODFJSPGVODJPOBQPEFSJBTFSBNQMJBEP MFWBOEPQSPWBWFMNFOUFBVNBSFEVPEBJODFSUF[B%FPVUSP MBEPP KVEJDJSJPFPTDBSUSJPT KVEJDJBJTFNQBSUJDVMBSOFDFTTJUBNTFS UFDOPMPHJDBNFOUFBUVBMJ[BEPTEFGPSNBRVFPTDSFEPSFTQPTTBNPCUFSJOGPSNBPEFGPSNBSQJEBFDPOmWFMoPNFTNPWBMFQBSBPTWSJPTSFHJTUSPTQCMJDPTFKVOUBTDPNFSDJBTVUJMJ[BEPTQFMPTDSFEPSFTQBSBDIFDBSTPCSFBJEPOFJEBEFFBDBQBDJEBEFEFQBHBNFOUPEPTQPUFODJBJTUPNBEPSFTEFFNQSTUJNPT/BBVTODJBEFTTFBDFTTPSQJEPDPOmWFMFEJTUODJBPTDSFEPSFTJODPSSFNVNDVTUPFMFWBEPQBSBBWBMJBSTFQPEFNPVOPPQFSBSDPNVNEFUFSNJOBEPDMJFOUF
*70CTFSWBFT'JOBJT&TUFUFYUPDIBNPVBBUFOPQBSBEVBTRVFTUFTQSJODJQBJTSFMBUJWBTQSPUFPMFHBMFKVEJDJBMEPTDSFEPSFTOP
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
FYJTUJOEPVNRVBTFDPOTFOTPFOUSFPTNBHJTUSBEPTCSBTJMFJSPTEFRVFBNPSPTJEBEFEBKVTUJBQPEFEJNJOVJSTJHOJmDBUJWBNFOUFDPNVNBNFMIPSBEFTTBMFHJTMBP
4FHVOEPBTEFDJTFTKVEJDJBJTFNEJTQVUBTFOWPMWFOEPPQFSBFTEFDSEJUPTPQFSDFCJEBTDPNPTFOEPFNHFSBMQSEFWFEPS&TUBBUJUVEFGSFRFOUFNFOUFSFnFUFVNDFSUPBUJWJTNPKVEJDJBMDPNBMHVOTKV[FTEFTDPOTJEFSBOEPPFTUBCFMFDJEPOBMFJPVOPTDPOUSBUPTQBSBQSPNPWFSBiKVTUJBTPDJBMwTFBMJOIBOEPDPNBQBSUFNBJTGSBDBOBEJTQVUBVTVBMNFOUFPEFWFEPSDPOUSBBQBSUFNBJTGPSUFPDSFEPS*TTPGB[DPNRVFBKVSJTQSVEODJBFPTQBESFTEFDPNQPSUBNFOUPEPKVEJDJSJPEFTFNQFOIFNVNQBQFMUPJNQPSUBOUFRVBOUPBMFJOBSFHVMBPEBTEJTQVUBTFOWPMWFOEPRVFTUFTDSFEJUDJBT"TJOUFSQSFUBFTKVEJDJBJTTPCSFKVSPTDBQJUBMJ[BEPTBOBUPDJTNP
BMJRVJEF[FBDFSUF[BEFDFSUPTUUVMPTEFDSEJUPFBQPTTJCJMJEBEFEFFYFDVPEFDFSUPTUJQPTEFHBSBOUJBTTPFYFNQMPTEFTJUVBFTEFTTFUJQP0TDSFEPSFTVTVBMNFOUFQSFGFSFNOPVUJMJ[BSEFUFSNJOBEBTMFHJTMBFTBURVFFTTFDPSQPEFKVSJTQSVEODJBFTUFKBGPSNBEP*TUPBKVEBBFYQMJDBSQPSFYFNQMPQPSRVFBBMJFOBPmEVDJSJBEFWFDVMPTUPCFNBDFJUBOPmOBODJBNFOUPEFBVUPNWFJTFORVBOUPOPmOBODJBNFOUPEFJNWFJTOPUFWFPJNQBDUPFTQFSBEP
INTRODUO AO PENSAMENTO ESTRATGICO
15FGV DIREITO RIO
InTRODuO TEORIa Da DEcIsO
15FGV DIREITO RIO
INTRODUO TEORIA DA DECISO
'(7%*3&*503*0
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mDJBNVNEFWFEPSFTQFDmDPFNVNBEFUFSNJOBEBTJUVBPQPEFNUFSSFQFSDVTTFTNBJTBNQMBTRVFQSFKVEJRVFNBQPQVMBPEFEFWFEPSFT7BMFEJ[FSQSFDJTPSFDPOIFDFSRVFPBUJWJTNPKVEJDJBMOPPSFTVMUBEPEFVNBMFHJTMBPTVCTUBOUJWBJOBEFRVBEB1FMPDPOUSSJPFMFPSFTVMUBEPEFVNQSPDFTTPQPMUJDPRVFUFNUSBOTGFSJEPQBSBPKVEJDJSJPBTPMVPEFDPOnJUPTQPMUJDPTF TPDJBJT&DPNPVNQSPDFTTPQPMUJDPQSFDJTB TFS USBUBEPUBNCNOBBSFOBQPMUJDBBUSBWTEBDPOTUJUVJPEFHSVQPTEFBQPJPBQMJDBPSJHPSPTBEBMFHJTMBPFEPTDPOUSBUPT
/FTUFTFOUJEPJNQPSUBOUFFTDMBSFDFSFFEVDBSPTBUVBJTFGVUVSPTKV[FTBSFTQFJUPEPDPOUFEPFDPONJDPEBTDBVTBTFNRVFFTUPFOWPMWJEPTBTSB[FTFDPONJDBTEFBMHVNBTDMVTVMBTBQBSFOUFNFOUFEFTCBMBODFBEBTFBTDPOTFRODJBTNBDSPFDPONJDBTEFTVBTEFDJTFTPDPSSJEBTBQBSUJSEBBEBQUBPEPTBHFOUFTBPQBESPEFDPNQPSUBNFOUPEPTNBHJTUSBEPT*TTPQPEFTFSGFJUPOBTGBDVMEBEFTEFEJSFJUPFOBT&TDPMBTEB.BHJTUSBUVSBNBTUBNCNQFMBTFNQSFTBTOBEFGFTBEBTVBTDBVTBTRVBOEPBQSFTFOUBEBTBPKVEJDJSJP
'JOBMNFOUFQSFDJTPOPTPCSFFTUJNBSBJNQPSUODJBEPTGBUPSFTMFHBJTFKVEJDJBJTOBFYQMJDBPEPTBMUPTTQSFBETCBODSJPT FEPCBJYP WPMVNFEF DSEJUPOP#SBTJM" JOTUBCJMJEBEFNBDSPFDPONJDB B FMFWBEBEWJEBQCMJDBPT JNQPTUPTFUD UBNCNUNVNB JOnVODJBEFUFSNJOBOUFOBFTUSVUVSBEPNFSDBEPEFDSEJUPCSBTJMFJSP&OUSFPVUSBTDPJTBTQPSRVFKVSPTBMUPTTPVNBDBVTBJNQPSUBOUFEPBUJWJTNPKVEJDJBM
3FGFSODJBT
"GBOBTJF51-IBDFSF./BLBOFiF%FUFSNJOBOUTPG#BOL*OUFSFTU4QSFBETJO#SB[JMw$FOUSBM#BOLPG#SB[JM
"JUI.i0*NQBDUPEP+VEJDJSJPOBT"UJWJEBEFTEBT*OTUJUVJFT'JOBODFJSBTwJO"$1JOIFJSP0+VEJDJSJPFB&DPOPNJBOP#SBTJM
#FDL5i*NQFEJNFOUTUPUIF%FWFMPQNFOUBOE&DJFODZPG'JOBODJBM*OUFSNFEJBUJPOJO#SB[JMw1PMJDZ3FTFBSDI8PSLJOH1BQFS*O8PSME#BOL
(BMJOEP"F".JDDPi$SFEJUPS1SPUFDUJPOBOE'JOBODJBM$ZDMFTw8PSLJOH1BQFSO*OUFS"NFSJDBO%FWFMPQNFOU#BOL
(BMJOEP"i$SFEJUPS3JHIUTBOEUIF$SFEJU.BSLFU8IFSFEP8F4UBOE w8PSLJOH1BQFS*O*OUFS"NFSJDBO%FWFMPQNFOU#BOL
-BFWFO-F(.BKPOJi%PFT+VEJDJBM&DJFODZ-PXFSUIF$PTUPG$SFEJU w8PSME#BOL1PMJDZ3FTFBSDI8PSLJOH1BQFSO#BODP.VOEJBM
-B1PSUB3'-PQF[EF4JMBOFT"4IMFJGFSF37JTIOZi-BXBOE'JOBODFw+PVSOBMPG1PMJUJDBM&DPOPNZWPMO
-PSB&i4USVDUVSBM3FGPSNTJO-BUJO"NFSJDB8IBU)BT#FFO3FGPSNFEBOE)PXUP.FBTVSFJU w8PSLJOH1BQFSO*OUFS"NFSJDBO%FWFMPQNFOU#BOL
INTRODUO AO PENSAMENTO ESTRATGICO
16FGV DIREITO RIO
InTRODuO TEORIa Da DEcIsO
16FGV DIREITO RIO
INTRODUO TEORIA DA DECISO
'(7%*3&*503*0
1BEJMMB"F"3FRVFKPiF$PTUTBOECFOFmUTPGUIF4USJDU1SPUFDUJPOPG$SFEJUPS3JHIUTFPSZBOE&WJEFODFw8PSLJOH1BQFSO*OUFS"NFSJDBO%FWFMPQNFOU#BOL
1JOIFJSP"$PSH
+VEJDJSJPF&DPOPNJBOP#SBTJM&EJUPSB4VNBS4P1BVMP
1JOIFJSP"$F$$BCSBMi$SFEJU.BSLFUTJO#SB[JMF3PMFPGUIF+VEJDJBSZBOE0UIFS*OTUJUVUJPOTwJO.1BHBOPFE
%FGVTJOH%FGBVMU*ODFOUJWFTBOE*OTUJUVUJPOT*%#
1JOIFJSP"$i+VEHFT7JFXPOUIF+VEJDJBSZBOE&DPOPNJDTwQBQFSQSFTFOUFEBUUIFTFNJOBS3FGPSNBEP+VEJDJSJP1SPCMFNBT%FTBmPTF1FSTQFDUJWBT*%&414P1BVMP"QSJM
4UJHMJU[+&iFSPMFPGUIFTUBUFJOmOBODJBMNBSLFUTw1SPDFFEJOHTPGUIF8PSME#BOL"OOVBM$POGFSFODFPO%FWFMPQNFOU&DPOPNJDT
INTRODUO AO PENSAMENTO ESTRATGICO
17FGV DIREITO RIO
InTRODuO TEORIa Da DEcIsO
17FGV DIREITO RIO
INTRODUO TEORIA DA DECISO
'(7%*3&*503*0
\!5,!
%JTDVTTPEPDBTPiHSPPUCPPNw
0DBTPBTFSUSBCBMIBEPCBTUBOUFDPNQMFYP5SBUBTFEFVNBTJUVBPWFSEJDBFNRVFTFDIPDBNEJWFSTPTJOUFSFTTFTSFBJTFTUBSPFNKPHPWJEBTMJCFSEBEFTQBUSJNOJPTUSBCBMIPFWBMPSFTEJWFSTPTEFEJGFSFOUFTBUPSFTTPDJBJT"EJTDVTTPQSJODJQBMHJSBSFNUPSOPEFDPNPEFTFOWPMWFSDSJUSJPTQBSBEFDJEJSVNBRVFSFMBFOWPMWFOEPEJSFJUPTJOEJWJEVBJTFTPDJBJToQBSUJDVMBSNFOUFPEJSFJUPNPSBEJBFPEJSFJUPEBTDSJBOBTQSPUFPoBTQPMUJDBTQCMJDBTFPTJNQBDUPTEFEFDJTFTKVEJDJBJTTPCSFBSBDJPOBMJEBEFEFQSPHSBNBTEPHPWFSOP0TGBUPTBQSFTFOUBEPTGPSBNBEBQUBEPTEFVNBEFDJTPEB$PSUF$POTUJUVDJPOBM4VM"GSJDBOB
"UPSFT0TEFTBCSJHBEPT
/PmOBMEBEDBEBEFBQSPYJNBEBNFOUFBEVMUPTFDSJBOBTWJWJBNFN8BMMBDFEFOF,SBBJGPOUFJOGSJDBEP4VMFNDPOEJFTQSFDSJBTFTFNBDFTTPBOFOIVNUJQPEFTFSWJPQCMJDP0TEFTBCSJHBEPTNVEBSBNTFQSPHSFTTJWBNFOUFEVSBOUFBEDBEBEFQBSBVNBSFBQSJWBEBCBMEJBOBKVSJTEJPEBNVOJDJQBMJEBEFEF0PTUFOCFSH'PJJOUFOUBEBFNEFNBJPEFVNBBPEFSFJOUFHSBPEFQPTTF0TCBSSBDFTFBQBSDBJOGSBFTUSVUVSBRVFIBWJBTJEPDPOTUSVEBGPSBNEFNPMJEPT"QTTFSFNFYQVMTPTEBSFBBOUFSJPSPTEFTBCSJHBEPTEJSJHJSBNTFBVNQBSRVFFTQPSUJWPFN8BMMBDFEFOFPOEFMFWBOUBSBNBDBNQBNFOUPUFNQPSSJP&NWJTUBEBTQTTJNBTDPOEJFTQBSUJDVMBSNFOUFQBSBBTDSJBOBTGPSBNBKVEBEPTQPSEJWFSTBTFOUJEBEFTBTTJTUFODJBJT6NBEFMBTGPJ+VTUJBFOUSBOEPDPNBPDPOUSBBTFTGFSBTMPDBMQSPWJODJBMFGFEFSBMEPHPWFSOPQBSBDPOTFHVJSBCSJHPUFNQPSSJPQBSBBTDSJBOBTFBEVMUPT&NEFKVOIPEPNFTNPBOPP+VJ[+PTNBOEFGFSJVEFGPSNBMJNJOBSRVFP$FOUSP$PNVOJUSJPEF8BMMBDFEFOFGPTTFVUJMJ[BEPHSBUVJUBNFOUFQBSBBDPNPEBSBTDSJBOBTFVNQBJPVBEVMUPSFTQPOTWFM
0THPWFSOPTNVOJDJQBMFTUBEVBMFGFEFSBM
"$POTUJUVJPEBGSJDBEP4VM CBTUBOUF SFDFOUF 4FHVJOEP B MJOIBEBT DPOTUJUVJFTRVF JODPSQPSBNEJSFJUPTIVNBOPTEFUFSDFJSBFRVBSUBHFSBFTDPOTUBOUFTEF$POWFOFT*OUFSOBDJPOBJTFMBQPTTVJVNHSBOEFDBQUVMPTPCSFEJSFJUPTTDJPFDPONJDPT0BSUQPSFYFNQMPQSFWRVFUPEPDJEBEPUFSEJSFJUPBVNBCSJHPTIFMUFS"MNEJTTPPBSUTPCSFPTEJSFJUPTEBDSJBOB
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oUPEPTFTTFTQSPCMFNBTUPSOBNBJNQMFNFOUBPEBQPMUJDBEFNPSBEJBNVJUPEJGDJM
0+VEJDJSJPTVMBGSJDBOP
$PNVNBEBT$POTUJUVJFTDPNQBSBUJWBNFOUFNBJTSFDFOUFTFBWBOBEBTOPNVOEPBGSJDBEP4VMUPSOPVTFVNMBCPSBUSJPQBSBFYQFSJODJBTKVEJDJSJBT4VB$BSUBJODPSQPSBVNBTSJFEFHBSBOUJBTTPDJBJTFFDPONJDBTRVFOPFOUBOUPBJOEBOFDFTTJUBNEFJOUFSQSFUBPQBSBTFSFNQPTUBTFNQSUJDB0+VEJDJSJPOPFOUBOUPSFQPVTBTPCSFVNBMJOIBUOVFQPSVNMBEPQPSRVFUFNRVFEBSWB[PBVNBEFNBOEBTPDJBMSFQSJNJEBUQJDBEFQBTFNEFTFOWPMWJNFOUPNBTRVFGPJFYBDFSCBEBQPSBOPTEF"QBSUIFJETPDJBM1PSPVUSPMBEPEFWF
INTRODUO AO PENSAMENTO ESTRATGICO
18FGV DIREITO RIO
InTRODuO TEORIa Da DEcIsO
18FGV DIREITO RIO
INTRODUO TEORIA DA DECISO
'(7%*3&*503*0
TFSVNBGPOUFEFFTUBCJMJEBEFTFSWJOEPEFNFEJBEPSEPTHSBOEFTDPOnJUPTQPMUJDPTPDJBJT*TTPQPSRVFBOPWBEFNPDSBDJBJOUFSSBDJBMTVMBGSJDBOBDPNPGPJSFTTBMUBEPSFDFOUFoOFDFTTJUBQPSUBOUPEFDPOTPMJEBP/FTTBTDPOEJFTBFTEFHSBOEFJNQBDUPOB+VTUJBQPEFNFWFOUVBMNFOUFJNQMJDBSFNQFSEBEFMFHJUJNJEBEFEBQBSUFEFHPWFSOPTEFNPDSBUJDBNFOUFFMFJUPT
'BUPT
01SPDFTTPOB+VTUJB
0TEFTBCSJHBEPTEF(SPPUCPPNMFWBSBNTVBDBVTBBPUSJCVOBM"QSFTFOUBSBNEJWFSTPTBSHVNFOUPTiQSJODJQJPMHJDPTwFNTVBFYQPTJP"mSNBSBNRVFPEJSFJUPDPOTUJUVDJPOBMBBCSJHPEFWFSJBTFSJOUFSQSFUBEPEFNPEPBJODMVJSVNNOJNPEFDPOEJFTEFNPSBEJBVOJWFSTBMJ[WFJTFORVBOUPPTQSPHSBNBTTPDJBJTRVFWJTBNQSPHSFTTJWBSFBMJ[BPEFNPSBEJBBEFRVBEBBUPEPTGPTTFNJNQMFNFOUBEPT&TTBJOUFSQSFUBPBEWNEFVNBMFJUVSBEJSFUBUBOUPEPUFYUPDPOTUJUVDJPOBMDPNPEB$POWFOP*OUFSOBDJPOBMEPT%JSFJUPT&DPONJDPT4PDJBJTF$VMUVSBJTEB0/6FEB$POWFOP*OUFSOBDJPOBMTPCSFPT%JSFJUPTEB$SJBOB
0THPWFSOPTGFEFSBMQSPWJODJBMFNVOJDJQBMDPOUSBQVTFSBNSB[FTEFQPMUJDBQCMJDBQBSBSFDVTBSBTQSFUFOTFTEPTBVUPSFT&NQSJNFJSPMVHBSVNBQPMUJDBQCMJDBSBDJPOBMFDPOTUSVEBEFGPSNBBJOUFHSBSBTBFTOPTEJWFSTPTOWFJTEFHPWFSOPFTUBSJBTFOEPQPTUBFNQSUJDB*TTPTJHOJmDBRVFPBSUJHPEB$POTUJUVJPTVMBGSJDBOBOPUFSJBTJEPWJPMBEP'PJPGFSFDJEBFYUFOTBFWJEODJBEPBOEBNFOUPEPQSPHSBNBOBDJPOBMEFNPSBEJB
&NTFHVOEPMVHBSUFOEPFNWJTUBRVFPTSFDVSTPTEJTQPOWFJTQBSBJNQMFNFOUBPEFQPMUJDBTEFNPSBEJBTPFTDBTTPTQSPQPSDJPOBSBCSJHPUFNQPSSJPBPTBVUPSFTJNQMJDBSJBQSFKV[PTBPQSPHSBNBOBDJPOBM1PSMUJNPGPJBSHVNFOUBEPRVFPEJSFJUPEBTDSJBOBTNPSBEJBQSFWJTUPOPBSUJHPOBWFSEBEFVNBPCSJHBPRVFEFWFTFSBEJNQMJEBQFMPTQBJTFOPQFMP&TUBEP
"MJTDPOTJEFSBOEPTFRVFEPJOUFSFTTFEBQSQSJBDSJBOBQFSNBOFDFSDPNBGBNMJBOPQPEFSJBFYJTUJSVNEJSFJUPFNTFQBSBEPEFBCSJHPEJSFJUPFTTFEFUJUVMBSJEBEFBQFOBTEBTDSJBOBT&NDPOTFRODJBDPOTJEFSBOEPTFRVFPEJTQPTUPOPBSUJHPEFWFSJBTFSJOUFSQSFUBEPDPNPNPSBEJBOPDPOUFYUPGBNJMJBSRVBMRVFSEFDJTPRVFQSPQPSDJPOBTTFBTDSJBOBTNPSBEJBEFVNBGPSNBJNFEJBUBFGPSBEPDPOUFYUPEBQPMUJDBOBDJPOBMFTUBSJBBVUPNBUJDBNFOUFBCBSDBOEPPTQBJT0JNQBDUPPSBNFOUSJPEFTUBGPSNBTFSJBJNQFOTWFMFESBNUJDPoUPSOBSJBRVBMRVFSPVUSBQPMUJDBQCMJDBJOFYFRWFM
0+VMHBNFOUPOB$PSUFEF"QFMBFT
05SJCVOBMSFKFJUPVPTBSHVNFOUPTBSFTQFJUPEPBSUJHPJFBmSNPVRVFFNWJTUBEBFYJTUODJBEFVNBQPMUJDBSBDJPOBMFBCSBOHFOUFEFNPSBEJBRVFFTUBWBTFOEPJNQMFNFOUBEBQFMPHPWFSOPPTEFTBCSJHBEPTOPQPEFSJBNFNCBTBSBTTVBTQSFUFOTFTOPEJSFJUPNPSBEJB$POTJEFSBOEPTFRVFPTSVTIBWJBNQSPEV[JEPFWJEODJBDMBSBEFRVFiVNQSPHSBNBSBDJPOBMEFNPSBEJBUJOIBTJEPEFTFOIBEPQBSBSFTPMWFSVNQSPCMFNBQSFNFOUFOPDPOUFYUPEFSFDVSTPTFTDBTTPTwRVBMRVFSBWBMJBPEBTRVBMJEBEFTFEFGFJUPTEFUBMQSPHSBNBoJODMVJOEPBPTFWFOUVBJTFGFJUPTTPCSFPTEFTBCSJHBEPToTQPEFSJBTFSGFJUBOVNQSB[PNBJPSQPTUPRVFiRVBMRVFSBWBMJBPEPQSPHSBNBHPWFSOBNFOUBMEFNPSBEJBEFWFMFWBSFNDPOTJEFSBPRVFUSTBOPTTPVNQFSPEPEFUFNQPFYUSFNBNFOUFDVSUPQBSBSFTPMWFSBDSJTFTVMBGSJDBOBEFNPSBEJBw
/PFOUBOUPBJOTUODJBJOGFSJPSBDBUPVPBSHVNFOUPTPCSFPBSUJHP&MBBmSNPVRVFPEFWFSQSJNSJPEFQSPQPSDJPOBSBCSJHPTDSJBOBTEPTQBJT.BTOBFWFOUVBMJEBEFEFRVFPTQBJTOPQVEFTTFNPVOPUJWFTTFNDPOEJFTEFGB[MPTFSJBEFWFSEFP&TUBEPTVQSJSUBMQBQFM.BJTEPRVFJTTPP5SJCVOBMDFSUJmDPVRVFBCSJHPTFSJBNBJTEPRVFBQFOBTVNBDBTB"MNEJTTPPBCSJHPBTFSQSPWJEPQFMP&TUBEPEFWFSJBTFSEFUBMOBUVSF[BRVFPTQBJTEFWFSJBNQPEFSOFMFWJWFSDPNTVBTDSJBOBT*TTPOPTJHOJmDBSJBRVFPTVKFJUPBUJWPEPEJSFJUPTFSJBNPT
INTRODUO AO PENSAMENTO ESTRATGICO
19FGV DIREITO RIO
InTRODuO TEORIa Da DEcIsO
19FGV DIREITO RIO
INTRODUO TEORIA DA DECISO
'(7%*3&*503*0
QBJToBQFOBTRVFVNBDSJBOBOPQPEFWJWFSFNJTPMBNFOUPEFTFVTQBJTi0NFMIPSJOUFSFTTFEBDSJBOBEFJNQPSUODJBGVOEBNFOUBMFNUPEBFRVBMRVFSNBUSJBRVFBFOWPMWBwFGBNMJBTOPEFWFNTFSTFQBSBEBT
1PSmNP5SJCVOBMJOGFSJPSDPOTJEFSPVBMHVNBTDPOTFRODJBTQPUFODJBJTEFTVBJOUFSQSFUBPDPOUSPWFSUJEBEPBSUJHPEB$POTUJUVJP4VM"GSJDBOB&NQBSUJDVMBSSFGFSJVTFQPTTWFMFOYVSSBEBEFBFTEFPVUSPTEFTBCSJHBEPTRVFUFOUBSJBNDPOTFHVJSEP+VEJDJSJPBCSJHPQBSBTFVTmMIPTFQBSBTJNFTNPTJOEJSFUBNFOUF5BJTBFTQPEFSJBNEFTFTUSVUVSBSUPEPPQSPHSBNBEFNPSBEJBBMNEFBDBCBSDPNBSBDJPOBMJEBEFEBQPMUJDBQCMJDBEFTFOWPMWJEBQFMBTEJWFSTBTFTGFSBTEFHPWFSOPBJOEBNBJTRVBOEPDPOTJEFSBEPTPTFTDBTTPTSFDVSTPTmOBODFJSPT
1BSBUFOUBSMJNJUBSBBCSBOHODJBEBEFDJTPB$PSUFGF[BMHVNBTSFTTBMWBTQPTTJCJMJEBEFEFFTUFOEFSFTTBEFDJTPBPVUSPTDBTPT&NQSJNFJSPMVHBSBTDSJBOBTOPQMPBUJWPTPEFTBCSJHBEBTFQSFDJTBNEFQSPUFP&NTFHVOEPMVHBSPTQBJTOPQPEFNDVNQSJSTFVEFWFSQSJNSJPFQSPQPSDJPOBSBCSJHPBTFVTmMIPT&NUFSDFJSPMVHBSBTDSJBOBTQPEFNTFSBDPNQBOIBEBTQFMPTQBJTNBTOPOFDFTTBSJBNFOUFQPSPVUSPTNFNCSPTEBGBNMJB
"%FDJTP
05SJCVOBMEFDJEJVRVFPSHPPVEFQBSUBNFOUPEP&TUBEPDPNQFUFOUFFTUPCSJHBEPBQSPQPSDJPOBSNPSBEJBBUPEPTPTBVUPSFTRVFGPSFNQBJTEFGBNMJBFTSFTQFDUJWBTDSJBOBT"EFDJTPOPFOUSBFNEFUBMIFTTPCSFPRVTFSJBVNBNPSBEJBJEFBM/PFOUBOUPP+VEJDJSJPEFJYPVSFHJTUSBEPRVFQSPWJTPSJBNFOUFCBSSBDBTMBUSJOBTQPSUWFJTFVNBGPOUFSFHVMBSEFHVBEFWFSJBNDPOTUJUVJSPNOJNPEFTFKWFM'PJDPOTJHOBEPUBNCNPEFTFKPEFRVFPMPDBMEBNPSBEJBQSPWJTSJBGPTTFEFOUSPEBNVOJDJQBMJEBEFEF0PTUFOCFSH
'B[QBSUFQPSUBOUPEBEFDJTPPSFDPOIFDJNFOUPEFRVFP&TUBEPUFNPEFWFSQPTJUJWPEFQSPQPSDJPOBSBCSJHPTDSJBOBTDVKPTQBJTGPSFNJODBQB[FTEFGB[MP%PNFTNPNPEPSFDPOIFDFTFRVFEPNFMIPSJOUFSFTTFRVFBTDSJBOBTTFKBNBDPNPEBEBTKVOUBNFOUFDPNTFVTQBJT
0TSVTEFDJEJSBNBQFMBS$PSUF$POTUJUVDJPOBMQBSBGB[FSSFWFSUFSUBMEFDJTP0RVFWPDBDIBRVFB$PSUF$POTUJUVDJPOBMEFWFSJBEFDJEJS
#JCMJPHSBmBDPNQMFNFOUBSWUFYUPBOFYPEF$BTT4VOTUFJO
-FJUVSBTVHFSJEBWUFYUPBCBJYPEF%JFHP8FSOFDL
"SHVNFOUPTDPOTFRFODJBMJTUBTF&TUBEPEF%JSUFJUPTVCTEJPTQBSBVNBDPNQBUJCJMJ[BP
%JFHP8FSOFDL"SHVFMIFT
3FTVNP0TBSHVNFOUPTGVOEBEPTOBTDPOTFRODJBTEFVNEFUFSNJOBEPDVSTPEFBPUNTJEPPCKFUP
EFJOUFOTBTEJTDVTTFTOBFDPOPNJBOBUJDBFOPNCJUPEBSBDJPOBMJEBEFQSUJDBFNHFSBM$POUVEPTSFDFOUFNFOUFBUFPSJBEBBSHVNFOUBPKVSEJDBQBTTPVBTFEFEJDBSEFGPSNBNBJTTJTUFNUJDBBOMJTFEBTDPOEJFTEFQSFWBMODJBEFTTFUJQPEFBSHVNFOUP/FTTFQPOUPPDPOTFOTPBUVBMFOUSF
4RABALHOAPRESENTADONO8)6#ONGRESSO.ACIONALDO#/.0%$)n#ONSELHO.ACIONALDE0ESQUISAE0S'RADUAOEM$IREITOREALIZADOENTREEDENOVEMBRODEEM&ORTALEZA#%%NVIADOPARAPUBLICAONA2EVISTA6IRTUALDO#/.0%$)NOPRELOFAVORNODIVULGARCIRCULAROUCITARSEMAUTORIZAO'OSTARIADEAGRADECERA.OEL3TRUCHINER&ERNANDO,EALE(UMBERTO"VILAPELALEITURAECOMENTRIOSAUMAVERSOPRELIMINARDESTEPAPER
0ESQUISADORDA%SCOLADE$IREITODO2IODE*ANEIRODA&UNDAO'ETULIO6ARGAS-ESTRANDOEM$IREITO0BLICOPELA5NIVERSIDADEDO%STADODO2IODE*ANEIRO5%2*
INTRODUO AO PENSAMENTO ESTRATGICO
20FGV DIREITO RIO
InTRODuO TEORIa Da DEcIsO
20FGV DIREITO RIO
INTRODUO TEORIA DA DECISO
'(7%*3&*503*0
PTKVSJTUBTQBSFDFTFSPEFRVFBSHVNFOUPTDPOTFRFODJBMJTUBTTPiNFSBNFOUFQSUJDPTwJTUPFYUFSOPTTJOTUJUVJFTKVSEJDBTFBPDPOKVOUPEFEFDJTFTRVFDPNQFNPEJSFJUPWMJEPBTTJNQPSGPSBEBJEJBEF&TUBEPEF%JSFJUPFEFWJODVMBPEPKVJ[MFJBKVTUJmDBPEFEFDJTFTKVEJDJBJTDPNCBTFOBTTVBTDPOTFRODJBTTQPEFUFSVNQFTPTVCTJEJSJP/P#SBTJMFTTBQPTJPGPJBSUJDVMBEBFTJTUFNBUJ[BEBQFMPQJPOFJSPBSUJHPEF)VNCFSUP#WJMBi"SHVNFOUBP+VSEJDBFB*NVOJEBEFEP-JWSP&MFUSOJDPw&TTBDPODFQPOPEDPOUBEBNBOFJSBQFMBRVBMPTUSJCVOBJTTVQFSJPSFTOBDJPOBJTFNQSFHBNSBDJPDOJPTEPHOFSP0PCKFUJWPEFTUFUSBCBMIPNPTUSBSRVFVNBSHVNFOUPDPOTFRFODJBMJTUBQPEFTFSFOUFOEJEPDPNPVNBGPSNBEFPCFEJODJBBPEJSFJUPWJHFOUFOBNFEJEBFNRVFP KVJ[ UFNBPCSJHBPEF UPNBSBEFDJTPRVFNBJTQSPNPWBBmOBMJEBEF TVCKBDFOUFEBOPSNBBQMJDWFMPVRVFNBJTQSPNPWBPFTUBEPEFDPJTBTFTUBCFMFDJEPDPNPPCSJHBUSJP&NBNCPTPTDBTPTJOFWJUWFMSFDPSSFSBSBDJPDOJPTDPOTFRFODJBMJTUBTQBSBTFDPNQBSBSPHSBVEFQSPNPPEFTUFPVEBRVFMFDVSTPEFEFDJTP
*OUSPEVP"IJFSBSRVJ[BPEFBSHVNFOUPTKVSEJDPTQSPQPTUBQPS)VNCFSUPWJMB
/PTMUJNPTBOPTBDPNVOJEBEFKVSEJDBCSBTJMFJSBUFNTFWJTUPEJBOUFEFVNTJHOJmDBUJWPDSFTDJNFOUPEPQFTPEBDPOTJEFSBPEBTDPOTFRODJBTEBEFDJTPOBGVOEBNFOUBPEPTBDSEPTEFUSJCVOBJTTVQFSJPSFToFNFTQFDJBMEP4VQSFNP5SJCVOBM'FEFSBM"QSFTFOBEFBSHVNFOUPTEFTTBOBUVSF[BOPFYFSDDJPEBGVOPKVSJTEJDJPOBMDPMPDBVNBTSJFEFEJmDVMEBEFTDPODFJUVBJTFQSUJDBTQBSBBUFPSJBEP%JSFJUPFNFTQFDJBMRVBOUPTVBDPNQBUJCJMJEBEFDPNBJEJBEF&TUBEPEF%JSFJUPEFmOJPEBTTVBTDPOEJFTEFSBDJPOBMJEBEFFMFHJUJNJEBEFEPTNBHJTUSBEPTCSBTJMFJSPTQBSBVUJMJ[BSBQSFWJTPEFDPOTFRODJBTDPNPFMFNFOUPEFDJTJWPOBTPMVPEFDBTPT/FTUFUSBCBMIPTFSFOGSFOUBEPBQFOBTVNEFTTFTQSPCMFNBTDPNPVNBSHVNFOUPRVFSFUJSBTVBGPSBEFVNBBWBMJBPEBTDPOTFRODJBTEFVNBEFDJTPFTQFDmDBQPEFTFSDPNQBUJCJMJ[BEPDPNBJEJBEF&TUBEPEF%JSFJUP "DPOTUSVPEFBSHVNFOUPTDPOTFRFODJBMJTUBTQPEFTFSFOUFOEJEBDPNPVNBGPSNBWMJEBEFPCFEJODJBTOPSNBTKVSEJDBT
/PQMBOPKVSEJDPBBOMJTFEFTUFUJQPEFBSHVNFOUPUFNTJEPQSBUJDBNFOUFEFJYBEBEFMBEP/P#SBTJMBDPODFQPUSBEJDJPOBMUFNTJEPBEFRVFBBUJWJEBEFEPTKV[FToTFKBFMBFODBSBEBDPNPiDSJBUJWBwPVDPNPiNFDOJDBwoFOWPMWFBBQMJDBPEFOPSNBTHFSBJTEFGPSNBSFMBUJWBNFOUFJOEFQFOEFOUFEFTVBTQPTTWFJTDPOTFRODJBTDPNFYDFPUBMWF[EFDBTPTFYUSFNPT6NEPTQSJNFJSPTUSBUBNFOUPTTJTUFNUJDPTTPCSFPQFTPEPTBSHVNFOUPTDPOTFRFODJBMJTUBTOPPSEFOBNFOUPKVSEJDPCSBTJMFJSPPEF)VNCFSUPWJMBRVFFNTFVBSUJHPi"SHVNFOUBP+VSEJDBFB*NVOJEBEFEP-JWSP&MFUSOJDPwQSPDVSBDPOTUSVJSVNDPOKVOUPEFSFHSBTQSJNBGBDJFEFJOUFSQSFUBP1BSBUBOUPSFBMJ[BEPJTNPWJNFOUPTBOBMUJDPTEJTUJOUPT1SJNFJSPQBSUJOEPTFEFVNDPODFJUPEFJOUFSQSFUBPKVSEJDBJEFOUJmDBEPDPN B UBSFGB EF GVOEBNFOUBS B FTDPMIB EBT QSFNJTTBT KVTUJmDBP FYUFSOB VUJMJ[BEBT OBEFDJTPGFJUBVNBEJTUJOPFOUSFEJGFSFOUFTUJQPTEFBSHVNFOUPTKVSEJDPTEFBDPSEPDPNPTFVGVOEBNFOUPoMJOHTUJDPTTJTUFNUJDPTIJTUSJDPTFQSUJDPT
4FHVOEPWJMBFNCPSBBSHVNFOUPTEFEJWFSTPTUJQPTQPTTBNTFSVTBEPTOBJOUFSQSFUBPKVSEJDBOPTFQPEFEJ[FSRVFUPEPTUFOIBNPNFTNPQFTP/FTTFTFOUJEPPTFHVOEPNPWJNFOUPBOBMUJDPWBMPSBSFTUFBSHVNFOUPTEFBDPSEPDPNPPSEFOBNFOUPKVSEJDPCSBTJMFJSP0PCKFUJWPEBEJTUJOPFOUSFEJGFSFOUFTFTQDJFTEFBSHVNFOUPTFNMUJNBJOTUODJBBDPOTUSVPEFQBSNFUSPTQBSBBWBMJBSEPQFTPEPTBSHVNFOUPTMFWBOUBEPTFNGBWPSEFVNBEFUFSNJOBEBUFTFWJMBUFODJPOBFYQMJDBSDPNPiPTBSHVNFOUPTQPEFNFEFWFNTFSVUJMJ[BEPTOBJOUFSQSFUBPKVSEJDBwFOFTTFTFOUJEPPDSJUSJPQBSBTFBGFSJSBGPSBEFVNBSHVNFOUPOBEFDJTPKVEJDJBMDPNPWFSFNPTBTFHVJSBTVBSFDPOEVPPVOPBPPSEFOBNFOUPKVSEJDP
4FFTUBMJHBPFOUSFBSHVNFOUPFOPSNBTKVSEJDBTWJHFOUFTJTUPTFFTUBTGVOEBNFO
3/,%22#6%.)%2#h2ACIONALIDADDELASJUSTIlCACIONESCONSECUENCIALISTASENLASDECISIONESJUDICIALESvP%STAOBSERVAOSEREFEREAOMBITOJUDICIALJQUENOPLANOLEGISLATIVOASCONSIDERAESSOBREORESULTADODAPROMULGAODEDETERMINADALEISOOBVIAMENTEDECISIVAS
6),!(h!RGUMENTAO*URDICAEA)MUNIDADEDO,IVRO%LETRNICOvP
)DEMIBIDEM
INTRODUO AO PENSAMENTO ESTRATGICO
21FGV DIREITO RIO
InTRODuO TEORIa Da DEcIsO
21FGV DIREITO RIO
INTRODUO TEORIA DA DECISO
'(7%*3&*503*0
UBNBRVFMF
JEFOUJmDWFJT TFHVOEPVNDSJUSJP GPSNBMFPCKFUJWPQPEFTFSWFSJmDBEBOBQSUJDBFOUPPBSHVNFOUPTFSJOTUJUVDJPOBM"QBSUJSEFTUFDSJUSJPQSPQPTUBVNBIJFSBSRVJ[BPEPTEJGFSFOUFTBSHVNFOUPTEFBDPSEPDPNPTFVQFTPTFOEPFTUFBGFSJEPBQBSUJSEBSFDPOEVUJCJMJEBEFEPBSHVNFOUPBPPSEFOBNFOUPKVSEJDPCSBTJMFJSP&TUBIJFSBSRVJ[BPKVTUJmDBEBEBTFHVJOUFGPSNB
i0TBSHVNFOUPTJOTUJUVDJPOBJTTPBRVFMFTRVFQPSTFSFNEFUFSNJOBEPTQPSBUPTJOTUJUVDJPOBJT QBSMBNFOUBSFTBENJOJTUSBUJWPT KVEJDJBJT UNDPNPQPOUPEFSFGFSODJBP PSEFOBNFOUP KVSEJDP 1PTTVFN OFTTF TFOUJEPNBJPS DBQBDJEBEF EF PCKFUJWBP0TBSHVNFOUPTOPJOTUJUVDJPOBJTTPEFDPSSFOUFTBQFOBTEPBQFMPBPTFOUJNFOUPEFKVTUJBRVFBQSQSJBJOUFSQSFUBPFWFOUVBMNFOUFFWPDB1PTTVFNQPSJTTPNFOPSDBQBDJEBEFEFPCKFUJWBPw
4FS JOTUJUVDJPOBM QPSUBOUP QPTTVJS OP PSEFOBNFOUP KVSEJDP WJHFOUF VNQPOUP EFSFGFSODJBPCKFUJWP JTUP VN GVOEBNFOUPOPSNBUJWPQBTTWFMEF WFSJm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iBSHVNFOUPTOPQSUJDPTwQBSFDFSFTJEJSOBQSFTFOBEFVNBOJDBQSPQSJFEBEFTFSPVOPJOTUJUVDJPOBM
"DPMPDBPEPTBSHVNFOUPTQSUJDPTOPEFHSBVNBJTCBJYPEBIJFSBSRVJBQSPQPTUBKVTUJmDBEBQPSWJMBEBTFHVJOUFGPSNB
i0TBSHVNFOUPTOPJOTUJUVDJPOBJTOPGB[FNSFGFSODJBBPTNPEPTJOTUJUVDJPOBJTEFFYJTUODJB EP%JSFJUP&MFT GB[FNBQFMP B RVBMRVFS PVUSP FMFNFOUP RVFOP P QSQSJPPSEFOBNFOUPKVSEJDP4PBSHVNFOUPTNFSBNFOUFQSUJDPTRVFEFQFOEFNEFVNKVMHBNFOUPGFJUPQFMPQSQSJPJOUSQSFUFTPCQPOUPTEFWJTUBTFDPONJDPTQPMUJDPTFPVUJDPT"TDPOTFRODJBTEBOPTBTEFEFUFSNJOBEBJOUFSQSFUBPFBOFDFTTJEBEFEFBUFOUBSQBSBPTQMBOPTEFHPWFSOPFORVBESBNTFBRVJw
/PDBTPFTQFDmDPEPMJWSPFMFUSOJDPPBSHVNFOUPQSUJDPDJUBEPQPSWJMBTFSJBPEFRVFDPOTJEFSMPDPNPiMJWSPwQBSBmOTEF JODJEODJBEB JNVOJEBEFDPOTUJUVDJPOBMQSFWJTUBOPBSU*7CJNQMJDBSJBVNBSFEVPTJHOJmDBUJWBOBSFDFJUBFTUBUBMUFOEPFNWJTUBRVFPTMJWSPTFMFUSOJDPTEFWFNTFQSPMJGFSBSDPNPBWBOPUFDOPMHJDPFBDPOTFRFOUFEJNJOVJPEPTTFVTDVTUPTEFBRVJTJPFQSPEVP"TTJNoDPOUJOVBSJBPBSHVNFOUPoJOUFSQSFUBSBJNVOJEBEFDPOTUJUVDJPOBMDPNPOPTFOEPBQMJDWFMBPTMJWSPTFMFUSOJDPTUSBSJBVNBHSBWFDPOTFRODJBRVBMTFKBBJNQPTTJCJMJEBEFEFP&TUBEPJODSFNFOUBSTVBSFDFJUBDPNBUSJCVUBPEFTUFQSPEVUP
&NCPSBOPOFHVFIBWFSFTQBPQBSBFTUFUJQPEFBSHVNFOUPOBKVTUJmDBPEFEFDJTFTKVEJDJBJTWJMBMIFBUSJCVJQFTPTVCTJEJSJPQPSTFSOPJOTUJUVDJPOBM"BOMJTFEBTDPOTFRODJBTFDPONJDBTPVTPDJBJTEFVNBEBEBJOUFSQSFUBPOPQPEFTFSSFDPOEV[JEBBPPSEFOBNFOUPKVSEJDPBPDPOUSSJPEBTDPOTJEFSBFTMJOHTUJDBTTJTUFNUJDBTFIJTUSJDBT0BSHVNFOUPOPUFNQPSCBTFJNFEJBUBGVOEBNFOUPTKVSEJDPTNBTTJNFDPONJDPT"TTJNQPSGPSBEBTFYJHODJBTEBTFQBSBPEFQPEFSFTFEPQSJODQJPEFNPDSUJDPFTUFFPVUSPTBSHVNFOUPTQSUJDPTOPQPEFSJBNPCSJHBSBEFDJTPEBNFTNBGPSNBRVFPTBSHVNFOUPTCBTFBEPTOPPSEFOBNFOUPKVSEJDPPCSJHBSJBNoQPJTBWJODVMBPCTJDBEPKVJ[DPNP
6),!(OPCITP
6),!(OPCITP
INTRODUO AO PENSAMENTO ESTRATGICO
22FGV DIREITO RIO
InTRODuO TEORIa Da DEcIsO
22FGV DIREITO RIO
INTRODUO TEORIA DA DECISO
'(7%*3&*503*0
EJSFJUPFOPDPNBFmDJODJBFDPONJDBDPNBFTUBCJMJEBEFQPMUJDBPVRVBMRVFSPVUSPFTUBEPEFDPJTBTEFTFKWFMTFHVOEPVNDSJUSJPEFEFWFSTFS
WJMBBQSFTFOUBBJOEBVNBPVUSBSB[PQBSBDPOGFSJSNFOPSQFTPBPTBSHVNFOUPTQSUJDPT0GBUPEFPTBSHVNFOUPTJOTUJUVDJPOBJTQPTTVSFNDPNPQPOUPEFSFGFSODJBPQSQSJPPSEFOBNFOUPKVSEJDPOPEFDJTJWPBQFOBTQPSGPSBEPQBQFMFTQFDm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mDWFM iBQJBNTFFYDMVTJWBNFOUFFNPQJOJFTTVCKFUJWBTFJOEJWJEVBJTDPOUSBQPOEPTFQPSUBOUPTFYJHODJBTEFSBDJPOBMJEBEFFEFEFUFSNJOBCJMJEBEFEBBSHVNFOUBPOTJUBTBPQSJODQJPEP&TUBEP%FNPDSUJDPEF%JSFJUPw1PSQSPNPWFSFNFNNFOPSNFEJEBPJEFBMEFSBDJPOBMJEBEFOBKVTUJmDBPEBTEFDJTFTKVEJDJBJTEFWFNQPTTVJSNFOPSQFTPOBBSHVNFOUBPKVSEJDB
"QBSUJSEBQJPOFJSB TJTUFNBUJ[BPEF)VNCFSUPWJMBQSFUFOEPNPTUSBSRVFPT BSHVNFOUPTiQSUJDPTwPViDPOTFRFODJBMJTUBTwQPEFNFNNVJUPTDBTPTTFSSFDPOEV[JEPTBPPSEFOBNFOUPKVSEJDPWJHFOUFJTUPOPTPOFDFTTBSJBNFOUFOPJOTUJUVDJPOBJTFDPOTFRFOUFNFOUFTFVQFTPRVFOPEFWFTFSBQSJPSJEFmOJEPDPNPTVCTJEJSJPKRVFQPEFNTFSEFDJTJWPTNFTNPFNDBTPTOPTRVBJTPTBSHVNFOUPTEFGVOEPMJOHTUJDPTJTUFNUJDPFIJTUSJDPBQPOUBNQBSBPNFTNPSFTVMUBEPOBJOUFSQSFUBPEFOPSNBTKVSEJDBT
"QPTTJCJMJEBEFEFSFDPOTUSVPEFBSHVNFOUPTDPOTFRFODJBMJTUBTJOTUJUVDJPOBJT
1BSBEFTFOWPMWFSBTRVFTUFTQSPQPTUBTHPTUBSJBQSPQPSBTFHVJOUFEFmOJPHFSBMEPRVFTFKBVNBSHVNFOUPKVSEJDPDPOTFRFODJBMJTUB1PEFNPTEFmOJMPDPNPTFOEPBRVFMFUJQPEFBSHVNFOUPRVFGPSOFDFSB[FTQBSBBUPNBEBEFVNBEFDJTPFTQFDmDBBQBSUJSEFVNBBWBMJBPEPTQPTTWFJTFGFJUPTEFTUBEFDJTP"TTJNQPEFTFFNQSFHMPQBSBKVTUJmDBSVNBEFDJTPDPNCBTFUBOUPOBTDPOTFRODJBTJOEFTFKWFJTPVEFTFKWFJTRVFBTVBiOPSFBMJ[BPwUFSJBPVQPEFSJBUFSRVBOUPOBTDPOTFRODJBTJOEFTFKWFJTPVEFTFKWFJTRVFBTVBFGFUJWBPUFSJBPVQPEFSJBUFS1BSUJOEPEFTUBEFmOJPBRVFTUPRVFTFDPMPDBEFUFSNJOBSTFDPNPBmSNBWJMBBSHVNFOUPTEPHOFSPiOPGB[FNSFGFSODJBBPTNPEPTJOTUJUVDJPOBJTEFFYJTUODJBEP%JSFJUPwPVTFBPDPOUSSJPQPEFNTFSSFDPOTUSVEPTEFNPEPBTFGVOEBNFOUBSFNFNQPOUPTEPPSEFOBNFOUPKVSEJDPPCKFUJWBNFOUFJEFOUJmDWFJT
"PCKFPEFRVFPTBSHVNFOUPTOPJOTUJUVDJPOBJTNPSBJTQPMUJDPTmMPTmDPTFFDPONJDPTTFHVOEPWJMBTPOFDFTTBSJBNFOUFJSSBDJPOBJTFOHBOPTB"DIBWFEFTFVBSHVNFOUPOPQPEFSFTJEJSOBBmSNBPEFVNBJSSBDJPOBMJEBEFJOUSOTFDBEFTUFTBSHVNFOUPToPRVFBMJTTFSJBEJGDJMEFTFSTVTUFOUBEPoNBTTJNOBJEJBEFRVFFMFTOPGPSOFDFNCBTFQBSB KVTUJmDBUJWBTBEFRVBEBTBP UJQPEF SBDJPOBMJEBEFRVF SFMFWBOUFQBSBPEJSFJUP0SFQEJPEFWJMBBPTBSHVNFOUPTiQSUJDPTwOPTFEFWFBVNBTVQPTUBJSSBDJPOBMJEBEFJOFSFOUFBUPEPFRVBMRVFSVTPRVFTFGBBEFMFT/BWFSEBEFTPDPOTJEFSBEPTJSSBDJPOBJTQPSRVFOPTFDPOTUJUVFNFNQPOUPTEFBQPJPPCKFUJWWFJTDVKBWBMJEBEFEFWBTFSSFDPOIFDJEBQFMPTQBSUJDJQBOUFTEBBSHVNFOUBP"TTJNQPSOPTFDPNQBUJCJMJ[BSFNDPNPUJQPEFKVTUJmDBPNBJTBEFRVBEBGVOPKVSJTEJDJPOBMUBJTBSHVNFOUPTTPTVCTJEJSJPT&TUBDPODFQPFTUJOUJNBNFOUFMJHBEBJEJBEFRVFPTBSHVNFOUPTiQSUJDPTwUNGVOEBNFOUPTOFDFTTBSJBNFOUFFYUSBKVSEJDPToPRVFSFDPOIFDJEPJODMVTJWFQPSNVJUPTEPTQSJODJQBJTEFGFOTPSFTEBDPOTJEFSBPEFDPOTFRODJBTOBEFDJTP
6ALENOTARQUECOMOJDEMONSTROU(ERBERT(ARTOSCRITRIOSDEDEVERSERPELOSQUAISAVALIAMOSO$IREITOEXISTENTENOSONECESSARIAMENTEMORAIS#Fh0OSITIVISMANDTHE3EPARATIONOF,AWAND-ORALSv/EXEMPLODOLIVROELETRNICOILUSTRACOMPRECISOESTEPONTOPOISOQUEESTEMJOGONOARGUMENTOPRTICOMENCIONADOPORVILAUMCRITRIOESSENCIALMENTEECONMICOO$IREITODEVERIASERINTERPRETADODEMODOAINCREMENTARARECEITAESTATAL
6),!(OPCITP
0RElROOTERMOhCONSEQUENCIALISTAvAOSTERMOShPRTICOvEhPRAGMTICOvnUTILIZADOSPOREXEMPLOPOR#HAM0ERELMANCFh/ARGUMENTOPRAGMTICOvREPRODUZIDONACOLETNEA2ETRICAS/ADJETIVOhPRTICOvPODEGERARCONFUSESPOISPOSSVELFORNECERARGUMENTOSPRTICOSNOCONSEQENCIALISTAS0ENSESEPOREXEMPLONADISCUSSOEMTORNODACONSTITUCIONALIDADEDOVALORDOSALRIOMNIMOENFRENTADAPELO3UPREMO4RIBUNAL&EDERALNA!$)N-#$&0ORUMLADOPOSSVELFORMULAROARGUMENTOPRTICOSEGUNDOOQUALSERIAIMPOSSVELDADASASCONDIESECONMICASDOPASESTABELECERUMSALRIOMNIMOCAPAZDEATENDERATODASASEXIGNCIASDO!RTO)6POROUTROSERIAIGUALMENTEPOSSVELFORNECERUMARGUMENTODIFERENTESEGUNDOOQUALAlXAODOSALRIOMNIMOEMUMVALORAPTOAATENDERSEXIGNCIASDO!RTOTERIACOMOCONSEQNCIAAQUEBRA3EACEITARMOSCOMOCORRETOSESSESUSOSDASPALAVRASEMJOGOPODESEDIZERQUEOCONJUNTODOSARGUMENTOShPRTICOSvOUhPRAGMTICOSvCONTMODOSARGUMENTOShCONSEQUENCIALISTASvMASQUENOSETRATAMDECONJUNTOSIDNTICOS!LMDISSOOTERMOhARGUMENTOPRTICOvTEMUMSIGNIlCADO
INTRODUO AO PENSAMENTO ESTRATGICO
23FGV DIREITO RIO
InTRODuO TEORIa Da DEcIsO
23FGV DIREITO RIO
INTRODUO TEORIA DA DECISO
'(7%*3&*503*0
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mDJUEFJOGPSNBPEFNPEPRVFQSFGFSWFMEFJYBSBEFDJTPQBSBVNNPNFOUPQPTUFSJPSPVBJOEBKVMHMBEFGPSNBNJOJNBMJTUBoJTUPOPTFBQSPGVOEBOEPOPTEFCBUFTKVSEJDPTBMNEPOFDFTTSJPSFTPMVPEPDBTPFEFDJEJOEPEFGPSNBBNBJTGPDBEBOPDBTPQPTTWFMEJNJOVJOEPBTTJNPTDVTUPTQBSBBSFWFSTPEFVNBEFDJTPRVFTFNPTUSFFRVJWPDBEBOPGVUVSP0JOUFSFTTBOUFRVFTFHVOEP4VOTUFJOPTKV[FTEB4VQSFNB$PSUFMFWBNFNDPOUBBTDPOTFRODJBTEBEFDJTPNFTNPRVBOEPUNDFSUF[BEFRVFBTVBSFTQPTUBQBSBPQSPCMFNBDPOTUJUVDJPOBMFNKPHPFTUDPSSFUB
i0GDPVSTFUIF$PVSUTSFTPMVUJPONBZCFSJHIUJOUIFTFOTFUIBUUIF$PVSUJEFOUJmFTUIFKVTUSFTVMU#VUFWFOJGJUJTSJHIUUIJOHTNBZHPCBEMZXSPOHF$PVSUNBZOPUQSPEVDFBQQSPQSJBUFTPDJBMSFGPSNFWFOJGJUTFFLTUPEPTPFSFNBZCFVOJOUFOEFEBEWFSTFDPOTFRVFODFTF$PVSUTEFDJTJPONBZBDUJWBUFPQQPTJOHGPSDFTBOEEFNPCJMJ[FUIFQPMJUJDBMBDUPSTJUGBWPST*UNBZQSPEVDFJOUFOTFTPDJBMCBDLMBTIJOUIFQSPDFTTPGEFMFHJUJNBUJOHJUTFMGBTXFMMBTUIFHPBMJUTFFLTUPQSPNPUFw
.FTNPRVBOEPQBSFDFOPIBWFSEWJEBBDFSDBEB JOUFSQSFUBPDPSSFUBFDPOTFRFOUFNFOUFEBTPMVPDPOTUJUVDJPOBMBEFRVBEBQBSBPDBTPQPEFTFSNFMIPSQBSBBTPDJFEBEFoQPSNPUJWPTJOEFQFOEFOUFTEBCVTDBQFMBTPMVPKVSEJDBQBSBPDBTPoRVFiBTDPJTBTTFKBNEFJYBEBTFNBCFSUPwQBSBVTBSBFYQSFTTPEF4VOTUFJO6NKV[PFNJOFOUFNFOUFQPMUJDP0MFJUPSOPUFSQSPCMFNBTFNBDFJUBSBRVBMJmDBPEFUBJTDPOTJEFSBFTDPNPFYUSBKVSEJDBTEJ[FNSFTQFJUPTSFTQPOTBCJMJEBEFTEB4VQSFNB$PSUFOPTJTUFNBEFHPWFSOPOPSUFBNFSJDBOPNBTOPBGFUBNBJOUFSQSFUBPFNTJEBTOPSNBTKVSEJDBT"SHVNFOUPTKVSEJDPTQPEFNMFWBSEFDJTPDPSSFUBFNNVJUPTDBTPTNBTNFTNPOFTTFTDBTPTBSHVNFOUPTFYUSBKVSEJDPTDPOTFRFODJBMJTUBTQPEFNKVTUJmDBSVNBOPEFDJTP
/P#SBTJMBQFTBSEFPTUSJCVOBJTTVQFSJPSFTOPQPTTVSFNBMJCFSEBEFFYQMDJUBEFEFDJEJSOPEFDJEJSPFNQSFHPEBTDPOTFRODJBTEBEFDJTPDPNPBMHPFYUFSOPJOUFSQSFUBPEBTOPSNBTFOWPMWJEBTFODPOUSBBNQMPFTQBPOBBQSFDJBPQPSQBSUFEPT5SJCVOBJT4VQFSJPSFTEFQFEJEPTEFDPODFTTPEF MJNJOBSFT FNDBTPTEFDPOnJUPTEFNBTTB/FTTFTFOUJEPP4VQFSJPS5SJCVOBMEF+VTUJBUFNDBTTBEPEF[FOBTEFMJNJOBSFTDPODFEJEBTQBSBBTTFHVSBSBFOUJEBEFTQSFTUBEPSBTEFTFSWJPOBSFBEBTBEFPEJSFJUPEFSFBKVTUBSPTWBMPSFTEBUBCFMBEP4JTUFNBOJDPEF4BEF/PTUFSNPTEP"HSBWP3FHJNFOUBMOB4VTQFOTPEF5VUFMB"OUFDJQBEB13
1SPDFTTVBMDJWJM4VTQFOTPEFUVUFMBBOUFDJQBEB3FBKVTUFEBUBCFMBEP4JTUFNBOJDPEF4BEF464-FTPTBEFFFDPOPNJBQCMJDPT*"$PSUF&TQFDJBMmSNPVP FOUFOEJNFOUP EF RVF BT JONFSBT BFT QSPQPTUBT DPNP JOUVJUP EF TFSFBKVTUBSBUBCFMBEP464UNQPUFODJBMTVmDJFOUFQBSBDBVTBSMFTPTBEFQCMJDBWJTUPRVFEFWFNTFSBQSFDJBEBTFNDPOKVOUPFOPFNDBEBDBTPQBSUJDVMBS**"QSPMJGFSBPEFBFTJEOUJDBTUFNQPUFODJBMTVmDJFOUFQBSBDBVTBSMFTPTBEFQCMJDBQPSRVBOUPPTSFDVSTPTPSBNFOUSJPTEFTUJOBEPTBPBUFOEJNFOUPEFUPEPPTJTUFNBQCMJDPTFSPEFTWJBEPTQBSBPBUFOEJNFOUPEFJOUFSFTTFEFQBSUJDVMBSFT***"HSBWPSFHJNFOUBMEFTQSPWJEP
PRPRIONATRADIOlLOSlCAESPECIALMENTEAPARTIRDOPENSAMENTOARISTOTLICO/PONDOSEAOShARGUMENTOSTERICOSvQUETMPORlNALIDADELEVAROAUDITRIOAACEITARAVERDADEOUFALSIDADEDEALGUMAPROPOSIOOShARGUMENTOSPRTICOSvVISAMAFAZERCOMQUEOAUDITRIOPRATIQUEOUSEABSTENHADEALGUMAAO.ESSESENTIDOTODOARGUMENTOUTILIZADOCOMVISTASACONDUZIRADECISOJUDICIALAUMADETERMINADADIREOhPRTICOv!GRADEOA.OEL3TRUCHINERPORTERMECHAMADOAATENOPARAESSEPONTO
#!,6/2#6%2.)%2#OPCITP
3USTENTARATESEDEQUEARGUMENTOSECONMICOSOUMORAISSOINTRINSECAMENTEIRRACIONAISUMEMPREENDIMENTODIFCILDADAALONGATRADIODEREmEXOSOBREMODELOSDEDECISORACIONALOUhCORRETAvTANTONOMBITOMORALQUANTONOECONMICO%SPECIlCAMENTENOPENSAMENTOECONMICOOPROBLEMADARACIONALIDADEDEPROCESSOSDECISRIOSVEMSENDOTRABALHADOCOMMUITOMAISSOlSTICAODOQUENOMBITOJUDICIAL#FATTULODEEXEMPLIlCAOASQUESTESEDEBATESABORDADOSPOR!MARTYA3ENEM3OBRETICAE%CONOMIAEh4HE$ISCIPLINEOF#OST"ENElT!NALYSISv
35.34%).#/NE#ASEATA4IME*UDICIAL-INIMALISMONTHE3UPREME#OURTPh!CLUETOUNDERSTANDINGMINIMALISMISTORECOGNIZETHATINDECIDINGCONSTITUTIONALCASESJUDGESOFTENLACKRELEVANTINFORMATIONANDTHEIRRULINGSMIGHTHAVEUNINTENDEDCONSEQUENCESv
./7!+*%2/45.$!2$#ONSTITUTIONAL,AW3T0AUL-INNESOTTA7EST0UBLISHING#O0
INTRODUO AO PENSAMENTO ESTRATGICO
24FGV DIREITO RIO
InTRODuO TEORIa Da DEcIsO
24FGV DIREITO RIO
INTRODUO TEORIA DA DECISO
'(7%*3&*503*0
"TTJNOFTTFDBTPBTDPOTFRODJBTEFVNBQPTTWFMEFDJTPQFMBNBOVUFOPEBMJNJOBSTFSJBNESTUJDBTUFOEPFNWJTUBBQSPMJGFSBPDBUJDBEFDBTPT JEOUJDPTRVFDFSUBNFOUFPDPSSFSJBTFP45+OPJNQFEJTTFPSFBKVTUFGFJUPQPSDBEBJOTUJUVJP&NJONFSBTEFDJTFTNPOPDSUJDBTQPTUFSJPSFTPT.JOJTUSPTEP45+VUJMJ[BSBNFTTFBSHVNFOUPQBSBTVTQFOEFSMJNJOBSFTFBHVBSEBSPNPNFOUPEFBQSFDJBSPTDBTPTiFNTVBUPUBMJEBEFw
&NMJOIBTJNJMBSP1SFTJEFOUFEP4VQSFNP5SJCVOBM'FEFSBM.JOJTUSP/FMTPO+PCJNUFNTJTUFNBUJDBNFOUFWBMPSJ[BEPFNEFDMBSBFTQCMJDBTFFNTFVTWPUPTPQFTPEBTDPOTFRODJBToTPCSFUVEPFDPONJDBToOBTEFDJTFTKVEJDJBJT.BTIVNBEJGFSFOBJNQPSUBOUFBRVJ1BSB+PCJNFNCPSBiPJNQPSUBOUFTFKBBDPOTFRODJBwBDPOTJEFSBPEFDPOTFRODJBTUFNDBSUFSTVCTJEJSJPKRVFTFOUSBSJBFNDFOBRVBOEPIPVWFTTFEVBTPVNBJTJOUFSQSFUBFTJHVBMNFOUFQPTTWFJTEFVNBOPSNBKVSEJDBFNVNEFUFSNJOBEPDBTP&TTBBmSNBUJWBOPQBSFDFJODPNQBUWFMDPNBIJFSBSRVJBQSPQPTUBQPS)VNCFSUPWJMB"NCPTDPNQBSUJMIBNVNSFMBUJWPDPOTFOTPFNUPSOPEBJEJBEFRVFPKVJ[FYFSDFOEPVNQBQFMEJGFSFOUFFNBTQFDUPTSFMFWBOUFTEPQBQFMEP MFHJTMBEPSPVEPBENJOJTUSBEPSBJOEBRVFFTUFDPOTFOTPOPTFFTUFOEBBPTGVOEBNFOUPTEFTUBJEJBEFWJODVMBPKVEJDJBMBPPSEFOBNFOUPKVSEJDP
"TTJNPMVHBSRVFPTBSHVNFOUPTDPOTFRFODJBMJTUBTPDVQBNOPQFOTBNFOUPEFWJMBFOBGBMBEPQSQSJP+PCJNQBSFDFTFSDMBSPFMFTFOUSBNFNDFOBRVBOEPBEJTDVTTPiFTUSJUBNFOUFKVSEJDBwKTFFTHPUPVTFNRVFUFOIBTJEPQPTTWFMBUJOHJSVNBSFTQPTUBBEFRVBEBPVEFUFSNJOBSVNDSJUSJPQBSBFTDPMIFSEFOUSFEJWFSTBTSFTQPTUBTJHVBMNFOUFQMBVTWFJT)OFTTBTQFSTQFDUJWBTVNBOUJEBQSFPDVQBPFNNBOUFSBGPSBOPSNBUJWBEBJEJBEF&TUBEPEF%JSFJUPFEFWJODVMBPTEFDJTFTUPNBEBTQFMPTQPEFSFTFMFJUPT$POUVEPBQFTBSEFBEFRVBEBBPPSEFOBNFOUPKVSEJDPCSBTJMFJSPBIJFSBSRVJ[BPEFWJMBOPFYQMJDBDFSUPTVTPTEFSBDJPDOJPTDPOTFRFODJBMJTUBTOBKVSJTQSVEODJBOBDJPOBM
/PKVMHBNFOUPEB"%*%'P4VQSFNP5SJCVOBM'FEFSBMEFDJEJVRVFPBSUJHPEB&NFOEB$POTUJUVDJPOBMOEFWFSJBTFSJOUFSQSFUBEPDPOGPSNFB$POTUJUVJPEFNPEPBFYDMVJSEPTFVNCJUPEFJODJEODJBPTBMSJPEBMJDFOBHFTUBOUFQSFWJTUBOPBSUJHPP97***0QSJODJQBMBSHVNFOUPTFSJBPEFRVFBBQMJDBPEPEJTQPTJUJWPBFTTBTIJQUFTFTMFWBSJBBVNBNBJPSEJTDSJNJOBPEBNVMIFSOPNFSDBEPEFUSBCBMIP0BSUJHPRVFTUJPOBEPFTUBCFMFDJBRVFiP MJNJUFNYJNPQBSBPWBMPSEPTCFOFGDJPTEPSFHJNFHFSBMEFQSFWJEODJBTPDJBM EF RVF USBUB P BSU EB $POTUJUVJP mYBEP FN 3 w 4FHVOEP P15#BVUPSEB"%*OBQMJDBSFTUFEJTQPTJUJWPBPCFOFGDJPEBMJDFOBNBUFSOJEBEFMFWBSJBWJPMBPEPTBSUJHPTP*7QSPNPPEPCFNEFUPEPTFP*JHVBMEBEFEFIPNFOTFNVMIFSFTFNEJSFJUPTFPCSJHBFT0DPOnJUPBRVJOPFSBJNFEJBUPQFSDFQUWFMFNUFTFNBTBQFOBTOPMPOHPQSB[P4FPTFNQSFHBEPSFTGPTTFNPCSJHBEPTBBSDBSDPNPWBMPSEPTBMSJPEBHFTUBOUFMJDFODJBEBBQSQSJB$POTUJUVJPFTUBSJBMIFTEBOEPVNJODFOUJWPQBSBOPDPOUSBUBSNVMIFSFTFNJEBEFGSUJM1PSVOBOJNJEBEFP4VQSFNPDPODPSEPVDPNPTBSHVNFOUPTEP15#FEFDJEJVQFMBOPBQMJDBPEPBSUJHP FNRVFTUP BPCFOFGDJPEBMJDFOBNBUFSOJEBEF$PNPBmSNPVP3FMBUPSOPBDSEP.JOJTUSP4ZEOFJ4BODIFT
i/BWFSEBEFTFTFFOUFOEFSRVFB1SFWJEODJB4PDJBMEPSBWBOUFSFTQPOEFSQPSBQFOBT3QPSNTEVSBOUFBMJDFOBEBHFTUBOUFFRVFPFNQSFHBEPSSFTQPOEFSTP[JOIP QFMP SFTUBOUF mDBS TPCSFNBOFJSB GBDJMJUBEB F FTUJNVMBEB B PQP EFTUF QFMPUSBCBMIBEPSNBTDVMJOPBP JOWTEBNVMIFS USBCBMIBEPSB&TUBS FOUPQSPQJDJBEBBEJTDSJNJOBPRVFB$POTUJUVJPCVTDPVDPNCBUFSRVBOEPQSPJCJVEJGFSFOBEFTBMSJPTEFFYFSDDJPEFGVOFTFEFDSJUSJPTEFBENJTTPQPSNPUJWPEFTFYPBSUP999
QSPJCJPRVFFNTVCTUODJBVNEFTEPCSBNFOUPEPQSJODQJPEBJHVBMEBEFEFEJSFJUPTQSFWJTUPOPJODJTP*EPBSUPEB$POTUJUVJP'FEFSBM/PDSWFMRVFPDPOTUJUVJOUFEFSJWBEPEF UFOIBDIFHBEPB FTTFQPOUPOB DIBNBEB3FGPSNBEB1SFWJEODJBTPDJBMEFTBUFOUPBUBJTDPOTFRODJBTw
!G2GNA34!02#ORTE%SPECIAL2ELPARAOACRDO-IN!NTNIODE0DUA2IBEIRO$*
#FPOREXEMPLOOENTENDIMENTODA#ORTE%SPECIALNAS3USPENSESDE3EGURANANS022302E026ALEOBSERVARQUEADECISOJUDICIALNA3USPENSODE3EGURANAEXPLICITAMENTEPAUTADAPORUMJUZODECONVENINCIAEOPORTUNIDADEOQUEPERMITEAAPROXIMAOCOMOARGUMENTODE3UNSTEINACIMADESCRITO.ASPALAVRASDO-INISTRO%DSON6IDIGALEMDECISOMONOCRTICANA3USPENSODE,IMINARE3ENTENA3,3Nn-'h;A=IMPORTNCIADOINSTITUTODOPEDIDODESUSPENSONOORDENAMENTOJURDICOPTRIOESTEMSERINSTRUMENTOGILEElCAZPARAEVITARLESESORDEMSADESEGURANAEECONOMIAPBLICAS0ATENTEAPOSSIBILIDADEDESECAUSARUMAGRAVEAFRONTAAOINTERESSEPBLICOCUMPREO0RESIDENTEDO4RIBUNALDEFERIRASUSPENSOREQUERIDA.ASUSPENSONOSEEXAMINAOMRITODACAUSAQUEDEVESERANALISADONASVIASORDINRIASNEMSEQUESTIONAAJURIDICIDADEDAMEDIDAATACADAMASCOMDISCRICIONARIEDADEPRPRIADEJUZODECONVENINCIAEOPORTUNIDADEQUEA0RESIDNCIAAVALIAOPEDIDODESUSPENSOv$*/USEJAASSIMCOMOOCORRECOMA3UPREMA#ORTE!MERICANANESSESCASOSO34*LEVAEMCONTAASCONSEQNCIASNOPARADECIDIROMRITODAQUESTOMASPARASABERSECONVENIENTEDEIXARADECISOPARAMAISTARDE
4RECHOSEXTRADOSRESPECTIVAMENTEDE*/")-.h$ISCURSODEPOSSENO4RIBUNAL3UPERIOR%LEITORALv*/")-.%NTREVISTAAOJORNAL6ALOR%CONMICOEM!EVENTUALDESOBEDINCIADO-INISTRO.ELSON*OBIMEMSEUSVOTOSNO34&STESESENUNCIADAS
INTRODUO AO PENSAMENTO ESTRATGICO
25FGV DIREITO RIO
InTRODuO TEORIa Da DEcIsO
25FGV DIREITO RIO
INTRODUO TEORIA DA DECISO
'(7%*3&*503*0
/FTUFDBTPBJODPOTUJUVDJPOBMJEBEFEBOPSNBTQPEFTFSDPNQSFFOEJEBBQBSUJSEPBSHVNFOUPDPOTFRFODJBMJTUBFTHSJNJEPQFMP15#FBDPMIJEPQFMP45'FNCPSBQSJNFJSBWJTUBB&$QBSFBHBSBOUJSVNEJSFJUPEBNVMIFSOPMPOHPQSB[PPTFVJNQBDUPOBSFBMJEBEFEJmDVMUBSBJOTFSPEBTNVMIFSFTGSUFJTOPNFSDBEPEFUSBCBMIP&NPVUSBTQBMBWSBTBDPOTFRODJBEBFYJTUODJBEBOPSNBRVFBUPSOBJODPOTUJUVDJPOBMNFTNPRVFPTFVUFYUPPVBTVBDPOFYPEFTFOUJEPTFKBNDPNQBUWFJTDPNPSFTUPEB$POTUJUVJP0RVFQBSFDFmDBSFYQMDJUPOFTTFDBTPVNBNBOFJSBFTQFDmDBEFDVNQSJSPEFWFSEFmEFMJEBEFTOPSNBTKVSEJDBTFOWPMWJEBTDFSUPRVFDPOTJEFSBEBFNTJBQSFWJTPEB&$RVFPOFSBWBPTFNQSFHBEPSFTFNDBTPTEFMJDFOBNBUFSOJEBEFOPWJPMBWBPBSUP*QPEFSBNPTEJ[FSFTUBNFEJEBSFTQFJUBWBPVIPOSBWBBJHVBMEBEFFOUSFIPNFOTFNVMIFSFTJTUPOPFTUBCFMFDJBEFNPEPJNFEJBUPDPOEVUBTEJTDSJNJOBUSJBT.BTJHVBMNFOUFDFSUPRVFTFMFWBSNPTFNDPOTJEFSBPPFTUBEPEFDPJTBTHFSBEPQFMBBQMJDBPEBOPSNBFNRVFTUPB&$QSPNPWJBVNFTUBEPEFDPJTBTDPOUSSJPBPFYJHJEPQFMBJHVBMEBEFFOUSFIPNFOTFNVMIFSFT
"EJTUJOPFOUSFIPOSBSPVSFTQFJUBSVNWBMPSFQSPNPWFSVNWBMPSBSUJDVMBEBQPS1IJMJQ1FUUJUOPDBNQPEBNPSBMJEBEFUJMQBSBDPNQSFFOEFSDPNPPSBDJPDOJPDPOTFRFODJBMJTUBQPEFTFSDPNQSFFOEJEPDPNPVNBNBOFJSBFTQFDmDBEFPCFEFDFSTOPSNBTKVSEJDBT4FHVOEP1FUUJUTFFVEFUFSNJOBSRVFPWBMPSNBJTJNQPSUBOUFEBWJEBIVNBOBBMFBMEBEFQBSBDPNBGBNMJBQPTTPNFQFSHVOUBSEFWPEFEJDBSUPEPPNFVUFNQPEJTQPOWFMBFTUBSDPNNFVTGBNJMJBSFTIPOSBOEPBTTJNBMFBMEBEFRVFUBOUPQSF[PPVEFWPEFJYBSBNJOIBQSQSJB GBNMJBEF MBEP F JOWFTUJSNFVT FTGPSPTOB UFOUBUJWBEF DPOTDJFOUJ[BS BTQFTTPBTQBSBRVFQBTTFNNBJTUFNQPDPNTVBTQSQSJBTGBNMJBTQSPNPWFOEPPWBMPSEBMFBMEBEFGBNJMJBS 2VBMBNBOFJSBNBJTDPSSFUBEFSFTQPOEFSBPWBMPSRVFDPOTJEFSPGVOEBNFOUBMoIPOSMPPVQSPNPWMP
0TNFTNPTQSPCMFNBT TVSHFNOBFTGFSBEBTEFDJTFT JOTUJUVDJPOBJToPRVF JODMVJ BTEFDJTFTKVEJDJBJTFTQFDJBMNFOUFEPTUSJCVOBJTTVQFSJPSFT"4VQSFNB$PSUFEPT&6"QPSFYFNQMPFTUJNFSTBFNVNBGPSUFUSBEJPEFWBMPSJ[BPEBMJCFSEBEFEFFYQSFTTP/PIEWJEBEFRVFBTJOTUJUVJFTKVEJDJBJTEPT&6"EFWFNSFTQPOEFSEFBMHVNBGPSNBBFTTFWBMPS.BTBQFSHVOUBEF1FUUJUQFSNBOFDFEFWPQSPDVSBSIPOSBSBMJCFSEBEFEFFYQSFTTPPVNFFTGPSBSQBSBQSPNPWMBBJOEBRVFJTTPJNQMJRVFWJPMMBOPDVSUPQSB[PFNVNKVMHBNFOUPFTQFDm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iNFSDBEPEFJEJBTwEFJYBFNBCFSUPBQPTTJCJMJEBEFEFRVFBMJWSFFYQSFTTPEFVNBQPTJPQPMUJDBJOUPMFSBOUFDPOEV[BFYDMVTPEFPVUSBTQPTJFT
"OBMJTBOEPBTEPVUSJOBTKVEJDJBJTEFBQMJDBPEBB&NFOEBOPT&6"3PCFSU/BHFMPCTFSWBRVFFNNVJUPTDBTPTBDPOFYPFOUSFBQSPUFPEBMJCFSEBEFEFFYQSFTTPFNEFDJTFTTJOHVMBSFTFBiQSPNPPTJTUNJDBwEBMJCFSEBEFEFFYQSFTTPQSPCMFNUJDB6NBEFDJTPKVEJDJBMRVFPCSJHVFVNBDPNVOJEBEFKVEBJDBBUPMFSBSBQBTTBHFNEFVNBQBTTFBUBOB[JTUBoDPNPPDPSSFVOPDBTP7JMMBHFPG4LPLJFWT/BUJPOBM4PDJBMJTU1BSUZPG"NoQPEFHFSBSTFOUJNFOUPTEFEJPFGSVTUSBPUPJOUFOTPTRVFTPCSFQVKBSPRVBMRVFS JODFOUJWPRVFPTNFNCSPTEBDPNVOJEBEFUFSJBNQBSBUPMFSBSFTQPOUBOFBNFOUFPQJOJFTDPOUSSJBT
NESTAENTREVISTANOINVALIDAOMEUPONTO!POSSIBILIDADEDEELESERINCOERENTENOTORNAMENOSPLAUSVELMEUARGUMENTODEQUEELEAlRMACONCORDARCOMUMAVINCULAODOJUIZLEIAINDAQUEMNIMA
3EGUNDOVILAh;O=SARGUMENTOSTRANSCENDENTESAOORDENAMENTOJURDICOPASSAMASERRELEVANTESNAINTERPRETAONOMOMENTOEMQUEALINGUAGEMEOSISTEMAJNOPROPORCIONAMUMAJUSTIlCAOPARAAINTERPRETAO3EOINTRPRETECONSEGUECONSTRUIRUMSIGNIlCADODEACORDOCOMARGUMENTOSLINGSTICOSESISTEMTICOSNOHRAZOSUlCIENTEPARAORECURSOAOUTROSARGUMENTOSv6),!(UMBERTOOPCITPG!RIGORVILANOAlRMAQUEOSARGUMENTOSNOLINGSTICOSENOSISTEMTICOSSOEXTRAJURDICOSMASSIMQUETMMENOREMBASAMENTONOORDENAMENTOJURDICO!INDAASSIMAAPROXIMAOCOMAPOSIODE.ELSON*OBIMVLIDANAMEDIDAEMQUEPARAAMBOSACONSIDERAODECONSEQNCIASENTRACOMOUMhCRITRIODEDESEMPATEvNOMOMENTODATOMADADEDECISO
!$)N$&2EL-IN3YDNEI3ANCHES*ULGADAPELO4RIBUNAL0LENOEM$*
!EVENTUALADOODEUMASEPARAORGIDAENTREhVALORESvEhPRINCPIOSvAQUELESOPERANDONALGICADAPREFERNCIAEDAGRADUABILIDADEESTESNADAOBEDINCIAESTRITAnESPECIALMENTENAVERSODEFENDIDAPOR*RGEN(ABERMAS#F"ETWEENFACTSANDNORMSCONTRIBUTIONSTOADISCOURSETHEORYOFLAWANDDEMOCRACYNOPREJUDICAARELAOPROPOSTAENTREATEORIACONSEQENCIALISTADE0ETTITEAARGUMENTAOJURDICA#OMOSEDESENVOLVERADIANTECERTASNORMASPODEMSERINTERPRETADAS
INTRODUO AO PENSAMENTO ESTRATGICO
26FGV DIREITO RIO
InTRODuO TEORIa Da DEcIsO
26FGV DIREITO RIO
INTRODUO TEORIA DA DECISO
'(7%*3&*503*0
TTVBT0FTUBEPEFDPJTBTQSPEV[JEPQFMBEFDJTPBDBCBTFOEPEFTGBWPSWFMBPFYFSDDJPEPEJSFJUPEFMJCFSEBEFEFFYQSFTTPRVFPBQMJDBEPSEP%JSFJUPWJTBWBBQSPUFHFS
"TTJNEFUFSNJOBSBiBPDPSSFUBwFNSFMBPBVNNFTNPWBMPSOPTMFWBOFDFTTBSJBNFOUFBVNBCJGVSDBPOFNTFNQSFIPOSMPFNNJOIBTBFTBRVJFBHPSBTFSBNFMIPSNBOFJSBEFQSPNPWMPOPMPOHPQSB[P.BTQPSRVFFTTBTDPOTJEFSBFTTFSJBNBQMJDWFJT BSHVNFOUBP KVSEJDB FNBJT FTQFDJmDBNFOUF BSHVNFOUBP KVSEJDB RVF PDPSSF BQBSUJSEPPSEFOBNFOUPKVSEJDPCSBTJMFJSP $PNPKPCTFSWBEPPTBSHVNFOUPTCBTFBEPTOBTDPOTFRODJBTEBEFDJTPTPFODBSBEPTQPSWJMBDPNPVNTVCTJEJSJPOBJOUFSQSFUBPEFOPSNBTKVSEJDBTBJOEBRVFQPTTJWFMNFOUFSFMFWBOUFOBNFEJEBFNRVFiOFNNFTNPJOEJSFUBNFOUFGB[FNSFGFSODJBGPSBWJODVMBUJWBEP1PEFS-FHJTMBUJWPFMFTOPTFEFJYBNSFDPOEV[JSQPSDPOTFRODJBBPTQSJODQJPTJNBOFOUFTBP&TUBEP%FNPDSUJDPEF%JSFJUPw$PNPKEJTDVUJEPWJMBFODBSBBTDPOTFRODJBTDPNPFYUFSOBTTOPSNBTRVFFNMUJNBJOTUODJBSFQSFTFOUBNPTEFWFSFTCTJDPTEPKVJ[QBSBDPNBTPDJFEBEFFNHFSBM
&TTBQFSTQFDUJWBFODPOUSBFDPOPNCJUPEBUJDBOPSNBUJWBPOEFCBTUBOUFGSFRFOUFPSFDVSTPEJTUJOPFOUSFPRVFDFSUPFPRVFCPN"TDPOEVUBTDFSUBTTPBRVFMBTNPSBMNFOUFEFWJEBTFPVFYJHWFJT$POEVUBTCPBTTPBRVFMBTEFTFKWFJTTPCEFUFSNJOBEPDSJUSJPEFiCPOEBEFw%FQFOEFOEPEBDPODFQPUJDBOPSNBUJWBRVFTFBEPUFQPEFTFEFmOJSPRVFDFSUPFNGVOPEPRVFDPOTJEFSBEPCPNQPSVNDSJUSJPRVBMRVFSDPNPGB[FNPVUJMJUBSJTNPFBTUFPSJBTiUFMFPMHJDBTwFNHFSBM
PVQPSPVUSPMBEPEFmOJSBDPSSFPEFVNBDPOEVUBDPNPJOEFQFOEFOUFEPTSFTVMUBEPTCPOTRVFQSPEV[BPVEBTCPBTNPUJWBFTRVFBHFSBSBNUFPSJBTiEFPOUPMHJDBTw
"QBSUJSEBEBEFiDFSUPCPNwQPEFSBNPTSFDPOTUSVJSBBSHVNFOUBPEFWJMBEBTFHVJOUFNBOFJSB&NVNSFHJNFEFTFQBSBPEFQPEFSFTPKVJ[UFNPEFWFSEFPCFEFDFSTEFDJTFTEPMFHJTMBEPSDVKBTEFDJTFTDPOTUJUVFNPPSEFOBNFOUPKVSEJDP-PHPPKVJ[UFNPEFWFSEFPCFEFDFSBPPSEFOBNFOUPKVSEJDP"JOEBRVFFYJTUBNGPSNBTEJTUJOUBTEFPCFEFDMPOBUPNBEBEFVNBEFDJTPKVEJDJBMFYJTUFNJONFSBTPVUSBTNBOFJSBTEFEFTPCFEFDMPFBMJOIBFOUSFFTUFTEPJTHSVQPTQPEFTFSUSBBEBDPNOJUJEF[&NVNOWFMNBJTBNQMPQPEFTFGBMBSOBiPCFEJODJBBPPSEFOBNFOUPwEFGPSNBCJOSJBPVTFPCFEFDFBP%JSFJUPPVOPTFPCFEFDFBP%JSFJUP6NBEFDJTPRVFOPQPTTBTFSSFDPOEV[JEBBPPSEFOBNFOUPKVSEJDPEFBMHVNBGPSNBOPIPOSBFTUFEFWFSEFPCFEJODJBQPSNBJTWBMJPTBRVFFTTBEFDJTPQPTTBTFSEPQPOUPEFWJTUBFDPONJDPQPMUJDPmMPTmDPTPDJBMFUD"TTJNPEFWFSEFPCFEJODJBBPPSEFOBNFOUPKVSEJDPEFmOJEPEFGPSNBJOEFQFOEFOUFEPWBMPSRVFVNBEFDJTPPVPVUSBQPTTBUFSTPCQPOUPTEFWJTUBOPKVSEJDPT0GVOEBNFOUPEBBUSJCVJPEFDBSUFSTVCTJEJSJP BPT BSHVNFOUPT DPOTFRFODJBMJTUBTOPPVUSB DPJTB TFOPB BEPPEFVNBFYJHODJBGPSUFEFPCFEJODJBTEFDJTFTJOTUJUVDJPOBJTRVFGPSNBNP%JSFJUPWJHFOUF
$POUVEP TFBEPUBSNPTBOPPEFRVFBPCFEJODJBBVNBOPSNB KVSEJDBQPEFTFSFOUFOEJEBDPNPBQSPNPPEPTWBMPSFTRVFWJTBBUVUFMBSPDBSUFSiCJOSJPwEBBQMJDBPEPEJSFJUPQBSFDFSJOBEFRVBEPDPNQSPNFUFOEPBQSQSJBJEJBEFiPCFEJODJBwRVFPTVTUFOUB7FKBNPT6NBEBTGPOUFTEFGPSBKVTUJmDBUJWBEPTBSHVNFOUPTKVSEJDPTPTFVNBJPSPVNFOPSFNCBTBNFOUPFNWBMPSFTDPOTUJUVDJPOBMNFOUFDPOTUJUVEPT&TUFTWBMPSFTTPUVUFMBEPTQPSNFJPEBTOPSNBTDPOTUJUVDJPOBJTRVFNVJUBTWF[FTFTUBCFMFDFNEJSFUBNFOUFRVBJTDPOEVUBTEFWFNTFSBEPUBEBT.BTOFNUPEBTBTOPSNBTKVSEJDBTJOTUJUVFNEFGPSNBJNFEJBUBBPCSJHBUPSJFEBEFEFVNDVSTPEFBP&NNVJUPTDBTPTPRVFPBQMJDBEPSEPEJSFJUPUFNEJBOUFEFTJVNDPNBOEPRVFUPSOBPCSJHBUSJBBDPOTFDVPEFVNFTUBEPEFDPJTBTEFUFSNJOBEPTFOEPPCSJHBUSJBTBTDPOEVUBTJOEFUFSNJOBEBTRVFMFWFNBFTUFFTUBEPEFDPJTBTFWFEBEBTBRVFMBTRVFPJNQFBNEFTFSBUJOHJEP&TTBDPOTUBUBPFTQFDJBMNFOUFWFSEBEFJSBRVBOEPTFQSFDJTBBQMJDBSOPSNBTRVFOPEFTDSFWFNEFGPSNBJNFEJBUBRVBJTDPOEVUBTEFWFNTFSUPNBEBTNBTTJNPFTUBEPEFDPJTBTBTFSQSPNPWJEPPDBTPEBTOPSNBTEFFTUSVUVSBQSJODJQJPMHJDB0TQSJODQJPTEFUFSNJOBNVNFTUBEPJEFBMEFDPJTBTTFOEPBDPOUSJCVJPPVOPEFVNBDPOEVUBQBSBFTTFFTUBEPJEFBMEFDPJTBTPQSJODJQBMDSJUSJP
COMOSEDESCREVESSEMESTADOSDECOISASQUEDEVEMSERATINGIDOS.ASUAAPLICAOAPROMOODOESTADOFTICODECOISASSERPASSVELDEGRADUAOSEMQUEAOBEDINCIANORMASEJANECESSARIAMENTEAFETADAEMSUALGICABINRIA
0%44)40h#ONSEQUENTIALISMvP#FTAMBM0%44)403-)4(-h'LOBAL#ONSEQUENTIALISMv
53
.!'%,2#ONSTITUTIONAL#ULTURESPP/AUTOROBSERVAPORMQUEUMAPROTEOJUDICIALDALIBERDADEDEEXPRESSOPODESERhMODESTAMENTEJUSTIlCADAvCOMBASENAIDIADEQUEOSTRIBUNAISTMODEVERDEAPLICARAA%MENDAAFASTANDOASSIMVIOLAESAESTEDIREITOINDEPENDENTEMENTEDAUTILIDADEDESSASDECISESJUDICIAISNAPROMOODEUMASITUAODEDEBATEPBLICOVIGOROSOETOLERANTE/PONTOASERRESSALTADOQUENOHRAZOPARASUPORQUEOSESFOROSDO*UDICIRIOPARARESOLVERCASOSCONCRETOSDEFORMAADEQUADAAODIREITOCONTRIBUIRONECESSARIAMENTEPARAOVIGORAQUALIDADEOUATOLERNCIADODEBATEPBLICOEDOUSODALIBERDADEDEEXPRESSOEMUMADADASOCIEDADEIDEMPP%STACONSTATAOREFORAAIDIAAQUIDEFENDIDADEQUEHONRARUMVALORALGODISTINTODEPROMOVLO
6),!OPCITP
2!7,3*!4HEORYOF*USTICEP$!6)3.h#ONTEMPORARY$EONTOLOGYvPESEGUINTES6ALENOTARQUEUMATEORIADEONTOLGICAPODETAMBMDElNIROQUEBOMEMFUNODOQUECERTOADOTANDOAhCORREOMORALvOUAhCONFORMIDADECOMDEVERESMORAISvCOMOCRITRIODEhBONDADEvCF2!7,3*OPCITP
/RECONHECIMENTO
INTRODUO AO PENSAMENTO ESTRATGICO
27FGV DIREITO RIO
InTRODuO TEORIa Da DEcIsO
27FGV DIREITO RIO
INTRODUO TEORIA DA DECISO
'(7%*3&*503*0
QFMPRVBMTFWFSJmDBBTVBBEFRVBPBPQSJODQJP0SBTFOEPPTiFTUBEPTEFDPJTBTwVNDPOKVOUPEFQSPQSJFEBEFTBTFSFNFODPOUSBEBTFNVNiNVOEPQPTTWFMwBWFSJmDBPEPTFVBUJOHJNFOUPQBSDJBMPVUPUBMQPSVNBEFUFSNJOBEBEFDJTPKVEJDJBMOPQPEFTFSFGFUVBEBBQFOBTDPNSFDVSTPBBSHVNFOUPTMJOHTUJDPTPVTJTUFNUJDPT7FKBNPTQPSFYFNQMPPEJTQPTJUJWPDPOUJEPOPBSUJHPP*9EB$POTUJUVJP
i*9MJWSFBFYQSFTTPEBBUJWJEBEFJOUFMFDUVBMBSUTUJDBDJFOUmDBFEFDPNVOJDBPJOEFQFOEFOUFNFOUFEFDFOTVSBPVMJDFOBw
"JOUFSQSFUBPEFTUFEJTQPTJUJWPQPEFUBOUPEBSGVOEBNFOUPBVNBSFHSBRVFTFBQMJDBEBQFSNJUF B FYQSFTTPEFEFUFSNJOBEB JEJB FPVPCSJHB B UPMFSODJBEFTTB FYQSFTTPRVBOUPBVNQSJODQJPRVFUPSOBPCSJHBUSJPTPTDPNQPSUBNFOUPTFNFEJEBTOFDFTTSJPTQSPNPPEFVNBTJUVBPTPDJBMOBRVBMBTQFTTPBTQPTTBNVTVGSVJSEFNBJPSFTQBPFEFNBJTPQPSUVOJEBEFTEFFYQSFTTPEFTVBTJEJBT$PNCJOBOEPFTUFQFDVMJBSDBSUFSEBTOPSNBTEFOBUVSF[BQSJODJQJPMHJDBDPNPWPDBCVMSJPQSPQPTUPQPS1IJMJQ1FUJUQPEFNPTEJ[FSRVFFNNVJUPTDBTPTQPTTWFMBSHVNFOUBSUBOUPQFMBQSPNPPEBTmOBMJEBEFTTVCKBDFOUFTOPSNBRVBOUPQFMBTJNQMFTPCFEJODJBBPTDPNQPSUBNFOUPTRVFFMBEFTDSFWF
0iFTUBEPEFDPJTBTw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mNDVKBDPOTFDVPPCSJHBUSJB*TTPmDBFWJEFOUFOPDBTPEBTOPSNBTDPOTUSVEBTDPNPQSJODQJPTFNCPSBWBMIBUBNCNQBSBBTSFHSBT4FBTOPSNBTKVSEJDBTQPEFNTFSJOUFSQSFUBEBTDPNPVNBFYJHODJBEFUSBOTGPSNBPEPNVOEPBUVBMFNVNNVOEPQPTTWFMQPSNFJPEBJOUSPEVPEFVNOPWPGBUPFNVNBDBEFJBDBVTBMFOUPQPTTWFMBmSNBSRVFPUSBCBMIPEPKVJ[FOWPMWFOFDFTTBSJBNFOUFVNDPNQPOFOUFEFBWBMJBPFNQSJDBDPOTFRFODJBM/PNFTNPTFOUJEP)VNCFSUPWJMBBmSNBRVFOBBQMJDBPEFQSJODQJPTPBQMJDBEPSEFWFiBSHVNFOUBSEFNPEPBGVOEBNFOUBSVNBBWBMJBPEFDPSSFMBPFOUSFPTFGFJUPTEBDPOEVUBFBSFBMJ[BPHSBEVBMEPFTUBEPEFDPJTBTFYJHJEPw
7BMFJOTJTUJSOPGBUPEFRVFBQSPNPPFBPCFEJODJBFNTFOUJEPFTUSJUPTPOBWFSEBEFEVBTGPSNBTEFPCFEFDFSBOPSNBTKVSEJDBT1SJNBGBDJFOPINPUJWPQBSBQFOTBSRVFBUSBOTQPTJPEPTDPODFJUPTEFmMPTPmBNPSBMFMBCPSBEPTQPS1FUUJUQSFKVEJDBSPDBSUFSEFPOUPMHJDPEBPCSJHBPEPKVJ[QBSBDPNBBQMJDBPEP%JSFJUP7FKBNPT"BSHVNFOUBPDPNCBTFOBTDPOTFRODJBTQSFTTVQFBBEPPEFBMHVNDSJUSJPQBSBTVBWBMPSBPTFRVFNBWBMJBBTDPOTFRODJBTPKVJ[WJODVMBEPBPPSEFOBNFOUPKVSEJDPPRVFDPOUBOPTPTVBTQSFGFSODJBTNBTTJNBTQSFGFSODJBTFYQSFTTBTQFMBTOPSNBT%BEBTEVBTQPTTJCJMJEBEFTEFEFDJTPYZ
TFBEFDJTPYQSPNPWFPFTUBEPEFDPJTBTEFUFSNJOBEPQFMBOPSNBBQMJDWFMFNHSBVNBJPSEPRVFBEFDJTPZJTUPTFBTDPOTFRODJBTEFYDPOUSJCVJSPNBJTEPRVFBTEFZQBSBBFGFUJWBPEFTTFFTUBEPEFDPJTBT
FOUPBEFDJTPYEFWFTFSiQSFGFSJEBwQFMPKVJ[FNEFUSJNFOUPEFZQSFDJTPUFSFNNFOUFQPSNRVFQPSUSTEBHSBEVBPEFVNDPOKVOUPEFEFDJTFTYZ[FNGVOPEBQSFGFSODJBFYQSFTTBOBTOPSNBTKVSEJDBTFTUOBWFSEBEFBHSBEVBPEPOWFMEFQSPNPPEBmOBMJEBEFEBOPSNBRVFVNBEFDJTPUFSDPNPSFTVMUBEPBWBMJBPFNQSJDB
DBCFOEPBPKVJ[EFUFSNJOBSTFFTUFOWFMFTQFDmDPEFQSPNPPPVOPPDVSTPEFBPFYJHJEPQFMBBQMJDBPEPQSJODQJPBWBMJBP
DESSAVINCULAOMORALDOJUIZAOORDENAMENTOJURDICONOPAClCA#ONlRASEPOREXEMPLOACONCEPODEPRAGMATISMOJURDICODE2ICHARD0OSNERPARAQUEMAOBEDINCIAAOSPRECEDENTESELEITOSOMENTEUMANECESSIDADEPRTICADEATENDERSEGURANAJURDICA0/3.%22h,EGAL0RAGMATISMvP
6),!(OPCITP
6),!(4EORIADOS0RINCPIOSP
#OMOJOBSERVADOACIMAUMAEVIDNCIADEQUENEMSEMPREAMESMAMEDIDAATENDERSDUASNORMASHIPOTTICASRESIDENOFATODEQUENOLONGOPRAZOPERMITIRAEXPRESSODEIDEAISTOTALITRIOSOUDEALGUMAFORMANODEMOCRTICOSPODEGERARUMESTADODECOISASNOQUALASPESSOASTMMENORLIBERDADEDEEXPRESSAREMSUASIDIASPOREXEMPLOSEAPROPAGANDATOTALITRIAPERMITIRQUEGRUPOSCONTRRIOSLIBERDADEDEEXPRESSODETENHAMPODERSUlCIENTEPARAFAZERVALERESSACONVICO
3/,%22#6%2.)%2#OPCITP
3/,%22#6%2.)%2#OPCITP
6),!(4EORIADOS0RINCPIOSP&ICAPATENTEPORTANTOQUEACORREODEARGUMENTOSCONSEQENCIALISTASDEPENDENOAPENASDAPLAUSIBLIDADEDESUARECONDUOAOORDENAMENTOJURDICOMASTAMBMDAVERDADEDOSENUNCIADOSCONDICIONAISQUEOSSUSTENTAMnh3EEUADOTARADECISOXENTOSERPRODUZIDAACONSEQNCIA#v3ENOFORVERDADEIRAACORRELAOENTREASAESPOSSVEISECERTOSEVENTOSACORREODOARGUMENTOlCARCOMPROMETIDA3/,%22#6%2.)%2#OPCIT%STEEXAMEQUENECESSARIAMENTEEMPRICOCOLOCASRIOSPROBLEMASPARA
INTRODUO AO PENSAMENTO ESTRATGICO
28FGV DIREITO RIO
InTRODuO TEORIa Da DEcIsO
28FGV DIREITO RIO
INTRODUO TEORIA DA DECISO
'(7%*3&*503*0
KVSEJDB"BWBMJBPEBDPNQBUJCJMJEBEFFOUSFPOWFMEFQSPNPPQSPEV[JEPQFMBEFDJTPFPDPOUFEPOPSNBUJWPEPQSJODQJPBQMJDBEPUFSBQFOBTEPJTSFTVMUBEPTQPTTWFJTiTJNwPViOPwiDPNQBUWFMwPViJODPNQBUWFMw
"TTJNOPIRVBMRVFSJODPNQBUJCJMJEBEFFOUSFBJEJBEFPCFEJODJBDPNPQSPNPPFPDBSUFSiEFPOUPMHJDPwEBBQMJDBPEFOPSNBTKVSEJDBTRVFBUSBEJPEPQFOTBNFOUPKVSEJDPWDPNPVNBFYJHODJBEPJEFBMEF&TUBEPEF%JSFJUP"PDPOUSSJPNVJUBTWF[FTPSHPKVEJDBOUFEFQFOEFSEFVNBBOMJTFEBTQPTTWFJTDPOTFRODJBTEFDBEBDVSTPEFDJTSJPQBSBJEFOUJmDBSPRVFBBQMJDBPEP%JSFJUPFYJHFOPDBTPDPNPPFYFNQMPEBMJCFSEBEFEFFYQSFTTPUPSOBFWJEFOUF
&TTBTDPOTUBUBFTTPBJOEBNBJTQFSTVBTJWBTRVBOEPWSJBTOPSNBTJODJEJSFNTPCSFPDBTP)DFSUBTSFMBFTEFJOUFSEFQFOEODJBOPTFTUBEPTEFDPJTBTEFPOUJDBNFOUFDBSBDUFSJ[BEPTQPSQSJODQJPTKVSEJDPTRVFTQPEFNTFSJEFOUJmDBEBTFEFWJEBNFOUFSFTPMWJEBTQPSNFJPEBBOMJTFEBTTVBTQPTTWFJTDPOTFRODJBT/BQSUJDBBQSPNPPEBmOBMJEBEFTVCKBDFOUFBVNQSJODQJPQPEFJOUFSGFSJSOBQSPNPPEBmOBMJEBEFEFPVUSP
04VQSFNP5SJCVOBM'FEFSBMTFWJVEJBOUFEFFWJEFOUFRVFTUPEFJOUFSEFQFOEODJBOPKVMHBNFOUPEP3FDVSTP&YUSBPSEJOSJPO410&TUBEPEF4P1BVMPBSHVNFOUBWBRVFBQBSUJSEB$POTUJUVJPEFP.JOJTUSJP1CMJDPTPNFOUFQPEFSJBFYFSDFSiGVOFTDPNQBUWFJTDPNBTVBmOBMJEBEFwRVBMTFKBiBEFGFTBEBPSEFNKVSEJDBEPSFHJNFEFNPDSUJDPFEPTJOUFSFTTFTJOEJWJEVBJTJOEJTQPOWFJTwOPTUFSNPTEPTBSUTF
"SU0.JOJTUSJP1CMJDPJOTUJUVJPQFSNBOFOUFFTTFODJBMGVOPKVSJTEJDJPOBMEP&TUBEPJODVNCJOEPMIFBEFGFTBEBPSEFNKVSEJDBEPSFHJNFEFNPDSUJDPFEPTJOUFSFTTFTTPDJBJTFJOEJWJEVBJTJOEJTQPOWFJT"SU4PGVOFTJOTUJUVDJPOBJTEP.JOJTUSJP1CMJDP*9FYFSDFSPVUSBTGVOFTRVFMIFGPSFNDPOGFSJEBTEFTEFRVFDPNQBUWFJTDPNTVB
mOBMJEBEFTFOEPMIFWFEBEBBSFQSFTFOUBPKVEJDJBMFBDPOTVMUPSJBKVSEJDBEFFOUJEBEFTQCMJDBT
%FTTBGPSNBTFHVOEPP&TUBEPEF4P1BVMPPBSUEP$11RVFFTUBCFMFDFBMFHJUJNJEBEFEP.1QBSBBQSPQPTJUVSBEFBPOBFTGFSBDWFMQBSBSFQBSBPFYEFMJDUPOPUFSJBTJEPSFDFQDJPOBEPQFMB$POTUJUVJP" GVOPEFSFQSFTFOUBP KVEJDJBMEFQFTTPBTDPNCBJYBSFOEBUFSJBTJEPBUSJCVEBQFMP$POTUJUVJOUFBVNBJOTUJUVJPFTQFDmDBB%FGFOTPSJB1CMJDBOPTUFSNPTEPTBSUTP-99*7F
"SUP-99*7P&TUBEPQSFTUBSBTTJTUODJBKVSEJDBJOUFHSBMFHSBUVJUBBPTRVFDPNQSPWBSFNJOTVmDJODJBEFSFDVSTPT"SU"%FGFOTPSJB1CMJDBJOTUJUVJPFTTFODJBMGVOPKVSJTEJDJPOBMEP&TUB
EPJODVNCJOEPMIFBPSJFOUBPKVSEJDBFBEFGFTBFNUPEPTPTHSBVTEPTOFDFTTJUBEPTOBGPSNBEPBSU-99*7
/PEFDPSSFSEPTEFCBUFTFOUSFPT.JOJTUSPTPRVFQPEFSJBUFSTJEPBQFOBTVNBJOUFSQSFUBPEFFYQSFTTFTDPNPiGVOFTDPNQBUWFJTDPNTVBmOBMJEBEFwiJOUFSFTTFTTPDJBJTFJOEJWJEVBJTJOEJTQPOWFJTwPVBJOEBEBTOPSNBTDPOTUJUVDJPOBJTRVFEFMJNJUBNBDPNQFUODJBEB%FGFOTPSJB1CMJDBFEP.JOJTUSJP1CMJDPUPSOPVTFVNBJOWFTUJHBPBDFSDBEBTQPTTWFJTDPOTFRODJBTEBOPSFDFQPEPBSUEP$11"NVEBOBEFFOGPRVFmDPVQBSUJDVMBSNFOUFFWJEFOUFOP7PUPEP.JOJTUSP/SJEB4JMWFJSBRVFBTTFWFSPV
i4FPBSUJHPEP$EJHPEF1SPDFTTP1FOBMRVF OPSNBBOUFSJPSBP TJTUFNBEB$POTUJUVJPEFQSFWRVFiRVBOEPPUJUVMBSEPEJSFJUPSFQBSBPEPEBOPGPSQPCSFB FYFDVPEB TFOUFOB DPOEFOBUSJBw TFS SFRVFSJEBiQFMP.JOJTUSJP1CMJDPw
QUALQUERTENTATIVADESERACIONALIZARAATIVIDADEDEAPLICAODO$IREITOCOMBASEAPENASEMCRITRIOSJURDICOS0ARAUMAANLISEDOSPROBLEMASDECORRENTESDESSAINEVITVELhTRANSIODOJURDICOPARAOEMPRICOvNAARGUMENTAOBASEADANAPROMOODEESTADOSDECOISASCF3#(5!24:,&.ORMA#ONTINGNCIAE2ACIONALIDADE
3/,%22#6%2.)%2#OPCITP
3EAEFETIVAODOSMUNDOSPOSSVEISSEDEMUMMUNDOATUALDERECURSOSESCASSOSACONSECUODECERTASMETASEMALGUMPONTOCOMPROMETERADEOUTRAS2EFERINDOSEESPECIlCAMENTEAOSTRADEOFFSDEPROTEODEDIREITOSEMUMADADASOCIEDADEOECONOMISTA!MARTYA3ENJDEMONSTROUCOMOORACIOCNIOCONSEQENCIALhFACILITAODISCERNIMENTOQUANDOINVESTIGAMOSOSINESCAPVEISPROBLEMASDEINTERDEPENDNCIAvENVOLVIDOS3%.!MARTYA3OBRETICAE%CONOMIAP
*ULGADOEM2EL-IN-ARCO!URLIO$*
.OCASOO3UPREMODECIDIUPORUNANIMIDADEQUEOARTIGODO#00DEIXARIADESERAPLICVELDEFORMAPROGRESSIVAnISTOSOMENTEPODERIASERCONSIDERADOINCOMPATVELCOMA#ONSTITUIONAMEDIDAEMQUEAS$EFENSORIAS0BLICASFOSSEMSENDOORGANIZADASEAPARELHADASNOS
INTRODUO AO PENSAMENTO ESTRATGICO
29FGV DIREITO RIO
InTRODuO TEORIa Da DEcIsO
29FGV DIREITO RIO
INTRODUO TEORIA DA DECISO
'(7%*3&*503*0
OPNFQBSFDFRVFBFTUBBMUVSBFNGBDFEPBSUJHPQBSHSBGPOJDPEB$POTUJUVJPBPBmSNBSRVFP.JOJTUSJP1CMJDPOPEFWFNBJTEBSBTTJTUODJB KVEJDJSJBBPTQPCSFTQPEFSB$PSUFBTTFOUBSEFDJTPEFDPOTFRODJBDPOUSSJBBPFTQSJUPEBQSQSJB$POTUJUVJPQPJTFMBRVFSPTOFDFTTJUBEPTUFOIBNBTTJTUODJBKVSEJDBFKVEJDJSJBQFMP&TUBEPwHSJGPTNFVT
3FEFTDSFWFOEPFTUFSBDJPDOJPOPTUFSNPTEFTFOWPMWJEPTBPMPOHPEPQSFTFOUFFOTBJPQPEFSBNPTEJ[FSRVFBEFDJTPQFMBOPSFDFQPEPBSUEP$11TFSJBVNiFMPwFNVNBDBEFJBDBVTBMRVFSFTVMUBSJBFNVNFTUBEPEFDPJTBTOPRVBMPTQPCSFTOPUFSJBNPTFVBDFTTPKVTUJBHBSBOUJEPoVNiNVOEPQPTTWFMwDPOUSSJPBPEJTQPTUPOPBSUP-99*7EB$POTUJUVJP"TTJNBPCFEJODJBFTUSJUBBPTBSUTFJNQFEJSJBBQSPNPPEFmOTEFPOUJDBNFOUFDBSBDUFSJ[BEPTQFMB$POTUJUVJP#SBTJMFJSB/FTUFDBTPQPSUBOUPPBSHVNFOUPDPOTFRFODJBMJTUBEP.JOJTUSP/SJEB4JMWFJSBFTDMBSFDFVBDPOFYPTJTUFNUJDBFOUSFBTOPSNBTRVFJOTUJUVFNP.JOJTUSJP1CMJDPEFVNMBEPFPQSJODQJPDPOTUJUVDJPOBMEBQSFTUBPEFBTTJTUODJBKVSEJDBHSBUVJUBBPTRVFEFMBOFDFTTJUBSFNEFPVUSP
$PODMVTP%FWPMUBDMBTTJmDBPEF)VNCFSUPWJMB
1PEFNPTBHPSBSFUPSOBSDMBTTJmDBPQSPQPTUBQPS)VNCFSUPWJMB$POGPSNFTFQPEFPCTFSWBSBQBSUJSEPKVMHBNFOUPEB"%*%'3FGPSNBEB1SFWJEODJB
PTBSHVNFOUPT KVSEJDPT GVOEBEPTOBBWBMJBPEBTDPOTFRODJBTEBEFDJTPQPEFN TJN UFS DPNPSFGFSODJBPTiNPEPTEFTFSwEP%JSFJUP/PIFNQSJODQJPOFOIVNCJDFSFDPOEVPEFBSHVNFOUPTDPOTFRFODJBMJTUBTBQPOUPTPCKFUJWBNFOUFWFSJmDWFJTEPPSEFOBNFOUP/PTPQPSUBOUPOFDFTTBSJBNFOUFNFOPTDPNQBUWFJTDPNPT JEFBJTEP&TUBEPEF%JSFJUPFEB4FQBSBPEF1PEFSFTEPRVFBSHVNFOUPTMJOHTUJDPTPVTJTUFNUJDPT"PDPOUSSJPFNDFSUPTDBTPTBSHVNFOUBSDPNCBTFOBTDPOTFRODJBTQPEFTFSVNBNBOFJSBFTQFDmDBEFPCFEFDFSBOPSNBTKVSEJDBTWPMUBEBQBSBBQSPNPPEFFTUBEPTEFDPJTBTDVKBDPOTFDVPPPSEFOBNFOUPJOTUJUVJDPNPPCSJHBUSJB"TTJNNVJUPTBSHVNFOUPTGVOEBEPTOBTDPOTFRODJBTQPEFNTFSSFDPOTUSVEPTDPNPBSHVNFOUPTJOTUJUVDJPOBJT
"MNEJTTPFNDBTPTEFJOUFSEFQFOEODJBFOUSFPTFTUBEPTEFDPJTBTEFPOUJDBNFOUFDBSBDUFSJ[BEPTQPSOPSNBTEJTUJOUBTPTBSHVNFOUPTDPOTFRFODJBMJTUBTQPEFNGVODJPOBSDPNPBSHVNFOUPT TJTUFNUJDPT iDPOUFYUVBJTwOPT UFSNPTEFWJMB
QPJT USBUBNEB DPNCJOBPUFMFPMHJDBFOUSFPVUSPTQSJODQJPTFBOPSNBPCKFUPEFJOUFSQSFUBP"OBMJTBSBTDPOTFRODJBTEBBQMJDBPEFVNBOPSNBNPTUSBDPNPFMBEFWFTFSJOUFSQSFUBEBEFGPSNBTJTUFNUJDBFNSFMBPTEFNBJTOPSNBTEPPSEFOBNFOUPDPNPOPDBTPEBJNVOJEBEFEPMJWSPFMFUSOJDP"QPMNJDBFNUPSOPEFTVBUSJCVUBPTFGVOEBOBJOUFSQSFUBPEPBSUJHP7*E
POEFTFFODPOUSBUFYUVBMNFOUFBFYQSFTTPiJNVOJEBEFEPMJWSPw.BTQPTTWFMBSHVNFOUBSFNGBWPSEBJNVOJEBEFEPMJWSPFMFUSOJDPDPOFDUBOEPFTUBOPSNBDPNPFTUBEPEFDPJTBTDVKBDPOTFDVPBMJCFSEBEFEFNBOJGFTUBPEPUPSOBPCSJHBUSJBUSJCVUBSFTUBTPCSBTMFWBSJBBVNNVOEPFGFUJWPOPRVBMBTQFTTPBTOPEFTGSVUBNEFQMFOBMJCFSEBEFEFNBOJGFTUBPEFQFOTBNFOUP/FTUFDBTPPRVFFTUFNKPHPNFOPTBiPCFEJODJBFTUSJUBwKRVFBTJNQMFTUSJCVUBPEPMJWSPFMFUSOJDPOPJNQFEJSEJSFUBNFOUFBNBOJGFTUBPEPQFOTBNFOUP
FNBJTBQSPNPPEBMJCFSEBEFEFQFOTBNFOUP"SFMBPTJTUFNUJDBFOUSFBTEVBTOPSNBTFNKPHPTmDBFWJEFOUFOBDPOTJEFSBPEFDPOTFRODJBT
"DMBTTJmDBPFBIJFSBSRVJ[BPEFWJMBTPQFSUJOFOUFTOBNFEJEBFNRVFBSHVNFOUPTOPJOTUJUVDJPOBJTEFWFNQPTTVJSEFGBUPVNQFTPSFMBUJWPNFOPSOBKVTUJmDBPEFEFDJTFTKVEJDJBJT.BTOPTFQPEFBmSNBSRVFUPEPFRVBMRVFSBSHVNFOUPRVFBQFMFBDPOTFRODJBTPVFGFJUPTQSUJDPTEFVNDVSTPEFDJTSJPWTFSOFDFTTBSJBNFOUFOPJOTUJUVDJPOBMQSFDJTPEFTGB[FSBJEFOUJEBEFFOUSFiBSHVNFOUPTOPJOTUJUVDJPOBJTwFiBSHVNFOUPTQSUJDPTw
%STADOSBRASILEIROS5TILIZOAEX