Download pdf - CEI Email 2.28.03

Transcript
Page 1: CEI Email 2.28.03

�&�rp �75�A�kA�

RECORD TYPE:V

CR�TQR: � O�&h� { cN�4�n Gr�/�U� fO� I 3

C�T pBI�Z)AZ:28'-FE� 2003 �30:07�4�

C1�ftate e pet� Qu�4ty P�t±tio4� FY�F pet $am J�z�tan

I V

77

c&��i C ey ( ��h±1 c ne/QU- Q/QQ��Z�4� � C� IV

i

�J4mq� c9�ma�g�W9fl ( VN=Je�ues c naug n/OU Q/O��Q� CI�Q � I

Q�$ �QP oi� �

Chr±a Ilornax �cno e�.92/i�8f2pQ3 4�i:1Q �7

�ord

�o: Jobn�G� fO10�/ P7

SUbjV,� C� t�e P�2Qua1±�r �et to� flIt pex� �en�7

/77

V�V

7> K�V 7

7

file;I/fl 7_1V95e�qj\O275_Q�paeQO3_ceqtxt 811/Z005

Page 2: CEI Email 2.28.03

Waishingtoni, DC 2003622 .331.010 p1#one202.3410640 ft*2 222445S&Rcll

FPQA O~ STP Peftib~n.~df

-M222054420310252Z2F1DA540300660J10302345

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~2

3

~~~~~~~66

TO

347 330 3~0<31018710000000 033~<3333

30438312~0PA0300000$O3326~0333

303le5333A'3827311Q030<26QDA 33 33 38Q/000QE00331

Page 3: CEI Email 2.28.03

I

II

I

/

Dire�to� of the om� of S<�i�uce �4 T�iuiology ?olicyE�e�i4ivoQ ofth�

II

Re

I

II

�llow� L)U� u9�V

I

I

ov fo�T ]phaLfof*�eTh��tive oftii�'1 T

).JW�l�4 lityfor

1

Page 4: CEI Email 2.28.03

I

I

c�equw*�r O$TP� EI�QAT �Ouide �r

j

�awu�bkb�Wbi�

I

Sup�visiQn

� �n accurate, imb�q�d

Rud �he �xe�uti�re Hrau�h).

The Wbi�e 1*�s� Of�ceo� an4 � �QM� Ints(�6ER4911S\fiftaliZ*4b)� S

ZQP2 Fiu*1 -. (67 F�9), -wi4o� (t�PQA $�ctien�t5�b)(I� We �tiuu� '2�

0STP'�iRina!Th�deI

�se of and �Iiau�e �ipwzPu � U�1J�4W �W y

sc1�1Ke Un4�r1yiU� regien�l and 0na1yse� (tMtC

3

Page 5: CEI Email 2.28.03

j

51�9f �LRWZfl�-554 Q�T?

aadaU�o�c1u8io�

&st

Cop�equences of C1im�te V ility .a�4 , or N�ona1 A (MACC).

I

*5 0�W� teilo�thatpr �sun1�[ CE1isa�

I

R1O�,5

2

Page 6: CEI Email 2.28.03

I

I

I

AU 0f�cse mwire tI�a�t of 1�AC%� �vi0We� PPQA'sp

f�r �bj�ctivity, utility mid

FDQA pr�bibits - and * * ofNAC�the�4c*asibI�#�o1�ect#� 4ueto4�at

miyptod�ict * � 1

I

I

,on*�. *ve �v�r�4�' cies. ltjgI

I

II

4

I

I

Page 7: CEI Email 2.28.03

Q>�W�&C. 2932

"V

/

I

wbkhisati in P .s�11ews:

(�)(2)

I

(3) - n(15

2. Thed6e & ii�4� one4 tN.s�m1tQ th. requisite FDQA Ievf'�jIy" �

herein.

5

Page 8: CEI Email 2.28.03

nE /

jfQ, � FDQKS'�

NACCa1sot�flsPDQKid�tand of ssa�i.1iiy ove�d�eyo�4�e peetstandar4&�

�th.�eviswofNACC1�y * k/ 4

at ofVi�i�ii; and 11,p�,higth� NA4�C i� ViO1RtK�ft

apprcpnate, 10! id�ed�pIat�4t0Y text ii me U

"August 1t� 2OOO.�.

with the tJSNA [ cited in this Petl4on � ihe NACCI is that itis lur � ni�4e1s, � of whicMVhc�o wi�ithe 1Q�y.ar

5� tO �RV�

bias) Pe�hat 1an�theUSNA bewwnftonithe untilitI,

� nde of wjenc�4N& 4td�CSflOtd�'thi�l ksd�ce'�. �mdat

elywh�t the FDQA � o bar front the poi pn�cess.

The two climate models u�d � the NACC m4ke p t*rnr of U.S. climate change based uponhuman alteratlons>ofthe atmosphere. Those alterations have b�een going onfir well over 100 years.

6

II

I

Page 9: CEI Email 2.28.03

thosc "Jbr (1.5.

of

There wa� no di�ce*,ii5Z� 4keration of the NA(C te4 �z to �kt� flqw� H�weve*� 4w

N4CCSyri4w� Team, co�.chafredby Th�$mw rl� �kectorofth�N' 0 Datafookthereksosw��thqt4wy �Oft4t�M(�0iO�

Iwh�,$Ve, �I�g l-year� 5-y�q�� t M25ns'm*WMPw of tbe �Thtv analysis ver�ed that k*fact both m spelonnetno &�tter than alable �frand��mapplied to the US. (JJimate Data. M� Karbww Abut to sehd the re�ultw ta this revisw�P

".,..the.�mGf�O40I �ieI&±Ofl. A� sthnwit fr� Pi�iire 9'$ oftheTbi$ nftheTh�ited I

QRieofthetwo os�fo�,i4heVS$A�the� ce�t�rf�CC)

(4.5�C)�b�* 2100, � ; lIZthiE4itb

2.1F (1 �$�C)i� the tJrnt04S overthe �urse

J.E�et�t� 1�9:O�$8a�a1 o� 4Jowwal of Geophysical

Resear4i, IO4� 3O�997-3 1,022\ or 10 times less th�ik the forevastfR hes siuce revised

7

Page 10: CEI Email 2.28.03

I

I

tb�NAcq iste�mr� J / � A

*�t It Zs ck4r that tb� N4C�C c4oa two ffxfremg mod�sfr *�'t of�fi4� I

dowr� that were ai ilabJ& This vk�1at&t the PPQA require�wtsfi�r '�, deW�4d�nthe thfrd aph of this Petition.

i

NO4kW0t o�bo�a�or� flQE(Jq�d{ �tQM at

tJSOCRP:

�A1so� r>�U �4icti*� from two ��ate W�*us'� Steveu 1.

GMn� S 8cie�*ist� A <Scionces and (Th�b�l Chango� Pacific tNott1r�VostLaboratory.

$

Page 11: CEI Email 2.28.03

MOTeisto uRo~1~~mt

Aro heseOCM~f~4' ~ f~ngo

W~~~~~iU~~~~~~~chl~~~~~~~~ger (12/17/99)~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~H

Page 12: CEI Email 2.28.03

are cQrrc�TeQ. MI �R�IVI� �U

as �ALA�3UI2US1T8

"a quality atx>ve aM �.ysn4 seine e�rseview quality s

O�v�n LJ$�CRP'� ref�isal tQ wait fot �u �f the

sector�l aM�y5e5,"�I w�lk4g� tfr 'te acieii�ificI

I

2 A4 i�CEIetaLv.Bush. �JS�RPita oWieus

their withtheltw'�s

3 This d�spite that the two NA�C �eeti�m ar� "Regions," and �Seetioj�," (SeehtpJ/www.2erio�o�gInatio

Page 13: CEI Email 2.28.03

3. NACC N�t inEaet Peer R�eviewed� t� Recor4 C�r

V --

ActFAC�94n1 t�.J

This � S

of $we�ewi4e1yo� �ii4 'tehano� �n1y tw�si div

c &e Udbyt�efoIM,*$

v340f to � of �tMt

3) 3i�� Ieeu�venferth�seoo !Mw*�ot�et�tore�4

in Its -� (W41i�*i T. Penn0$;

1)OC / *$ NOT REMW �R

5) "This i� >not ready to� goP' fWifli.i� M.

These r�fleetan impiieationeftizningover cetndofaproductI

11

Page 14: CEI Email 2.28.03

A C

I

� y

V >

C

II

I

1O�1 AvenuoNW

Wine: %202) 331-2260tax: (2Q4$$1

I