Click here to load reader

CEI Email 2.28.03

  • View
    269

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Text of CEI Email 2.28.03

  • &rp 75AkA

    RECORD TYPE:V

    CRTQR: O&h { cN4n Gr/U fO I 3

    CT pBIZ)AZ:28'-FE 2003 30:074

    C1ftate e pet Qu4ty Pttio4 FYF pet $am Jztan

    I V

    77

    c&i C ey ( h1 c ne/QU- Q/QQZ4 C IVi

    J4mq c9magW9fl ( VN=Jeues c naug n/OU Q/OQ CIQ I

    Q$ QP oi

    Chra Ilornax cno e.92/i8f2pQ3 4i:1Q 7

    ord

    o: JobnG fO10/ P7

    SUbjV, C te P2Qua1r et to flIt pex en7

    /77

    VV

    7> KV 7

    7

    file;I/fl 7_1V95eqj\O275_QpaeQO3_ceqtxt 811/Z005

  • Waishingtoni, DC 2003622 .331.010 p1#one202.3410640 ft*2 222445S&Rcll

    FPQA O~ STP Peftib~n.~df

    -M222054420310252Z2F1DA540300660J10302345

    ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~2

    3

    ~~~~~~~66

    TO

    347 330 3~0

  • I

    II

    I

    /

    Direto of the om of S

  • I

    I

    cequw*r O$TP EIQAT Ouide r

    j

    awubkbWbi

    I

    SupvisiQn

    n accurate, imbqd

    Rud he xeutire Hrauh).

    The Wbie 1*s Ofceo an4 QM Ints(6ER4911S\fiftaliZ*4b) S

    ZQP2 Fiu*1 -. (67 F9), -wi4o (tPQA $ctient5b)(I We tiuu '20STP'iRina!ThdeI

    se of and Iiaue ipwzPu U1J4W W y

    sc11Ke Un4r1yiU regienl and 0na1yse (tMtC

    3

  • j

    519f LRWZfl-554 QT?

    aadaUoc1u8io

    &st

    Copequences of C1imte V ility .a4 , or Nona1 A (MACC).

    I

    *5 0W teilothatpr sun1[ CE1isa

    I

    R1O,5

    2

  • I

    I

    I

    AU 0fcse mwire tIat of 1AC% vi0We PPQA'sp

    fr bjctivity, utility mid

    FDQA prbibits - and * * ofNACthe4c*asibI#o1ect# 4ueto4at

    miyptodict * 1

    I

    I

    ,on*. *ve vr4' cies. ltjgI

    I

    II

    4

    I

    I

  • Q>W&C. 2932

    "V

    /

    I

    wbkhisati in P .s11ews:

    ()(2)

    I

    (3) - n(15

    2. Thed6e & ii4 one4 tN.sm1tQ th. requisite FDQA Ievf'jIy"

    herein.

    5

  • nE /

    jfQ, FDQKS'

    NACCa1sotflsPDQKidtand of ssai.1iiy ovedeyo4e peetstandar4&

    th.eviswofNACC1y * k/ 4

    at ofViiii; and 11,p,higth NA4C i ViO1RtKft

    apprcpnate, 10! idedpIat4t0Y text ii me U

    "August 1t 2OOO..

    with the tJSNA [ cited in this Petl4on ihe NACCI is that itis lur ni4e1s, of whicMVhco wiithe 1Qy.ar

    5 tO RV

    bias) Pehat 1antheUSNA bewwnftonithe untilitI,

    nde of wjenc4N& 4tdCSflOtd'thil ksdce'. mdat

    elywht the FDQA o bar front the poi pncess.

    The two climate models ud the NACC m4ke p t*rnr of U.S. climate change based uponhuman alteratlons>ofthe atmosphere. Those alterations have been going onfir well over 100 years.

    6

    II

    I

  • thosc "Jbr (1.5.

    of

    There wa no dice*,ii5Z 4keration of the NA(C te4 z to kt flqw Hweve* 4w

    N4CCSyri4w Team, co.chafredby Th$mw rl kectorofthN' 0 Datafookthereksoswthqt4wy Oft4tM(0iO

    Iwh,$Ve, Ig l-year 5-yq t M25ns'm*WMPw of tbe Thtv analysis vered that k*fact both m spelonnetno &tter than alable frandmapplied to the US. (JJimate Data. M Karbww Abut to sehd the reultw ta this reviswP

    ".,..the.mGfO40I ieI&Ofl. A sthnwit fr Piiire 9'$ oftheTbi$ nftheThited I

    QRieofthetwo osfo,i4heVS$Athe cetrfCC)

    (4.5C)b* 2100, ; lIZthiE4itb

    2.1F (1 $C)i the tJrnt04S overthe urse

    J.Eett 19:O$8aa1 o 4Jowwal of GeophysicalResear4i, IO4 3O997-3 1,022\ or 10 times less thik the forevastfR hes siuce revised

    7

  • I

    I

    tbNAcq istemr J / A

    *t It Zs ck4r that tb N4CC c4oa two ffxfremg modsfr *'t offi4 I

    dowr that were ai ilabJ& This vk1at&t the PPQA requirewtsfir ', deW4dnthe thfrd aph of this Petition.

    i

    NO4kW0t oboaor flQE(Jqd{ tQM at

    tJSOCRP:

    A1so r>U 4icti* from two ate W*us' Steveu 1.

    GMn S 8cie*ist A

  • MOTeisto uRo~1~~mt

    Aro heseOCM~f~4' ~ f~ngo

    W~~~~~iU~~~~~~~chl~~~~~~~~ger (12/17/99)~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~H

  • are cQrrcTeQ. MI RIVI Uas ALA3UI2US1T8

    "a quality atx>ve aM .ysn4 seine erseview quality s

    Ovn LJ$CRP' refisal tQ wait fot u f the

    sectorl aMy5e5,"I wlk4g tfr 'te acieiiificI

    I

    2 A4 iCEIetaLv.Bush. JSRPita oWieus

    their withtheltw's

    3 This dspite that the two NAC eetim ar "Regions," and Seetioj," (SeehtpJ/www.2erioogInatio

  • 3. NACC Nt inEaet Peer Reviewed t Recor4 Cr

    V --

    ActFAC94n1 t.J

    This S

    of $weewi4e1yo ii4 'tehano n1y twsi div

    c &e UdbytefoIM,*$

    v340f to of tMt

    3) 3i Ieeuvenferthseoo !Mw*otettore4

    in Its - (W41i*i T. Penn0$;1)OC / *$ NOT REMW R

    5) "This i >not ready to goP' fWifli.i M.

    These rfleetan impiieationeftizningover cetndofaproductI

    11

  • A C

    I

    y

    V >

    C

    II

    I

    1O1 AvenuoNW

    Wine: %202) 331-2260tax: (2Q4$$1

    I