56
eaisia siaqAq oixsiow siaavi T'IA :51UOH UI4A TUTTJO aDIsIq U3AH IYJA14A JADISINM3 J3UOM HDLq Y)ID1T A T40 dm,io$1 .t oilut 84 .oM 1q rthhoW HD5IAH5L DIMOMOD O uAasnJa JAMOITAT4 unvA ud3M OOt 8EIO AM ,,bhdmsD Q1 idm,U bri1o$1 In&Ii 01 kiw o1 I .ivbs iol bioThooW 1d3iM 01 id,b uormon 1w wo I rn ioi hA .noqqu rbmsi io1 12T4 fj b1w jnmmo3 ioI imo5I biviU brw uodlrn3fl vminoM bns no1jSIfl3uR 3lfnoflo33 ni &nioiq ibiisi '51HflM lo flaq i 1qBq idT .nwo ul3Siufl InoiiM rfj Io orfi ion bna iodiirn di lo odi besrqx3 noiniqo nA .imonoz3 .tblBa$I 3imono3 lo OWi bs3X, 01 ton ix3i lo noii jiod2 .bvsi irth hA .grdrn3ro$1 .t oilut d IQQ1 © © nibubni ,iibsi Ilul iBdi b3bivoiq noia2irrrIq ii3iIqx3 tuodjiw b1oup d m ,dqiaisq .331LJO 3(11 01 fI3V! i 33110fl

NBER - tog6061 · 2020. 3. 20. · J1G oLqou (oo) Gdn9oIJ 2 COU2!2cGIJ4 mcrxf pp nu€wbJo?uJGu; L9çc !2 922OCWG 1AçJJ anpaGdncuc 9jja u nuGmbJo2iiiGuc 9Uq (JCLL Ja!o) uq bL!C62

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    0

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: NBER - tog6061 · 2020. 3. 20. · J1G oLqou (oo) Gdn9oIJ 2 COU2!2cGIJ4 mcrxf pp nu€wbJo?uJGu; L9çc !2 922OCWG 1AçJJ anpaGdncuc 9jja u nuGmbJo2iiiGuc 9Uq (JCLL Ja!o) uq bL!C62

eaisia siaqAq oixsiow siaavi

T'IA :51UOH UI4A TUTTJO aDIsIq U3AH IYJA14A JADISINM3

J3UOM HDLq Y)ID1T A T40

dm,io$1 .t oilut

84 .oM 1q rthhoW

HD5IAH5L DIMOMOD O uAasnJa JAMOITAT4 unvA ud3M OOt

8EIO AM ,,bhdmsD Q1 idm,U

bri1o$1 In&Ii 01 kiw o1 I .ivbs iñ iol bioThooW 1d3iM 01 id,b uormon 1w wo I rn ioi hA .noqqu rbmsi io1 12T4 fj b1w jnmmo3 ioI imo5I biviU brw uodlrn3fl

vminoM bns no1jSIfl3uR 3lfnoflo33 ni &nioiq ibiisi '51HflM lo flaq i 1qBq idT .nwo ul3Siufl InoiiM rfj Io orfi ion bna iodiirn di lo odi besrqx3 noiniqo nA .imonoz3

.tblBa$I 3imono3 lo

OWi bs3X, 01 ton ix3i lo noii jiod2 .bvsi irth hA .grdrn3ro$1 .t oilut d IQQ1 © © nibubni ,iibsi Ilul iBdi b3bivoiq noia2irrrIq ii3iIqx3 tuodjiw b1oup d m ,dqiaisq

.331LJO 3(11 01 fI3V! i 33110fl

Page 2: NBER - tog6061 · 2020. 3. 20. · J1G oLqou (oo) Gdn9oIJ 2 COU2!2cGIJ4 mcrxf pp nu€wbJo?uJGu; L9çc !2 922OCWG 1AçJJ anpaGdncuc 9jja u nuGmbJo2iiiGuc 9Uq (JCLL Ja!o) uq bL!C62

84Q 1q nthoW $1HM 4QQ1 idmU

MA :2$IUOH UVIA TUTfUO ,2aDIsIq U3Aa IYJAMA JADI5II1M3

J3UOM HDISI Y)ID1T A MO

TA$ITHA

s diiw tni2no3 i (8Q1) grndm1o$I no baad 1bom hq biia !qmi s lath wod I

lath wori I 1s1u)JrIsq it! .iuqluo bits iuod 3fl lo noflsl5rlo3 dJ nurn33no3 ia1 lo ithav

niIw 33nq bits luqiflo lo Iv! bbn5Ij3b 3rh n3w33d noiJaI5no3 3VL16n £ riliw ifl3iifl03 i ii

a 113U2 .aiab iuqiuo bits hq di diod bn5u3b oi beau i bodirn no1*I-bhvfl rIi

3fli baa iuqiuo iii aininvom 1dal3ib3iq ,dj nwld noiaI5rIo3 i1n3n a .i ,floiia!5r1o3

3111 riiiw tniinoD .ajab .2.U ni (noil 13V baa) 3n,iq i hq iii 1n3m3vom 3Idai3ib5Iq

oIa I .how lo wod baa 3hq nv1i3d rIoIia13Tio3 nadi noii ai noilaI3TIo3 ii1i Jbom

tuqluo 31d533b51q chiw b3i6i3oaa is lath atn3m3vom 33hq 31d5131b31q dj lo di biil

vis1nom ni ?in3rn3vom 31da13th51q ,is zc1i cbidw 03 ib 3111 fl 113w in3m3V0m

1dil b3f1 ol bw s 1s1 dT .luqluo ni 3n3m3vom 3!dnl3ib3lq rhiw b3isboaa 2335 1a b33qx3 i1idai 03 b3ni23b 3i1oq a b3uwq 25(1 rt,a3$1 lai,b&I 3113 rbidw 03 ib 3(13 (tO

.noiisllni

i3d(n31o$1 .t oilul. Iood3 th2ufl biavisH

VV llnH naioM bso$I b13i1 213ib1o

1O AM no32oa 51E1814 bits

Page 3: NBER - tog6061 · 2020. 3. 20. · J1G oLqou (oo) Gdn9oIJ 2 COU2!2cGIJ4 mcrxf pp nu€wbJo?uJGu; L9çc !2 922OCWG 1AçJJ anpaGdncuc 9jja u nuGmbJo2iiiGuc 9Uq (JCLL Ja!o) uq bL!C62

I

j€q ot on;bn; qcjin jo jcq ;p GxbGcç9.çioIJ o bLJcG JIJCLG922

12 9.bbLoxJm91? BLoboLpou9.J fO JJG L126 JXJ IJJOIJ6? i2GJ JJJJ112 IJJOIJGç9.L? !Wb012G2

i'r on ocp€L puq bLicce c9.u p cxbccGq o couçun LJ21IJ nuç JJG LJ2G

no jou inn GJGCç2 on onbn onçbnç oLcc;q ;o qccJuG pcj !c2 acc9.qX

mOIJGçL 2OCJ 9ç; L922 poçp bLcG2 9.uq onçbn s p12 woucçi imbnjeG

JJpG LG9.20U 2 }JG OJJOM!U C!AGIJ 9. 2In!2JJ !U2c9UI9.UGOIT2 LG2bOU2G ot bLicG&

JJOL!OIJ2

bLGqicça 9' UG9.A6 COLLGJ9.OII GMGGU bLcqcç9.pJc bL!CG 9uq onbnç motcui€uç2 o,cL Jou

eucc j pon 9.U9.J?41C9.JJ? 2iu.IbJG 2ç!cJ bLcG LuoqGJ 2nplcc; oxJJ? uJOIJcç9.L 2OCJ2

BLTcG uioqj p9.eGq on ccjjnw (iao) j? 9.u9.J?2i2 combJGuJcu; riqq 9'uq JLGp9.uq (Jr)

c9n JG9. 4O fIG 2OL4 O IJG9'4IAG COLLGJ910JJ2 onuq pX oi"" (jj) in 9.

OfIGL JJ9.uq fIG 2!mnJ!oua o piqq 'uq J,LGJJ9.uq (JM) po pç uJouGç9.L). 2pocJ

;po o pnc (Jj) JJ9.?IJOL (iao) uq E!2CFGL (f3)] IU9.? 9.AG p6611 fUhIJGCG229.L? o'

j,pA r.c9.q uqiu 9.2 211 G2U JJ9. Gwbp9.212 on qGAGJobu moqj [2ncp 9.2

1JG9.L qGçiGuqGq) 26L1G2 jpi onbn uq bL!c onuq p COOI Uq OP9.U!9.U (JJ)

JJOLTOU2 JJJI2 !2 CJO2GJ? LGJ9.cGq 4O JJG UG9'!AG COLLGI9.r!OII pGMGGU IPG Hh JGLGq (9.2 tAGJ!

nc9.çiAG coLLGJ9.ciou pGcMu bLGqTc9.pJG onbn s'uq bLGqicç9.pJG bLicG moi uuç oiL jou

OUG o bLcqicçiou2 O fIG IJJOqGJ !2 COU2I2GUç MIfI boe-M9.L fl 9.9. 2 fIG 2LOU

JJ9.AG ill fJJG iUUiçG 11fflLG

UJOLG IJJ9'U JJG q1jGLG1JCG GPAGGU JJG C11LLGU A9.JIIG o onibni uq fIG A9.J11G rç ie Gxbcc;cq

qGçLGuqcq) onfbrlr iu b9.LpcnJ9.L GAGLJq€-GJ2ou UJG9'211LG o c?cJ!c9.j ociçbn i uocjJu

in onbn 9'LG ot !UfLG2c in bç pGc9112G pG? COLLG2b0Uq 4O 9. U9.J1L9.J UJG9.211L6 O C?CflC9.J (oL

CMGG1J pc biGqicç9.pJG WOAGWGU2 in bc oriçbnç 9'uq JJ011L2 J,JJG bLGqcç9.pJc WOAGWGIJ42

ooqoq (j) j b 2bGcJgJ 9.ççdnfiou uJoqGJe P!J'A o LGbLoqncc c0LLGJ9.c!0u2

fIG onbn-buc€ uq porlL2-bLicG COLLGJ9.OU2 onuq in fl q9.9. j'OçGWpGL 9.uq

9liq 2JJ0M2 fI9.I GAGIT MJJ€U iç 12 217p)GCc O1IJ?t oo 9 b9.Lç1CITJ9.LJ? 2pubJG UJOGJ IMJJ 2c1CJ bLicc2

LP!2 b9.bGL 2plqiG2 fIG COUIJGC41OU pcçiicu 9.LG9.G onbnç 9.LG9.G JJOJTL2 O MOLJ

Page 4: NBER - tog6061 · 2020. 3. 20. · J1G oLqou (oo) Gdn9oIJ 2 COU2!2cGIJ4 mcrxf pp nu€wbJo?uJGu; L9çc !2 922OCWG 1AçJJ anpaGdncuc 9jja u nuGmbJo2iiiGuc 9Uq (JCLL Ja!o) uq bL!C62

5

GM6GU bL!c62 uq onbnç ou €dn6uc? jj ipu ouG bbji€ ;o ;p p#o GL!GiA€j? coLLcJ€q Hiçp q€;LGuqGq onbnr K!u uq ;aou (J3) 2JJOM UJOLG GUGLJJ? ;pç JJ6 COLLGJ9TIOIJiipij€ q6LGiiq€q bL!c IGAGI ra uIGJ) COLLG9çGq Mrfp pG qGILGIJqGq onbn; cic içiou boei-

mGiJl2 qGbcnqa on pc jj€i pgç za 6wbJo)Gq jjJna' pqp uq Lg (j) uq nu (jr) apom cpc12 rmboLuç pGc9na& no enLbL!2!uI? GAGU fG au o p€ COLL6JIOIJ o bncc xq onçbriç ZJIOAG-

IUAOJAG AGCOL 9nçoLGLG2aiOUa (266 tOL Gx9u.ibJG 211112 (To8 JFUCJJ9L (TY R!' uqJU biicnj açnqa o GuJb!L!c9J LGJçou2pb o bLcGa 9uq LG9J A9L!9plGa 110/A

ILP6 J!cGL9cnLG ou IJJG hp!jJ!ba CflLAC p92 cp9ucq cou2q€L9pJ? !u pG j2ç MO qGC9q

2IJJ9JJ !UCLG62 !U bLTc

JA!cp cj n; w' bLGqcçGq !UCLGG2 LT GuJbJo?uuGuç 9LG M!çJJ LGJ9fJAGJ?

4pJ12 /Ai4p L1262 111 cuJbJo?LuGuç J1pn bz€enwpj? J1G oLqou (oo) Gdn9oIJ 2 COU2!2cGIJ4

mcrxf pp nu€wbJo?uJGu; L9çc !2 922OCWG 1AçJJ anpaGdncuc 9jja u nuGmbJo2iiiGuc 9Uq

(JCLL Ja!o) uq bL!C62 (QOLqOIJ o) V22flhIJU GIIJbJO)UJJCU LCAGLç2 p9'Cj 4OM9Lq2 !

9U9j22 2JJ0M2 JJ94 JJJ1 1TUGuJbj0?kIJJGIJç !2 9220C9G M!çp 2J0/A LOM}J 111 9AGL9G M9G2

JJT!2 2çnq?. 2 CJ02CJ? L6J9çGq cL9qçoIJ9J 9U9J?2!2 oj jrba CIILAG2 jpa L9OU9J

flJG UJOG

111 4JJG IJ6X d119LçGL 92 MGJf J 2JJ0M JJ9 0L CGLç91u b9L9W6çGL2 4JJ12 coo 12 COUaIacGIJc !cp

onbnç LOM AGL 1J6X drI9LçCL3 ouG LGA!262 nb/Lqa OUG2 €2LU9G O UJ9OIJ

2GLIG2 OAGL cJJG UCX dn9LcGL 12 9'Cfi19JJ? bo2ifTAG IIJJ12 i OUG LGA2G2 nbM9Lq2 OUC2 G2f1WG o

JJOL0U2 2 IJG9JG JJG COLLGJ9flOU PC/AGGU LGA!2!0U2 !U flJG bLcqcpJc IJJOAGWCIJf 2 111 JJG26

2OL4 JJOL0112 JJ}1JG C0LLGJ9!O1J GMGCU bLGqcpJG bLJCG uq oncbnc CJJ91JG2 OAGL JOUR

211J9'JJ !' 2!G GCOUq J afflcfk bLGqic9pJG UJOACIJJGU2 U bLCG2 9uq Oflçbflç OAGL LGJ9cJAGJ?

26L162 aponjq G Boe!cJAG 111 ;pG qç' cou€J9c!ou !2 uqGGq bo2!c!As jçponp e dn€

;pc moqj mbp pç cou.€jçiou pG66u ;pG nu9u cb9q wocmGuç2 111 MO

nubLcqc9pJG oncbnc uq BLICG IIJOAGWGIJç2 MP611 eflpiGcc GXCJU2LAGj?. co mOUGc9L?. 2JJOCJ2

O COLLGJ9OU GMGGU 1PG bLcG 9uq oncbnc 26L162 iL2ç 12 COLLG9OU GMGGU

IIJ9IfI qGLGUc COLLGI9c!0U2 o bL!c& oncbiic 9'IJq JJOJTL2 IIJOAGIIIGU;2 J 2LG22 MO OfJJGL c?bG2

0116 9A9U9G O MOLJUU MJJJ 9 2BGCIUC woq€j !2 IP9c 0116 C9U CJJGCJC 2 C0U2!2cG1JC? !1J

CJJ9UG2 9Uq GXbGCçGq Oncb nc CJJ91J62 OAGL J0U JJ0L!0u2

LP!2 WG91J2 JJ9 I1J0UGc9L? iwbnjaca GuGL9çG 9 UG9c!AG COLLGJ9cIOU CfMGGIJ cxbGccGq bLcG

Page 5: NBER - tog6061 · 2020. 3. 20. · J1G oLqou (oo) Gdn9oIJ 2 COU2!2cGIJ4 mcrxf pp nu€wbJo?uJGu; L9çc !2 922OCWG 1AçJJ anpaGdncuc 9jja u nuGmbJo2iiiGuc 9Uq (JCLL Ja!o) uq bL!C62

bei1id asd iuIsx9iII idi lo auo1 9di aflAV oi nivom iii .((IeI) nu'! (1I) noasW

inods ain9misie moil sws bus a1.subiei SLAV 9cli lo 8noitsi1qiini 1swi3u1i abiswo

anoiisvonni noms enoii.&Lsrioz 9d 4uodi) noiisfini bus iuqIuo lo nois1enoz Ilsievo di iuo beinioq svsd Blodiu.5 'nsm aA .(noin9is o iauoms iisI s b9vi31 eIld ii a9rLt lii

1uffiib n3ilo ai ii eaus35d iluoifiib al anoiisvonni SLAV edi oi efloiisi9lqisini IswiDulie nivi n3Vi ns oi ieth 13SM 111w asldshsv wonsobns lo noilsilidmoD 113111w hohq s snimisieb ol

I .esonsdiuieib 1siuiuiie 1iinsbi oi niiqmsiIs luorlliw a5IAV a e1sns I udT .borla

boda rbss aissil eiuisisii1 airiT .isqaei isrilons iii eiuisisiil SLAV edi mo1 iisqsb oais

ai rbirlw) isrilo class rliiw bsislsnoonu sis aborla edi isdi iii 'Ono ion i3rziiaib nisd as

3irrisn'b edi isdi th oafs hid (aboda 1sinerrisbrni1 lo lea ns lo inemsiuiipsi a Idsmuasiq

Dimsnb sill oi s3nsldrneasi ns ised ion been boda 0110 'ens ol monoe sill lo eanoqasi

111 'SW 1sDLqi 5f11 110 1sat3siq 20211301 eieIsna auIi laSLtff 03 H .ieifio iis 01 senoqasi

.aboda 10 dismisils sill ni inem'o1qms bits iuqiuo 1111w asvom-03 noilsflni cbidw

-ioD siom sis atnemevom siiq eld.5iDibsiq isrileriw ai iowans oi rlaiw I noiiaeup beisbi A

.bs1iow aiuod iii alnemevom eldsiDibeiq 1111w io ainemevom luqiuo sldsioibsiq 1111w beisLoi

-due c1uoi1i inem"o1qmsnu ol i1no bsislsi asw noitsIlni aqi11id d buia Lsriiho edt ni

cA .115w as 2flOi82515i tOfu iii diwoi iuqiuo bebulorn (OVI) nobioD s?111 esibuia ineupsa

lebom sill einomovom iuqiuo lo insnimioisb Ino sill ion ei lilidshsv 1isienOm as

1noile siom sd bluoda noziod rio1s isvo diwoi eeFxq b9ieqx9 isrli aiasua insaeiq I

oT .dbwoi ainod beleeqxs 113kw nsrIl diwoi liiqiuo bel3sqxs illiw belsisnoD (levilson) absel isdi asiiinuhoqqo 1s3io1onrbs1 11k snsrb bsl3eqxs 118 2k sisdi jail eaoqqua air1i sea

a ol absel oal.s cull 3i1oq 'islsnom eviaasq a ilhiW .iuqiuo iii sassi3ni beieeqxs ns 01

nO .dbwoi iuqiuo bits eiriq bsbsqxs lo hflsrflsVomoD sviissn a ol audi bits asq ni snib

asiiinuiioqqo LsDio1onfbei 111 sassini bsieeqxs aid dw noassi 011 81 siedi bnsrl isdio sill

lo sqi airli lo s3fIsiaiXs sill audT .aiuod ni sassi3ni na lo notisi3sqxs sill ol basi bluoda

I .diwoi eeiiq bits aiuod bei3sqxs neewbed notistooaas sviissn sill ansqmsb 'iilidshsv

r{iiw beisislioD acel bsebni ci diwoi aiuorf bsbeqxs ioI esiisa sill sisb sill ni isdi brifl

.diwoi luqluo bsl3eqxe iol eskise sill at nail r1lwoi eeiiq bsiDeqxe

C

Page 6: NBER - tog6061 · 2020. 3. 20. · J1G oLqou (oo) Gdn9oIJ 2 COU2!2cGIJ4 mcrxf pp nu€wbJo?uJGu; L9çc !2 922OCWG 1AçJJ anpaGdncuc 9jja u nuGmbJo2iiiGuc 9Uq (JCLL Ja!o) uq bL!C62

bopcX LG9C2 O }JG2G 2JJOCJ2 J9 ObGL9!OIJ9JfG dncçiou j cowb9LG q9 o NJJ!wbGcn2 pcpiuq onbnç CJJ9UG2 m9) pG IJOU-11JOIJGJ9L JJJG 211G 2 JJGIJ JJOM UJOUGI9LA

JJJG 2GCOUq CJ922 Oj, UJOGJ2 J couiqGr. 12 OIJCG 9 CJ922 o woqcj ThGLG OL!U9J

O LG9' 2OC2 }J9 L9J2G onbnr

bIO22GL (ioi) on;bnç uq bLTcG2 LT2G OG}JGL GC9I12G UJOIJG? L2G2 GUqOGUOfl2J? IIJ LG2bOIJ2G

uq oiibn 2 911 9LçJCG o flJG GIJqoGuGç2 0J 4JJG woii€? 2f1bbJ? ccoLqiu o yu 9uq

9uq JJO2GL (T4) ! MJJ!CIJ O11J LG9J 2JJOCJC2 911.6Cc Oiibnc Uq couuGcçiou PGM66U bucGa

ju b9Lc!cnJ9L3 J 2Cfl22 4MO O W0q6J2 JJJG 11L2 !2 2OLç o moqj 2n G2c6q p?. K'

moqj CcoU qi2Crra62 JJG 6L66 MJJ!Cp O1JJGL LtJOJGJ2 916 CO1122GIJ1 IAJJ IJJG uqIJ2

eInq?k oujA GLGC MJJ!CJJ jJG bLicG-onfbnç C0LLGJ9çiou2 916 COUai2çGUç MIçJJ 9 b9LcicnJ9L

M9 pG cmb!Lc9I 1Juqiu 2flG2 9ponç UJOIJGc9LX bojic? MPH6 G9LJIGL 26CçiOu2

2 !2 LUOLG 2bGCfll9c!AG P9IJ JJ6 bLGAion2 01162 IU bLoJqqG2 9 UJOLG GUGL9J q2CI122OU

f 4JTLU2 12 9IGUPOU 0 4pG COLLGJ9II0U PGMGGU bL!cG 9uq jJOflL2 CJJ9IJG2 GCOU

COLLGJ9IG MpijG LGA 0U2 oi ou€ dn9LcGL OLO11 916 bo2iAGJ? couGJ9q

bo2!c!Asj?k coLLGJ9c6q B'GA2!OU2 u bLGqcc9pJG IJJOAGUJGIJf 2 OACL jOU JJOL!S0112 916

ic !2 GL6 cv'i i 20M uJoqGJ lmbpG2 !1JIJOA94OIJ2 111 bLJCG2 9uq on;bn; 916

cçiou e ;p 9u9j22i2 o coLLGJ9c!oUa CMGGU bL!cc 9uq oncbnc moi€-

JJG 24LGIJJJ O 9220C19cIOIJ pmccu }JG2G 261162 !2 JJ9LGL 4O 922G2

COLLGJ9IG 92 916 JJG bL!cc 9uq oncbnc 2GL!62 o, C°°J Uq OP9U!9U (ii) j.,p

111 TIJJ9pOU B COUL924 GxbGCcGq iuu9ciou uq cxbccc€q oncbnc LOMP 916 AGL 2GL!9J1?

UJIUG MGfGL 4JJ6 LGM210U2 IU oiibii LOE4jJ 916 21U!11C9JJJ COLLGJ9G NJJJ }JG LGA1210U2

1iGLGIJ bO!Uc2 111 UJ6 916 rnJCOLLGJ9cGq IAJçJJ 69CJJ OçJJGL I 12 }J1T2 LGJ9çiA€J? 692?k Cj6cGL-

b9LCuTJ9L 9ccGZIc!OU 4O LGA12IOIJ2 !" GxbGqGq oticbii 9IJ bLc6LOIA GC9112G LGA!2!0U2 9i

cxbGcc6q C9U62 in bic 9Uq on;bnç 92 PAGJJ 92 L6M2!0U2 U jJG2G GxbGcc€q CJJ9IJG2 I

ponjq G IJG9ciAGJ? COLLGJ9c6q• iIj 2c!I 5 ] bLG2GIJç m2. P92!C UJGflJoq OL COU2cLnCc!u

bo2!c!A6J? LGJ94G !UUOA9IOU2 pi bLc62 MJJIIG bLGqcç9pJc IJJO1GUJ6U2 OAGL pOLOU2

pn2!11622 lCcII9ç10U2 j 2OM2 IJJ; ;p uoqsj !mbl!62 pc

Jp6 b9bGL bLoccGq2 92 tOjjOM2 6Cf IOU J bLG2Guca 9 AGL? 2c?qGq mOUGc9L? IJJOqGJ o

Page 7: NBER - tog6061 · 2020. 3. 20. · J1G oLqou (oo) Gdn9oIJ 2 COU2!2cGIJ4 mcrxf pp nu€wbJo?uJGu; L9çc !2 922OCWG 1AçJJ anpaGdncuc 9jja u nuGmbJo2iiiGuc 9Uq (JCLL Ja!o) uq bL!C62

qj Isnimon b9i33qx9 ir1i oa Di1oq ia vtiior1ius 'isienom sdi Ii biiuxo 9vsd bluow

iuqiuo ci eas3l3ni bb9qxe insieq no a 1subshtnuo3 airfi isbnU .iusiano3 ai dJwoi

I iSIIJ sisb £.U 911T .Jn&n9q no b cib9b eohq b9i5qx na iliiw besboaas 5d bkrow

.a riiiw b5isboaaa ai icqico ci 3a6913n1 bi39qx9 in9zrIeq eno a isdi biani woifa 'buia

in3ieianoD .11gw as 111 at b3i3qxe ed ri,s '1U0 Lanirnon isdi oa aeziiq ci eculDeb beiDeqx9

anoiior1 no1 1eviis1i ievo eaorli 1ishJ3iiq iuqiuo ci eeassiDni eidai3ibeiq aidi if liw

.'csnom lo iiinsup edi lo aewasem auoiw, edi ci aenibeb diiw beithoaas 1Laiene exs

baa) '1qqua enom erli nbubei lo i1oq £ woliol ol aiseqqa svieaeI Laieb&I eiLt audT

aA .eah at b iDeqxe ai iuqiuo &iedw aboiieq ciub (aeDilq ci anoibubsi nbubni aurli

eaii oi bebeqxe iaom ei iuqiuo eierlw aboiieq edi wor1a (1) biolbooW baa iedmio,H

baa aboiieq eaedi ci evibiiiaei ai 'çiloq 'iienom auriT .anoiaaeei lo amoiiod erli eis

en I ci beaanrnaib eis viLoq audi lo aiflened has aiao edT .anoi ei eaedi no1oiq ysm audi

.noibea nibuI3aoz

leboM 93j1q bi 91qm12 A .t

iedmeioH no beasd ai Jeborn emiT .eeiiq biia nIMw lebom elqmia .s ineaeiq I noliDea audi nil

aeiiq ninsib 10 aicoD DiisIbup aebuIDrii ii lanli ci (@@1) iejiioq baa iIuaiisH baa (8QI)

-inas 1aiiqa emoiixe edi at elqmia iqeA ci Lebom edT .tibih lanirnon lo enuoe cii as .bei3eIec sis lebom (QI) ieuiioq bins imusiisH erli lo ei3eqaa iedio nam bins noiislxicnr

Jail 1 oc 'iibiii e3ilq lo anoiis3ilqmi 1slice3 edi ceisnla leboin nwob beqqhia audi IIu1eqoH

esw no becad ecodi as rbua elebom eiiq vbiia iedio mail wofi bliow cnoiisu1qmi islimia

bsni9no3 918 iseis 9di as ill as ,iaekviupe ci eiiq ninsd3 lo aiao3 3iisib8up diiw f9bom edT 9dT .iiq i9di niiaujb1o bissad Jusiano, S vszf cmiii Lsubivibnii 9idw (C8QI) ovisO as tbua 19bom S ol

&di Janis.s 9n9biv9 (OI Ina bns o19I1sd50) imoaoosm bins (1Q1 qsc1as)I) imonooi3im rliod ci 111w miii s isdi (biscsd) 'iilidsdoiq 9113 sin1w el9bom bssiani aiovs1 33n8biv9 eidT .Iebom bisssd insieno3

I .iiq b91iab cii moil ailsq9b iiq nuiaix3 cii d3idw oi in9ixe 9113 Si (iia89i3fli ci eiiq cii 3fLsrb al9bom 3vij3iliasl 19viis131 Eno 11isnuJio1nU .Iebom biscsd insicfIo3-uon £ d3ua au oi 19lIq cmli bluow

odw (I) rfsJ bus nilqsD ai as b9ibuia lduoiodi 3com 9dT .935b 03 b9vloa nd 9vs11 9q3 aidi lb ai1n aiilT .1Isw mobusi s awollol nom 113111w iii a93nq ninsib lb aiao b3xiI diiw I3bom S

audi I .insiioqmi aisqqs w9iv lb inioq Lsiiiqme us moil ,d3idw diwoi euom ni noiisleno3 Lsiisa 9113 muftno '11suin9v3 111w aI9bom biscsd irisienlo3-non sili isdi 9qoxl 9113 iii lebom iao3 Diisibsup 9113 au 9113 b9nino ci iiLsiiusn-rion 'isinom as 181 as 3a831 IA .91911 b&l9biano3 is isdi anoii3ib9lq 1siin

.aico3 3iiaibsup no basd cia'1sns ii1is rli muftno3 a9ob l3bom (QI) ds9J-nu1qsO

Page 8: NBER - tog6061 · 2020. 3. 20. · J1G oLqou (oo) Gdn9oIJ 2 COU2!2cGIJ4 mcrxf pp nu€wbJo?uJGu; L9çc !2 922OCWG 1AçJJ anpaGdncuc 9jja u nuGmbJo2iiiGuc 9Uq (JCLL Ja!o) uq bL!C62

.(O8f) io1T baa (VT1) i1b8i'I d biaadqm9 miol 8di 10 nui3siirxo3

.boo bei.aiin311Iib eno Bewbo1q dzirlw lo ibae ab1or1eeuod bevi1-1eiinftth V ei eiedT

oi merli eu idi &nift eviiiieqmo Lbeheq 'd beaarbwq eis Bboo beisiineieTlib eer{T

-3nul noii3ubolq eL&e oi enwiei iaaiano3 ohiemrna edi ol nib1o3Ds iuqiiro Lnft eDIJbolq

:aoLt

(1)

mift eviiiieqmo '1ioeheq edi lo iuqiuo edi ineeoiqei { noiiupe eirli iii

* e3nq a e1sfb aadi ieulio (thlodeauod) anrth ILa idi eaoqqu .' boos 10 iuqni au e erli (1O1) friolbooW baa iedmeio5I iii eaaiani iol nworia eA . i aiDubolq iiedi iol

boos iol baameb eieia erli irIi 1qmi nerli (1) lo ariiuisi laflianoD baa 'iiemmve

id nevi ai

() (){= baa

el5flW

O>(1)' baa I=(1)b .<= ol nibiox blorleeicocl lo xodsl en I aethspei boos beiiinei&1uib lo noiiDubolq silT

noii3nul noii3ubolq sill

() 0> " 0 <'s. =

lo eiaia sill lo xsbni ru ai 'i( baa emil is blodeansoif 'd beFrow aiuod edi sis 'jil eiedw

id nsvi el bloi{eauod 10 yiiliiu ILsievo edT . ts volonnlDsi

() —

(S)ol] — — =

sill 1i1qmie oi lasem sis Jan11 anoiiqmue.s 10 isdmun .s asibodme noibnul 'ii1iiu culT

1.6 51.61 1.651 sill aexft noiiqmueno3 lo noibnul s as 'ii1iJu lo 'Jn.6sfluI sill leii'I .eiajjsn.6

zsiiq rHnsrb lo aieoz sill JaIl )asl siLl iliod bnoDs .bsinuooaib is eiiloiq emiul ibidw

sill i1i1qmia noiiqmuanoD ioI sld.6Iisva luqino sill s3ubsi Ion ob eilJ 1.6111 baa Dii.6ibsup Sis Iiliiu sill illod saisi ( vo1onrbsJ flu einemsvoiqmi isill ci noiiaDlIiIqmia 1snft sIT .aia'jsaa

o

Page 9: NBER - tog6061 · 2020. 3. 20. · J1G oLqou (oo) Gdn9oIJ 2 COU2!2cGIJ4 mcrxf pp nu€wbJo?uJGu; L9çc !2 922OCWG 1AçJJ anpaGdncuc 9jja u nuGmbJo2iiiGuc 9Uq (JCLL Ja!o) uq bL!C62

— jo(j')J3} ()+—i f;+—i\ f f'ii+jr+ f'j+D

___ + __'I I " I.!?__ —Ui —

L clb;+1 1 —j

JjJi2 conbj€q () 9Uq pC; (2) !2 puqu !mbJ?. ;JJ9 (f) C9U G ML!IICU

= .'J-I())

(!)

nnbJiG2

1JJ!2 moq o bLoqnc6 9u?;p!u o1JJGL cp9Ir IJJG 9UJOflU 2 20Jq3 lG qGuJ9uq jIucr!ou ()

9LG JJG 291UGi JJG JGAGJ O O9J bnLcp92 Wfl2 GcJn9J I\' UCG JJGLG 2 U0 LG920U

COu2L9!Uc (2) 2cL!C!?. ppJqu JJJJ!2 WG91J2 9ç 9 2?JJJUJGLiC 6dnppLcrw MJJGLG jjbi.c(20 JJ9 +1) 12 211J9JJGL JJ9U OUG tOL 9JJ JJG ponpojq MJJJ CJJOO2G cO UJ9G UG

jou JJG GxbGcfGq L9G o bLicG qG9ou tLOIJJ .. ;o i. + j ! 2LIJ9JJGL 9U 4G qeconuc LYTG

/AJJGLG 9LG 0AGLUWGU4 L9IJ2GL2 0 mOUG? MJJCJJ 9LG UJ9G !U JfiUJb 2JIUJ 92pOU V2

= i(x)+ — + i' ()JJG Ofl2GOJ2 IUcGLcGUJbOL9'J pnqç Cou2çL9!uç 12 1AGU pi

ThJJGLG 1J 12 JJG 9W0flU4 0j WOUG JJOJ12GJJOJ LJ2 OAGL LOIJJ bGLoq ; — i bLçCIiJL

(2)

mOuGL? bOJ!CX bJ9)2 9 L0JG ] C0U2GL 9 2IJJbJG c9'2p-u-9qA9ucG COU2cL9!iJc 0 JJG 0LW

ju9'J ooq içp 4JJG bLoqr1crou jIIUCrIOU (j) 12 eojq 9ç 9 bic O i 92 MGJJ J40 GU2IILG

flJGIL onbnr LGLGCf combGçipou JJGU GU2flLG2 OfTçbllç o pG 11Lm2 bLoqricu JJG

V JJG 2)UJJWGçLIC GdrnhrpLInw I COU2iqGL 9JJ JJ0I12GJJOJ2 C9LG G 29UJG bL!cG j OL

bLoqncpou pi2 GU2ITLG 2GCITJ9L JUCLG92G2 y, qo uo JG9 26CffJ9L CJJ9IJG2 !U JJOIIL2

JJLJJ2 (Tc) 922flUJbl!OU 4JJ9 GCpuiC9J bLoL6a2 12 4G 29WG U JJOUJG 9uq m9LJG4

O tAOLJ 9Uq 4pG q2nfl om bLicG CJJ9UG2 L!2G !Mf p 'i ri LGGUMO0q1 jOGL20U 9uq

29UJG cpu1c9J bLoLG2e bLoqncçiou o W9LJGç onbriç 2 LG2flJ pG q2f1JflçX

JJG 9'JcGLu9çA6 0 W9LJCG4 bLoqnc;ou !a bLoqcicçiou tOL JJOUJG 112G 9Uq JJOUJG bLoqnccou

CO22 0 !AOLJqU 9uq JJG flJ CO22 0 L9J21J bLCG2 JJJJG 2UJbJG2 L9IOU9JG tOL cP!2 !2 çpc

Page 10: NBER - tog6061 · 2020. 3. 20. · J1G oLqou (oo) Gdn9oIJ 2 COU2!2cGIJ4 mcrxf pp nu€wbJo?uJGu; L9çc !2 922OCWG 1AçJJ anpaGdncuc 9jja u nuGmbJo2iiiGuc 9Uq (JCLL Ja!o) uq bL!C62

8

(!) qGb€11q2 011 (\''f) IUOL!U C0U29U2 fJJG JoJUG9L6q AGL2!OU oj (o) 12

(i°(''\')) MPGU C9LL? U oiiç fJJ!2 10J1UG9L!9f IOU I f9J6 1UO 9'CCOI1Uf p6c9n26 0j

JUG 40 J0JiUG9L!G (o) 9LOI1Uq 2çG9qX 2ç9'fG A9J1162 o 9UcJ

;p€ CC0IJ0UJ C9U G €XbGC4Gq 40 LGUJ9!U UG9L !c2 q€fcLwu2çc 2cc9q? 29çG JJpI2 9JJ0M2

]36C9112G ;JJG2G bLocG22G2 91€ 2c9c!0U9L? 9uq 922flUJU 9 2ç9pJç2 couqçou 2bGJJGq oriç GJ0M

112G9q 4JI9 IIJOIJGA L0ThJJ 9uq 6CJJU0J0 L0MJJ tOJJOlA 2c91!OU9L? 2cOCp92c!C bLoc62eG

LGdIJ!L62 JJ9 møu€? Uq GCJIU0J0 LOM 9 9 C0U29U L94G [ 9'221111JG

CoU249'Uç 92 J0U 92 (jo('+1\g)) uq (jo('j+'\y)) 9LG COIJ29U jp!a 2cG9q? 2ç9G

uiucou o (o) JI92 9 2;G9q 2ç94G 2OJ1I10U 111 MJJICJJ JJOITL2 9UcJ 9LG

j1 uq 'J ou Of pGL p9uq () 1111b1162 JJ9c JJOJIL2 9169 qGGLuJuecc

Edfl9!011 () W9JG2 iApicp qGbGuq2 OIJJ%. 011 JJOi1L2 moLJGq jjrucçou ot it\

011 UJ9LJG 9C4iAiç? (2111C6 JJOfl2GJJOJq2 WfI2 pojq C92JJ 0L 0116 bGLoq PGtOLG JJG C9IJ COU2I1UJG)

119112611 (1088Y ;JJG uoq€j 9J20 !uJbJ!62 cpc !11Uc!0U L6f1CC2 onçbn; GC9112G iç Cça

moLJcGq. Jpn2 fl2fWJ imbcqccç coujb€çi ou JOMGL2 9LG9f onbn 2 111 C00JG 9U

L1-'!2 !U IULU IIUI)J1G2 p9' oribnç 12 211J9J1GL 2!IJCG \ 2 1UCLG92!IJ 9uq '12 qGcLG92iU 111 JJOITL2

pn2 iwbp€ UJ9LJU9J qrIc1Jc tLOUJ bLoqriciU 911 9qqiriou9! ooq UJff2f pG 2UJ9JJGL

2flp2Jçfl;9pTJJ;A o ooqa ImbilGa P9c ! J9LGL (ponp W112f p€ 2w9JJGL - I0 4JJG UJ9LU9J 114flç? 0 C0U2flUJ!IJ 011€ 9qqr0U9J (IU1 0 JJ€ 9LG9G ooq JmbGLGcç

11691 0U6 111 ;P! C92& ;pG uJ9Liu9J qi2nfflI o bLoqnciu 011€ 11U! o ooq s 12 Gdn9J

4JJG q2conu 9CçOL 12 21119JJ (20 \ ! UG9L 0116) 9U JJGLG 12 110 !UU9T1011 cJ112 GXbLG22IOLT 12

J JJG qGLu9uq tOL G9CJI Uqiiq1I9J ooq 12 AGL? G192f!C (20 % 9 J9LG 1JG9çJAG urTuJpGL)3

W9 ipcp 12 W ojbLoqncu ou€ 9qqç0U9J nrnç 12 cdn9J

f JIG 9p2GUCG 0, C022 0 CJJ9U!U bL!c62 1.GJAJIGU C 12 Gdn9J 0 SGL0 JJ!2 Gdll9clOU !Lubl!G2

(e)

i [\(q(j)+ T)' —

tJ)]—

c(Jo('b;)—

jo('J)) + '__\c(jo(+I) —

1JL2 oLqcL coUqIpoU (€A9Jn9çGq 9ç pc 2?unuGçLIc GdrnppLrnw ThJJGLG % 12 €dnccj o ') 12

ob1w9J bL!cG 12 JJfl2 Op9UGq p? (g) icjJ L62b€Cç o pi2 bL!c€ Jp€ LG2(!Ic!U

111 Gdn9çiou ouj?. q€qou 1p!cp p92 911 OU ITçJJI 12 CJJOICG O ' JJJJ€

Page 11: NBER - tog6061 · 2020. 3. 20. · J1G oLqou (oo) Gdn9oIJ 2 COU2!2cGIJ4 mcrxf pp nu€wbJo?uJGu; L9çc !2 922OCWG 1AçJJ anpaGdncuc 9jja u nuGmbJo2iiiGuc 9Uq (JCLL Ja!o) uq bL!C62

d nsvi

(01) 0 = [(.— tt— ist)r+(q— x÷tc)13

elidw aiii1 qqu eviieqai 9d1 lo mdhiiso1 sill insesiqsi aislisi 9&83 iswol eisifw \ lo enoii3nnl sis emismsisq ssrli lo owl iaill silT .eisismsisq sviiiBoq sis baa ' illiw 9 baa 's lo asviisviisb sill bits basmsb lo lbilasls sill slsi noiisfini sisia bssla sill

lo sisi ssisvs sill ai sisriw ( + 1)iz\ ol Isups ai isiemsisq biiD silT .W ol i3sqasi

ssisvs sill Ii ois ai ' auilT sDiiq lo diwoi lo sisi ssisvs sill ai bits '1. 10 i1iwoi

sill iii bits lLama cissd asil sisi noilsilni ssisvs .2.U sill isili nsviD .ois ai noiisflni lo sisi .awollol isilw iii oie ol Laups isismsisq audi isa audi I Jbilqmia lo lasisirti

noilsups iliaiisimisrb saodw ni noilsups 33ns1s1ib isbio bno3sa 5 ai (01)nouisupa

noiiuloa sviaolqxsrton supinu a asri noilsups audi 81) iedmslo$I iii eA .aiooi owl asil

d nwoila aA .srio nsili isisl ai isrilo sill liilw sno nsdi is1lsma ai aiooi sasill lo sno Ii

3111 ol noiiufoa supinu sill xoI Jisqorq airli svsd oats laum aiooi sill (81) bioThooW

usd1 noiiuloa silT .() ol noiiuloa sill ol Laups lsismixoiqqs sd 01(01) noilsupo bssiissnil

as is Isvsl siiq sdi asvi

(11) {+— 1)(— 1)+ =

.noilsups Diiarisi)slsfb sill lo looi isrlio sill al ?\1 bits sno nsrli isllsma iooi sill ei siorlvt

rbidw d risvi al iwbrnq aiilT .wolsd sloi £ aslq ?\ aiooi owl sill lo i3uboiq silT

93ni2 .i\t& lo suisv sIsia 'bssie sill ai YI\ sisdw —

alsups ) niau

.sno nsdl isisl ai aiooi sill lo iouboiq aiill sno usd1 isliarna ai \ bus sviissri ai 1 + 'b

sill 'd nsvi ai m sisrlw sasz sill ilhiw bsn1s3no sd Iliw I asaoqwq svilsiiaulli io'I

:aaso1q Diiasil3oia niwollo1

($1) + (..itt — rt)t = —

lo eeu silT .insianoD ai zt isril llsiiini smuaas I bits .b.i.i ai bus isismsisq a ai n eisilw

sill nisd as bswsiv sd bluorla sit ) nsviD .visihidm 'leiiins ion ai aasoiq oiiasiboia airli

Page 12: NBER - tog6061 · 2020. 3. 20. · J1G oLqou (oo) Gdn9oIJ 2 COU2!2cGIJ4 mcrxf pp nu€wbJo?uJGu; L9çc !2 922OCWG 1AçJJ anpaGdncuc 9jja u nuGmbJo2iiiGuc 9Uq (JCLL Ja!o) uq bL!C62

To

i6bL62GU!OU 0 JJ6 1W6 GLIG2 pGJJ9AiOL O J1fOç6UJp6L (j) uq trn (ii) 2flG2f Mrçp bo!AG uq o ponç (j) 12 bLaiwouion22iu!ucilc In LGL62210IJ xbjiijiii IJ3G JO qq€L6uCG Iii UOIJJUJ CDb P 2 9J20 MOLJJ UO!U pc pOcJJ

wbLicnJ& uGrçJJGL J1L}JGL J92 OpC C}JUG III IJOW!IInI 0Db UOL qGcGLwna4c Luq LG 22IC1!

bLpcnJL iç L9i2c2 jpc i'ja€ ;pc oL U pG t9'L pcnLG p) c;\(j — tt) JGoçpci puq c bGLuusu Gj6cç ou p€ JCAGJ o iuouc?. 2nbbJ? ju

I —— (se)

pA p€ CXG1Jç 0 fl2 !IJ!c!9J qGcfluG IJ9WGJ2

JOD LIIU C[GC oU onibn !U JJ!2 inoqcj onbnç L0Th LoW o !UUUj 2 LGA2Gq 11bM9Lq2

140Th COU2ICJGL LGM2JOU2 IU JJC LOThçJJ o onbn tLOUJ ou/A9Lq2 ucc t p uo

Juno! !ou2 iu pop 2GLG2 ponjq pG bo2;!AcJ coLLCj9'Gq

LoMçp o uJ0u62 o pG eçpoui) bL!c62 uq onfbn4 WoAC !' 4JJG 29111G qLCcOu jpne ;JJG

CXCGG2 OUG 20 JJ 2 JOUR 2 t ! 2UJJJGL cjJu ou€ (Mp!cp LGdnLGq OL IJJG LG O

p? !-€ uq L912G2 oubnç pX 2 MG 2'M pot.c bLoqrlc; 0j ;pc po L002

0u2qGL 1JL JJG !uuol !ou2 !u oriçbnç uq bL!c JJJG 2pocJ c L9!2G2 bL!cG JGAGJ

=' +—

(c + (s1 — ns)) (12)—

oi pc joiiçpw oj ouçbn— b 20 pc (Ta) !mbJ!62

(b — b11) = — b) + (t + (r — — 1—3)) (N)

20 fI2iU (j5) ouc€ iij iuJ9ç1ou 12 fGU

= + —c;i) (13)

fl2!U () uq iu0uu (jj) pGCOUJ62

bL!cs 9uq oiiçbiiç UJ0AGUJGIJ2 go uoç LGdIT!LG UX U0IJ-UJ0IJGL? 2J10CJC2

C0nUçGLTCçJ1J pii Ic 9'JJ0M2 LUG o GWOU2LG cJc cIJG 21IJ2 0 }TG COLLGJOU2 GPAGGU

yc uc j 9'2211W6 12 JJG ouj2. 2p0CJ GCc!U JJG G0U0UJ? 9' 2 0pA!O1T2J?

MCfl qcecLpcq p? (15) t pG!U Gd119J 12

J0 0 U0LUUJ CDb I 11LU2 0fl JJ9f JJG GAOIIIc!OU 0 JJ2A9L!PJG !U boa;-ML fl q99 2

Page 13: NBER - tog6061 · 2020. 3. 20. · J1G oLqou (oo) Gdn9oIJ 2 COU2!2cGIJ4 mcrxf pp nu€wbJo?uJGu; L9çc !2 922OCWG 1AçJJ anpaGdncuc 9jja u nuGmbJo2iiiGuc 9Uq (JCLL Ja!o) uq bL!C62

311158 sdi d '1JsuPn3v5 aaii 13v91 3D11 9111 15111 a9ilqmi audi looda edi 10 ii1siiu9ux nui noL

edi (11eaii nsdi eael ai ibidw) 31j alsupe eah Isiini a1eve1 eohq erli isdi neviD .inuoms

alsupe iinflni ol rrtoil dJwoi soiiq bsiDeqxe 111 1 is noiaivei

(\ (u—1)+(?— 1) ' ) (—I)(u—1)

beislerlo3 'Ieviisen ak noiaaelqxe 5(11 noiaae1qxe airli flu eviiiaoq al lo inebffieo3 edi eni .(O1) ni noiaivsi diwoi iuqiuo edi (111w

iii .noiislei evilsen aidi lo ebuiirism Is3niqme ecu eijs oi iaeieini lo oats ai 11

ai diwo iuqiuo nedw aeaii noiaivei ecilq ecu doidw 'd inuoms ecu siuqmo I 1sluDxJIsq

airli 1 is bor1a lno ecu ai isili emuaas oi niuniJnoD .ineuieq eno d ebiswnwob beaivei

II .(1) cii noiaaslqxe sdi oi (Vt) cii noi2asqx9 ecu lo oilsi edl lo eviissn ecu d nevi ai

alsurpe audi

81' — + —

(u —

I) + ( —

1)u ¼ I (u—)(u—1) — (—)(—1)

no1 aA .(oie al i Ii eno aLsupe li aseiedw) eviiiaoq li3nia al u as no1 as eno abesexe rbidw

u{iwoi sDiiq evtiiaoq £ ieils niaii eunuiclo3 oi beieqxe ai 'enom isili oa eviiiaoq ai u as .afriswriwob beaivsi ai r{iwo luqiuo usd1 eiom d abiswqu beeivei ai abiswrio I moil

diwoi ecthq bus luqino ui anoiaivei 'c1rio belevoD asri eia'1srrs edi inioq audi ol qtJ

awollol ii 1uH .eia[sns LaDiliqifie edi auDol 111w I rbidw no ai3ejdo 5(11 ei.s eaedi eausDsd

ed laum Jinftni oi I moil diwoi iuqiuo lo noiisiDeqxe Ilsievo sf11 Isdi (1I) bits (.t) moiI

oa) noiiod emsa 5(11 ievo diwoi eoiiq lo rioiisi3eqxe Ilsievo edi 1111w beislenoo ijjeviiserr

.(beisleiioD 1eviisen eis iuqluo bus &iiq lo aeulsv bsbneiieb noa1e14-ebiieveEI sill isdi

as3neuflni eviiiaoq liexe lo aeulsv bes! eviiiaoq idi aeilqmi (M) isril sion aidi sea oT

eviiiaoq £ Jiexe lo u1sv bssi eviliaoq isdi eeilqmi (I) 'hs1imi2 .noiisfini inertuD no

all oi riiulei oi bei3eqxe aiswLs al iuqiuo eausoeH .iuqixio lo level inenuD edi 110 5DfiSiJfihL

ui anoiiwbei boiDeqxe oi bssl 'lo aeulsv bes1 eviiiaoq isdi aeilqmi audi ,level elsia bseia iinftni oi I moil iuqluo ui ainernevom beiDeqxe 858USD evi1ieoq 'ns io1 audT .iurqiuo

• ernsa sill 'd beausD eiiq ui ainemevom bebeqxe sill as nia eiiaoqqo sill evsd isdi

beislerioD leviissn eis iuqiuo bus eiiq cii ainemevom beiDoqxe easdi isdi 81 iluaei silT

II

Page 14: NBER - tog6061 · 2020. 3. 20. · J1G oLqou (oo) Gdn9oIJ 2 COU2!2cGIJ4 mcrxf pp nu€wbJo?uJGu; L9çc !2 922OCWG 1AçJJ anpaGdncuc 9jja u nuGmbJo2iiiGuc 9Uq (JCLL Ja!o) uq bL!C62

T5

(T8)

10 pOITL2 CJJ9UG2 J1JJJG LC9201J !2 ;p'; (j) uq () !WbP IJJ9T fG JO 0 JJOJIL2 ! AGIJ p2

CIAGU JJ I 9AG IJOLG C1J9UG2 IJ ' ;p 90AG 9bbj!c2 macp ;o oaçbnç

iu buce L0M1 OAGL 2JJOL JJOL1OU2

LGM2JOIJ2 IU 0fib1T4 LOIA4 OAGL 2JJOLI pOL1OU2 9LG 9J20 uG9c!AGJ) COLLGJ94G IA!1JJ LGA!2OU2

;p!2 moqGJ oaçba; cxbGc;Gq s;; ;o mo, mouo;ouc9JJ) 9CJ ;o ;pc 2G9 2;9;G pn&

UG9!AGJ? COLLGJ9Gq MTflJ LGA!2!0U2 !' bLicG LOMçp OtGL 9IJ9J0Ofl2 JJOL0U2 B1 1I!J

onçbn; LGAGL2 p9CJ 4O UOLUJ9J 20 LGAI2IOU2 111 oiibii LOM OAGL JOUR pOLIOU2 9LG

OLGOAGL 1J'I woqcj 9J20 !wbIc2 9f bL!CG2 L2!IJ 9'IIGL 9 UJ0UG9L !IJ1GCIIOU MpiJG

20 ouc cu cxbccç iuuo!pou2 ru bucca 'IJq oIT;bflç 0 pG b02!;!AGJ? COLLGJ9;Gq

J12ç J1JG pJ 1P! 0IJG !uiJ0A940U2 !IJ IUOIJGX JG9 J0 UCLG92G2 u po;p onçbnç uq bLcG2

cou;L92ç 1ATJJ ;pc moucç9L? uioqcj o CPc!'° uq E!CP 911111 (5) JU jJI UJ0qGJ

po;p bLice uq onçbnç LOM OAGL uex; bGLoq j,pa bLGqc;ou bnça ;pJa uoqcj u ap9Lb

112 a;cq) 29G I9JnG J.,pna 9 boaiçTAc c JGqa ouc LGA!26 nbM9Lq2 0UG2 0LGC9'2f 01

couqiçiou 12 mc; 9 boa!;IAG jcqa ocr;brrç 10 L2G IIILIJJGL L0UJ 110 1+ J G0LG Ic LGAGL2

JJJG2G MO LGA!2!0U2 9LG b0aAGK COLLGJ91G€J 92 J0IJ 92 (c + ) GXCGGcJ2 OIJG jp€u p!2

j —

[c + (r — 2)] —

Mp!JG JJG coLLc2bouqu LGAJ2JOU 0 bicc L0M !2

T —[c+ci—j]

onçbnç L0M 0W 110 1 + jç jojjoiAa Lom () IP!2 cdnja

01 buce uq onçbnç L0M OAGL jou poLiou2 0u2qGL !u B9L;!CITJ9L JJG LGA!2J0U 1

PGIMGGU PG2G 21J0L CLW LCAI2!01J2 C9U JJ9AG JJG obboi 2iii 92 JT6 COLLGJ9;IOIJ 01 LGAJ2IOU2

c9'ff? cowbcl!u UJ0UG;9L? moqcja ju b9L;!cnj9L ;JJG moqcj !mbJG2 flJ1 JJG COLLGJ91!0U

O'-' LGU2OIJ IOL qou 20 2 IJJ9 11J626 C0LL€J90U2 C9U 2GLAG 40 qa;yrqap JJ2 iuoqcj GWb!L-

UOM ;riLu m? 9IIGUIIOD 0 LGM2JOU2 !U onçbn; 9uq bI.!cc L0M OAGL 2JJ0LGL p0L!0U2

Page 15: NBER - tog6061 · 2020. 3. 20. · J1G oLqou (oo) Gdn9oIJ 2 COU2!2cGIJ4 mcrxf pp nu€wbJo?uJGu; L9çc !2 922OCWG 1AçJJ anpaGdncuc 9jja u nuGmbJo2iiiGuc 9Uq (JCLL Ja!o) uq bL!C62

T3

111 rpie cdniou \J1 LCbLG2GUç2 2OWG bnpJiepGq (oL ocxj) mou ocJc mjnj r¼M

(50)

coaibou€ua:

OLUT9IJ? 2flbb026 P !2 (i2G O 29fj2J ( 1J1 COU2!22 O MO

o Mpicp mou€z.%. bojc? 12 Gxb9ua!ou9L? jo 266 4G cowbJ!c9!ou uAoJAGq 2OW6MJJ94 IJJOLG

(2o LGdn!LG uo cpi'u u bicc) L94JJGL JJ9IJ L6bL62Gu1J 9 CJJ9IJ6 !U cJJ GL6C

CGIJL9J p9IJJc 2 9 L62(TJ W9U? O }JG UJOAGWGU2 111 VIT LGBLG2GUç L!OIJ 0 AJO! 2P!T.2

rn jè 0L 4L9U29CçiOU2 J,pG LG2f1Jf!1J CJJ9UG2 !IJ AGJOCç? 9LG OGU f 4JJG

CJJ9IJG2 OI6L 1WG IU JJG GLG6 MJJJCJJ bGobJG i126 9uI b9LçicnJ9L 26 o 922G2 2i1C 92 4JJO2G

GLGG o ipicp bGobJG 9/ 9'CC622 922G2 fp9 jp'cipç9 GCOU flJGLG 9LG

20 PT !4 ' flUJ1JCJ?k j (oL 9u? OGL 2iUJbJG 21111J UJOUG9L? 9L69S) UJG9VTLG2 JJG

2POL1COIJJ1J2 E1L2 9 A9L!6 O qqJGLGUç 922G2 916 1126q UT 9 A9L!G O q6LGu L9U29CçJOu2

JGAGJ O 92 911 Uqc94oL o qcLcc ;o IApTcp mou6ç9L? bojicX 12 cxb9u2!ou9L2. 92 2OWG

J1J-'!J O2G LG2flJ2 bLoiqqc 2OLIJG 2ITbbOLç oL pc uJoqi3 i 12 CJG9L cp fJJG 1126 oj IJJG

jJG 6uJbL!c9J ijiqiç? o AGL 2flJ9L UJOqGJ fl2UJ Jo9L!cpw o jpj W692ITLG OL

c!q L24 lJJG PGP9A!01 O Inoucç9L? 9LG9G2 I'J J{OGWpGL (5) j rurjXqJJJuc on b6cç2 O uJoqj JJ94 916 UJOLG T11C1qGU9J

LOJiJi B COUfL92 pGJJ9'A1OL O UJOUGç9L? 9 LG9I62 IJq L94G2 O LG1TLU 2661112 lO

opI€cciic o woqj MJJ!cp 12 q62JuGq o bL!c€ onbnç

COLLGJ9çlOIJ2 266111 UJOLG LOfI2 9ç JG92 in 2OUJG L62b6Cç2 ju b9Lç 26UJ2 tLOUJ I}JG UJ9!IJ

iiq IJJOU69L? 9LG9rG2 JJpG L69'201J 12 ;jiç JJ6 UJOGJ2 !UJbJ!C9!OU2 OL bL!CG-Oflcbf1

on onbn bL!cGa 9uq O11L2 MJJIJG U6J6Cc!IJ ;p GIJJb!L!C9J PGJJ9A!OL O Uf6LG24 L962

B6°16 CJO2U JJ2 2CCOJJ J qi2CfT22 IAJJ) GIubiLic9J 9U9122!2 bnç2 20 I1J(ICJJ 2L622

;pG bI4cG-porn.2 COLLGJ9çiOU2 211 G2 9p0f1

110 CJJ9UG2 !U JJJGIJ JU GCfJOU fTL1J O 1AJJ9 4JJG qJjGLGUCG2 JU J16 bLJcG-orlçbnç uq

onbnç COLLGJ9!O1J2 9IJ 266 O MJJ9 GXç6Uç p6X 9LG COU2I2çGIJç MJçJJ 9 UJOGJ 111A0JA62

COLLGJ9I1OU 0 9Uq ? içp bLJcG2 O CJJ9IJG2 JU pi 2GCc!Ou 2 I MJJj OCfl2 OIJJ?. OH JJG bLJcG-

MJJGLG 9' COGfflC1GUç 2W9JJGL JJ9'1J 0U6 JjJfl2 IJJoqGJ 9cfLJpncG2 JIjGL6UCG2 JU J-1G

Page 16: NBER - tog6061 · 2020. 3. 20. · J1G oLqou (oo) Gdn9oIJ 2 COU2!2cGIJ4 mcrxf pp nu€wbJo?uJGu; L9çc !2 922OCWG 1AçJJ anpaGdncuc 9jja u nuGmbJo2iiiGuc 9Uq (JCLL Ja!o) uq bL!C62

N

TUGLbLGç 1J WOLG pLoqJ? 92 IJ Ic6LIwl!A6 rLU9Cf7O1J 4GCJJIJOJO

2J,p€ CJOG !U2cfl;!0UI 9IJJO OL 1tk !2 cJJG 2;OCJC O CCLc!IIC9TG2 pfl; I bcci. ornc uq ojc€? (i) tOL UJOLG LGJi2pc uoqj M6L6 eoiiic ooq cU p brncp€q Oil

0L !UJbJ2!I3 IJJ 9'II 1JCLG2G IJ JJG WOUG 2fibbJA JGq2 4O 9 1IJCLG926 LT

140M COIJ2qGL JJG pGJJA1OL O L9G2 J<iu (j) p cL1ç1c1q e1cJ bLc6 UJGJ2

pop oribiiç uq iuçou 12 MGJGUGq

2lOCJ LG2bouq 0 AL1910U2 !U !U OLGL ;o 2pJJiG 1J 4JJG COUUGCOU 6M66U \M

u iji n2ç 2 qo ALW10U2 !U B !U20i.L 2 CJJ9UG2 111 OjC!J UJ692ilLG2 °T, mou€2

JJJJGLG I2 0 C0J1L2G 110 LC2OU 9220U16 12 COIJ29'IJ A9LWç10U2 169(1 O A9L!9OU2

uc6 () puqu 1u1b1162 12 JJG !6Jocif o cJLcnJ9çiou o 0JJCJ9J WOUG?I

= ()woucA o pc b9Lç o ocwj mouc? ocjc Jpn&Ju bçicnj 922111176 JJG poripojq 2GCfOL 92 9 Th0JG IA9U 9 L9'cc!0u J\J\ ot PG!L

CJJ9L9CccL!2!C2 O 4JJG 922G42 qGçGLwiuG JJG L9Cçi0u Oj G9CJJ 4}Wç jic? Miap pojq

4JJ6 722116L M01TJ 266111 O G 1uqu[6LG1Jc GM66U JJG M0 J 928111116 9L6 201116 0JJ6L

j2 92 L9IC 0 LC11LU !2 C0IJCGLIJG(1 I uq 1JX 9LG pG 291116 20 JJ0f12GJJOJ2 OçJJGL JJ9U

o quiuq uq G 6U62 ThGU bGobJG cpoo o pojq IJJOLG 2

JJ6 2llbbflGL !2 oc€q 4O L€(1G6IJJ 111112 0 9J6LU9AG WOIJ6) 0L OfflCJ9J 0116 J bGobJG

MJJGLG 1js 9LG JJG 2f1bbJiGL2 OfflCiJ 1JJoUG? JJoJq!u2 9'ç pc pGuuu o + j pç= '1i(w) + — + ?' + ti?' — (51)

!UfGLcGaTb0L9J pnqç COU2L9iU 12 JJGU

omu bnLcp9262 9uq 4JJ9 JIG C9UU0 06L ;o b92 !U;GLG2c 013 IJJ!2 W0UG? luG 211bbJ!GL32

JJ9c OUfX 0116 9GU4 C9U 122(16 4JJT2 W0IJG 9GU C9UU0 1126 JJ12 uJoUG? 0L JJ12

, nbbo 4JJ9 JJGLG 12 9 LG24LTcçJo1J 0U JJG enbbj) 0 JJG 9JcGLU9çIAG IJJOIJG?i 1S% J 922111316

LG9J!2f!C) (0LW9Ji9ci0U 0J 1q69 JJ9 11161110(12 0 bm€uç OçJJGL m0UG? 9LG

GX126UC6 0 p12 9JGLU91AG jOLW OJ bw6uç LGbLG2GUI2 9 2!UJbJG (çponp 110 IJGCG229L!J?

LGbLG2Gul2 wouG? bLo!qGq p?, IJJG bLIA91c 2GC0L IJ 201116 0LIJJ 1JJ1 !2 IJ0 LuG2nL6q JJJG

Page 17: NBER - tog6061 · 2020. 3. 20. · J1G oLqou (oo) Gdn9oIJ 2 COU2!2cGIJ4 mcrxf pp nu€wbJo?uJGu; L9çc !2 922OCWG 1AçJJ anpaGdncuc 9jja u nuGmbJo2iiiGuc 9Uq (JCLL Ja!o) uq bL!C62

L9.G2 ju 9UUG (ii) arcjA BL!CG uJoqG Ji2 9.J20 jG9.2 iii UOIll1U9.J 11J6LG24 L9.4G2

Gxb9.1121ou ! onçbn Juqnccq p? pc mOuGç9.L?k cxb9.u2!ou 9.j20 o lu LG9J JuçcLG2c

CGUL9.J E!L2 ! 12 couc&c !u cou2uluJbc!ou (L9.;JJGL pgzJ J!1J€9.L)

JJJI2 COIIUGLIyCçII9.J !1nbpc!ou JflU€ 013 9.ebGca o IJJG IJJoqGJ p9.; 9.LG UO LG9.JJ?

J9. 1UcLG2 L9.4G2 9.JJ MGLT mou€'i bopc2 pccow Gxb9.u2iou9.L?

JG9.q 0 911 IUCLG9.26 lu JJC UOWJU9.J LG11LU 0 B COUL9.2 2 miq6J?. 9.cccb;Gq

cwboL9.L!! 9.J20 jG9.2 bLoçL9.cç6cj bGLoqa 0 JJJJGL !uJ9.c!0U 2flCP 9. 2JTOCJ MonJq JJST2

iu 6daiJpLrnm itouç 9.ccrr9.Jf? p (2 M 29.ht 9. 2pOCJ 4JJ9.f L9.!262 ori;bri

Jpn& 't+3\(+I\) 12 qoJJ9.L L9fG o LGflLIJ GfMGGU s + T ou uouwou6ç9.L? eGç

?JGJq2 J\1+1 I11J12 O COU2fTLIJbçiOU 9. + T 9.GIJP 91€ iuqiGL€I1ç GMG6IJ JJG 9.226ç2

JJ!2 9.22Cc 9'ç ?€jqa j \\+1 rnriç oj cou2rnnbçiou 9. + 5 1UCC 9. 09.L 1UAC2G 313 WO1JC)

IJJOUG?k c ; + J C9.U p€ n€q oL couanuJbc!ou 5 p€ L€2ITJ 12 O9.L uAG2;Gq lu

;pc!L J9.0L ucouJc 9'ç % 9'uq j+\(+J\) OJJ9.L2 9.f + J JAJJCJJ 9.5GL 6xcp9.uGq OL

bL!uc!b!G comb9.pJG mi p cIJG GX!2cGUCG O 9.U 9.22G 1J NJJiCJJ C9.U I3AG2 013€ qoJJ9.L 0

qoLuuç€ moucA uq Morrjq j€q uoç H0MGA6L uioq€J 12 IJ

pG!L J9.OL !UCOIJJG 9.ç 3 (12€ p€ bLocccq2 oL COU2llWbc!OIr 9f + F fTC 9.2G2 tAoIIJq

b9.LpcnJ9.L 1; L13J62 onç CXI2çGUCG o uç€Lç pC9.LJu 922G2 113 b€objc C9.U

JJJJG C9.2J1 U 9.JA9.IJCG COU24L9.iUç LG2L!Cç2 JJ€ UJGUIT O 9'A9.iI9.PIG 9.22€2 4O 20113€ GXc€Ur JU

L9.cC2

LCI9.cGq UJ0qJ !" pG bbcuqix ThGLG !UCL€9'G2 !U UJ0UCX I0ll 2IJOLç €LW UOUJI1J9.J IJGLG2ç

19.CJ2 1G249.pJC !UJbJic9'cioU2 OL 1IJçCLG2 L9.ç€2 J0 2JJOIA 9.uJprnçic2 UA0JA€q I bioiqc 9.

/Arçpoac wjuu €xbjrcrç 9.22nwbçroue 9.POI1 L9'IJ6 Ot 9.A9'IJ9.pJ€ 9.2262 W6 moq€j

O 9.22G2 9.Uq i 110 9.22G OJJGL JJ9.U WOUG) bLoAq€ jdnqcA 2€LA!CG2 I 1JJGU 9.L11G cpe

p) 2JJOM1U cJc pi CLIpCI2UJ 12 uqG€q A9.Jiq i JJ9.AG 9.CC622 co 9. LG19.cAG1) LICp UJGUII

OIl M9. OUG 9.221IUJG2 ponç UIJ9.IJCT9.I 922G2 91€ 9A9.iJ9.PJG bcobj€ JJJ112 J 29.L4

qconu; JJG tUI1LG IJ9WGJ) i\\, Bc J M!JJ 9L11G J19.; ;}JG 0LCG o ;pa ctçc!e1u qGbGuq2

;o ;pc moqcj bLGecuçcq JJGL& 2!UCG ;pç UJOqCJ p9. 9. C0U29.U4 LG9.J L9.G 9 wpcp b€objc

!13;6L62c L962 f1CJJ 9. CLIJC12UJ MonJq 2GGLU o b9LçicnJ9.LJ)i bGlpuGu; p€u 9.LG226

Page 18: NBER - tog6061 · 2020. 3. 20. · J1G oLqou (oo) Gdn9oIJ 2 COU2!2cGIJ4 mcrxf pp nu€wbJo?uJGu; L9çc !2 922OCWG 1AçJJ anpaGdncuc 9jja u nuGmbJo2iiiGuc 9Uq (JCLL Ja!o) uq bL!C62

LGI1LU 011 2IOCP LGJUITAG 0 o poUqajucpLq (Taa2) uq I JIG LGGLGUCG2 cicGq 1JJL!U J1JCLG2G2 111 iUJp0U 2GGUJ 10 L2G IJIG L96 0

p'2q uJ!JJ; G pOI1p4 JJg'4 pc UJOqGJ 112611 conjq G f12G 0 niqc fjJi2 CJJOICG H0MGA6L

0131 11112 C0UJb119pOU j W112 JL21 COO2G WG 1U1.0Lm91!0U 261 013 MP!CP JJ626 1.OLGC12 MIII po

JIJ 11112 acCioif I 2JJOM JJOM i cowbn;6 OL6C92C bL1c orr;bnç 9nq JJOFIL2 CJJ9U62 O C9LLA

BJ j,jçpoqojo!11132L9162 JJ94 113€ CJ9'22 01. LUOGJ2 IIUqGL 2çnqA 1392 1.L9!1G !UIGLG2I L96 !UJbJ!C9l!0U2

1101 1.01. 1116 L69J12UJ O J36 UU9UCI91 IIJ94C61 iWbGL1.6C110U2 11J1 11 iucoLboL9';Ge pil4 pGC91126 11

In 9qq;oU !UCLG9262 lu IIJOIJGA JOMGL JJ6 UOUJ!U9'J LGIILU 013 pouq2• LLPI2 LIJOqGJ 12 0CL6

AGLA 2!uJbJG iuoqcj IAJJGLG poiq LG1iLU2 91.6 213J9JJGL flJ9U 2OCJ L61ILU2 On 9AGL9C 9Uq M}16LC

1.9162 01 LG11LU 12 M61J pcAoUq 13G 2cobG 0111112 b9b6L p fJJG ybbcuq1x I qo COU21LITC

L962 e CoU2;LThcc!U 9 L69J2C noq€j MJJGLG InU9;I0U 9UGCI? 13G qi6LGU;9J 13GM66U 6X-

p91Jq OUG Monjq M9U1 9 UJOGJ In MPICP 1116 €dii1A bLcunw 12 LGJ9'1G 10 CJJ9IJ62 IU !IJU9c!On

AGJq& (vG;pG AI6pL9-bLc2c0;c bfl1G) 01. GAGU LG9GL LGJGA9IJCG 10 4JJG 1221162 1

Th9U 0 qq UU91ICI9J W9LJG1 q12;0L10u2 MJJICJJ GU2IILG 139 2c0cJc2 9uq ponq 139AG q[€LGUc

11.0116 MGLG 40 9IJJGU 1136 iuoq€j 20 Il !UC0Lb0L9162 LG91!21!C 9226; m9LJG& 0136 MO11J

111 IGLUJ2 01. IJJOUGA JJJ112 136 113161.621 L9G iUJbJiC9110132 01. 136 uoqc 91.6 U04 c€n;y

111112 !U161621 L9;62) pn; nnpç M€JJ 139AG no GILGCI on €111161. bLoqnc;ou Oi. bL1cc 01. 002

10 4JJC moqcj MonJq 91jGC W6 bL!cc 01. 92262 916 1J0 L9qGq In GdfI!J!pL!IIIJJ (9uq

1116 GXI2GUC€ o u9ucT9J W9LJG; q12çoLç1oU2 ItIOLGO/GL qq!' Ju9nc!9I UJ9LJG1 q2;oLçoU2

;pcur B111 111€ LG2fTJ1!n bL1C6 9U W112 136 pGJJ9AIOL 01.113161.621 L9'G2 12 opA!oIl2JA 26U21TA6 0

9poAc pA a6;c!u 113611. buc€ ! 211613 9 M9A 139 91.6 nqGLcn; M!IJJ LG2bGc; 0 poJqn

2llbbJA 9nq 9LG 110 L9'qcq In GdfIIJIpL!flUF 1112 boe21pJG ;o bL!cG 2IICJJ 922C12 92 I 139'A6 qOIJC

1J0qJ AG2 110 qILGC LOJG 0 1JU9'UCI9J 9226f 2 O13GL 139U wou€A 2JICjJ 92262 91.6 GL0 IJ6

Gcouq3 ;pc moq€j qoc no; !ncoLboL9fG 9nA UU9IJc!9J W9LJC6; qi2çoLflOUa LU 1.9C JJG

9uq monG;9LA 2JJ0C2 91.6 26L!9JIA iuq€b€nq€u;

92 JOUR 92 136 !116L6mb0L9I cJ92;iciçA 01 2Ilp2cicfIlon 01. con2nujbçiou 12 211J9JJGL 4JJ9U OUG

Page 19: NBER - tog6061 · 2020. 3. 20. · J1G oLqou (oo) Gdn9oIJ 2 COU2!2cGIJ4 mcrxf pp nu€wbJo?uJGu; L9çc !2 922OCWG 1AçJJ anpaGdncuc 9jja u nuGmbJo2iiiGuc 9Uq (JCLL Ja!o) uq bL!C62

Muo isili eioia&1 sill Its sbulDni ion asob ii isif I oa sislqmoD sd ol inssm Ion al Isbom sill

slqrnia airli isrlisilw Las 01 ai mis '1m isillsSI .eiuod bus asnq nilasosio1 ui qled 01

Hsul3s sis Isdi alnsrnsvorri sIdsIessio1 sill noms anoilsIsiio3 srIl ioI inuo3s ns Isborn

asldsiisv siom asbuknxi isril ls noiisrniolni us san I isili eiasua airiT .sisb sill ui lnsasrq

san sill ilhiw irIslaianoD shiup ei Ilsali Isborn sill 1Isul3A .Isbom sill ui lnsasiq saoili usif I

noassi sifT . ui anoiisiisv sldsia&eioI sis sisill as noI as isa noiismioIrii ibii liis1 s lo

sldsbasDsioI sasili illiw bslslsiioD sd Jilim esldsiisv rlDiilw ol as Inolia ai lebom sill isuil ai

us as Ino lnssrn al (SI) m lo noiiulovs sill ioI aasoiq bemueas sill isvosioM .einsmsvourz

sill noilsups dill asioni sno II .noiaeuDaib lsoiisiosrli sill asisliliDsi isull noiismixoiqqs

bus asiiq lessio1 qlsil bluorla .u niiasoeio1 ui aqisuf lsill sldsiisv ns Isril eiaeua Isborn

.bsbubni od ol asvisesb audi bus hucqiuo

asnsil3 bslDsqxs 13uiiano3 ol MAV s san binoila sno Isril iasua arioilsisbieno3 sasriT

sno iiiH .(anoilsups niias3s1o1 sisiisvirxu niau sa oi bsaoqqo as) asiisa auoiisv sill ui

.niiaaosio1 ioI beau ci isill 5IAV sill ui aeldsiisv nsm ool obuI3ni ol ion Lu1ois ed leum

enoilslsrIoz) sill isill oa niilffievo d bsisriimslno ed ol alasDsioI asno bssl bluow oc nioU

)feea I isili ci noilsiebiano3 Isnfl A .sldsifeinu sd bliow aslisa bebasosiol cuoiisv sill neewied

sill ui aensilD oi iaudoi eis Isill asiisa ainoil bus luqluo siiq bslasDoioI sill lo esiiieqoiq

issbnu uliod ciii saussd inslioqmi 'hsIuzilisq ai culT .riiiassio1 io bsau lea nolismiolni

sbubni Lqmia oi euoiensb ciii bus nules3eio1 iol beau ed oi huluo celdsiisv ibiilw IlDsxs

.insvslsi ldiaaoq sis isrli asldsiisv sill Its

luqluo ui snscb sill sis SlAV sill ui bsbul3ni sd ol besri Ieouivdo Isill csldsiisv owT

sulsv sen I (!I) biolbooW bus isdmsio$l niwoHo'I ' aoiiq ui snsil3 sill bns

insaoiqei iolsfleb nibnoqas1ioD sill 1sf bus asiisa luqluo 'm as ioicsa olsviiq sill ui bsbbs

I eioi{lus anoismun 'd iliwoi iuqiuo Ioibsiq ol nwoila need evsil csill saus3eH .ae3rIq

1o Isvsf bsbnsiisb eull bus ( —

) iuqluo oi noiiqmuarxo3 lo oiisi sill oafs ebuloni asvils

aasriiaud Issi bisbasbe sill worf a (lI) biolbooW bus isdmsloSI as ievosioM 8 ainoil

.'(18noiiiB ion abvI iidi isdi 11iI iiup ei ti ausd ansis'flib ia ii b9bubni 915 9a3dT 9W 319c1w (t9OI) bioThooW bns iedrrj&ioH iii s rnsa 3111 ai e9Idsilsv 9111 10 noiiinft9b isx9 9dT8

no 9luiibn3qx3 imuano 'd fl9Vi ei noiiqmuanoD .iuqiuo ni s331o1 is boos Iis1uiiisq s 'edi tdi

TI

Page 20: NBER - tog6061 · 2020. 3. 20. · J1G oLqou (oo) Gdn9oIJ 2 COU2!2cGIJ4 mcrxf pp nu€wbJo?uJGu; L9çc !2 922OCWG 1AçJJ anpaGdncuc 9jja u nuGmbJo2iiiGuc 9Uq (JCLL Ja!o) uq bL!C62

T8

CC9fl2€ coImnoqiç) bLTcG2 LC otccu LCLq€q nnj ru JoL6cuiu oçp o ooq bL!c€°. Cowwoq iscp BflLCff)2 iuqGx o comwoq bL!c6 w) AL!9pJG I CU26LG

oI opu6q G22Gu;!JJ? iq6ucrcJ ''Ic ;q) naGq GiçpGL fpG J° O p€ bLrcG O CL(Iq€ O OLCEIbLGj€LLGq 2bGcTUcioU Mp!Cp COU2LI1C12 flJG MGJp2 112IIJ YffIJIW moqGJ uq MJJ1CIJ fJi6? cjj vinw

p6) 2JJOM 46LC 91G 2AGLBj M9)2 O COIJ2LUCIU J1G M€ipç TU W6 CE LrçG HGLG I fl26 4p6ILIUP0L !'q;° UIPl uq jp (Jo8) uq EAUGLJIGL n2G2 o p€ cou2nwbpou pL& 266 Cwbp6JI (i.i) uq COCPUG suq OLOUG (J9) OL i'c o.uouqnpja uq 2GLMCC2 MpiJG J1011L2 ULG W692(1LG 92 UJU-JIOflL2 iu p€ bLAç€ uou-LJcnJpIL9} eGcçoL LOL

9LG 2c94!0U9L? J{OfGWGL uq jooqoq (i) LGboI4 D!cG-LnhJGL G2 2ç9ç121C2 4pT

BGtOLG L1TUU!U 9 \IfJ M1JJ JJG2G A9L19pJG2 OUG JJ92 O UJ9JG 2ITLG JJG2G A9LWJG2

MGLG JJ6 C92& pip m9LJu1b2 onjq pG COLLGJ9G içp 2Up2GdflGU LGflCOU2 !U bL!cG2

922oc96q M!;JJ JOM on;bnç 12 9J20 22OC9G M!cP 9 qnccou lu LU91JU1b2 OAGL WG i

1UJ91UG 4JJc piJJ JGAGJ ot uJu'LJurbe MJJ1CJJ jgoccmpc 9uq p/ooqoq (i) 2OM o p

1JJG J9pOL 2JJ9LG !2 9IJ uqic9coL o JG JCAGJ O W9LJ.C11b2 u GcououJ? yuq OUG UJ4 MGJJ

iq Ii2 9/G 9U JuqGbGuqGu qjc; ou bL!cG suq osiçbnç cpu€ couq

J9prn. uq cbçj 9i aGb9LçG !ubn;2 E!L2c 1rc1Tq1J cP!2 A9'L!9PJG UJG9U2 cc I W 9JJO/A!IJ

9LG ThO LG9201J2 O iUcJllqG JJ2 A9L!9PJG poçp O MJJC LGJ9'çG O LIJOLG COLUbjGX UJOGJ2 P'

29LG oj J9OL cowbGu2çiou iii A9JfIG qqq o coLboLrçc pn2iuGa2 2GCOL a JJJGLG

2P AL19pJG 12 uoç LGJ9G O U9UC!9J W9LJCG2 9 9Jj prç COU2I2f 2 JIJ2çG9cJ O Ot

uqC9OL2 O W U ;pc A9L!9U qjcnecq u p€ bbGuqpc i 9J20 C0U2qGLGq jyjç !U M}I!CJJ

9LG 1111J!JGP O p€ iqGUçJcj O UJOAGWGUf 2 flY W JIJGLG2 L9IG2 OU 4pG OIIJGL p9uq 9'LG IT2GtIlJ

IIJOAGWGU2 IU 1 (9Jçponjf tOt JJG LG920U2 q2CI122Gq 9OAG IJJOAGWGU2 U 9LG9G2

LG920U tOt UcJflqu mOIJGç9L? LG9fG2 12 JJ9 JJG2G W9? COU9UJ IUtOLUJ9f IOU 9Ofl

CJJ9U6 !U cP CE LUOIJCçL? ¶TLG9f C O DL!2C01J uq htP9 (Y vvi°UJOUG9L? p92& 4}JC JO C9UG ui JJG JO CJJ9UG !U I5 VV'I' 9uq joM1JJ JJG JO CJJ9UG2 O tOiTL WG92JILG2 O JJG 2OCJ ot iiiøuc% J,JJ62G 9LG WG I° CJJ9IJG !U 4JJG

4JJG LG2flJ2 opç9iuGq ThI4JJ JJG GqGL9'J ITUq2 L9G MJJICJJ !2 J9pGJJGq r j 9J20 GXbGLUJGUcGq

L9G OU -IJJOUJJ COWWGLCI9J b9bGL BGC9U2G JJG LG21IJ2 MGLG 20 21UJTJ9L J LGboLç

UCJflqGq A9L!9P16 JJpG2G !'"Jqq llO IJGLG24 L9G23 U9UJGJ)

JJG pobc O 0pWUiU LOpJT;2 LG2IIJc& I 6XbGLUJGUGq M!cp 2GAGL9J C9Uqq9fG2 tOL

CCJG uJoqGJ 2I1G22 JJ9 IJJG2G A9Li9pJC2 2}JOfTJq JJGJB tOLGC92 onbnç toljr

Page 21: NBER - tog6061 · 2020. 3. 20. · J1G oLqou (oo) Gdn9oIJ 2 COU2!2cGIJ4 mcrxf pp nu€wbJo?uJGu; L9çc !2 922OCWG 1AçJJ anpaGdncuc 9jja u nuGmbJo2iiiGuc 9Uq (JCLL Ja!o) uq bL!C62

baa — o io eeFie emil erli ni iooi linu a lo O3fIei2ixe ecu iDejel ns eno idi worla

sill bits M ,IM 16111 ziisua eilimsi iioqei (II) .sdisioq bits llooahCl 1scfmeJo5I . 91.8 easrll rlw al rbidw 'ion asob n91ellib Jail usd1 iluoili aloou linu evsil sasd us1snom

iluorll alevel iii isnoilsia ed I1suls sm siseus ID silT .aeDneu&lIib jail iii bebubni

(bsiuoqeu Ion) alasi usLfu'I-biG .lilidsusqmo3 uo1 flew as aeDneu&fiib iaull iii Ii sbubni I

.isnolIsla sus susila uodsl sill lo swassm m baa aelsu Jaeueirii sill isdi Iasua oafs

-booW baa uedmsioH .5IAV sill iii ebuloni 01 as1 aam wod 10 noilasup sill aevssl aiilT

ni rxiau ms I asldsiusv ssucll lauft sill 10 asl owl nsdl suom nibubrii isdi bnuol (1I) buol

bnoosa edl briosd asl hslimi .ainet3ffleo3 iris3iliniacxi IIs3ii2iisie ol abssl bula airil

audT .susil belebiano3 erneia'a ueusl sill ni 'Iswoq ioisnsIqxo inslioqmi eilldhino3 ion ob ' .bebuloni eus as1 owl frio

21 noiisDFIi3sqe .HAV sill ezrieH

() + i—1 =

euedw

('u —

qL

= baa = o (i—At

— o o o

£13118 ill belsdsl sus alsubiasu silT .beismiias ed ol been l. lo awou esuril evil sill lno bits

'isi&nom 9diIo idi ishrniiisq iii bn a9 S3S18 '1sJ9nom iboI9v inoni i1i 1bnd id)o &di iriO' liinu usnoi3.sia as bew9iv n9d asd $M b v)i3o1v moni sr{T .isnoiJsie w9qqs Jon ob IM lo baa asd

lo auseH .auoiluqa Idsdoiq aw JiisnoiJsJa aidi JsdJ iaua M ni 2inIm9vom JfIs91 sdJ Jud 'Iia3391 !bom edi lo Jnsiisv sdi Jsdi Jo .SIAV if3 ni aeiuaam iboI9v bubrii Jon bib I iiwnoiiia 1o bs1 aidJ

.iboIv ni ein9m9vom 'tsaoiJsianioa diiw JttsJeianro l3Jlqmo3 ei () baa (O) aazi Jdi lo 'qnsm ,(1) btolbooW baa Idm9ioiI1o msiaa Ldahcv sidi 9di ni b811u03o iadw 1i1nu ,iadi e3oV1

a3JamuJa9 Ja9bIfl9o sadi idi ansm eidT .ina31linian1i 11soiJaiJa3e s mJaa iis[ thdi flu aifli3fflo3 tfi 911 i iuiqa oJ 91d5 ai isdi BAV Je9lqlnia snfi lo 2inebfft9o3 dJ nanfi eion ni1qrnsa iom 9v511 1d.sc1oq

isezi ol a9nlalW 9(10 1i sldsJiv9ni '(Idsdolq ei aion nilqmsa aidi iv9woll .sisb &di ni anoiisL3I1o3 ia9iLza .m3iaa isist s iii aeldsiisv di us '1Lg3i1i9mma

Page 22: NBER - tog6061 · 2020. 3. 20. · J1G oLqou (oo) Gdn9oIJ 2 COU2!2cGIJ4 mcrxf pp nu€wbJo?uJGu; L9çc !2 922OCWG 1AçJJ anpaGdncuc 9jja u nuGmbJo2iiiGuc 9Uq (JCLL Ja!o) uq bL!C62

o' o i coLLc2bouqiu coGuJciGu2 !U driçou 6xbJ9iuiu iUIJci0U }39 ;-2ç9I2ç!c 01 J5

ThJJGLC \ = ' I'' ("!') 4G GAGLqG-GJ2011 qGuiciou O C?CJiC9J couibouGuç o

ThJJGLG AGCfOL IJJç JJ9 011€ IIJ fJJ€ JL2 b02!0IJ uq GLO2 !LT 9'Jj OçJJGL2 E0L fG

(54)

12 !AGU pA

o LM pGçm€Gu uq + pA ju p€ c o oiiçbnç tOL GxuJbJG €xb€cç€q

!U pc AL!0I12 ALWpJ€2 LOL IJA A9L!TPIC qcuoç€ uonuç pA picp i; 12 sxb€c€q

V2 Jç0çGWpGL 9IJq ooqoq (T4) () cu p€ 112Gq o Cou2çLnCç cxbccc€q cpuc2LCBLG2GU1 JO!A w911u1b2) 91€ 9'22oc19c€q micp JG/€J2 o enpe€diicuç HJJ90W

bLicG2 JJ fO PL!U UJ9Lflb2 p9CJC o ;pp G9qA ijn pp A9J11G2 o (Mp!cJJ

C0u22GU JAJ;JJ 4JJG MGIA JJ9' 9' JJJJJ J9'pOL 2JJ91G IJJG9'1J2 JJ9'J Lu9LJ<nb2 916 JJ1}J 20

JJG -29';21C 0J W€ j€q 19'POL 2JJ9LG A9'L9'pJG !U JJG cxbJ91u!u 111JJ9T!OU !2 535

e!u!uc9'u bLcqccoL o 1IJJ9'f1oIJ 9'jç€L 1JcJfTqu J9'2 o p€ C —\ 9'uq V A9'L19'pJ62

J6 1U0U€9'LA p926 flUJ!JCC cJJG IIJOUGA L0MJJ A9'L9'pJG& J9OL 2p9'L6 R 12 9' 2;9'çI2cICUJfA

uou ] eo coueqGt 9'j20 9' 2X A9'Li9'pJG yg iuCjnqGe pop p€ GqGLJ flHq2 Lç€ 9'uq

E-l62f 9JJ0M2 0116 O cccbç cp pAboçJJG2i2 iç qoc uo p6Jou iu ;pc LGL€22iO1J €xbjirnu

2iuiuC9'uc CO€flJC!GU !2 UJOUG9'LA p926 EAGU 4JJ0f1p 2 JJJ}J62 -2c9f!2fC 12 J1 'uq u

9'qqiu 9 eixçp A9L9'pJc LcbLG26uçJu IIIOUGA L0MJJ qJG 011€ JJ9' 92 UJ02 2ç9çi2ciC9JJA

OflJGL puq 1 0116 9'JL69'qA ucJnqG2 4JJ6 GGL9'J nuq2 L9f€ 111 4JJ6 Jf If 9U 9120 C0u2qGL2

pG pAbopc ;p9 ou€ cu 6xcJnqG pom uçou Gdn9c!ou 9'Jfo6p€L o' cpp9'AG ;-2ç912;iC2 cxcG€qiu j u €dnç1oua cxbj1u1u !UU90U uq L-4622 9'CCGbç

21J1C9'U C0GC1GIJ 12 JJ6 CE WG9211L6 JJJJ6 OçJJGL UJC9'211L€2 0 UJOIJGA L0Mf IJGAGL

916 IJJIICJJ j622 2i1JiUC9Uc O1 JJG UJOIJGA 20CJ( W69'2LTL623 JJ6 0116 M1IP 4p6 IJJ02 249çi2çiC9JJA

1u1jou (M1p -29'12iC2 OU JJ€ M0 C06fflC1GIJ42 p9ç cxc€cq )pii JJ6 HIOU6A 20CJ W€92flL€2

NLJ 2 a 1A61J pA IJ 11J€LG24 L96 iç 12 2c9;!2;JC9'IJA 2iJJUC9IJ4 111 JJ6 €c1nou GxbJ9lulu

j cou2qGLGq c9'uqq9çG2

OcIJGL A9L!9pJ€2 JJJG A9L!9'PJG 12 j€ç nuab6cJ€q 9' bo!u GC9IT2G 92 GxbJ9uGq 9'pOA&

/A9'A JJ9'4 4p6 !uuoA9'clou u 12 q6uoçGq pA c uq 21W119LJA 0L JJ€ ruuo;iou2 111 JG

Page 23: NBER - tog6061 · 2020. 3. 20. · J1G oLqou (oo) Gdn9oIJ 2 COU2!2cGIJ4 mcrxf pp nu€wbJo?uJGu; L9çc !2 922OCWG 1AçJJ anpaGdncuc 9jja u nuGmbJo2iiiGuc 9Uq (JCLL Ja!o) uq bL!C62

= — ')= —

(5.)

—-

buoq G quoçcq pA j €drwj2

A9Li9pJG €xbcçcq 'ç i ;o bJ9cG pGcM€Gu ; + uq + + y j' p!2 LOMu GxbGcGq LOM}J L9IG2 J,O C9JCflJ9G LGM21OIJ2 ! ! II2Gf1J 4O 29L M!cP c}JG LOM O 9

!2 IIUCOLLGJ9Gq OACL J1J512 J9CJ O, COLLCJ9TOIJ OAGL 1WG 12 9 bLobGLçA O 4JJG L2OU2

L9ç62 O A9L1O!12 A9L19pJG2 iç 2 pç;t O cJG9J Th!IJJ pc bç o GxbGccGq LOMJJ pç

292C9J 1ULGUCG2 pøiiç JJG 2L6UçJJ O LGI9c!ou2p!b pG;MGGU IIJG GxbGcGq LOMIJ (5) () 9Uq (EQ) 9LG 2GLJ9JJA COLLGJ9 92 !AGJf EOL 2OUJC bnLbo2G2 u9LIJGJA o L9M

BGC9fl2G 4}JG A9L19pJG2 IU 9LG 2GL9JJA coLLGJ9Gq cJJG €xbcq C9U coiubnc€q 92

JJ9UG OAGL 911 IUIJ1IG pOLJOu !2 2JLUbJA UG9I!AG O IJJGL C!1LLGU A9JIIG

2p9L6 4OG 4JJ9 GC9IT2G jJG A9Li9pJGa JJ9 G1JGL 92 JGAGJ2 9LG 2c9!OU9LA JJG!L cxbGcGq

tOLIJJITJ9 9bbJ!62 JT OIJG M!2J1G2 o combn;G GxbGcGq CJJ9UG2 JU !UIGLG2I L94G2 OL JLT 4JJG J9OL

MJIGLG ! qcucq 9U9JOOfT2JA o 'uq p1jc 2GCOU GdIT9J!;A GJUG2 'q 2JUJJJ9L

= —()

LOTh O pOflL2 12 1AGU pA

Gxbccccq cp9'u o A9Li9pJc2 GUGL 92 JG/€J2 u ;ps j\qjç LOL Gx9uThJG GxbGcfGq

CJJ9UC2 111 InouGA 2cocjr v 2JpJA q!u.GLGUc OLWflJ9 9bbJJc2 MGll oUG ipc couJbnG

O1TLJJ bO2JçJOU 9uq GLO2 JU 9JJ 4JJG OcpCL2 2!m!J9L OLLU11J92 9bbJA oi. coinbnçJu cxbccccq

ThGL6 2 couJbncGq pj ' fJJ9 J2 LGbJ9cGq pA AGCOL M1JJ 9 OIJG !U

112G 9IJ9JOO1T2 JOLUJIJJ92 COWbuTçG GxbGc;cq CJJ91JG2 JU bLJccw JJpG2G 9LG JAGU

= —(2)

JO J /AJJJCJJ 32 1AGU pA

Page 24: NBER - tog6061 · 2020. 3. 20. · J1G oLqou (oo) Gdn9oIJ 2 COU2!2cGIJ4 mcrxf pp nu€wbJo?uJGu; L9çc !2 922OCWG 1AçJJ anpaGdncuc 9jja u nuGmbJo2iiiGuc 9Uq (JCLL Ja!o) uq bL!C62

Iii as bebwiinoD i iii baa s1cfiiav oi abnoqerxoD isdi xiiism sf{i insesiqsz a sisriw

xo () () isdio nI .abohsq A ixsn sdi isvo diwo bsiDsqxs a iii M noiaivsi sili sionsb isJ

i ii efriow ( — —

( —

fupe aii{i (V) niaU

(tç z+\ — — ) — —

iol siuiiidu oi (1) niau dJwo iuquo iii noieivsi sili iol slurrrio'I sdi noiisiieuLIi as i noiiiups evods sdi iii sr1

(8) (1\ +... + K + + Is.) = . sisriw (J\ — =

sd bsebni .b9is1sno3nu &'is rbidw arioitsvonni lo oJsv sdi 2i —

) isdi siol4

aisilib asnsrb sziiq lo noiivsi sdi isdi o1s sioM .smii isvo bsisIsllo3nu sis enoiivsi

.s 1o bssini s sau Jaurri 5110 isdi ni lrio (8) ni isril moil

.sLdshsv insi11ib io1 anoiivsi sill nsswisd qidnoiisIsi sill riliw bsrns3noD sd Iliw I

baa lo sDnsiisvoD sill lo xhlsm aaiuwo3 siisiisv sill siorisb \f nulisJ

() —

nsewlsd asDnshsvoD erli as llsw as noiaivsi sasdi lo asaaiisv sill svi anoilsups ialirriia bits

noiisvonni noilsilni baa iuqluo sill nsewisd eonsimvo3 sill isril oals sioVI .anoiaivsi isdio

.xiilsm iiinsbi sill 'd bsoslqsi k if Jiw Jud (p2) d nsvi ai

sill no sldshsv sno in frOrarVel sill b noieiei sill ai noilsxooaas lo siijassm insillib A

lo insDfflsO siLt ni bsiesisini l1sfuDii1sq ed Iliw I woIsd bseauoaib aA .isrfions ni noiaivsi

elsiips aidT no qL lo noiaasisi a 'Q PIN \VIN \11k1 ' 5 Jtj r ' — 'ij n5

" / —

iii aisismsisq sill no bnsqsb (DC) nil isdi bits (@) in noLi oaas 'b siuassm sill dloH

siuqmoD I (lI) biolbooW bits isdmsio5I iii aA .'js2i3s1q bsismilas Jon sis sasdi bits K

Page 25: NBER - tog6061 · 2020. 3. 20. · J1G oLqou (oo) Gdn9oIJ 2 COU2!2cGIJ4 mcrxf pp nu€wbJo?uJGu; L9çc !2 922OCWG 1AçJJ anpaGdncuc 9jja u nuGmbJo2iiiGuc 9Uq (JCLL Ja!o) uq bL!C62

2UJG wonu o bLGqTccpJG LUOAGUJGIJç2 W JJ C2G2 2IJL qcçou O flJG

qo uoç qGbGuq ir.? urncp ou 2bGcijcioIr yjj bGcqcçJoue ;pn GUGL€ pon

q !UUU! oj bLcG2 uq oriçbnç IUGLc!UP JJG 29iJq9'Lq qGAcou2 o bL6qcç€q CUG2

JJJJG UGX 4JJLGG ioii it pc u9jooaa bLobLl 62 ill JJG LGAI2IOU2 OL JJ6 LOMçp GMG6U

qJLGcpoU2 JJI2 coo 2flG2l2 borpt€ couioimuç PGMG6U bL!cG uq oiiçbnç iUUoiOU2

!0IT2 916 nciAGJ?. coijçq arncc nucwbJo%iuGuc uq oncbnc cuq moic rn obbo2i

MO A9119pJG JJ{ COU2!2c!U O ITIJGUJbJO2JJJGUc 9'uq UJOU suq 2JJOM IIJ9 JJGL !UUOA9-

wc°' pGcMGGU onçbnç cpu uq bL!cG cp9uG2 uq pj9ç2ou (Jr) gurJ?6cp€ GcououJ6çLic cdniou o oqou (To) J2O 2O/i g 2LOIJ coucGuJboLuGone bo2içiAG

iuJ1J91 LG2fTJç2 p/G p6611 onuq p oçpL JJJG uoç concjJGq iu oj, jyjç713 p20Jfl6 uJiJifaqc fpu 4JJO2G bLcqJcçcq p pç woqGJ

bLGqicciou2 o LUOIJCç91A IJJoqCJ O 2GCf IOU J 9JpO13JJ JJG COLLGJ9'f!01J2 916 UJIIC}J 2UJ91JGL

f6 orrçbn; uq iLrJç1ou xuijoiioua LG cou212çucJ2. bo2l 6 Jp i cou r;cuç M!cP

JJ626 2nq91q GLLOL2 916 pecq 013 IIJbJ!IJ A91J9IJC6 O \ J2p6 COLL6JOU 61A66U

JIJ GCJJ C92G GLLOL2 91€ qi2bJGq GJOM cIJG €2JW9cG2 MJJ€L6 9

uq !UU1OU !UUOA91OIJ2 !AJJJJG JJG COLLCJcI0U PGcMGGU fJJG2G !UU0f!0U2

1391176 0 W€ ncjiiq€q A9L!9'PJG JJJG UL2 M0 LOM2 A6 JJ€ 291J9L qGtqc!OUa o oricbnc

9'IJq JJG UJOUGç9l?k p92G jp€ OJCL IJcJf7qc1fT2ç AG ALpJ€2 91J IJJG COJfIUJIJ pGq6L A€2 cpc

! bLICUJL qi2bJ2 L62i1Jc2 uI2JIJ 2jX A91J6 pqç JJc UCI11q€2 JJG 6q6LJ nuq2 Lff€

2GU 2bGciUc9'ciou2 cp'c q'€i rn p€ A9119pJ62 ;psç c ucJI1q€q 113 ;JJG JJf JJJJG J2ç COJf1UJlT

jp€ p2IC L62I1J2 CO1JCGLIJJU bLicG uq onçbn; LG bL€2Guçcq rn j,9pj6 J jp€ COJIIIJJIJ2 LGbL€-

2 BLJCG JIJ OflcbTh4 I/OAGIJJGIJ2

/91191JCG-COA9L!gUCG W9cLIX O cp6 GJGUJ€Uc2 0 'F

LG2bGCç cJJG €JGUJGIJ2 o 'F JJJG A9L19UC6 O I.1J UJG2i1L€ 12 6U VJrJ !A6L6 J 2 cJJG

W692IILG o (so) uq cprc 'u (30) i coujbnç€ 4JJG A6CcOL 0 qGLAç!AG2 D IA!W

922oci9cGq MIcJJ IJJ6 62çUJfGq COGIIJCIGU2 u 4JJ6 AVW JJJJ!2 2 qouc 92 oJJotA2 LOL €CJJ

UJG92flL€ o cpc lTuccLç uç? !' fC2C W69213L62 12 quc cpc 2guJbJru flUCGLf91U

Page 26: NBER - tog6061 · 2020. 3. 20. · J1G oLqou (oo) Gdn9oIJ 2 COU2!2cGIJ4 mcrxf pp nu€wbJo?uJGu; L9çc !2 922OCWG 1AçJJ anpaGdncuc 9jja u nuGmbJo2iiiGuc 9Uq (JCLL Ja!o) uq bL!C62

EAGIJ f}YO11JJ UJOLG ALWJG LG JucJflqGq JU 4JJG BLG2GIJ 2nq uq 2rUJbJG o

o bbJA!u (5) 0 JJG 2 AP1G yJç jJ JucJnqG2 GGLJ f1U2 UTçG

;pc cxbGcçGq LoMçJJ o onçbnç jtow !uuc? LOUJ jçoçcmpc uq jooqoLq () 9'2

JU JOGWGL uq M°°qI.°'q (J J,OL U !11'c'c!" o bou; MG qJ2bJ U JJ11LG J

Jy]ç2 coUaiqGLcq JJGLG LG G22GUcJJJ? !qGuc!c9'I O IJJO2G tLOUJ 3 /9L!pJG AVI couqLq

ic ponjq G q gç JJG Ofl2G cpc bLGqccGq onçbn; UJOAGGU2 LOW JJ A9LJpJG

ID btic 'uq oribn wj 'a 2guJbJG b9p2 OL LGM210U2

IPl2 i ' tOLWflJ pJ () (52) uq (g) o COU2LflC 29wbJG b9Tp2 IOL GxbGcçGq moJmGu

"q oPU!U(IJY G I1IJ G!cJJGL JJUGL OL oqLcJC-LGcoçc LGuq2 JO U9J?G

JJJ JG9AG2 JJG dnG2çiou O /AJJGJJGL OUG Gç2 GAGU 2LOUGL COLLGI!OIJ 112!L1 JJG WG4}JO2 O

qçuqcq onçbn uq bLJcG2 MJJGU cJJG cAGLqG-GJ2Ou mpoq fl2G OL qGcLGuqu JJJ!e

JJJG moqj imbpc2 91Jq LG C011212ccUç MJfJJ 9 uGç!AG COLLGJ9çiOU GMGGU

22OCG po;j CflLLGIJ4 uq GxbGccq fJflLG uoW

2Oq9'Gq MIçJJ f1(TLG JUCLG9'2G2 ID bcc J,pn2 nbIALq WOAGWGU2 JU CflLLGIJ 9cciAJ4A LG

LOM? oj oncbnr yuq G2G qoMum9'Lq2 LGA!2!OU JJ J1flLG OfJçb11 LOMfJJ L6 GUJGJAG2

!U CI1LLGU GCOLTOJJJ!C cçJAJç? 9LG 122OCJGq MJcJJ qoMxJmLq2 LGAJJOU2 JU GXbGCGq 3.JIILG

CJILLGUf UCLG2G2 bucc IATOLGOAGL 92 f JIG GIJIJI JIUG O JJ9JG J }JOM2 nbM9Lq LGAT2JOU2

OAGLJJ bJCçflLG JJJç GWGLG2 J2 JJG OJJO1AJU U flbMLq2 LGAJ2JOU2 JU CIILLGU CfJAJç JG9'q2 o

J2 2IJJJJGL pu - (/ApGLc cJJG coLLGJc!ou JIGMGGU 1UUOA9çJOU2 Gdfl912 ponç ) j,p€

p2OpIG A9J11G JJG COLLGJJOU O JJG !UUOA9çiOIJ JU JJ JJG 2bGCijJCriOU2 cJJ!2 COLLGJOU

J2 uGcJAG3 92 ;pG uioqcj OT 2GC4JOU J bLGqic2 JUçGLGJLJJ? COLLGI9IJOU 12 UJIICJJ JLGL u

jpG 2XJI LOlA JAG2 f JIG yG2 UqU u9uJGJ? 4JJ JJG COLLGJcJOU GMGGU JJG /AO LGAJ2JOU2

LOMIJJ JJJJII2 JJJIICJJ J9'LGL tL9c!1J O bLJcG UJOAGWGU2 J2 oLGc92c9'pJG

JJG LGAJ2JOU U GXbGCGq JU1J9fJOU J2 ponç /A1CG 92 JLG 92 JJG LGAJ2JOU IU GxbGcGq onfbllç

IUUOA9ç1Ou 12 Ofl4 JJgJ 92 JLG 92 JJG JUUOA9pOU iU oiiçbiiç IAJJGLG92 JJG 2ç913q9Lq (JGA191JOU

29UcJ9Lq qGAJ9;Jou 4JJ9U JUIIOA9çJOU P L9C dIG 29IJ9L GAJ9IJOU OJ, JJG JUJ9JOU

!11U0A9d!0U ]U dIJG C92G OJ JJG bLGqJcc€q LOMJJ Oj br.Jc JIG LGA!2!OU JI92 9 UJITC}J J9LGL

GxbGcdGq LOMdJJ oiibriç 2 2OIJJGMJJ9d J9LGL 4JJ9U dJJG 29U9L cJGA!9d!OU o dp orldbnd

Page 27: NBER - tog6061 · 2020. 3. 20. · J1G oLqou (oo) Gdn9oIJ 2 COU2!2cGIJ4 mcrxf pp nu€wbJo?uJGu; L9çc !2 922OCWG 1AçJJ anpaGdncuc 9jja u nuGmbJo2iiiGuc 9Uq (JCLL Ja!o) uq bL!C62

bLoAiqG 2OWG GAJqGLJcC cou2!2cGIJc miçp f jIG uioqj o accçJou J JOM LGbOLç2 f JIG LGLG22JOIJ

flGOLG CJO21U JIJ2 eGcçJoIJ J 1ILIJ W 9'4fGIJ1OU O JJG JS2 2!X LO1/L2 O J,9pJG V MJJJCJJ 9J20

JJG COLLGI9'f 10112 LG 2iUJ!1'L (ruq 2np2çufJIrJ) lu

9LG ]9LGL OL 2IJJ9JJGL f JIG bLG-J COLLGJ41OIJ2 qGbGuq2 011 MJIJCJJ LJpJ J2 JUCJflG 92

boç- bGLioq JJJG2G COLLCJc!0IJ2 LG AGL? 2JUJJjL MPGPGL ;JIG bo2ç-J COLLGJ9;OIJ2

qJ2b2 JJG COLLGI9c!OU 01. PG LGM21OIJ2 iu onçbnç uq bLJcG2 1.01. pop 4JIG bL€-Jj uq JIG

T.9I1ILG2 01. jJs GuciLG bcLIoq IIIJqGL uJ22 JqG1.1 0( pI2 cU p€ onuq JU jpJG 5 MJJJCJJ

LG2J1Jl 0( JJG pGJJAJ0L 0( bL!cGe 9uq orrbnf OAGL b9'LcJcnJ9L 2npbGLoq Ju2G9q p€X 91.9

JJV W0LG0AGL 92 J2 2nc2çGq p? EifTL6 5 4JJJ2 C0UUGCI0U 12 uoç 1 IJG

pG 2?2çGW JJ9ç 11262 f JIG (GqGL9J 'T V2 1P '"ic JU JJ9'JG J JJG J2

on;brii L0IAlJJ jLouJ s ;o iuuiç? J,1nLG 3 bLoAJqG2 9 2C9GL WL9LU 0( 1JG29 LGAJ2JOIJ2 (01.

I 11DM nLU o 9'U 9U9J%2J2 oj e9mbJG b9çp2 o ;pc LGAI2IOU2 Ju GxbGcfcq bLJcG 9uq

L0M1JJ•

9ç JG92 b9LçJA LG2bOU2!pJG (01. JJG UG9çiAG COLLGJ9çJOU p€çMu onbn uq buc€o( cxbcq bLJcc LoIAp JJJJ2 211G2ç UJoUG9L) bopc? 9'uq uo eribbj?. 2pOCJ2 91.9

JI9 pL011JJç 011 fJJG p!JJG2 JGAGJ 0( GxbGCçGq oui;brrç L0MJJ 9uq UG9LJX }1G j0MG2

12 LG9JJ) 4JIG T085 LGCG22!0IJ MJJJCJJ 12 MJGJ 9;çLJpnçGq 0 COU4L9CJ0U9L? W0UG9L?. bojc?

L9c622J0U pop lucLG92Gq cxbccc€q onçbriç LOMJI 9uq LGqIICGq GXbGccGq !11;J0U flfT4 Ic

q9f9 JJJJG UI1LG 9'J20 2JJ0M2 20111€ b9LfJcnJ9L GbJ2Oq€2 p€ JU(OLLUJAG J,JJG TO

r C°°J 11q OPJI" (JJ) (01. CTcJJGL J1UG9LJ) 01. (JJf€Lsq

¶TLG UG9cJA6JA C0LLGJI7G 9uq COLLGJ9c1OU - GXCGGCJ2 9U?k O( pG COLLGJ9JOU2 onuq

(1.0111 ; O iUUUic?, (LOW JH2 29WG 2 A9L19pJG 22çGUr JJJG 1J(1LG W9JG2 CJG9L 4JJ9'ç pG2G

EflL6 qJ2bJ9)2 flIG 291.192 (01. pocp bLGqiccGq oncbnc LOMflJ uq bLGqJcçGq BLJC€ LOMJJ

40 LGCOACL)

MJJ6L6 GxbGccGq oricbiic LOM4JJ 12 p1pG2f (pGc9n26 f9 €couow? JI92 cp I11o24 L011IJ

Jll poçji C92G2 cp poçcoui 0( L9C62210U2 92 G(JUG P I4BEJ coLLc2bouq CJ02GJ?

JJG M0 261.162 9L66 011 9JJ iuJbOLc9IJc LG2bGcça 9U 91.9 p1JJJ COLLGJ9cGq m1JJ G9CJI OçJJGL

!2 qqLu (pcc91129 cp q9'ç9 1.01. fF6 J0fGWGL 9uq ooqoq 2cnq?. 2f9Lf JU

Page 28: NBER - tog6061 · 2020. 3. 20. · J1G oLqou (oo) Gdn9oIJ 2 COU2!2cGIJ4 mcrxf pp nu€wbJo?uJGu; L9çc !2 922OCWG 1AçJJ anpaGdncuc 9jja u nuGmbJo2iiiGuc 9Uq (JCLL Ja!o) uq bL!C62

! cxbGcçcq onçbnç LOMJJ LOUJ 011 J{OM 2OM2 4JJ9 OL 9J 2bCcJUc9;1OIJ2

JOTh2 JJ 9Uq JJ jOCfl2 OU JJG COLLGJ9c!Ou GMGGU oiiçbriç uuo/9pou2 % 9IJq LGA2OIJ2

orrçbn; 0 COIJçTJJJIG o LT2G GMGGU 9JJJ + J

bo2içiAG 2GLJ91J?. C0LLGJ9çGq JU p2 C92& boçAG UJOUG;9L? !UUOA9c!0U2 9f jq bL!cG 9uq

couF2f€u IMçp JJG uJoqcj o 2Gcç!oIJ I 92 J0U 92 J2 bOr;iAG 20 JJ9 UJOUG LOMJJ !2

b02itG V2 qJ2crT2ecq G9'LJiGL cJ1!2 qGLGUCG U GMGGU 20Lf 9uq JOUR poL!Ou L€A!2!0U2

onçbnç 9uq bic L0M LGA!2!OU OAGL IJGXç dfWLçGL (pGcMcGu uq + j) 9cf1wJJA

LGi!2OU2 OAGL 913 potoir 0" 0JJGL JJ9U LOM 2JJ0M2 JJç JJG COLLGJ9cIOU 0

LOMfJJ OIGL J df1914GL2 12 1JG9ç1AG uq 2JUJ!J9L P' 2! O JJG COLLGJ90U O J6 coLLG2bouqu

2JJ0LGL JJOL!O1J2 Jç0M LGAG9J2 4JJ9 C0LLGJ9OL1 G/AGGU LGA!2!0U2 !IJ bL!cG uq oribri

OC12 Ou JJG COLLGJ9cTO1J2 GMGGIJ LCM2TOU2 III bLicG uq oriçbrr LOM oit

LCAI2IoU2 onfbnç LGM2IOLJ2 12 COU2J2çGUç miçp (J) 92 J0U 92 3 ! 2cL1ccJ? bo2içiA

JOIACL2 cxbcCçGq bL!cG LOMJJ p? JJJOLG ou bGLcGur JpI2 J9LGL LG2BOU2JAGUG22 ot bL!cG

JJJJG LG2I1J2 ! LOlA Uqc9çG 9 0136 bGLccu !UCLG92G 1'-' Gxbccc6q onçbn LOMfJJ

lA0 LGAI2IOIJ2 p2 LflU1J1U 9 LGLG22!0U o bLicG LGAI2IOU2 013 onçbnç L6A1210112

lfl2iUG2 UJC92J1L1U 4}JG CGCç 0 9 biC9J mOUGçLX q2ç11Lp9UCG OU JJC LGI9I!AG 2G 0 fJJG

W0UG J2 9GCG ouj? !U IJJC qi2ç9IJç fTfnLG JjJ112 CX12çGUCG 0 4JJ12 20L O L9'Uq0W11622

!UUU!f J1cnLG ITIJLGJ9G cpi L9U0UJ1JG22 9iJ C1TLLGU onçbn LGeboUqe ouj?. 2J1jJcJ?. i

L9IJ01JJU622 0 bopc? pgu onçbnç L0/AJJ LGAT2IOU2 JJpG LG920U 12 wç onbn rn

CJJ9UG2 IU UJ0IJG? 113 JJ6 qi291Jç JTç13LG ;p bLicG L0lAJJ LGAJ2JOU2 9LG IJJOLG 9GCG p?k JJG

0JJGL c!W62 IPG!L !U0LW9c0U JflCG2 2UJ9JJGL L0MçJJ 2 J0IJ 92 4JJi2 JUOLIJJ9ç10U COUCGLU2

JJ9AG !UIOLUJ9IIOU JJ9'f J61 fCUJ 40 GXbGCç JJ1JJGL UJOIJG?i L0MfJJ 9U /U p? (j) IAJJ!IG

LG94 4JJG m0UG? 2i1bbJ? LflJG (J5) 92 913 9AGL9G OL 4ThiC9j LI1J6 JJJJ112 bGObJG 2OUJGc!13J62

UGGcJ 0 LUll 9 LGLC22i0IJ 0 COWb9LG J36!L LGJ9JAG 2G H0MGA6L !2 LUOLG L69201J9JG 40

cou.ccç bL!c6 uq onçbnç LGAI2!01J2 monjq G bcL6c;J? C0LLGJ9Gq 9Uq JJ6LG lAOllJq pG 130

LG2boU2G 0 2J10CJC2 J }JG IJJOGJ iUcJf1qiU flJG I3J0UG? 2nbbJ2 Lf1JG (j flLG combJGçGJ2,

! onbnç L0ThçJY JjJ12 !2 9 WG9211L6 o LGJ9;TAG 2i6 o bL!cG 9Uq onçbnç LGAJ2IOU2 1U

C0GfflCGU 0 JJG LGI20U 113 bLics L0IAJJ L0UJ IIJUIçA OU 4JJG c0LLG2b0UqU LGA!2!OU

Page 29: NBER - tog6061 · 2020. 3. 20. · J1G oLqou (oo) Gdn9oIJ 2 COU2!2cGIJ4 mcrxf pp nu€wbJo?uJGu; L9çc !2 922OCWG 1AçJJ anpaGdncuc 9jja u nuGmbJo2iiiGuc 9Uq (JCLL Ja!o) uq bL!C62

oncbnrcouboucu o onçbnç (v&iu pc fl fLGU JGAGj o onçbn) !2 M!P qGcJIJG2 JU C11LL6U

JJ ! cou!2cGU !P 2P!0 uq M20U2 (J) uqiu 1J 1} !UUOA9!OU ! fG bGLLIJU6Uç

couucciou pçItGu nuGLub1o?uJGu uq uou ab oujX €uq o

onçbn; L0MJJ (MJJIJG 9J20 bjiu 9 CG9LGL LOIG III }1G uJoqcJ u1IJGL ;nq? jp€ Gwb!L!c9J

C9112G JçO6mpGL M°°qI.°'q (ii) poi ;pç 4JJG2G LG IJJOLG LOUJ? 1!UY9 o GxbGcçGq

IJqJC9OL2 9uq JUUcoIJ. i dllJb}J92!G LUO2J 4G couucçou qccuqq W9U-JJOIIL2 p-

p!2 2cCç!OLr bcunc jj1LJJGt gzwj?aia o COUUGC0U GPAG€1J J9pOL W9LJG4

nubJo?wGn JJi2 12 bL€C!2GJ? JJ6 2OLJ O IJJS C0LLGJJOIJ GwbJJ92Gq !U ;p bJJ!JJ!b2 CJILAG

J3011L2 o p 2occq wjlp pJJ GxbGccGq uuou 'ir jgGbJ9c!u pJJ }JOIIL2 !AJJ

GxbGc4cq onbri qGcpu€ LG 922ocq miçp p1p GxbcçGq iuou OUG ionjq €xbGc pp

9 J1IJ1 CI1LLCIJ JGAGJ O }JOIIL2 eponjq pG aOCGq M!}J GXbGCCq onçbnf qGcUG2 11JCG

J0IJ JJOU0IJ LG 2!mbJ? GdcwJ (urnrn2) C11LLGU qcuqq JGAGJ 0j JJ0flL2 Jpn2

cxbGcGq onbri LOMçp OLGOAGL 2IUCG JJOflL2 LG 2c9!OU9LA GxbGcçGq JJOflL2 LOIA4}J OAGL

suq ooq,oLq (j) 2JJOM iuqGGq JJOflL2 LOM 916 pipjA COLLGI9IGJ p

/GLG biccçj COLLGJ9;6q jir bL9cpcG JJ12 COLLGJ9ciou !2 uoç BGqGCç 9JcponJJ ico;€aipct

III moç o JJG qGAGJObWGU4 O 2GC0U J I iuoLcq A9L!Tc1OU2 TU 1 20 JJ9f oiibiiç 9uq JJO(1L2

Onbrr .AGL2II2 HOL2

LCA!2!0U2 GxbGcçGq bLieG omcp 916 bo2!c!AGj? ocçq cp JJG CHLLGJJ !Ull0A90U U

9LG 2OWGMJJ9 JOMGL p9U J LOM 2JJ0M2 ;pc 92 WG uJoqGJ 9120 !UJb!!G2

uUooU iu on;bnç MJJGLG2 ;pG woqj bLGqc;2 GdrwJ -j ;p€ bo!u G2c!WcG2

coc!cu (combriçcq u (30) o 4G LG/1210U o orrçbrrç LOM [LOW 1'" OIl 4JJG

omçbn oçjr p 9WG mupiqc p€ iuuoi ou ru onçbnç LGboL;2 LGLG221OU

TJP LOlA t0C112G2 bLccieGJX ou dnG2pou 0 MJJGJJGL 4JJG OMUM9L2 L6A2!OU U GxbGc6q

bo2!;!AG !UU0A0U2 UJI12ç pG 0JJ0MG p) qGcJiuG2 U onbrrç o 4G 2UJG UJ9IJfl11qG JpG

9CC0LqiU o 4J1G WoqGj 9JJ JUU0A9!0U2 1U OfTçbJ14 oaçbn ouj?. JJJ112

;Mo iuçnqa upicj) coLLGJcq jpi Ia GX9'CcJ? iijç uioqj bLGqcca 2!IJC&

Page 30: NBER - tog6061 · 2020. 3. 20. · J1G oLqou (oo) Gdn9oIJ 2 COU2!2cGIJ4 mcrxf pp nu€wbJo?uJGu; L9çc !2 922OCWG 1AçJJ anpaGdncuc 9jja u nuGmbJo2iiiGuc 9Uq (JCLL Ja!o) uq bL!C62

noLis3ilqrnt a19bom 3rIi wod au3eib oi (01) eu I i1uar IHiqms eili niinosiq io13H

bewolLs ei t nedw enoiisIeilo3 iziqiuo-eDiiq io1 eaodi moil i&ffib noxi.si5Txoz) eluod-e3hq xo

bsbeqxenu ns ei lath edT . iii noisiisv lo eqii owl iebi2noD I noiisiieu1Li io'I ' .iisv ol

erli d 1(ivii3uboiq inerwD eei.si bor{ eidi ;ieveiol iaiaieq oi beiDeqxe i isdi flu 9f1fb nedw bsnLsiieine ei eqi idi lo aboda liiO .iivii3uboq ewiul aeisi ii as irrnorn emsa

saeqqsd isdw 1ebiLio3 I!I bnoe2 .11sw mohnsi s wo1Io1 voIonrbei Jsdi berrzuas ei ii

edi isdi wod iliw I .eiuiijl et{i ni woi 111w isdi I is belsevei ai noiisrniolni nedw

ei{i lo abor1 isienom Ilila em eierli eierlw lebom s ni) bnbl lath ecu lo a?bor{ lo &neiixs

beisleiloD 1sviiioq eioin ed ol &joiisvonni ehq bris aiuorl absel (xeihse belebianoD bnbl

isdi eeilqmi boda lo eqi bnoDea edi lo eneeiq edT .anoiisvorini eiiq bns inqino nsrli

edi usd1 ieAsew ed bluoda r1iwoi eiiq bus r1iwoi aiuocl neewied noiisIeTxo3 evii&en ecu

.diwo sDhq beiDeqxe bus r1iwoi Juqiuro beiDeqxe neewied noiisbTio3

I -r us io1 c aeaisi d3idw bus 1 is LrwonI aemo3ed Jsdt borla s iaill iebiarroD

bnoqeei ion asob boia snom edi nimuaas istii aeilqmi (11) noiisup .inuoms emsa ecu

1snoiiioqoxq ai iuqiuo eauszeH .boda edi 10 inuoms ecu aemii ( —

1) d 11s1 I is aeDrIq

sill lo iriuorns edi aemii ( —

1) id asaii iuqiuo isdi eeilqrrii airli aeDrIs1sd enom Lasi ol

Ihul sill 'd saii bluow luqiuro ernia I is IlsI ieum bnsd iedio sill no bshow eiuoll .boda

ui bus L eDfIia IDOfla 3111 isfiA .insianoD bsnismsi aiuod-nsm Ii bor{a odi lo inuomg

bsbeqxe sill oi Isnoiiioqoiq em aiuod ui asgnscb bsiDsqxe ecu snsr1o at boiosqxs ion sis .iuqiuo iii asnsrb

isdi noiis3ilqrrn sill isils ion esob ?boria yo1onc13si lo sq'i aicli b eneesiq edi audT

as iliwoi luqino ui notatvsi ol sw ems sdi ui beislei ed bhsoda diwoi siiq ui anozatvei

bus asoilq flO 133113 auoensin&iani us asil looula s rloua iu .c1iwoi eiuod ui anoiaivs-i at

9Ediudhi3 9d vjm 93ib1q iii i11ib anoiiI9no3 9i1q-a1uod bas 93i1q-Juquo riw nozi 9di lo j1q l9bom &Ii 13v9woH . ni enoiiiiv 'd bs1uiq3 ai ooi aidi jebora ebUI aidi nI .noiJhJmu33s lsiiqs3 oi

bn8 i1u1iEH eea iriuoxs olni air! i aei isif I Isbom s ioI . ni anoiisiiv eaerli b iierxeobne edi eieferi .(QQI) jj1oq

edi iii .au,orf bn inqino aeathi l3orfa voIonrbei eviiiaoq jebom eb' aaeniaud 1ei bibnia edi nI eviiiaoq s absI Isbom edi sausoed eldixefi eew ae3iIq 'Ii neve iniano 'sia bluow eiuod bbom 1u911u3

aeDilq eldixeft rfiiw bluow ii ndi east asaii iuqiuo iadi e-zuane nsrli asiiq 'bii .'Iqqua iodsl lo eanoqae .11th aiuod Isdi oa

8$

Page 31: NBER - tog6061 · 2020. 3. 20. · J1G oLqou (oo) Gdn9oIJ 2 COU2!2cGIJ4 mcrxf pp nu€wbJo?uJGu; L9çc !2 922OCWG 1AçJJ anpaGdncuc 9jja u nuGmbJo2iiiGuc 9Uq (JCLL Ja!o) uq bL!C62

WOAC u obbo2!cG qi.cou2 iJ LGabou2G 2flC 2pocJ2 HoMCL 2111CC rpc iio 2CLIC2 9LC

ir 2icJ bucG woqG o 2GCc!Ou T 2UCG woqcj qe onçbnç uq ponLe o

!UUoJ9T!oU iu oribnç JJP!2 iIJCOU2çGU M!cIJ J9LC LoJC OL L9IJOW M9JJ

JJJG 2GCOJJ LO/A 2JJ0/A2 4JJ9 ILTJJOA 011 !U JJOITL2 !2 GX1L6WGJ? pTJJj? COLLGJ9C M1JJ IJJC

IA1p gC 24LG22G 111 j<qjuq 9IJ bLG2CO (j) pOIIL2 moi j ;jJu on;bnç92 92 JJG 29119L qGAJ9çJou oj JJG Juuoi;iou !U on;bnr ! drnfG co11212ç611;

o, ;pe 9JG 2OM2 ;pc eçuqLq qGA9;ou o iuuoiçlou iu ponL ! ponç jwjI COU2GL LGJ9!ou2p!b PC/ACCU UJ9U-JJOTIL2 uq UJ910U !U JJ9'pJC Lç LOM

LOMJJ

2LOIJGL (9uq IJJOLG IJG9iAG) p9u jJG COLLG2boUqU COLLGJ9OU !UAOJA!IJ LGA!2O112 !' OITL2

J1G COLLCJ91011 GfMGCU LGA1210112 iu onçbnç iomçp uq LGA2OIJ2 !IJ bL!cG L0/AflJ 2ponJq JG

LOMp 91J LGAI2IOU2 111 br.c LOMp Jpfl2 4JJG GX2GUCG 0 fJJ2 2JJOCJ morijq !mbP PT

9n4JJOL? 1J9 qOC2 uo Lc2bouq) /AG9JCU2 1JJG UG9TAG COLLGJ9;iOU GMG6U LGAT2JOU2 111 JJOTTL2

9j20 pc cxbcq€q o 2pocy (9JM922 9ccomb9uGq p? 9 iJOUC;9L?

2111CC 0ITL2 LJ2C 9 S 11J112 G Gxbccccq 0 CCJ11JC GJACGU 9IJq + (XY !IJCG bL!C C9U

G GxbCcGq ;o jyJI T + C MJJGIJ JJG GCOUOUJ JIJ9JJ? q0G2 GCOUJG IJJOLG bLoqncçAG uqq

buc MIJJ COU;IIJIIG yjj uq onçbnç /AJJJ COIJIUITC 4O LOM HOflL2 011 JJG OpGL JJiTq C9U

2nc!G1JcJA ]9LG JJJJ2 LIJG9U2 oriçbnç 9uq JJOIIL2 LI2G 9; J3G 2JJOCJ JLUbJIG2 ;pç

(ii) !mbJ! ;prç bLrcc2 29L jjJJu I1 GqcGJ? cjionj JJCL j9jj 9 mjj pc 29JJ !e

pci; L9!2G2 OL 9Jj £ LG9CL JJ9U % + V BGC9fl2G btc€a 9LG 24CJ 9uq jOLM9Lq joojqu

GCO1IJC2 JJOM G9LJ1GL JjJfl2 fJJG 2JJOCJ 9ç 92 110 GILGC 011 OL £ 9LT(T % +

NO/A CoU2iqcL 9 2!W1JL 20L O bGLuuGuç 2OCJ ;O bLoqrrc;A;? pci; !w!UC ;J; !;

!2 flbJJGJq

COLLGJ9JGq bL!cG uq oiibri IJUOA9i0IJ2 2 MC 2JJY'JJ 2G& bLGqc;ou O lJJG 4JJGOL?

29A 0UJ W JJG2G IJJOAGWGU2 Zt JG9J bL!CG uq JJOJIL2 !11110A9!0112 ;o p IIJOLG

flG9;!AG y22nLu1u JJGLG 9LG 9J20 1JJ0UC9L 2poCJ2 0 JJG 20L cou2qGLGq C9LflGL OUG C9U

;1o112 bo;1i JAP!JG 1; ;uqe ;o W9J<G ;JJG COLLGJ9';!OU GJAGGU onçbn; 9U bLCG !UU0A90U2

JJOITL2 o ;p 29UJG 2U jç ;cuq W9JG ;JJG COLLGJ9!OU pGMGCU JJOI1L2 9uq bI.!cc !UUOA9-

Page 32: NBER - tog6061 · 2020. 3. 20. · J1G oLqou (oo) Gdn9oIJ 2 COU2!2cGIJ4 mcrxf pp nu€wbJo?uJGu; L9çc !2 922OCWG 1AçJJ anpaGdncuc 9jja u nuGmbJo2iiiGuc 9Uq (JCLL Ja!o) uq bL!C62

20

1o"V M}ICU J1fl iucJnqG flJG lp0L 2JJLG 91G pOflL L€A2OIJ2 IJJOIG CIOGJ? ociçGq Micp GxbGcccq

coGfflccu oIl JJG poriL A9L9jG 12 21119Jj 9uq 2ç92cc9JJ? lu2iuqc9uç MJJIJG ;pG cojci€uO 9 LGLG22JOU W9c ucjnqca Ofl4bST L€iiiou p9 Gaacuf19J no j€cr jp6

J3G C92G MJJGLG 1jic ucjnqc 4JJG J9OL 29LG 9qqIJ IJG LGA!2OU O J1011L2 LOMJJ

LGboI4cq jOL Gdfl9j jo cJII9LçGL2 9uq O UlJç?

bTp O '7b OIl 4JJG OçpGL M0 LGA2OU2 JJJJG LG2flJfIJ G2c!w9G2 9Uq 249Uq9Lq CLLOL2 9LG

tOJJOM2 tLOIJJ cJJG bo!uc c2c!UJ9cc2 o €2cw9cGq AVW JjJGIf J Urn LCLG22!0U o 29wbJG

! JPP1G JOL G9'CJJ 2bcCqC9'çJOu j COIJLITC mbj€ bçp o 7b yI\ uqo onçbn LOM 911q LGA!2!OU O JJOfIL2 LOMJY IIGLG22OIJ2 O fJJ2 2OL4 9'LG LGbOLGq

UrU LGL€221OU2 CXbj9'IU LGAI2IOIJ2 TU bLGqcçGq bLICG IJJOAGUJGU2 M1JJ pOJJ flJG LGAI2IOU

GxbcccGq LOM in onçbn !2 IJJOLG CJO2GJ? LGJ9G GxbGCcGq bL!cG IJJOAGIJJGU2 !2 °

bctJJ9'b2 moic qiLc in€cpoq OL 2rrq?4u p€ GxbGcçGq LOMçp lu OITL2

pocj o ;cpuojo c s + IJJ9'4 GCOUJG JCIJoMu

P!2 2)2ICIJJ3 cpG COLLGJ9'c!OU ThGGU I\ V'bQ !2 -J5 JJJJ2 211G22 2OUJG LOJG J0L

- MJJGII O}J JJC HJGLG22 L9çG 9'JJq 4JJG IJJOUG49LA p9'2c 9'LG ucJnqcq !u JJG /TJf MJJ!JG !U

cIJ9U 12 oiiçbiiç LGAJ2IOIY LOL Gx9'nJbJG fG COLLGJ9!OU GMGGU 7l 9Uq V 2 oiij?

pOL!OU) !2 GUGLJJ?k UJOLG MG9'JCJ? 9'22OC9'IG MflJJ JJG bL!cG LGA!2!OU OAGL JJG !UU!IG IJOL!OU

011 4JJG OIJJGL JJ9'IJ fJJG O11L2 !IJUOA9'!OU (ot 4}JG LGA!2!OIl !IJ JJOJ1L2 LORJJ OAGL 111J1.1!

p cowbiu GUçLIG2 111 4JJG cplLq LOM O J9JC 2 O O2G !U f PG LOlA O j9'pJG F

pG buc Juuoi9'çiou rç pciiu onçbnç 'uq bLicG !UUOA9'c!OU JJJJ2 C9U pc 2GGU

' IJJ9' GCOIJJG JrUOMU 9 JJGLG 12 9' 2LOUGL boeiçrAG COLLGJ9!OU GIAGGU 1IJG JJOflL2 uq

2OWG 9'2b6Cç2 O rnuOA9'pOrr COU2!2GU !A1JJ JJG GX!2çGUCG O 2OIJJG 2JJOCJ2 O IGC)JUO1OA

9LG 2!WbJ? JJG IJG9';1AG O 4JJG JUIJOA9'pOU 111 J1G JGAGJ O J1011L2 94 % 20 WG l9'PIG 9'J20 2}30M2

}GC9JJ OI1L2 9'LG 2f9';IOU9'L2. 20 LGM210U2 111 4JJG LOM O JJOI1L2 GfMGGU % 9'uq i +00

J 112G LGA!2!0U2 !IJ ;JJG LOMJJ O, uJ9'u-ponL2 92 obboeGq o LGA!2!0U2 !U IJJG LOIAJJ O oncbrir

JpG uGxç 2Gf O LOtA2 qi2bJ9'?2 UJ9'U? O COLLGJ9cOUa qJabJ9'2Gq u jp'pj j GxcGbç

no BGLGC;J?k COLLGJ9'G 2IICJJ 2JJOCJ<2 c9u uoqcc LoJG

Page 33: NBER - tog6061 · 2020. 3. 20. · J1G oLqou (oo) Gdn9oIJ 2 COU2!2cGIJ4 mcrxf pp nu€wbJo?uJGu; L9çc !2 922OCWG 1AçJJ anpaGdncuc 9jja u nuGmbJo2iiiGuc 9Uq (JCLL Ja!o) uq bL!C62

2T

HO1AGAGL OL couJbJGçcuGe2 4JJG pOOIJJ LOM 0 JpJG bLc2Guç2 COLLCJ10U2 0j buc LGM2TOU2

p! qou€ p12 UJJUJ?k GCfJ2G Luu-ponL2 LG UJOLG cJo2GJ? i,ip onbnç LOMfJY

obbo26q O fJJG UJOLG COIJAGJJI1OU9'I LGJ9!ou2JJ!b iiçp nuGlubjo2iuGur y2 2flG2G GLflGL j

ju ;pi cou prt cou2qGLGq ouj? LcJ!ou2pb GfM6GU W9u-ponL2 uq bL!cGe 2

LOMJJ 'uq cxbGCcGq O11L2 LOM4JJ 12 bLox? 0L 4JJG2G 2yop

GL JJ LGC 0 CGL11J cccpuojo 2J10CJC2 9'IJq ;jç IJJG q6LGucG GMGGIJ GxbGCcGq OflL2

bo22ipiJiç? MO2G flJJ GxbJoLçJou urneç 9w1; TJTLcJJGL moq 12 pç mou€2 2abb1) qo€uqGbGuqcuc bo2çAG GGC ot GxbcccGq Offl2 LoMf p uo 20 G92? L1OUJ1G O

2 JOUR 92 4JJGLG 9LG AL 10112 !11 JJG GXbGCcGq LOMfJJ 0 0 JJG Of JJGL puq f}1G

!u fG bLceducc o fC cxbccccq JJOflL2 L0Mf AL!PJG !2 C0u2!2cGuf M!cp fJJG uoq€j 0 2GCf0U

j,pG p'cç pç Gxbccfeq onçbnç LOMf m9iufiu2 If 2 UGfIAG GUGCc oil buc LOMf GAGU

!U bL!CG2 6!U poJqiu CO112f9Uf LGA!2oIJ2 p1 OflL2 LOMfp

04JJGL puq bo2rfiAG LGAI2IOU2 !11 OfTfbfIf LOMfJJ LGUJ9'!U UGf!AGJX COLL6J9fG tMf}J LGM2IOU2

9LG bo2 tci1. LGp1fG !uc!ou poJqu COU2f9f ffJG LGA2OU pJ oITfbfIf LoMcp o" fGMG 266 f G 0bb02ifG b02!cAG LGAI2IOIJ2 JJOIIL2 Lomcp (vGu6ciA6 iuuoAfiou2 111 JJOIIL2)

9'220CfGq mifp boaiçii LCAI2IOIJ !U GxbcccGq !UUc!011 B"f3 III f JIG LGLG22T0U2 0 j,9pj€

bLicc2 LP!2 WG9Uf 9 fiJJ CfILLGUf p1pOL W9LJG ( bo2ifiAG IUUOA9f IOU 111 pollL2) M92

JIOIIL2 L0MfJI (OL UGrf JAG JJOITL2 iIJ1J0Afi0U2) MJIGLG UGfiAGJ? C0LLGp1fG MIfJJ LGAI2IOU2 111

CKILAG G[GCf 2IICIJ bP!IJ!b2 C11LAG 6ILGf bLG2GUf !11 JJPIG MJJGLG bo2if JAG LGAI2IOU2 III

!U fP Of JIGL 2bGC!UCf!0U2 Bf fJ112 GGCf 12 0 fJJG obboerfG 21IJ fJJU f JIG 1121WJ bP!JJ!b2

011 f JIG OfJJGL JJUq LGM2IOU2 JU JJOIIL2 L0MfJJ cjo JJ9AG 9IJ JuqGbGuqGuf GGCf 011 !UJ9c!OU

JU JJOi1L2 JL0W fO IUIJUIf?i

JIAG cJJG 2911J6 GGCf Oil iufJfiOu /AJJGfJJGL OL IJOf fJJG? fLG 922OCp1fG MJfJJ GxbcccGq CJJ911G2

011 !UWf!0U 011 fJJG Of JJGL JI9IJ fJJG LGLG2210U LG2IlJf 2 2 f}l9f LGAJ2JOII2 p1 onçbnç LOMfJI

IIJOAGUJGIJf p1 JJOIIL2 L0MfJJ fJJf 12 UOf C0LLGJ9fG MIfJJ onfbnf L0MfJJ JJ92 110 iUJb0LfUf G[GCf

1pG C0LLGJf!0U OJ GxbGcfcq orlfbnf L0MfJJ MJfJJ JJOI1L2 L0M;JJ 111 Of JJGL M0L2 9U?

2bGCqJc9ci0u COLLGp1!OU OJ f JIG LGAJ2IOU 111 JJOIIL2 L0MfJI MJfJJ !U1Jf!0U L0MfJJ J2 (JuG fO

OIl JJG Onfbnf A9Li9pJG LG AGL?. 2JUJJJL fO fJJO2G L€boLfcq GJ0M JU J,9pJG JJJS12 JIJ IJJ!2

Page 34: NBER - tog6061 · 2020. 3. 20. · J1G oLqou (oo) Gdn9oIJ 2 COU2!2cGIJ4 mcrxf pp nu€wbJo?uJGu; L9çc !2 922OCWG 1AçJJ anpaGdncuc 9jja u nuGmbJo2iiiGuc 9Uq (JCLL Ja!o) uq bL!C62

bsbn9li5b erli ebu1zrni isili MAV ifi I eeerli riiido oT .anoiivei irxem'o1qmenu ditw

thido oi beau ed a& SlAV eiriT .aiuod-asm bebnezieb usd1 Isilisi 5151 inemofqmsnu

riis.s eno em nothod siinfhui sill iol doidw lnem'olqmenu lo elsi uliwoi siLl ui enoiaivsi

8id1 lo noislsiio sill alnsasiq woi las! silT .noiisvorini insmolqmsnu sill (aunim) ol [slips

lqsx1 .diwo sziiq iol rioiaivsi nibnoqaeno sill riliw nothorl siinfirii sill isvo anoiaivei

usd1 isffsrna lid £ eiiup em anoilsisrIoD sill aebuloiii SLAV sill sisrlw sas sill ui

-rism sill abes3xs noilsisrioD lrzemoIqmsnu sill eliilW .aiuoil-nsm rIiau anoilsisrioD srI I ilhiw MAY sill ;(C8.) lisma sliup ai sia siuloads all M lo eas erli ui noiis1sno aiuod

.anoiaivsi snq bus aworl-nsm lo noiislsrlo3 wol 'ILsuaunu eisieno 01 ansqqsil iauj M isnoiia sisione ol mesa ion asob eiuorl-nsm nsili isrilsi insmo1qmsnu lo sau sill auilT

.noiisfmni ilhiw aqidanoilsisi

1!0q 1EterIoM lo nietJ 911T

lebom isdT .1 noilsa lo Isbom sill lo amisi ui 'GIno sDnsbive sill beisbienoD evsrl I is1 oe

nsbnoqesno bsoid iisv s ioI beIool Lno svsrl I isili oe svii3iIhesi Isv seiuoz lo ci

ciii uI .aiuoil bus asDiiq iuqiuo lo ainsmsvorno3 sill bits enoxiDibs'Iq alsbom sill neewied

lisle I .anibnl1 lsDiIiqms sill o enoils3ilqmi sill !bsoid siom isrlwsmoa eau3eib I notiosa

asil isdi I noibse 10 Lebom sill 1 insrisv a lo lilil ui ahluesi ieihse sill niisiqisinieI 'd noiaauoaib Isiens siom £ ol mul I risilT .eesiiq eldixell bus 'olloq 'islenom auonsobns

.3r1oq 'isieriom lo nisiisq sill luods 'Iqmi enxbnf1 sill isdw lo

sDhq lo noilsisnoD ns dhiw hfisiaienoD Ci I nOLi)sa lo lebom sill Isdi isslo sd bluoula II

em asonq bus anoilsuloufi luqluo lo soiuoa 'lno sill ci t Ii nsve erioiisvonrit huqino bus

buoqasi m isili ci bebseri ci isili Ifs (18I) isaaolq baa niX d iuo bsinioq cA .sldixs[t

noilsilni sill lo aiosfie sill niioni isill sion eiill sea oT ui eensilo ol 'Ieisibernrni

inslarioo S ol qu ci Isili ci iluasi silT .Jnsianoo sis eiuorl isili Iqmi ceonq eldixeil xsi isill saoqqua woVI

— m ol Isupe lnsbanoo s oh qu riias ai sliilw ol Lsups

ifhiw isilisoi ecu oi aeoiiq bssl iliw ui anoiisvonrii ovihiaoq rteilT .IIsw mobrisi a awollol

sill esvssl culT .hinu eno usd1 siom icc asaisi iii sassiom iinu sno s as noI as luqiuo

Page 35: NBER - tog6061 · 2020. 3. 20. · J1G oLqou (oo) Gdn9oIJ 2 COU2!2cGIJ4 mcrxf pp nu€wbJo?uJGu; L9çc !2 922OCWG 1AçJJ anpaGdncuc 9jja u nuGmbJo2iiiGuc 9Uq (JCLL Ja!o) uq bL!C62

o ;p cç cp p ou 9.JJ0M2 mou€? ;o LG2bouq o nuucicibi€q bGiui9.uGuf C9.UG2 lu GCJ1UOJOia!h1!WUI AnU2 (To4) LGGcçiou O pJ6 bucG woqcj MYf g moucçtX £qP ! bLop9.pf? qnG

woq€ 9j2o jq o OLGC99.JG oiiçbnç LUOAGIJJG2JJ L6 UiiTCJJ 21119116L JJU JJG O2GLA6 0U62ijoçcupct uq ooqoiq (ii) LI1G }Jf L9.UOUJ IA9.JJC UI fccpuoJo)L tAflJ 9. LICJ6L 1J6OCJ22!C9.J

LGCOUC!JG JJC2G q9ç9 JATçJJ qJGLGUç bLicG 2GççJIJ LUoqGJ2 92 JoIJ 92 OUG !2 11!Jfl11 O GUcGL9!U

JJG J!q!c o b1Lf!CITI9L moqja o bL!cG 9uq oiibnç qGçGLwJU9;oIJ OJJGL MOL2 OUG C9LT

12 92 1UOLW911AG 9OfT PC Th9X JJG UJOUG2. acOCJ GAOJAG2 IU LG2bOU2G 92 12 ponc

jç eponjq pc 9bb9LGuç LOW cp!2 q2cn22ou p mu bL!c€ uq onçbnç

L12C2 nuGxbGccGq2. pii qoe uoç qGcJuG 92 !c2G! t9'J12 9CJ 4OM9L2 142 UOLIJJ9J in€

O GUJbOL9'L2. !ucLG92G2 u OUG onjq 9.AC GxbJ9.!u IAp2. &s L!2G2 qL9uJ9c9JJ2. MJJGU

!UUOA9c!0U2 rn onçbn 9LG 922OC9C m1p cxbcç€q q€cpuG u onbnr i f P!2 2 9fLpflçGq

MP tAonjq 2CLU wj fpi2 9 b9LpcllJ9LJ2. qcnJc 2J 2 92 MC 29M bo!AG

MJJGGL UJ9JC2 2GU2G OL IJJOIJG2. 4O LG2bouq qGLGuçJ2. o o WOAGUJGU2 IIJ

uq nubLGqcç9.pJC UJOACWGU2 u 12 JCJ OL t11LPGL LG2G9LCJJ 12 o 9IJ9'J2.G

q!WJ 9L2G2 GC9i12C cIJG!L cCqp9cJ LIlIG W9.2. uoç qi2c1urrap 211WCTGIJ4J2. GfMGGU bLG-

4CCpUOJO2. 2JJOCJ2 GAGU 9IJGL 9J1OMiU OL 9 91LJ2. GJ9OL9G mOuGç9L2. GG9CJ( LITJG JJJG

pq qjcrrJf2. GxbJ9.1uJu cpG pcp!oi o bL1cc JGAGJ 1" UJoqJ UAGU 6XCJ1121ACJ2. p2.

O UJOAGUJGU2 u 9LG 9uicib9cq jp m2. GxbJ9.!u MJJ2. }(iU 9uq M92011 (J)

qGLGuCG 113 M92. UJOUG2. LG2bouq2 ;o nu9.u1cb94€q C9UG2 !U 9IJq M92. LG2bOUq2

UJO/GIJJGIJ2 9LG uG9c!AGJ2. COLLCJ9G Micp bLGqcç9pJG onçbnç UJOAGWGU2 GLG Wfl2 p

J,pn2 oL oirçbnç uq bL1cc uuoA9pou2 pG bo2!!AGJ2. COLLCJ9G MJJ1JC bLGqicc9pJG BLICG

bcLioq !c LIJJl2f PC fiG C92G IA!!! UO L2G 91 + p2. 1J11Cp 92

JOLGC92ç p9ç OfTçbfIf MiJJ L!2G GMGGU S 9'Uq + JJOL bLICG2 O pG OLGC92G 4O qGcJuG OAGL

MGLG 12 2çLICf2. bo2içiAG n GCOWG2 JUJOMU ;pç MIff Li2G 9GU2 91 i MIII

J0LGC92;9pJG oiibiiç UJOACUJGU2 It 1UOLIJJ9p0U 12 LGAG9JG 91 9pOfl UJOAGUJGU2 ! +

110 tOLGC929'PJG UJOAGWGU2 ! onçbii i L tOJJOM2 9 L9UOUJ M9JJC g B'I C9U

OPA!0fl2I2. fiG UGJGC O C9b!ç9.J 9ccilLUilJ91JoU 1WB11G2 4JJ91 111 moqcj IJJGLG 9LG

UJOAGUJGU2 111 bLicG2

thi€eçiou O Mp2. tOLGC929P!G IJJ0AGLUGU2 iu onçbn 9LG UG91iAGJ2. COLLGJ91G M!P tOLGC929PJG

Page 36: NBER - tog6061 · 2020. 3. 20. · J1G oLqou (oo) Gdn9oIJ 2 COU2!2cGIJ4 mcrxf pp nu€wbJo?uJGu; L9çc !2 922OCWG 1AçJJ anpaGdncuc 9jja u nuGmbJo2iiiGuc 9Uq (JCLL Ja!o) uq bL!C62

3cf

IJOIJJ!U9J 0Db 12 UO GXbGCcGq O cpuG JpJ212 9' JGS2c COU2I2çGUç lMJJ JJG UG9çJAG COLLG-

o am m9uiç1IqG uq oBBo21çc q€cçou u b ju O JJGL !AOL2 f 2 9' LflJG MJJGLG

c9'29'pJG C9'UG2 u I\ Low ouM9'Lq2 uneç p 9'ccowb9uGq p? OLGC9'2ç9'JG cp9uG

c1' pi2 woucçL? bojic?. LflIG 111 9'qA9'uc coua9'iuç () n.ubp pç oi.-

iwb1cwcupu p12 LITJC 2IIJCC jci UGG2 ouj? ;o cpu€ lu LG2boueG ;o bLcqcç9'pJG UJOAGIJJU2

JJ9' 4JJG GXI2çGUCG O J9'2 JU 4JJG GGC2 o CJJ9'UG2 lu mou ou onçbnç boa€a uo bLopJGm OL

% 4O !UU0A9'1!0U2 lu t !' !c 9'JJ0M2 jj bGLoq !UUOA9'c!0U2 o 9IGC E!U9IJ uoçG

o" OfJJGL p9'uq JIG LIIJG qo uo LGdnJLG p 9'JG o LG2bouq

bL6qJcç'pJc C}J9'UG2 JU J JJG AGJOC1c? O JJG OJC1J JI (55) M1JJ CJJ9'1JG2 JU

2IICJJ 9 UJOUGf9'L? LfTJG GIJJp0qJG2 JJG OAGLUWGIJ J2 GxbGcGq O2G

9LG UO 2?2fGUJ9'c1C9'JJ?k LGJ9'4Gq O JJLWGL CJJ9'UG2 JU JJG GjGC4AG mou nbbj? I4OG

1flJ62 IAGLG S C9'IJ CJJ9'UG JIJ LG2b0U2G IUUOASçIOU2 9'ç pnç MJJGLG JJG2G bGLJoq s

!U LGRbOU2G 0 9'U? 1IJOLW9ç!OU JJ9' J2 LGAG9'JG 9' ju OJJGL ThOL2 j !AJJJ cou2JqGL UJOUG9'LA

yccoLqiu fpJ2 bojic? CGIJLj p9'uj ionjq uoç 9'JJOM us CJJ9'UG LOW $ + j OUM9'L2

ot fl o iipç ouG !AOf1J bLcqc WOUGI9'L 9'nfpoLJ ,oJJoMcq en.ubJG bojic2

J,O LU9'JG LGJ9'ciAGJ GUGL9'J 2ç9'GWGIJç2 9'pOSI IJJOUG9'L? bOJ1C j MIff COLUb9'LG

JJG 4IAO 9'22cç2 92 !U (55)•

2JUCG JIG iioq€j 12 COU2J2çGIJç MJçJJ 4JJG GXJ2GUCG O 9' 2GCOIJ WOIJGç9L? 9a2Gç 9' !' (so) Uq

J2 UO AGL LG2LiC;i,G j €J062 uo LGdITTLG 9' COU2f9U AGJOCJç? O OjJCJ9J UJOUGç9L? 9L69G2

2GC41OU3 j /MJJ fO qo 20 J/X JUGLCU2 M!JJ PG p9'2Gq OU JJG A9JiqJç). O (2) psic cJJJ2

9'pO1I 4JJG UJOUG? aiibbj? LITJG JJ9' C9'U G qG2cLJpGq JU GUGL9'J fGLW2' JU 4JJG LG2l

Jj!2 L9J2G2 pc dnG2çiou o MJIG}JGL bLJcG-o11çbn c0LLGJ9';Joua GLupoq? IUOLUJ9'f IOU

9'uq IJO OO MiqGJ? 9' A9'LJ9'UCG M!IJJ JJ6 O2GLA6 UJOAGWGU2 JU UJOUG49'L? 9'LG9'G2

bLicc-onçbn COLLGJ9ioU2 12 11 JUA0JA 9' ujouc). 2nbbJ2. LflJG cp9' J2 eJuJbJG bJ9'n2JpJ&

UJ0qGJ2' MJ'c UJ9'JG2 JJG 2ciCJ(?. bLice LuoqGJ Oj 2GCJOU I 9'ccL9cl!AG 9'2 911 GXbJ9'U9'4JOU o cjic

bLJcG-on;bnç COLLGJ9'çJOIJ2 COUç9'JU 110 JU0LUJ9'p0U 9'OIT bLice qGcGLuIJu9'cJoU JU 9'LG94IAG

qicLcuç usoqcja jOL çJJG 2ç0CJ JJJ9' J2 uoç fO 29A ;J19' 4JJG

Page 37: NBER - tog6061 · 2020. 3. 20. · J1G oLqou (oo) Gdn9oIJ 2 COU2!2cGIJ4 mcrxf pp nu€wbJo?uJGu; L9çc !2 922OCWG 1AçJJ anpaGdncuc 9jja u nuGmbJo2iiiGuc 9Uq (JCLL Ja!o) uq bL!C62

32

pG 29UJbJJIJ A9L1TIJCG iu \ i2 enujcicuçj? 2UJJJ pc3 Gxc€bç in ou€ c92G OIJG cu LGlGc;

LOE4JJ p? UJOLG JJflJ OUG bGLcGuç j COGWCGUI2 9AG 20JflC A9'J11G2 9pOAG J J uq

AGLC onçbnf LONJJ p? ou bGLcGuç GxbGcçGq bLcG LOMJJ JJ2 2JJOL O 9'AGLG BL!CG

LOlA o J9'pJC j jjn iuqic'ç tAJJCIJ GxbGccGq oriçbn; LoMçp LOW ;o iuui GXCGG2

!1191 CDh) ! bL!cnIL UL2 LO/A o, 9pJs MJJ!cp LcbLoqncc2 4pG 2GACUJJ

qL9'mic9'JX ,LoW 4G boJ!c? o, jm1ugu bLGqccpJC moimu u ni (9uq JJJ12 JU 110111-

O1J' JJIG LGLG221OU COGCicUç2 G2 'JJ9 }J6 9'Cc119'J bojic? Ot cJJG JGGL9'J J'G2GLAG fljGL2

2 qi2bJ9'?e G2G LGLG22JOU2 9'2 /AGJJ 9'2 2!LIJJ9'L LGLG22OU2 tOL 4JJG OUG dn9'LGL IJOL!-

oc9'cGq /p bLIcC LCM2JOU2

IJJG LGLG22!OU O LCM2JOU2 U GxbGcccq bL!cG L0MJJ OU LCA!2OU2 U Oflçb1T4 LO/Af 12 WO2J

bLcqrcçcq bLcc LOMcJ1 V2 J 9'LflC C9'LJ1CL cJJ12 2flG2 JJ9' OL pOL!OU2 JJG CLLOL

JJG t9'L tITJ1LG 12 UGJipJG f pc OçJJGL pnq 2ITCJJ 91J !UCLG9'C }J9'2 9' 2iuqc9'uc GGC OU

G1.GC On C11LLGU onçbnç (ruq ou bLGqcç9'pJc L0/AJJ !U orrbric) ot 9'U JUCLC9'2G in

moqGj 2flC o, 2ccc!ou j MJJGLC bLCqcç9'pG IJJ0UG9'L?. bojic 9'2 LG9'J G1GC2 cp€

MJJGLG bLGqlcccq onçbnç to/p 12 iuqcbGuqGu; o bLcqcçcq mouGç9L? bojic? Be CAGU

oujX on cpuoJoic9'J obboLcnu!cG2 jç monjq 9'J20 PC 9'2GU !u pc jnc (T3) moqcj

GxbGcGq cp9'uC u onçbnç iç2cJ' ricp 9'u G[,Gc; onjq G CU;!LGI? 9'p2cIJc ! oirbnç qGbcuqGq

9'22IIIJJC T,nLc}JGL G2G 2Jipç IIJCLC92G2 OL qGCLG9'2G2 III Lt JJ9'AG 9' UGJ!!p1C GJGCI OU

9'220Ci9'4Gq /AIçJJ 9' 2jipç JUCLG9'2G 111 J 9'IJ 20UJCf1JG2 9'220C9'Gq 9' 2I!P qGCLG9'2G' J

/A1JJ enbbo2G p9'ç LITJC i uoç CX9'Cç: 9'u? 1AGIJ GxbGcçGq ori;bnç CJJ9'IJG 12 20UJGLIJ62

9' qGGLIIJ1U12ç1C LGJ9'10U G/AGGU GXbGCcGq bLrcG uq GxbGcccq onçbnf CJJ9'IJG2 \j 9'poA&

J JJG IJJ0Ucç9'L? LJ1JG /ACLG oJJotAcq CX9'CJ uq (2) pcjq /AiçjJoiTç GLL0L JJGLG Moflq p

9'LG9'G2 JJGUJ2GJAG2

GxbGccGq onçbnç c9'UG JJJJG eccouq 12 JJG op2GLA9'c!ou o cxbGcGq CJJ9'UG2 !U fG UJ0UGç9'L?

pG 2çnq? o, ;JJG muçnq€ o ;JJG GxbGcfGq bLicG cp9'uG ipc !2 v22oc!9'cGq MJJ 9' /GU

uq ou JJC qiLccçiou !U ThP!CJ i; qcb9'Lça j,Low C9'IJ pc Opc9'IJGq J,LOIJJ AO 20(1LCG2 JjJG L2

!U J9'pJG I' EJ1LPGL !U0Lm9'c!0U OU ;JJG GXGU 0 /AJJJCJJ 4G GqGL9'J }'G2GLAG OpG?2 4JJ2 LIIJG

J9T!OIJ GMGGU 1.OLGC9'2c9'PIG bucG uq onbnç LU0AGUJGU2 OAGL Jou poLou2 W9'c i bLG2GuçGq

Page 38: NBER - tog6061 · 2020. 3. 20. · J1G oLqou (oo) Gdn9oIJ 2 COU2!2cGIJ4 mcrxf pp nu€wbJo?uJGu; L9çc !2 922OCWG 1AçJJ anpaGdncuc 9jja u nuGmbJo2iiiGuc 9Uq (JCLL Ja!o) uq bL!C62

iBILsrna xs 2in5bffisoD noiaeii saerli tsrli eiBer1ioqd 5f1i 1ev51 ezn fiint 1snoiin9vnoz

io 1 sdi iii insianoD .sii riiq1 n&Ii ir{si aur1T .3u1v ojuloeds iii no oi !fi11p3 io

enm airiT .llsI sn iL oi ais9qq6 'ihoi1Jus vienom edi iuqiuo iii asini 31dbibIq ,s

b5i39qx5 abiow isdio iii .diwoi &iiq b9138qx3 ni 'iiIiiov erli idieosxe ziIoq edi isth diiw ed bluow ii nr1i i1oq Isuiz vieae5l 1iebe'J ecu iLtiw e1diisv eiom ai diwoi &thq

.q[3 isnirnon iii r1iwoi beioeqxe en I nsiano niqeoJ lo 3ifoq sift

noiaivsi ecu no anoiiod auohv s c1iwoi eriq iii anoiaxvei sill lo anoiaaeiei ni oals I

isnil ninssm sviisri us sis einsbfflso3 cxillusi silT .iirifIni ol moil rliwoi luqiuo ni

.iinani ol moi1 saii oi beJDsqxs ai luqino nsnfw anothorl Ifs isvo ILsI ol bebsqxs sis lsdi is1 sill moil bsnssl ed ns scioionom bsl iii ei asziiq flu inemevom sill Isnil sDnsbiva

.ansi{insl nothod sill as sulsv uloads iii saii anoiaasisi seinil lasi easdi no nsbfl1so sill

(llsuaunu ol aeludnlno3 viloq isieciom sas eniilsasd sill ol sviislei lsili sbulDnoz audi I

.linflni bns nsswiod sflul3sb ol bslsqxs ai luqluo isveneilw noilsilni rfid aboiisq sis anoiaaszsi lnli ai laift silT .nibnft airli ioI anoiisisiqisini Isievea sis sisilT

qmsl3 ol eeunulnoz) b&I sill isril bins noilsftni nui nol s3ubsi ol niii ai bs'I sill smdw

ieilis sill lo iiiiqa sill iii doum 'iev ai ainfi .noiaaeosi s nil ai 'monos sill isfts neve nwob

S lo e3nsiatxs sill bns anoiisuizufi iuqluo Ifs beauso iiIidsiani 'islenxom rbidw ni aiasns .ciinslnlti ierLhul d bswolfoI ed bluow isnoieasoei £ isnil beilqmi (SI) nil n oviliaoq

sm iIuasi sill bslanI .acxoiaao3sl sill nuis313 ni bs'I sill ol sloi on aniaas bno3ea silT

ens 8floi22335i sasilT .asDioI isillo d beaus3 anoiaasoei ol noiiosei bs'I s ol sub sd ijjqmia

luqluo iii i{iwoi lath alilT .iasI woi ol bel3eqxs ai iuqluo 51511W asrisvosi d bewollol

.niiseilisvo biovs oi bebeon ai iIinsldii £ isili nivsi1sd olni b&I sill sisza vsm

asassiDni bsl3sqxs sisl lLs3iqis ol abssl 'ç)iloq 'mienom isdi nworla svsd I is1 o sis IUD lsn iii auth bslDsqxe auniT .LIsl ol bel3sqxs ai IUD Issi neilw q(R) Isnimon iii

sasili isdlsilw Aas won I .sas snilsasd sill ni nisill 'nifoq 'isrIoiansqxe siom s diiw bsishoaas

io asissis isisnom fsbfflo nil asaseini IsulDs iluiw bslsboaas 515 EeiDiloq v,1snotanisqxs

I saoqiuq emIl io'I .esilioolsv tCslssls sill ni esassi3ni at sub lqmia sis sifl ieilisifw

A .anoieivsi dlwoi luqino bns iliwoi 'scnom iii anoieivsi neowied noilsboaes sill ibuia

Page 39: NBER - tog6061 · 2020. 3. 20. · J1G oLqou (oo) Gdn9oIJ 2 COU2!2cGIJ4 mcrxf pp nu€wbJo?uJGu; L9çc !2 922OCWG 1AçJJ anpaGdncuc 9jja u nuGmbJo2iiiGuc 9Uq (JCLL Ja!o) uq bL!C62

iii biujb ei 1Laii boie nom 3rLt isdi 5Dnebiv3 ebivoiq bluow flOii6DOaS 5V1i5IT

sisI hs1u3iiiaq ei r1iwoi 'snom isd Iqrth bluow II .noisftni b9iD9qxe iLidsia8b I&I[i

eboH9q di I92i3siq si 325di iuH .Ilsme ai r1iwoi iuqiuo neriw aii ium noiisflni uI oe

lo fui r1i b3woIIoI in9mirievo erfi Ii nave ts1 f5viJs1ei 3d biIs bhiow noiisflni 5191fw

.diwoi nom nii1idsta

issis 11si5nom euohsv lo diwo 911i iii enoiavei n3ewi9d enoiis131io3 aworia e1dT

diwoi nom niisIei ain3bffi5o3 noiaasi avslqaib oaI ii .diwo Iuqiuo iii 2fl0121v31 bas

nibuI3rIi anoiiDfi!D3qa eaorli iol 'GIno fiWOrfa sis 525f{T .anoiaiv5l r1iwo iuqiuo at enoiaivi

ais131 nmuIoD rbs5 ni 19biano I noiaivsi boia 'nom 9di voioM i&nom s iasL sili audT .noiisofiiD3qa anmuIoD isili ni in3aiq ai isrli 5iss1s isi3nom sifi at 9di moI b9iuqmo eis idi easd yi3nom 9di ni arioiaivi lo ioivsr{3d r1i aworia rmuIo3

.3is1 abnxjl 1si3b9I rfi bns 5asd 1si3nom edi r{iod aebxJIDrxi i6di JIAV

buia I isdi ais isinom 11 xo1 isr1i sidsi aidi iii woi iaft edi moil eee eW

-ivei Juqiuo rliiw beis1enoD fsviisen beebni eis 'iinflni oi t molt arioiaivei diwoi venom iuqiuo eviiiaoq inneq eno £ isrli 1361 9(11 diiw ineiaiarioc ai airiT .iini1ni ol I molt arroia

arioiaaeiei 9111 iz)s1 nI .inecneq eno nsdi ieis1 aenuIz)eb eiiq s diiw beisboaas ai noiaivei

diwoi iuqiuo n9dw eriom ni aentloeb bsiDeqxe lo eia 9111 isili eis3ibni woi brlo39a 3111 lii

aidi isili aworla eldsi edi 10 woi biirli ecu 11sniI .Isiirisiadua eiiup ei abiswqzs beaiv,i ai

bsei1s ai iiiqiuo ni anoiaivsi abisviqu misi rxo1 rliiw beisiDoeas ai isdi snom ni enulDef)

.beaiv3l 21 i1Jwoi iuqiiio ieiIs 191115L1p 5(10 eoIq e)1si ol bei3eqx9

ecu 10 in3iDffleo3 ecu ni1sqmo3 d 'ir3o1ev ni ainem9vorn beiDeqxe Juods nisel ns 9(10

edi lo tnebffleoo edi bns 2flO2jV91 iuqiuo efli oi flOi2iV31 'efxom 3111 asisIsi IsrIl flO122S131

at isupe az iernioI 9111 II .noieivei iuqiuo 9111 oi noigivsi 9iiq edi aelsisi isdi noiaaeiei .eensr13 iuqiuo bei3eqxe ol beisleinu 915 aensrb 'ii3oI3v beiDeqxe SCO 2Ufltffi 191161 SIll

noiaee1ei sill ni aineL3ffleO3 9(11 9I59is 3) 9(11 bus easd 'isienom 9111 lo easc 9111 uI

sulsv eiuloads ui sis1 oa eis Jinfini oi I molt dJwoi 'enom ui ff0181V5i 9111 ninis1qxe

iuqluo ui noraivei abiswqu as ai 519111 nedw abiswqu beaivei ai iI3O1sV ni diwoi SILt idi M bus IM bnsu1 iodio ecu nO .emloeb oi beiDeqxe 21 IUD Lsnimoci c1uodi cieve f1iwo1

Page 40: NBER - tog6061 · 2020. 3. 20. · J1G oLqou (oo) Gdn9oIJ 2 COU2!2cGIJ4 mcrxf pp nu€wbJo?uJGu; L9çc !2 922OCWG 1AçJJ anpaGdncuc 9jja u nuGmbJo2iiiGuc 9Uq (JCLL Ja!o) uq bL!C62

.2blswqLJ biv31 ai diwoi iuqino n5dw thiswnwob b5iv5i i if iwo ibofev

1183 iuqiuo n5rfw Irfii e Di1oq iieiiom isif I ri noilosa eirli lo nor2uIDnOo bsoid 9dT

91911w boh9q oni .ioninoo oi bioeqx9 ed nso ii 11911w eaool bits bnsqxs ol bsiosqxs sd

ion ob anibnft sasif I noiaasoei ol bnoqasnoo 11sisns bnsqxs oi bsiosqxs ed nso iuqiuo

wod 119111 ai suaai sdT .anoiaasoei lo rnbns edi ol aoiixdiiinoo oiloq 'cIsienom isrll iaeua isdi ebubnoo oriw (I1) ierno.51 bits iemofl lo seodi illiw befbnooei ed nso anibnft easril

ios1 iii .bsnsvisith ion bsd iiioi{ius 'isisnom sill Ii saiow 151 rissd svsd bluow anoteasosi

ismo5l bits ismoJi lo saodi dliw insiaianoo '1eu11 sis ieqsq airli lo anibnf1 Isoiiiqrns sill

worla sc1i bits oi1oq isienom lo aioisoibni as asisi lasisirti no jjaom auool edT .([QI)

moi1 aenibsb monoos sill as Ilsi asisi lasisini aisi l1snoiineini evisas5l I rsb&1 edi isdi

isienom isili lioqei (4QQ1) ismo51 bus ismoSl emii emsa srii is iuH .arluoii ol a1ssq

au abiswoi bsd abnsqxe monoos edi as) duoii erli tells 1sisibsmmi Jr1ii aniul oiIoq

.(eisie 'bseia

I isriw Liosxe ai saii oi beioeqxs ai luqiuo nodw aboiisq riiiub oiIoq lo ninsidii airiT

isdi SLAV sdi nI .anothod islioda iol aiierfi ilhiw insieiarioo ai isr{i sonebive bnil oafs I .bna

ni arioiaivsl (aiailsns usd1 oi sldsusqmoo iaorn audi ai bits) sist ebnul Isiobsi sill asbubni

sill ni anoiaivsi diiw bsisiooaas 1eviiieoq Lnouia sus teitsup ixeri sill usvo if iwot Juqiuo

enoiaiveu owl seoul nsswisd noiislenoo edT .iehisup isili tevo sist iastsini sill lo iliwoug

.(O. ol Isups ci isdi I lo eonsiusv nilqmsa sill d beoubni torts busbusia £ rliiw) 1. ci

bebeqxs ci iuqiuo bus iuqiuo iii noiisvonrii eviissn s ci eusdi anoiaaeost lo isano sill IA

tevo diwot iuqiuo ni enoiaiveu abuswnwob scenT O .telusup ixon sill iii tsrlitul IlsI oi

iii asniloeb diiw bsisboaas icsua (1'1) temoJi bits iemoSL as ieu sis usiusup ixsn sill

.aslsu isisliii ninsaoo1 s insaetqeu aelsu iaeteini ui asritloeb ecenli isdi euts (lI) uemoSI bits uemo5I

bluow ii as qssb as nirnooed moil noteesoet sill inevetq 'srli isdi bits 'oiJoq usisriom lb

lo ninseooI cull isrll ewodc ailuasu 'm 'ion 10 cliii if Mw cssis silo isrIisifW .sd saiwusillo

moil s(iwoi Juqiuolo enoieivi rliiw b I&tio 'Iovisn ei anoiivonni iuqiuo leiIis9 b3aauoaib I aA° .1 + oi moi1 i{iwoi iuqiuo b anoiivi rbiw bii3oea '1eviiioq s dJ Jud infbni oI t

8C

Page 41: NBER - tog6061 · 2020. 3. 20. · J1G oLqou (oo) Gdn9oIJ 2 COU2!2cGIJ4 mcrxf pp nu€wbJo?uJGu; L9çc !2 922OCWG 1AçJJ anpaGdncuc 9jja u nuGmbJo2iiiGuc 9Uq (JCLL Ja!o) uq bL!C62

28

CGUL9J 9IJ 2f9piJiGq GxbGcçGq L96 o Locp oj 11011J1u9J CDb G2G sxbccçq onçbnç

iso; pocy ;p' i.9i26 onçbnç ;GiuboL9LJJ? j€sq o GxbGcç9rou2 o onçbn; qGcJJuGa i cp

;}TG JGGL9J 1{2CLAG 262 UJOIJG? 111 1JJG 96LUJ9JJ O 2pocy2a MJJGJJGL 4G2G G mou6ç9LA OL

J,JJG LG2ITJ2 ¶1J20 9JJOM 0116 4O qcqnc 201136 G1J€L9J Cp9LCGL2çC2 O JJG M9A II! MpICp

!UUU! mnç pG 922oc9cGq !Mcp bLqicçpj qGCJUG rn wouG? L0W o !uUu!c)

IM 211p2ç9UçJ9J JUCLG92G2 111 WOIJG? MJJGLG92 bLGqcç9pJG bo2i;i/G LOMJ3 rn onçbnç pow

L69J 2pocJ2 ju b9L!cnJ9L nuGxbGc;cq bo2!AG WOAGWGU2 u onbnç urna pG aoCçGq

ucp 9 L69J 1u6LbLG9çiou qoa 26GW o LcdJnLG 913 flUfl2fl9J 2G o LG2b0u262 o WOUG?

JJ3626 LG21112 qo uOç LITJG Ollc p9 4JJG AoJ9'c!I!c? O OITfbI1 p92 OGL LG9J cn€

LG/J2iOU2

onbn LOMjJ oi€r. ucxç dn9LçGL 916 boeJcTAGJ?k 922ocçGq inJçp coLLG2bouqiu BLICG

OIJCG ;pG?. 916 qGLG1JCJGq I12!IJ JJG GAGLqG-GJ20u wGpoq) jp€ pLq 12 16A1210112

COLLG2b0uqiu LGA!2!0U2 0 bic Lonp (eo ;p bL!c62 uq onbn 916 1JG9pAGJ? C0LLGJ9G

!2 ;p; LGAI2JOIJ2 'U oriçbnç LOMJJ tLOLU % o iuuiç? 916 UG9çAGJ? 9220C19Gq MLJJ 4JJG

IJJ0AGUJGU2 u oriçbnç 9LG bo2ipAcJ? 220C19lG mçp iluGxbGcc6q bLJcc UJOA6UJGU2 JJJJG 2GCOU

!wboL9u C9TLC2 o bL!cG 9Uq onbnç co-woAGuJGuç2 JpG 1JL2 o JJG2G flJ94 nIJcxbGCcGq

ori;bn A0J9f!iç? 10 UJ0LJG91? qi2cnLp9uC62 C9U G92J? pG LGCOIJCjG M}J JJG LGG WO2

JJJJG 113911 WG229G 0 JJJ2 b9BGL !2 JJ9; 9 LGJ9flAGJ? 2!UJBJG 2;!CJ bLcG 11J0GJ JJ9ç 9c;L!p13c62

o COJJCIrI2!0U2

C9112G bLop9cçGq 0U62

OCCJIL LGJ9cJAGJ? dncJq? 92 M6JJ 1P1323 MJJ!IG bL!cG Jqç W9? C9(12G LGC622!0U2 14 0G2 uo

;9J€ bjcc micp!u pc UGXç to dn9LçGL2' JAfl2 211G242 qJ9ç JJG IJGGqGq bL!cG 9Cflfl2fWGU42

mo2 O JJG oiiçbiiç UJOAGIJJGIJç2 916 cxbccGq o ;j bJcG 6AGun9JJ2. 916 GxbGclGq

ju fl q9;9) LGCG22IOU2 Guq LGJ9pAcJ? drncjq) y JgofGIiJpGL 9IJq jooqoiq (TaM) 2JJOM

9bbG9L 0 pG 1JGGG O €uq LGCG220U2

!'1q!' 4JJG COIJçL9CçIOU9LX bojc?. 9çGL !2 2ITCJJ 4JJ94 2flP219U49J bL!CG qGCUG2

bopc? 0G2 U0 OpAi9çc JJG IJGG 0L bLJcc 9qifl2cUJGUc2 JJJG GULG bcpG O UJ0UGç9L? boj-

Page 42: NBER - tog6061 · 2020. 3. 20. · J1G oLqou (oo) Gdn9oIJ 2 COU2!2cGIJ4 mcrxf pp nu€wbJo?uJGu; L9çc !2 922OCWG 1AçJJ anpaGdncuc 9jja u nuGmbJo2iiiGuc 9Uq (JCLL Ja!o) uq bL!C62

bssiariI .sbuiirism emsa sill lo a asini s3Hq bsDsqxs riiiw bsJsboaas ed blirow asnulDsb

sis isdi asasol3ni s3nq bsiDsqxs illiw bsisi3oaa& ss asnibsb iuqiuo bsbsqxs isril brth I bsieqxs lo sarioqasi b sissxs aidT .asnul3sb iuqirio sill nsdi sulsv siriloads iii ieisl

rliwoi iuqiuo risdw lsebsiq '1snoiansqxs ai 'foq 'xsisnom isdi eiasiia rliwoi szmq

noiisllth bsbeqxs 'fo iiliis1ov ieisl s asilqmi 3iloq s fl3u2 .lLsrria sd oi bsisqxs sd nsz

.quo Lsrxxmon iii diwoi b bsqxs sill ssilidsia ot bsiii isif I 3i1oq s moiI iluasi bluow usd1

saoqqua isluoiiisq uI .sldsiiasbnu issqqs sm isa ai snom sw sill lo oiiaiisisisrb airiT

iinftni ol moi1 uliwoi iuqiuo bsisqxs isril oe noiaasDsl s ui Ilseli thrift monozs sill isril

£ usril JIsI ol lisi asrq saus3sd lno bsizsiioiq ai noiaes3si sdi isdi ilsi srio II .oisl ai

sill nO .svii3uboiqisinuoD mssa bluow sDnsiani audi ni r{iwoi snom rIi3ubs1 lo

oi issi asoiiq isdi sw silt aiDsIs oals 'Diloq audi isili brim iii iqsl sd laum ii brzsd isrilo

asilqmi isqsq audi ui bsirisasiq Isbom siiq 'Qbiia nbloo1-biswio1 sill is1uziiisq iii .athorla

sill Ii Bsmlz)sb siiq auosnsinsiani isisl riliw bsisi3oaas 515 aborla sviissrz isioqmsi isrfi

audT .snom iii anoilDubsi 'd bsiasqmo33s sd ol beiosqxs sd 1153 borla sill moil isvosi '1srIoiaas3s1 sill s3ubsi sm snom iii aenulosb riiiw y'isvo3sl sill rIirxsqmo33s lo oiloq sill

.boda sviissn lsniiio sill lo iosqmi

ol

Page 43: NBER - tog6061 · 2020. 3. 20. · J1G oLqou (oo) Gdn9oIJ 2 COU2!2cGIJ4 mcrxf pp nu€wbJo?uJGu; L9çc !2 922OCWG 1AçJJ anpaGdncuc 9jja u nuGmbJo2iiiGuc 9Uq (JCLL Ja!o) uq bL!C62

I

OflLU OI \JbbpGc ECO3OU3GLic'a 'pTTJ-2GbcGwpGL TO I3-EA9'U2 coLc:nçbnç uq fluGwbJo?uJJcuc DU9'WC2 !U fJJG flUçGq 9'G2:

1jouG9'A Ecouou3ic jajC°°J JJJJOUJ9'2 E 'q 1' E OP9' JJG CJ!'9'J BGJJ9'A!OL O J14CG2 OflLB9'1 O1

oqj n4c9'u Ecouousc cbçGwpGLCOOJG JJJOUJ9'2 E 9'Uq C9" W H9'IVILPG IUU9'!0IJ FX JU 9' BWI BU2!UG CJG

I 1flUG\2GbcGWpGLbouGuça o J4b 9'IJq bLicG&. '1onLu9" O 'jCOUOU3C D 39'U31C 9'13 COULO'

COCPL9'UG 1PU if 9'Uq LI9' poLqouG: IIJçJA9'LJ9'çG E2!m9';G2 Ot JJG bGLW9'UGU4 Ca1

JJLSU2IJJ!22101J yGCp9'IJiUJ flOL'(fl3 b9'bGLCPcJ 'i ''q JcpGup9'nmJdnJqJ EILGC2 uq ;j€ OUGç9'L?

unuJGo j'B9'UJ<!W 9iJq E2ML L9'29'q:rLG hL!CG2 COnUGLCACJ!9'J AJqGUCG jLow

JJG2ç O JJG I''''-' Hb0cPJ2 ECOUOLC9' J4OAGWGL I88C11bpGJJ 'IOJJLT J:TJoGe 29'AiU yUçiCib9'çG DGCJ!U!U yu yJcGLU9'pAG

bLICJIJ UJJUJGO J35c9'bJ!u yuqLGM 'uq 'lOpH pG9'JJ?: 'LG9'IOU uq bc!wJ9'pou 'Jlp GbGUqGUc

OfIfbflc EjrTccn9'ciou2 Ein.ob ECOOC GI& J5'C9'PI16L0 jçcLqo ' uq qn9'Lqo g'y' EUGI: BL1CG giiqip 'ywwcçLic& 'uq

1JoBGçL' ECOUOU31C?! I5 J03 3-2C9'JAO OFIJJJGLW0 2c9'CLGq b! JIJ 9' flçiJ!ç?- X!W!1U JL9'UJGThOLJ 'O1U39" oi

D!2cnLPUCG2 \JU3GUC9'U ECOBOI3JC AGH 2GbGUJpGLflJ9'IJCp9'Lq OJ!A!GL q DUUA OrI9'p:J2pG DU9'w!c EUGC o yLG9'G nbbj? uq

J0: -jj-: oicucu; rn EdnJ bLGm!UW OO(iB 1bGL Oil ECOI3OUIIC \JCç1M

C9'U ECOI3OUflC GMG i DGCGWPGL T08 IN@-JIf'flJ'LTcJJLq OJ!A!GL [: r JL9'qiçJoU9'J UçGLbLGç9'pOU o 9'CLOGCOUOIIJ1C LJ(TC9'1!OUa \1133GL

11 J{GLGL6IJCG2

Page 44: NBER - tog6061 · 2020. 3. 20. · J1G oLqou (oo) Gdn9oIJ 2 COU2!2cGIJ4 mcrxf pp nu€wbJo?uJGu; L9çc !2 922OCWG 1AçJJ anpaGdncuc 9jja u nuGmbJo2iiiGuc 9Uq (JCLL Ja!o) uq bL!C62

ii (joLçpcouiu)JcOwcL CPf!IJ IJq Dq J{OUJGL MP91 Eq GCG2OIJ2 1J9CLOCCOUOUflC

I3OUflC citiç) Jo: j-jbGLL ai F: CPL!I Aj9LJCC2 9iJ 1IJ110I BLOO1u4 b9bc'L o'u co-

ECOUOW? ECOUO UC9 fJ-2I3iic E L 9Uq uc? r 2coGYIouG? uq juccLcç u

C9U ECOUOUJC 3-331°P E L: OUJG JUGLU9OIJ9J AqGucG OU 0nbn-1u111ou qco. \JmcL-

Jc\GL9\ LGGLt'.G 913'( OI 1JprnJG9bop c5n9LcL1K cncu abLTu To)qJ9Uq E!UU 9Uq Eq'q hLG2co:Bff2!UG22 CCJ: JgG9J 9U 9

UGiG-1OC?GGL CO131,GLG13CG 013 1flC b011C tOLl COUJU— uq — : LJJG h021-M9L 112 Lpllflba c G !2!OU2l H!fOL)

CJC XJJ9IJII2CL!bç bLG2cuccq 9ç 4JJG OCIOPGL T883 T.4BEIc COUOLLqC EJf1CIT94OU2J(IIJ JçopcLc 3 9uq AT9LJ pj /9f2oIJ J/OUG? I'll J94G2è bL!CG2 9Uq JJG Bfl!UG2

CIG \JU3GUC9U ECOUOI3JIC T8 3Q310I<!IJ JSOPGLI a uq CP9LIC2 bJo22GL:jIollG IIlGLGl 9uq C'q!f u HG9I

R! IOPGLl 0: jATOIJG? 9IJq BflUG22

ECOU0C flGR92P?9b UJJ Ic: 2c!CJ bL!c: MGM iqqcucc tLOIJJ jçcç9iJ C99J0flG2 GMGtt. 01

b°1112 c CP9fl22G2 TIC9UU6 01! !Gd4oIll!IJ9J Jçiqiçrc2 uq dnqc?k EUGCl unmco ECOJG M9;JOiJ9JG

lP Bn21UG CCJG EflL0bG9B ECOIJOI331C 1GMGN OI4JJCOUflUJJ9TL9flJ 'IG9IJ-OJIMCL 9uq EL9ucJ boLlicL:Jouc2 McM-Rc2uc2i9u AJ9CLOGCOIJOW!C2 9Uq

ECO13O.C 1SGMG VI9? Tö8O:v C !2IGLTI CP9L9CIGL!9I!0U 0 9 J4G9L C€UIffL O bLICG BGP9A10L \J133L1C913

oo'uii b9bcL 013 EC0130U1C cMO TiO:T 8-UOGL 'J,pG JçGCGTJ 9CCGJGL9'çIOU O I"U9c!01' 9IJ fG22OU2 tOL 1JJG EITP1LG

2flbbl? icnjc 0flLB9 O0'iiC9' 'jCO13OI3iK T8L TTOE12cpcL pou J,GLuJ L9çiOU9J Gxbccç9çiou23 9Uq Obl!11J ouc?

Page 45: NBER - tog6061 · 2020. 3. 20. · J1G oLqou (oo) Gdn9oIJ 2 COU2!2cGIJ4 mcrxf pp nu€wbJo?uJGu; L9çc !2 922OCWG 1AçJJ anpaGdncuc 9jja u nuGmbJo2iiiGuc 9Uq (JCLL Ja!o) uq bL!C62

13

9LOnUq DGcGLIIIIU!2c!C cGq? nubJ1pJpGq fluAGL2ç? oooqoq cJJcJ:ccioIJL? riuabo; dnpL: LP C2G o 2"-'JJ EInccn!oU2

W1UJCO flUJAGLi O CP!°AflU Jc: j4owu9'J bL!c€ g!!q!f ou€? 2nbbj2. uqoGuGç? uq

Ecojom T8O T-53J?qOL 'OpU B LGWçG DU1UC2 uq 'OflLI3 oi

AICH! GGLJ J{G2GLAG pUJc O M!UcCL 5-T@2!'' CPL!20bPGL v: vLG boJic? UJGJ2 fl29pJ9 OL bOJ!C? VIJ9J?12!2 M'

dncucc o 2cOCJJ9f!C C MJJ UJIUJGO

IIOIGUJPGL 'lflI!0 uq pCJJY'GJ ooqoLq: j2 P6 Bfl2!UG22 CIG MGCG2L2 C'"-

ie OLflJCOUJ!UEAqUCG LOIJJ MGM J/OUGçL? yLG9'çG 'OflLU O IiG2 Uq ECOUOUJ1.C

OçIJJpGL nJo y opu c DL!coJIuq j, bocGLp V\IouG? oncbnc uq j,Lc€:

J5 TTgi-MFllOfWPGL 'npo : bLicG2 iu fJJG flu!Gq2fG2 'orni o ECOUO

Page 46: NBER - tog6061 · 2020. 3. 20. · J1G oLqou (oo) Gdn9oIJ 2 COU2!2cGIJ4 mcrxf pp nu€wbJo?uJGu; L9çc !2 922OCWG 1AçJJ anpaGdncuc 9jja u nuGmbJo2iiiGuc 9Uq (JCLL Ja!o) uq bL!C62

xibnqqA esisfi ie31inI rnwoJ 'noM ni asirnI ic1w ins hsV A

nI .enoisensii iol beau ed ns isril aieaas owl em elefli isrli niss eno eaoqqu d oafs tud °& enom fsbfflo lo sau efli d taut ion beisiilbsl em enoiiDsansli isluDiimq eisi iaeiirzi erli no noiieithsi na eaoqmi ion ob I won iuH ieaas iedion.s lo eeu erli isdi ilqmie emuces I .arrriei Isei iii lqqua Isiol cii ioHieei I ierlisi1 .ieaes aidi d bisq

jqqua lsei edt bexft aqee)l inemfl1eVO edt isril bus inemnievo erli 'd beuaai ai ieaas edi °'t& lo lqqua lsei edt mv lnemnievo erfi iel Iliw I bnsd iedio edt nO '

.eioled as T niisv aerisv niuiei b olsi eviislex iiedi r{uodi neve bebnsmeb em aieaas rliod isuli eiuane oT

'd nevi won ci () tsu{t ornucas I

(IC) '()"(°&) � k inislienoD iebud lsioqmeiieini bloubeuorl edt iilsupe us as eblod (IC) riimuaas aseiedw

asmoed () ti¼1r

trc I tu \rzi v tQ — ______ I 1. LL'. k — +

Jeces evilsineils edt no iaeieird lo eisi Isnimon suit eineasiqei noiisupe cull ru

aiinu emsa edt un benuasem ed isril esliupsi (IC) eeuscod isiuisrr ci noiisthqieini ciriT

isilob eno ninisido lo is leo milob ecu alneasiqei ---j- aunilT bns °& as (aisliob) .it:( 10

oiloliioq iiedi eaoorb oi icisw afsubivibni is be1iow aiuorl lo eculoub nsvi ns xo'I ieils eDioub oilothoq airli efrn edi emneas I .1 + is noiiqmxsaruoc usd1 eirnixsm ot uiecli cenimueieb rbidw e3iuq boiueq usd1 cuiiiea ueils as flew as uslansui suit nivissu

emiT . is inemolqrrie

(CC) x(+I)II rtt

evsd ew insieno3 ci isdl niuedmemeu buns 'i 'd duoudi nibiviG

(C) insieno=

as neiliuw ed nsz lebocn ieaas owl aidi ni '1illiu Mdi awollol ii (CC) bus (CC) (IC) cuiaU

— + ('_) _+ 1__I[(

— I)(_ + I)]}\<a = I_+L 1_+:k

(k)olJ —

((() +i) '-s) s

oi ub bsxft ci '1qquc cii 3rii bns '(1sivi1q bucai ci Jcc di idi 3mucas b1uo no 13viin13i1At 9ffT .[sii1lo3 a beau ed 'tdibs n isdi aiaas 1o boia b9iimil £ lo 5niaix9 9di ot io anoiislui

b9xft I noasi edT .ainislienoD iebud aisuaci eili sisDilqrnoD 1,evewod 1bluow suaai siviiq1o noiisloqlo3ni bluow aic'tn6 di Jufi .beucai ci nrLw I

— i nwon,1 ion ci S ii{i ci \'tf ndi iedii 11_M\'t& .1\'t& 1o I

— i noiisieqxe erli anw bexit bernuaa asw iir1w 1'c 11i b9nsdDnu ni&nei

14

Page 47: NBER - tog6061 · 2020. 3. 20. · J1G oLqou (oo) Gdn9oIJ 2 COU2!2cGIJ4 mcrxf pp nu€wbJo?uJGu; L9çc !2 922OCWG 1AçJJ anpaGdncuc 9jja u nuGmbJo2iiiGuc 9Uq (JCLL Ja!o) uq bL!C62

moil eiT1ib noiiibno3 iobio Jaift di 3liflw bns (8) oi i1imia 'iv ai rIoiifwp aidT nimei lebom ei{i lo a3iii9qoiq 9viisiLsup eu eii aeierxi ed aebul3ni ii irIi ni ()

iziqiuo aeaisi hid x-- aeaisi th eaeizni n 'd beDnnft ni eaSeIDflL nA .i1imia 10 noiiiaoqmoD erli elqoeq eioled eIq eLsi iaum ielensii aidi e3ni2 .Ifsw as I + is £ asd leborn eili eILs1 I + bns neewied elsi iaeieini erli isrIi asilqmi (1) oiLoIiioq iiedi

edi ae3r1q 1)I3iia if liw eaxisoed alisi abnod no eisi iaeieini Isnimon silT .be11e iibiupiP slqoeq iuH .aebivoiq ii ieaas Jasisini ois sill lo Iqqua Issi sill niassini ai inernnisvo

no eisi lasisini sill Ii ieaas neimd sill lo iniioms beasel3ni audi bloil ol niIliw 1no sis .alIsI aisaas niisqmoD

Page 48: NBER - tog6061 · 2020. 3. 20. · J1G oLqou (oo) Gdn9oIJ 2 COU2!2cGIJ4 mcrxf pp nu€wbJo?uJGu; L9çc !2 922OCWG 1AçJJ anpaGdncuc 9jja u nuGmbJo2iiiGuc 9Uq (JCLL Ja!o) uq bL!C62

—010

—00Q

000

00Q

010

2 A9LJ1'PJG 2GW - - - -: 3 A9LI'JPJG 2X2Gm

LGqc9'pJG 0riçbriç 0IoMcp

LHLG I

Page 49: NBER - tog6061 · 2020. 3. 20. · J1G oLqou (oo) Gdn9oIJ 2 COU2!2cGIJ4 mcrxf pp nu€wbJo?uJGu; L9çc !2 922OCWG 1AçJJ anpaGdncuc 9jja u nuGmbJo2iiiGuc 9Uq (JCLL Ja!o) uq bL!C62

C) .-4

C)

C) 0

C)

C)

C

C

C

C

C

V

C

C

C

V

P0 C4

8 8

C

C

C

c4

V

C

'0

C

I I

C

C

C

4 C

Page 50: NBER - tog6061 · 2020. 3. 20. · J1G oLqou (oo) Gdn9oIJ 2 COU2!2cGIJ4 mcrxf pp nu€wbJo?uJGu; L9çc !2 922OCWG 1AçJJ anpaGdncuc 9jja u nuGmbJo2iiiGuc 9Uq (JCLL Ja!o) uq bL!C62

9.

4 4*

t sz

0

4 0t0

4 4

4 4k

4 4 4 4.4•

4 4 4 4.

4 4

4 4.

4 4.

4.

4.

4 4.

4 4.

4 4 0e0—

4 44

4 4 4.

V

4

4

4.

4 4

Page 51: NBER - tog6061 · 2020. 3. 20. · J1G oLqou (oo) Gdn9oIJ 2 COU2!2cGIJ4 mcrxf pp nu€wbJo?uJGu; L9çc !2 922OCWG 1AçJJ anpaGdncuc 9jja u nuGmbJo2iiiGuc 9Uq (JCLL Ja!o) uq bL!C62

00J8 0012 OOT 0052 OOI 0013 OOT

C0LL(cbVk0) O28 O•501 0210 OJ5 032J OT2f o3J'

OOf! OOf OOf3 OO2 OOsf OOt OOL!-J3 -T120 -JQ -T'cTO -T5 JT 15!O

00J8 OOJ! 0012 0053 OOTO 0018 OOJô

C0LL(V,) -O3O -OiY -O2 -0810 -0!ô5 -O88 -O!

00T8 OOJ 001Q OO'TJ 0013 00J5 OO1C0LL(V10Vb10) -OQ -O3 -Oô -Of2 O! -OO8 -OQ4

OO 003! 0038 OON OO1 0022 O'O5C0LL(V1Vb1) OO OJJ 0355 O3I

O.O OOO OO2 OO OOJ OO2 [email protected] -ii -rt -io -joo -n -jOO5 00J2 0012 OOI OOT 0011 OOI

C0LL(VV) -O@ -O.i -O1'f -O3 -O8. -O84 -OJ5

E'f E-f 8E-f F2E1 8E-4 8E-4 JEl0051 OO2 OO5 O'Oil 0052 0032 OO4

E- E- 3E'f E- 3E- 3Ei00T5 0015 OOT 00T5 00J2 0015 0015

001Q OOJe OOTQ 00T@ OOT OOI. OOJoo oo ooe oo ooT 0120 OO!

2E- E-2 2E-2 2E-2 2E- 2E1 2E10002Q OOO OOO OOO2 00028 000N OOO2

2E-2 QE-2 E-2 QE-2 E-2000!! 000J 0O0J 0O00 O008 00081 000!!

jucpiqq A9L: 7\$ vi vv VV1AGL2fl2 LGA!IOU2 lu bLGqiccGq cp9uG2

j,pc bLobçJ o '11119T'011 uq onçbnç cpuG2:

JJpJG T

Page 52: NBER - tog6061 · 2020. 3. 20. · J1G oLqou (oo) Gdn9oIJ 2 COU2!2cGIJ4 mcrxf pp nu€wbJo?uJGu; L9çc !2 922OCWG 1AçJJ anpaGdncuc 9jja u nuGmbJo2iiiGuc 9Uq (JCLL Ja!o) uq bL!C62

v3

S

2ripwbj€ 2c'p'Jc O C0LL(V 7b)c°ic°' o p3jçiou 'uq 0rbn;

J,pIG

-O!2

O2T

-o •

-oca

-o 8T

-o

-0•i

Page 53: NBER - tog6061 · 2020. 3. 20. · J1G oLqou (oo) Gdn9oIJ 2 COU2!2cGIJ4 mcrxf pp nu€wbJo?uJGu; L9çc !2 922OCWG 1AçJJ anpaGdncuc 9jja u nuGmbJo2iiiGuc 9Uq (JCLL Ja!o) uq bL!C62

OOT 002J OO 0031 0035 OOTC0LL(VVb) OO O5O O52 O5 O24 O2

OO 0032 0033 OO OO3 OO OT2C°'(V\,V,) -0232 -OI5 O5 OOO -OTh -OC -O2O

OO2 05J2 015! OOT OO3 002T OTNC0(V\10Vb10) -Oi -FOOQ O5O -O8 -Oi8 -O'f58

OO5 0052 0032 0033 0053 OOT@ 0080

C0LL(7'17b1) O2T O2 O'23 Of52 OOQ O8T O2'f

OO2 OO2 OO2 00Qf OO'f5 0023 OO2'f

C0LL(€b) 0Thf8 oi@e OPf1 OO 050T O25 OT!

OO2 OO4 OO OOiO O'035 002e OOOCoLL(c ) ot

00003 OOOO 00003 0000a 00005 00003 000032D O.OO OOOT3 OOOf1 OOOJ OOO2 OOOfJ 000'f5

ucjriqcq AL: s 71$ VVjoçj ?u-ponL2 IJq IUc!01

J,pJG

Page 54: NBER - tog6061 · 2020. 3. 20. · J1G oLqou (oo) Gdn9oIJ 2 COU2!2cGIJ4 mcrxf pp nu€wbJo?uJGu; L9çc !2 922OCWG 1AçJJ anpaGdncuc 9jja u nuGmbJo2iiiGuc 9Uq (JCLL Ja!o) uq bL!C62

O2 ON 02! O OOOIl 2( 2f8 OIOO O2 0J3 O'5 O3

COL CII 7\ -35 -3 -3 -J -JB'GL€22JOUa sxbjirnu vk

038 o'L O3 0J! OLCII YIIO I 125 T2 -01T 5J

OT OT 012 OJJ 000 0T@C°W CII -Jf -T2i -F21 -T4 -TN -T5

jçGLG22IOu2 GxbJ9IUiu 7b

JucjrIq€q AL2: s nnCU Oncb HOflL2 CLOThP JSGAI2!OIJ2

J{GLG22IOu Ot hL! CLOMP }GAi2TOU

JJG f

Page 55: NBER - tog6061 · 2020. 3. 20. · J1G oLqou (oo) Gdn9oIJ 2 COU2!2cGIJ4 mcrxf pp nu€wbJo?uJGu; L9çc !2 922OCWG 1AçJJ anpaGdncuc 9jja u nuGmbJo2iiiGuc 9Uq (JCLL Ja!o) uq bL!C62

00J 0012 OOTQ 0052 0012 00T3 00T0Oil 7 -O22 -0ô8 -085 -03Q -0U -JI3 -0005

00T8 0012 00T 002 00T2 0013 00J0Oil V\ O0 -0T5 -032 05J 0T0 -0215 -oi

O0T 00T2 00J 002 0012 00T3 O0Tv\ -0J0 -OJOT -OJOJ -00Q2 -0JJ -0T32 -005

005 00T 0030 0050 005 0050 0T850J8'T 0T 0TT 002 0T 00 0T0.0 00@0 002 00 002T 0023 00@

V, -118 -F2'H -TL12 -1880 -1200 -T30

jucjnqcq AL2:

IPG A1uTcflqG O XIcGq WCG CF9'UG2

2

Page 56: NBER - tog6061 · 2020. 3. 20. · J1G oLqou (oo) Gdn9oIJ 2 COU2!2cGIJ4 mcrxf pp nu€wbJo?uJGu; L9çc !2 922OCWG 1AçJJ anpaGdncuc 9jja u nuGmbJo2iiiGuc 9Uq (JCLL Ja!o) uq bL!C62

OOJ OO5 OJ2I OVJO OOb-0815 002! -OO -32 -JTQ

o.oo o•o OO2 OOQ OOM-O8J -0358 -O38 -OJI -T52i

o.o OOf3 OOfO OO2 0050coLL(v? 'j) -o -o -oi -oo -oeeucnqq v vW vv v'v

xbccccq U OuGç9L? LGG2tJ,pJG e